The Flash: Battle for the Gem Cities (Day 12)

#1701

thellama73 wrote:
Bullzeye wrote:
thellama73 wrote:You know, I was willing to drop my suspicion of Bullz for a while. He sounded authentic in the wake of my lynch. But the constant whining about an impending NK is starting to feel forced. I'm not quite sure what to make of it, but it is starting to swing me back in the "suspicious of Bullz" direction.
Am I talking about an impending NK? No. I'm talking about one that would have happened in a certain circumstance. Don't twist my words.
I am hunting scum. what are you doing?

srsly, rvs, sus(s)

None of that is an answer to the fact that your post misrepresents what I'm saying. Just because you're a confirmed civ doesn't mean you get to make things up.

#1702

timmer wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:
Bass_the_Clever wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:
Bass_the_Clever wrote:DH what do you think of Roxy?
I don't feel great about her waiting so long on the Aces thing.
Thanks. Who are you thinking about voting today?
I'm mulling some things over. If Made were on the poll I might have voted for him.
Thanks for the reply, DH, but I think you are twisting things a bit. This^^ is from what I can tell, your first mention of Made today. Thus, it had NOT been established that he was on the poll yet. Right?

I brought up the bulk of my Made suspicion after it'd been established who he was on the poll. I did consider voting for him before that, but that was more of a last resort, participation-based vote.

#1703

The thing that holds me back from voting DH is the fact bf voted there. bf has been going on and on about Bullz then suddenly he switched to DH which now in turn has me doubting myself inre: DH.

Idk what I am going to do.

#1704

Aces - where are you looking today?

#1705

I'm really conflicted about this lynch. Yesterday ended up making me doubt a lot of the things I thought I had down, and I don't have anything I'd call a major case to lay down atm.

#1706

Timmer if you had to vote right now who would you vote for?

#1707

Bass_the_Clever wrote:Timmer if you had to vote right now who would you vote for?

Well I'm not going to toss my vote or anything, so I'll likely go along with either the bf or DH lynch idea. Neither is great imo, BF's posts read a certain way, and DH's reply about Made is conflicting me, but neither of them feels like a civvie, so I don't think a lynch in their direction is necessarily bad.

#1708

timmer wrote:
Bass_the_Clever wrote:Timmer if you had to vote right now who would you vote for?
Well I'm not going to toss my vote or anything, so I'll likely go along with either the bf or DH lynch idea. Neither is great imo, BF's posts read a certain way, and DH's reply about Made is conflicting me, but neither of them feels like a civvie, so I don't think a lynch in their direction is necessarily bad.

Thanks.

#1709

I'll go with BF. If my hunch about his role were correct, I think I would have seen something today that frankly, I didn't see. So my thoughts on his role are likely wrong.

BF

#1710

timmer wrote:I just did a complete reread of BF.

About the only really ping-y thing i could see was his "wtf?" reaction to how the Bass 1.0 lynch went down. For the rest, I've got an alignment in mind for him, and he seems to be pursuing leads as he sees them. I'm not sure I could say he's bad, but I don't think he's an Old Rogue, either. I won't vote for him, but won't really be going out of my way to defend him, if that makes sense?

timmer wrote:I'll go with BF. If my hunch about his role were correct, I think I would have seen something today that frankly, I didn't see. So my thoughts on his role are likely wrong.

BF

lol quick turnaround...

I was hoping we'd hear more from BF. And everyone else really. Less than an hour til deadline and tons of votes/players unaccounted for :-/

#1711

Does no one at all have the tally from the first Day 3?

#1712

Well look I'll spell it out.

Even though back when the bullz/BF thing happened BF said he was not a detective, I still felt that he likely was, and when llama rezzed, BF even said "WB friend" which felt co-detective-ish. But frankly, llama's few posts today haven't clicked with that. All he said was "BF's defense of me was odd and unexpected, but I do not read him as bad. I don't think baddies stick their necks out like that."

Maybe that's calle dbeing subtle and in my mind if it were me, I'd be a bit more blunt, but it doesn't feel like I'm right about my hunch.

And yes, quick turnaround, but I'm about to leave work and had to make a decision.

#1713

For some reason I thought this ended tomorrow. I am voting for Timmer. He just feels insincere to me. I know that that is going to annoy him, but it is what it is.

#1714

If anyone has a better case to be made against other lynch contenders, I'll poke my head back from home right before deadline.

I don't really want to end up lynching a detective, so if you guys think my hunch was right, please say so. I'm very conflicted today.

@SVS, it does, but nothing I can do about that.

#1715

timmer wrote:Well look I'll spell it out.

Even though back when the bullz/BF thing happened BF said he was not a detective, I still felt that he likely was, and when llama rezzed, BF even said "WB friend" which felt co-detective-ish. But frankly, llama's few posts today haven't clicked with that. All he said was "BF's defense of me was odd and unexpected, but I do not read him as bad. I don't think baddies stick their necks out like that."

Maybe that's calle dbeing subtle and in my mind if it were me, I'd be a bit more blunt, but it doesn't feel like I'm right about my hunch.

And yes, quick turnaround, but I'm about to leave work and had to make a decision.

No I get it and I'm basically on the same page. Was laughing at how adamant you were about not voting for him a second ago. Llama's defense of BF could be intentionally subtle but he could also know nothing about BF at all given how he worded it. BF also could have let us play up his detective status but he didn't coast with it and made sure to say he had a different role in mind for Llama. Either way it was important to cover his ass there so he wouldn't be NK'd or get suspicion from the real detectives, but I don't know, the rest of BF's play doesn't make me feel great about him.

#1716

Voting BF.

#1717

Ok I need to vote and I'm not sure who to vote for. BF game seems different to me then it did in Roger Rabbit where he was civ. That game he was on point baddie hunting this game he just seems to be looking at couple people and not adding to the other areas of discussion. So I think I have made upp my mind and I'm voting BF.

#1718

Also gonna stick my vote on BF. I feel sure he's not a detective, and a lot of people seem to think he's bad. Let's see.

#1719

I was hoping to hear more from Roxy in response to my last post, which was largely about her and Aces.

I assumed that Aces had the most votes at the end of the original Day 3 because it was him that was in the lynch story post. So did Daisy definitely have the most votes?

My vote is going to Roxy. For now. If she says anything that changes my mind in the next 20 mins, I may reconsider where that vote is placed.

#1720

I will join the BF vote.

#1721

Long Con wrote:I assumed that Aces had the most votes at the end of the original Day 3 because it was him that was in the lynch story post. So did Daisy definitely have the most votes?.

This is what I have been trying to figure out. Lynch post makes me feel good about Aces, but if Daisy actually had more votes then I have some questions.

#1722

Daisy definitely had the most votes.

#1723

Wow, I cast my vote, I guess I didn't realize how many people have voted for BF already, because it surprised me to see. It's looking like a solid train on BF, so I hope he's bad. I do kind of suspect him, but I also think that Llama's comment on him is exactly the right way to vouch for a Detective partner without getting all info-droppy, which a bunch of people here have issues with.

Llama saying anything that confirmed BF's Detective status in a direct or indirect way would be the EXACT same as saying "Yes, he is my Detective partner". What Llama said was the right way to do it, because it doesn't confirm anything solidly. Down with Infodropping, right everyone?

#1724

FZ. (8), timmer (9), Turnip Head (11), Bass_the_Clever (12), DharmaHelper (13), Bullzeye (15)

I considered that my words might cause some people to reconsider their BF votes, so here's where votes for blindfaeth stand right now. In case it is useful later for some reason.

#1725

S~V~S wrote:Daisy definitely had the most votes.

Well she never seemed too concerned about dying if you ask me. How close was it, was she only ahead by a vote or two?

#1726

And yeah LC I'm surprised by how quickly the dogpile onto BF happened too.

#1727

Yeah the way the post reads it was Aces who was going to be lynched. The lighting thing made me think weather wizard but I'm not sure.I need to check out his role.

#1728

I'm caught up now.

LongCon, SD had the most votes when the poll closed. Ignoring any vote manipulations, she should have been the one lynched. I don't know why I was the one in the lynch post. Flavor text, possibly?

I haven't figured out my vote yet.

#1729

AceofSpaces wrote:I'm caught up now.

LongCon, SD had the most votes when the poll closed. Ignoring any vote manipulations, she should have been the one lynched. I don't know why I was the one in the lynch post. Flavor text, possibly?

I haven't figured out my vote yet.

Were you by the flash museum?

#1730

LC - what more would you like me to say about Aces and me? I said everything yesterday. I know you asked me to say who it was eaarly on but no way I was going to do it without giving him a fair chance in bts - he was very sincere and what he said made sense. I feel if I had said something earlier a lot of people would have used my post as a reason for their vote -so I waited - I really felt I saved Aces and he was worth it.

But yeah I was so busy defending I did not take notice of the poll votes

I am with my gut I voted DH

#1731

Turnip Head wrote:
S~V~S wrote:Daisy definitely had the most votes.
Well she never seemed too concerned about dying if you ask me. How close was it, was she only ahead by a vote or two?

This is true.

#1732

Turnip Head wrote:
S~V~S wrote:Daisy definitely had the most votes.
Well she never seemed too concerned about dying if you ask me. How close was it, was she only ahead by a vote or two?

I want to say 2, but I don't know for sure. It did not occur to me to pay too much attention. I figured the poll would be saved

but iirc 2.

#1733

I wish Roxy or Aces could answer my question.

#1734

Bass_the_Clever wrote:
AceofSpaces wrote:I'm caught up now.

LongCon, SD had the most votes when the poll closed. Ignoring any vote manipulations, she should have been the one lynched. I don't know why I was the one in the lynch post. Flavor text, possibly?

I haven't figured out my vote yet.
Were you by the flash museum?

I'm pretty sure our host has told us not to discuss our exact map positions. If you are asking if I caused this repeat day, I did not. I was pretty sure I was going to get lynched until about 1 minute before the poll closed, and everyone was changing their votes. I think if you look back, you'll see my frustration with the situation. If I knew there was a event like this coming up, I would have shown a bit more indifference to the vote.

#1735

I switched my vote to Timmer. His recent posts feel wishy washy. Not want I would expect from Timmer at all.

#1736

I have to vote. I'm not caught up all the way, not going to lie.

LC. Not a very informed vote. This is a ping from days 1 - 2. I'm only about half way through my catch up. I suck.

#1737

I voted for Daisy's....In Space! because I don't really like any of the other leading options.

#1738

OK WTF with the poll?

Still, Cong Lon? whatever, Ill be able to finally get posting this week.

#1739

AceofSpaces wrote:
Bass_the_Clever wrote:
AceofSpaces wrote:I'm caught up now.

LongCon, SD had the most votes when the poll closed. Ignoring any vote manipulations, she should have been the one lynched. I don't know why I was the one in the lynch post. Flavor text, possibly?

I haven't figured out my vote yet.
Were you by the flash museum?
I'm pretty sure our host has told us not to discuss our exact map positions. If you are asking if I caused this repeat day, I did not. I was pretty sure I was going to get lynched until about 1 minute before the poll closed, and everyone was changing their votes. I think if you look back, you'll see my frustration with the situation. If I knew there was a event like this coming up, I would have shown a bit more indifference to the vote.

Ok well the reason I asked is because how the post read it said the lightning hit by the flash museum.

#1740

AceofSpaces wrote:
Bass_the_Clever wrote:
AceofSpaces wrote:I'm caught up now.

LongCon, SD had the most votes when the poll closed. Ignoring any vote manipulations, she should have been the one lynched. I don't know why I was the one in the lynch post. Flavor text, possibly?

I haven't figured out my vote yet.
Were you by the flash museum?
I'm pretty sure our host has told us not to discuss our exact map positions. If you are asking if I caused this repeat day, I did not. I was pretty sure I was going to get lynched until about 1 minute before the poll closed, and everyone was changing their votes. I think if you look back, you'll see my frustration with the situation. If I knew there was a event like this coming up, I would have shown a bit more indifference to the vote.

I will attest to this.
If Aces had known something was happening I do not think he would have said/acted the way he was in chat.

#1741

With regards to the inactive players, I think now would be the appropriate time for our wonderful host to ask, "what would The Sock do?"

#1742

#1743

Roxy wrote:LC - what more would you like me to say about Aces and me? I said everything yesterday. I know you asked me to say who it was eaarly on but no way I was going to do it without giving him a fair chance in bts - he was very sincere and what he said made sense. I feel if I had said something earlier a lot of people would have used my post as a reason for their vote -so I waited - I really felt I saved Aces and he was worth it.

But yeah I was so busy defending I did not take notice of the poll votes

I am with my gut I voted DH

I haven't had map BTSC yet, so I don't know the details about what goes on. Are you allowed to roleclaim, and is that what happened that made you trust Aces?

#1744

No roleclaiming is allowed. Other things were said to understand each other.

#1745

Roxy wrote:No roleclaiming is allowed. Other things were said to understand each other.

What makes you so sure that he wasn't deceiving you? Saying what he knew you wanted to hear? Especially since he was quite under the gun at that point.

#1746

Sure he could have deceived me but I just don't think so. There were lots of things said and done to let me know I can trust him.

I really do not want to elaborate the conversation. At this point I have found zero reason not to trust his motives.

#1747

It would seem our illustrious host is tardy again. I think we should have lynched Roxy, but I was serious when I said I didn't know who BF is, so I guess we will see.

#1748

Day 3 (Part 2): Everything's Not Golden...

Len Snart used to be thankful he lived in Keystone City instead of somewhere like Gotham, a cesspool for several different crime factions, or Coast City, which was the site of a catastrophic attack years ago.

Now it seemed like his quiet city was going through a crisis of its own. The people he thought he knew so well were rabid with paranoia, hunting down anyone who they feared. Now, they had gone too far.

Even Leonard Snart, Captain Cold, can't always keep his cool. He broke down and sobbed when he saw what they'd done to his sister. Lisa just wanted to be like her big brother, Lenny. That wish got her strung up by an angry mob.

Blindfaeth has been lynched. You guys lynched Golden Glider!

Effective immediately, Devin the Omniscient will be replacing Ika. Welcome!

You have 24 hours to send me PMs.

#1749

Holy shit that sucks

#1750

Oh no

Sorry BF. Rest in peace.

Can Someone Finally Die?