[ENDGAME] Bullets Over Broadway Mafia

#701

Who killed Dom??

Poll runs till Thu Jun 18, 2015 10:19 pm
You may select 1 option

Bass The Clever
0
No votes

BirdwithTeeth11
0
No votes

Black Rock
0
No votes

Bullzeye
0
No votes

Cobalt
4
TinyBubbles (5), Scotty (6), Sloonei (13), timmer (19)
19%

Devin
0
No votes

DFaraday
0
No votes

Dragon D. Luffy
0
No votes

DREAM
0
No votes

Epignosis
0
No votes

Fingersplints
0
No votes

Golden
1
Canucklehead (12)
5%

Gumshoe
0
No votes

Hedgeowl
1
Golden (15)
5%

Long Con
4
Metalmarsh89 (2), Epignosis (8), Turnip Head (18), nijuukyugou (20)
19%

MetalMarsh89
0
No votes

MovingPictures07
0
No votes

Neverwhere
0
No votes

nijuukyugou
0
No votes

Nutella
0
No votes

Scotty
0
No votes

sig
0
No votes

Sloonei
0
No votes

SVS
6
MovingPictures07 (9), nutella (10), DFaraday (11), S~V~S (14), Cobalt (16), sig (21)
29%

Timmer
0
No votes

TinyBubbles
0
No votes

Turnip Head
0
No votes

XthAtGAm3RGuYX
1
XthAtGAm3RGuYX (17)
5%

Trick question, IT WAS LLAMA!!! [dead/non]
4
Dom (1), Heiots (3), Roxy (4), juliets (7)
19%

Total votes : 21

#702

Epignosis wrote:SAVE OR BUS

Come on Mafia

This is beyond interesting!

#703

@ Sloonei I've played with someone who would always vote for themselves after to many people became suspicious I don't think it is a good mafia method but one person has in the past fooled me bydoing that and I've seen two others do the same, it is a mindgame which always makes me think they are mafia trying to make themselves seem like civilians.

Nijuuk if your wary of SVS why not vote for her? I'm not understanding your vote

**http://www.last.fm/user/nutella23** · #704

I changed my vote to Cobalt. Sig, I encourage you to do the same if tiebreaking was your only motivation for your vote (though that's pretty lame if it is)

#705

I wish any one of these three was around to defend themself right now.

#706

@Epi really I have never seen a role that does that it.

#707

sig wrote:@Epi really I have never seen a role that does that it.

That's because I invented it.

#708

15 minutes and we're sitting at a deadlock. Anyone want to do something about it?

#709

sig wrote:@ Sloonei I've played with someone who would always vote for themselves after to many people became suspicious I don't think it is a good mafia method but one person has in the past fooled me bydoing that and I've seen two others do the same, it is a mindgame which always makes me think they are mafia trying to make themselves seem like civilians.

Nijuuk if your wary of SVS why not vote for her? I'm not understanding your vote

Because I wanted to make it interesting. I'm wary of all three of the top candidates and am okay with any and all getting votes. (PS you can call me Nijuu or Blooper if you want)

**http://www.last.fm/user/nutella23** · #710

@ sig Whether or not it is a role Dom said he has a procedure, which albeit vague makes me think that a tie will end in one of the candidates getting lynched.

@ sloonei LC said he wouldn't be around (a factor in my picking Cobalt over him). SVS's self vote I think constituted at least something of a defense (although it was more of an acceptance of her still-uncertain fate), worked for me anyway. Idk about Cobalt but his SVS vote just reeks bad to me, possibly LC teammate.

#711

nijuukyugou wrote:
sig wrote:@ Sloonei I've played with someone who would always vote for themselves after to many people became suspicious I don't think it is a good mafia method but one person has in the past fooled me bydoing that and I've seen two others do the same, it is a mindgame which always makes me think they are mafia trying to make themselves seem like civilians.

Nijuuk if your wary of SVS why not vote for her? I'm not understanding your vote
Because I wanted to make it interesting. I'm wary of all three of the top candidates and am okay with any and all getting votes. (PS you can call me Nijuu or Blooper if you want)

would you consider changing it if it meant breaking the tie?

#712

nutella wrote:SVS's self vote I think constituted at least something of a defense (although it was more of an acceptance of her still-uncertain fate), worked for me anyway.

#713

Sloonei wrote:
nijuukyugou wrote:
sig wrote:@ Sloonei I've played with someone who would always vote for themselves after to many people became suspicious I don't think it is a good mafia method but one person has in the past fooled me bydoing that and I've seen two others do the same, it is a mindgame which always makes me think they are mafia trying to make themselves seem like civilians.

Nijuuk if your wary of SVS why not vote for her? I'm not understanding your vote
Because I wanted to make it interesting. I'm wary of all three of the top candidates and am okay with any and all getting votes. (PS you can call me Nijuu or Blooper if you want)
would you consider changing it if it meant breaking the tie?

Are you really that freaked out by a tie?

#714

Also would you say things have been made more interesting by your LC vote, Blooperstranger?

#715

Sloonei wrote:Also would you say things have been made more interesting by your LC vote, Blooperstranger?

Oh, quite! It's garnered some good reactions.

#716

nijuukyugou wrote:
Sloonei wrote:
nijuukyugou wrote:
sig wrote:@ Sloonei I've played with someone who would always vote for themselves after to many people became suspicious I don't think it is a good mafia method but one person has in the past fooled me bydoing that and I've seen two others do the same, it is a mindgame which always makes me think they are mafia trying to make themselves seem like civilians.

Nijuuk if your wary of SVS why not vote for her? I'm not understanding your vote
Because I wanted to make it interesting. I'm wary of all three of the top candidates and am okay with any and all getting votes. (PS you can call me Nijuu or Blooper if you want)
would you consider changing it if it meant breaking the tie?
Are you really that freaked out by a tie?

a little bit. i come from a community where tied votes = no lynch, so we always avoid them like the plague. But wouldn't you rather the vote is decided by us, the players, rather than a mod's mechanic? Or are you nervous about casting the defisive vote?

#717

Epignosis wrote:
sig wrote:@Epi really I have never seen a role that does that it.
That's because I invented it.

Very cool no wonder I've never seen it.

I have 10 minuets I will reread Cobalts and SVS posts

@Sloonie considering Dom said he has a means of deciding I'm not as worried know I just didn't want a no lynch

#718

How do you vote for your damn self and someone else call it a defense?

#719

Time is running out but I've only made it to the end of page 12. I would like to get my vote in on time so it goes to my number one suspect by the end of page 12: Long Con.

I think what I will do now, despite time no longer being a factor, is continue my rapid fire responses to what has happened these last two days and post that first and then later go back and do more digging on what stands out the most to me. It just makes sense to me to continue it this way.

#720

nijuukyugou wrote:
Sloonei wrote:Also would you say things have been made more interesting by your LC vote, Blooperstranger?
Oh, quite! It's garnered some good reactions.

this is good news.

#721

Okay, wow, and you guys were concerned about a tie. Eek.

I gotta stick to my strongest feeling here and stay with LC. I would be suspicious of someone changing their vote at the very end.

#722

I'll break the three way tie.

I wanted to give SVS some time in that to realise that not everyone was against her (even if they suspected her), remove her self-vote and hopefully vote for someone she thought might be bad. But that didn't happen.

linki - guess that vote recreated a tie.

#723

the tie is back, as hedgeowl has just dropped another vote on LC

#724

Ugh, I am like 5 pages behind, but I don't want SvS to go down on a self vote. Voting LC because between him and Cobalt I feel more suspicious of him, but very weak still.

Linki no idea what is going on in the vote lol.

#725

I uncreated it. I don't want a tie.

#726

I recreated it because LC voted that way.

#727

Sloonei wrote:
nijuukyugou wrote:
Sloonei wrote:
nijuukyugou wrote:
sig wrote:@ Sloonei I've played with someone who would always vote for themselves after to many people became suspicious I don't think it is a good mafia method but one person has in the past fooled me bydoing that and I've seen two others do the same, it is a mindgame which always makes me think they are mafia trying to make themselves seem like civilians.

Nijuuk if your wary of SVS why not vote for her? I'm not understanding your vote
Because I wanted to make it interesting. I'm wary of all three of the top candidates and am okay with any and all getting votes. (PS you can call me Nijuu or Blooper if you want)
would you consider changing it if it meant breaking the tie?
Are you really that freaked out by a tie?
a little bit. i come from a community where tied votes = no lynch, so we always avoid them like the plague. But wouldn't you rather the vote is decided by us, the players, rather than a mod's mechanic? Or are you nervous about casting the defisive vote?

Fair enough. I've also seen it result in no lynch, but more often than not I've seen a tie-breaker mechanic (and Dom says he's got a system, so...I trust that means the latter). And look - things have gotten VERY interesting! I leave well enough alone and things go batshit crazy. Love it.

#728

Golden wrote:I recreated it because LC voted that way.

Or at least, I didn't recreate a tie, I voted SVS again.

#729

Okay looked over both I will be sticking with SVS I can't get over that she voted for herself and I'm taking a gamble here but if she flips mafia I will think Cobalt is right about LC as well, if she flips Civ I would think Cobalt is mafia.

#730

And all this fuss and squall about a tie.

#731

Some hosts have tie = no lynch, and I don't think that's good for anyone on day one.

#732

Act One, Scene One - cont'd

EPIGNOSIS: That LC... he sure is... a ... a....

SVS: A what??

EPGNOSIS: A baddie.

SVS moves to the apron SL.

MOVINGPICTURES07: What's that SVS?

She exits.

COBALT: Well...

LONG CON: That was weird.

MOVINGPICTURES07: What was that, Cobalt?

All leave, but COBALT and LONG CON.
A beat. Or Five.

SVS enters SL.

Blackout. All enter.
Lights up on a hanging body:
SVS

SVS has been lynched. She was Oscar Hammerstein II.
It is now Night 1. You have 24 Hours to send in your night PMs.

#733

Who killed Dom??

Poll ended at Thu Jun 18, 2015 10:19 pm

Bass The Clever
0
No votes
BirdwithTeeth11
0
No votes
Black Rock
0
No votes
Bullzeye
0
No votes
Cobalt
5
TinyBubbles (5), Scotty (6), Sloonei (12), timmer (17), nutella (20) 21%
Devin
0
No votes
DFaraday
0
No votes
Dragon D. Luffy
0
No votes
DREAM
0
No votes
Epignosis
0
No votes
Fingersplints
0
No votes
Golden
1
Canucklehead (11) 4%
Gumshoe
0
No votes
Hedgeowl
0
No votes
Long Con
6
Metalmarsh89 (2), Epignosis (8), Turnip Head (16), nijuukyugou (18), Gumshoe (21), Hedgeowl (22) 25%
MetalMarsh89
0
No votes
MovingPictures07
0
No votes
Neverwhere
0
No votes
nijuukyugou
0
No votes
Nutella
0
No votes
Scotty
0
No votes
sig
0
No votes
Sloonei
0
No votes
SVS
7
MovingPictures07 (9), DFaraday (10), S~V~S (13), Cobalt (14), sig (19), Long Con (23), Golden (24) 29%
Timmer
0
No votes
TinyBubbles
0
No votes
Turnip Head
0
No votes
XthAtGAm3RGuYX
1
XthAtGAm3RGuYX (15) 4%
Trick question, IT WAS LLAMA!!! [dead/non]
4
Dom (1), Heiots (3), Roxy (4), juliets (7) 17%

#734

I guess that elicits a minor woohoo.

#735

No woohoo from me. There is no evidence Hammerstein was a threat. Sorry SVS

#736

Quick question do the independents count as civilians against mafia or no? Some games I've played they do others they don't

#737

Not a civ. Goodie.

Long Con tomorrow? I had to help my sister put the kids to bed cuz she's really sick, and then I got a little distracted. Wasn't around towards the end, or I probably would have moved my vote back to LC.

Anybody have anything they want me to answer, go for it.

#738

nutella wrote:@ sloonei LC said he wouldn't be around (a factor in my picking Cobalt over him).

This caught my eye. Is this true? Because apparently he was waiting and watching the poll without posting as he swooped in last second to finish off SVS.

#739

sig wrote:Quick question do the independents count as civilians against mafia or no? Some games I've played they do others they don't

I doubt we know for sure, but I usually presume they can win with either faction or have some unique win condition unrelated to who else wins, unless they start killing people.

#740

Cobalt wrote:Not a civ. Goodie.

Long Con tomorrow? I had to help my sister put the kids to bed cuz she's really sick, and then I got a little distracted. Wasn't around towards the end, or I probably would have moved my vote back to LC.

Anybody have anything they want me to answer, go for it.

Please don't bring real life or sick people into this. I won't entertain it.

#741

Epignosis wrote:
Cobalt wrote:Not a civ. Goodie.

Long Con tomorrow? I had to help my sister put the kids to bed cuz she's really sick, and then I got a little distracted. Wasn't around towards the end, or I probably would have moved my vote back to LC.

Anybody have anything they want me to answer, go for it.
Please don't bring real life or sick people into this. I won't entertain it.

Ok. I wasn't around. End of story.

God damn.

#742

Gumshoe wrote:
nutella wrote:@ sloonei LC said he wouldn't be around (a factor in my picking Cobalt over him).
This caught my eye. Is this true? Because apparently he was waiting and watching the poll without posting as he swooped in last second to finish off SVS.

That's why I want him gone.

#743

Cobalt wrote:That said, I'm moving my vote to SVS for now, as it doesn't seem that Long Con is gaining any traction, Epi.

In fact, it almost looks like he's keeping under the radar so as not to draw too much attention to himself.

Did I call it or did I call it? As soon as he could put the final nail in someone else's coffin, he did.

#744

Cobalt wrote:
Gumshoe wrote:
nutella wrote:@ sloonei LC said he wouldn't be around (a factor in my picking Cobalt over him).
This caught my eye. Is this true? Because apparently he was waiting and watching the poll without posting as he swooped in last second to finish off SVS.
That's why I want him gone.

That's why? Not all the other reasons you gave earlier? If you still want him gone, why did you vote for SVS?

#745

Cobalt wrote:
Gumshoe wrote:
nutella wrote:@ sloonei LC said he wouldn't be around (a factor in my picking Cobalt over him).
This caught my eye. Is this true? Because apparently he was waiting and watching the poll without posting as he swooped in last second to finish off SVS.
That's why I want him gone.

Good job making that happen.

Except, according to you, you weren't even around when LC voted.

#746

Sloonei wrote:
Cobalt wrote:
Gumshoe wrote:
nutella wrote:@ sloonei LC said he wouldn't be around (a factor in my picking Cobalt over him).
This caught my eye. Is this true? Because apparently he was waiting and watching the poll without posting as he swooped in last second to finish off SVS.
That's why I want him gone.
That's why? Not all the other reasons you gave earlier? If you still want him gone, why did you vote for SVS?

That's why I want him gone ESPECIALLY now.

We didn't have Long Con voting SVS while not posting on the record earlier. Him doing that was the last straw for me now that I see how the votes played out.

Epignosis wrote:
Cobalt wrote:
Gumshoe wrote:
nutella wrote:@ sloonei LC said he wouldn't be around (a factor in my picking Cobalt over him).
This caught my eye. Is this true? Because apparently he was waiting and watching the poll without posting as he swooped in last second to finish off SVS.
That's why I want him gone.
Good job making that happen.

Except, according to you, you weren't even around when LC voted.

I wasn't around. But that's apparently what happened. I can fucking read.

#747

Epi, got something to say to me? I can practically TASTE your salt.

#748

LC definitely does need to answer for that vote. I've not been suspicious of him all game, but that was a bit peculiar.

#749

Epignosis wrote:I'm going to harp on this:

Long Con had three votes: MM, Cobalt, Epi

S~V~S had three votes: MP, nutella, DFaraday

Tied.

S~V~S votes her damn self.

Colby-Jack says the LC vote has lost traction, so he's changing his vote to S~V~S.

Ah, this must have something to do with it.

First of all, I'm named after a hue and an element, not a fucking cheese.

Secondly, I'm not used to people not voting until later in the phase. I'm used to most votes being laid out earlier and then adjusting them over time. To someone like me who is unfamiliar with the style here, it didn't look like LC had any traction when it turns out he did. I was late to the party, my bad. Sue me.

#750

Sloonei wrote:LC definitely does need to answer for that vote. I've not been suspicious of him all game, but that was a bit peculiar.

LC threw himself under the damn BUS with that vote tbh. I won't be stopped next phase. I want his head on a pike now.

Who killed MM? (not changeable)