Tree Mafia [GAME OVER]

#951

Epignosis wrote:
MacDougall wrote:I will be pushing for Epignosis's lynch unless something occurs to make it impossible at which point DFaraday would be a possible vote.

a2thezebra
MovingPictures07
Sorsha
Diiny
DrWilgy
FZ.
JaggedJimmyJay
DFaraday
motel room
TheFloyd73
Epignosis

This is where I am at right this second.
48 hours to reach a decision and your best move is to follow 3J again at the last minute?

So if you had control of my vote, where would you put it?

Epignosis you are making it sound like I am just blindly following Jimmy. This is incredibly disingenous. I called you bad multiple times yesterday. You have consistently been a bad guy read for me.

#952

Is that why JJJ made the drop from blue to orange, Mac? What else contributed?

Epi, sell me on why you think Mac is bad.

#953

MovingPictures07 wrote:
JaggedJimmyJay wrote:
MacDougall wrote:
JaggedJimmyJay wrote:Building entire mafia teams before any of them has died is almost always pointless. Matt F Dougall
You would say that.

You're the second person to call me Matt F today. I think it's pretty conniving tbh.

Jimmy let's lynch Epignosis then and reassess.
No offense intended if you're reading Matt. Sometimes wild theories make the person generating them look more town, so it's a positive even if the theories are wrong.

My vote's still there. I do admit that this one is a difficult choice. I didn't find any slam dunk baddies in my reviews.
JJJ, refer to this question from my response post to your FZ. ISO.

MovingPictures07 wrote:JJJ, thanks for this ISO of FZ.

Third, I'm intrigued that you called your analysis a "mixed bag", because it seemed to me like you gave her significantly more negative points than positive ones. What's making you hesitate to declare her a stronger read?
Thoughts?

The quantity of good/bad might not bear the appearance of balance, and I do agree that the bad did outweigh the good (I called her orange in a hypothetical rainbow). The thing that gives me doubt is her interaction with DrWilgy on Day 2. I don't understand much of anything about what she did re: Wilgy on Day 1, but her Day 2 vengeance vendetta seems genuine at points. She's a top three suspect though.

#954

Working on rainbow list now.

Linki w/ JJJ: Thanks for elaborating, that seems reasonable enough.

#955

Mac, I was kidding. I am not a robot, I am capable of humor.

#956

MovingPictures07 wrote:
MacDougall wrote:I will be pushing for Epignosis's lynch unless something occurs to make it impossible at which point DFaraday would be a possible vote.

a2thezebra
MovingPictures07
Sorsha
Diiny
DrWilgy
FZ.
JaggedJimmyJay
DFaraday
motel room
TheFloyd73
Epignosis

This is where I am at right this second.
Why am I more town than Sorsha?

Because you're alive. Dead people are just one step away from being undead zombies.

Lol but seriously yes my bad. I left her in there by accident.

#957

I want to remind the folks watching at home that Mac said I am responsible for people thinking Floyd is civilian, and that Floyd and I are teammates, yet he won't pull the trigger on Floyd first.

Be reminded that this is the second time MacDougall comes up with some bullshit reason the last hour to pile votes on someone.

Notice that there is a certain expectation regarding what civilians do and don't do (at least according to 3J and Mac)- that's an expectation I have never bought into, but they do. Yet notice how many times MacDougall has asked some variation of "Would I do that if I were scum?" or said "The easiest thing for me to do if I were scum..."

Marinate on that.

#958

Well the current course is a Wilgy lynch given Zebra's abitrary drop. I think FZ or Epignosis would be the best choices.

#959

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:Mac, I was kidding. I am not a robot, I am capable of humor.

Liar. You are a Mafia playing robot. I know you are hilarious but it's not usually forthcoming with 10 minutes left in a day with no stand out candidates.

#960

Epignosis wrote:I want to remind the folks watching at home that Mac said I am responsible for people thinking Floyd is civilian, and that Floyd and I are teammates, yet he won't pull the trigger on Floyd first.

Why should Floyd go first?

#961

MacDougall wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
MacDougall wrote:I will be pushing for Epignosis's lynch unless something occurs to make it impossible at which point DFaraday would be a possible vote.

a2thezebra
MovingPictures07
Sorsha
Diiny
DrWilgy
FZ.
JaggedJimmyJay
DFaraday
motel room
TheFloyd73
Epignosis

This is where I am at right this second.
48 hours to reach a decision and your best move is to follow 3J again at the last minute?

So if you had control of my vote, where would you put it?

Epignosis you are making it sound like I am just blindly following Jimmy. This is incredibly disingenous. I called you bad multiple times yesterday. You have consistently been a bad guy read for me.

No I'm not. I'm asking a question:

MACDOUGALL:

48 hours to reach a decision and your best move is to follow 3J again at the last minute?

(And you call everyone bad multiple times- doesn't mean a damn thing)

#962

Does Mac's reaction to enrique really read like bullshit to you?

#963

Day 2 EOD MP rainbow list:

No strong town reads

Epignosis
MacDougall
DrWilgy

Diiny
motel room

TheFloyd73
DFaraday
JaggedJimmyJay

a2thezebra
FZ.

No strong mafia reads

Players are NOT arranged alphabetically within groups; they are arranged by read.

Ugh, there was some movement, but my strong reads at both ends of the spectrum are gone. I'm not sure what to do with zebra; I didn't move her for now since I have no reason to, but I still find FZ. more suspicious than her.

#964

Epignosis wrote:I want to remind the folks watching at home that Mac said I am responsible for people thinking Floyd is civilian, and that Floyd and I are teammates, yet he won't pull the trigger on Floyd first.

Be reminded that this is the second time MacDougall comes up with some bullshit reason the last hour to pile votes on someone.

Notice that there is a certain expectation regarding what civilians do and don't do (at least according to 3J and Mac)- that's an expectation I have never bought into, but they do. Yet notice how many times MacDougall has asked some variation of "Would I do that if I were scum?" or said "The easiest thing for me to do if I were scum..."

Marinate on that.

Because you are more scum than him if that possibility is off the table, I have had a scum read of you since well before I made that tinfoil read. You know it, you're ignoring it to discredit me.

Hyperbole in the extreme. I am not "piling votes" on you. I have put one vote on. Also seeing enrique exactly imitate caught scum enrique in this game = bullshit reasons to you I guess.

Your third paragraph is words for the sake of words. I have no idea what you are trying to say.

I will leave my vote where it is. I suggest people follow.

#965

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I want to remind the folks watching at home that Mac said I am responsible for people thinking Floyd is civilian, and that Floyd and I are teammates, yet he won't pull the trigger on Floyd first.
Why should Floyd go first?

That's a bizarre question coming from you. You said I'm on a team with Floyd. Mac said I'm on a team with Floyd. I suspect Floyd. Yet you two seem okay lynching me even though I'm participating heavily and Floyd has 12 posts.

That doesn't look good for either of you.

#966

We need to agree on someone or Wilgy is dead.

#967

I don't like that Wilgy's in the lead. I'd be willing to move to DFaraday I guess, unless folks are willing to move to FZ. with me.

#968

MP, before the flip I want you to pick your single scummiest read. 'No strong mafia reads' is a horrible sentence

#969

Epignosis wrote:
JaggedJimmyJay wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I want to remind the folks watching at home that Mac said I am responsible for people thinking Floyd is civilian, and that Floyd and I are teammates, yet he won't pull the trigger on Floyd first.
Why should Floyd go first?
That's a bizarre question coming from you. You said I'm on a team with Floyd. Mac said I'm on a team with Floyd. I suspect Floyd. Yet you two seem okay lynching me even though I'm participating heavily and Floyd has 12 posts.

That doesn't look good for either of you.

You're full of shit. You're suspicious. Floyd isn't. The only thing working against him is his association with you.

#970

MacDougall wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I want to remind the folks watching at home that Mac said I am responsible for people thinking Floyd is civilian, and that Floyd and I are teammates, yet he won't pull the trigger on Floyd first.

Be reminded that this is the second time MacDougall comes up with some bullshit reason the last hour to pile votes on someone.

Notice that there is a certain expectation regarding what civilians do and don't do (at least according to 3J and Mac)- that's an expectation I have never bought into, but they do. Yet notice how many times MacDougall has asked some variation of "Would I do that if I were scum?" or said "The easiest thing for me to do if I were scum..."

Marinate on that.
Because you are more scum than him if that possibility is off the table, I have had a scum read of you since well before I made that tinfoil read. You know it, you're ignoring it to discredit me.

Hyperbole in the extreme. I am not "piling votes" on you. I have put one vote on. Also seeing enrique exactly imitate caught scum enrique in this game = bullshit reasons to you I guess.

Your third paragraph is words for the sake of words. I have no idea what you are trying to say.

I will leave my vote where it is. I suggest people follow.

There is no "more scum" or "less scum." You either are or aren't. And if you had a read of me of that nature, you would have pursued it. You didn't. You were in here griping about motel room all damn day.

You deserve to be discredited.

#971

Moving to FZ

Don't want to lynch Doc

#972

Diiny wrote:MP, before the flip I want you to pick your single scummiest read. 'No strong mafia reads' is a horrible sentence

FZ.

Just like before, I only am indicating that I feel slightly better about her, hence her ascension to "moderate" read. I just want to express my personal assessment of the strength of each read to the best of my ability.

#973

Diiny wrote:Does Mac's reaction to enrique really read like bullshit to you?

A better questions would be does it read like bullshit to you, or to MP, or to anyone not named Epignosis. And if not then why is Epignosis bringing it up at all when he isn't dumb.

Linki: I pursued various scum reads Epignosis. I have multiple scum reads. Which is normal. Don't try to pretend I am playing at anything. It's not believable.

#974

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
JaggedJimmyJay wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I want to remind the folks watching at home that Mac said I am responsible for people thinking Floyd is civilian, and that Floyd and I are teammates, yet he won't pull the trigger on Floyd first.
Why should Floyd go first?
That's a bizarre question coming from you. You said I'm on a team with Floyd. Mac said I'm on a team with Floyd. I suspect Floyd. Yet you two seem okay lynching me even though I'm participating heavily and Floyd has 12 posts.

That doesn't look good for either of you.
You're full of shit. You're suspicious. Floyd isn't. The only thing working against him is his association with you.

Bullshit. You don't even believe the things you are saying.

#975

I thought that question implied that I didn't, unless you're asking if it was BS to me rhetorically.

#976

Epignosis wrote:
JaggedJimmyJay wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
JaggedJimmyJay wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I want to remind the folks watching at home that Mac said I am responsible for people thinking Floyd is civilian, and that Floyd and I are teammates, yet he won't pull the trigger on Floyd first.
Why should Floyd go first?
That's a bizarre question coming from you. You said I'm on a team with Floyd. Mac said I'm on a team with Floyd. I suspect Floyd. Yet you two seem okay lynching me even though I'm participating heavily and Floyd has 12 posts.

That doesn't look good for either of you.
You're full of shit. You're suspicious. Floyd isn't. The only thing working against him is his association with you.
Bullshit. You don't even believe the things you are saying.

I absolutely do.

#977

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
JaggedJimmyJay wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
JaggedJimmyJay wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I want to remind the folks watching at home that Mac said I am responsible for people thinking Floyd is civilian, and that Floyd and I are teammates, yet he won't pull the trigger on Floyd first.
Why should Floyd go first?
That's a bizarre question coming from you. You said I'm on a team with Floyd. Mac said I'm on a team with Floyd. I suspect Floyd. Yet you two seem okay lynching me even though I'm participating heavily and Floyd has 12 posts.

That doesn't look good for either of you.
You're full of shit. You're suspicious. Floyd isn't. The only thing working against him is his association with you.
Bullshit. You don't even believe the things you are saying.
I absolutely do.

Then come get some.

#978

Ugh. Well, here's hoping the Wilgy voters are right, though I don't feel good about this.

#979

For those of you who like trees AND beer, this is one of the best IPA's I've had.

This is also an advertisement for Craft Beer Mafia, coming soon to a Syndicate near you.

#980

NIGHT 2

DrWilgy has been lynched. He was Spruce.

And he was ...

Spoiler: show

It is now Night 2. You have until Saturday, 9:00 PM EST to submit any Night Actions, approximately 24 hours.

You are permitted ONE (1) reaction post to the lynch. No otherwise thread chatter is permitted.

#981

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:Moving to FZ

Don't want to lynch Doc

TBH I totally expected you to take your vote off Epignosis. You made him unlynchable and you've now gone to red and my argument has even more credibility. If you wanted to save Doc, you could have voted for Diiny. See you tomorrow scumboy.

#982

FLIP.

I feel good about Wilgy but not my fellow wilgy voters.

Linki: I feel incredibly bad

#983

*prolonged fart noise*

Good night y'all.

#984

RIP Wilgy.

#985

#986

DAY 2

Who felled Sorsha?

Poll ended at Fri Dec 04, 2015 6:04 pm

a2thezebra
0
No votes

DFaraday
1
motel room (3)
7%

Diiny
2
TheFloyd73 (5), DrWilgy (8)
13%

DrWilgy
3
Diiny (6), FZ. (9), a2thezebra (12)
20%

Epignosis
1
MacDougall (13)
7%

FZ.
2
MovingPictures07 (11), JaggedJimmyJay (15)
13%

JaggedJimmyJay
0
No votes

MacDougall
1
Epignosis (14)
7%

motel room
0
No votes

MovingPictures07
0
No votes

TheFloyd73
0
No votes

Ricochet (Hosts/Nons/DeadHeads)
5
Metalmarsh89 (1), Enrique (2), HamburgerBoy (4), Golden (7), Turnip Head (10)
33%

Total votes : 15

#987

Good bye friends.. Good luck!

#988

DAY 3

DFaraday has been nightkilled. he was Alder.

And he was ...

Spoiler: show

It is now Day 3. You have 48 hours to lynch a Feller.

#989

Sig is replacing FZ.

#990

SO hello hello I have an epicly (is that a word) big post since I'm FZ and have the role info ignore me saying FZ is bad I'm not going through my post to edit it since it isright know 15 pages long with 6 more in game pages to go. I will summarize it of course and a good portion is quotes, but I think i've got the scum team down, getting FZ role is acutully very helpful orginally I was thinking JJJ/FZ/Diiny with FZ gone either Mac/Floyd/Motel

#991

First thing first when I replace in I make it as realistic as possibly and use any knowledge I have from kills and lynched, I didn't know SOrsha was cleared by Enrique until I read the post and almost all my posts were done in a realtime sense, I find it is the best way to play as a replacement if the thread isn't to big. I added some questions into my post as I went, and atpoints got rather heated, but I think overall I got some very good reads from my post from a different perspective. I have six more pages to read then I will make my master post.

#992

We're getting dangerously close to lylo here.

#993

Welcome Sig

Thank you Sig!

Almost done three more pages to go I'm skimming at this point.

#994

A note from your host, sig was originally going to sub in for DFaraday, but DFarday was nightkilled. So I used my magical hosting powers to assign sig to FZ.'s role because she asked to be replaced last night.

This change is not indicative of alignment, only of my own convenience.

#995

Metalmarsh89 wrote:For anyone who cares, sig was originally going to sub in for DFaraday, but DFarday was nightkilled. So I used my magical hosting powers to assign sig to FZ.'s role because she asked to be replaced last night.

This change is not indicative of alignment, only of my own convenience.

Jolly good job host! Magnificent if I must say!

#996

Wilgy, I suppose this makes us even from Pet Sounds.

#997

Quick thought Mac is calling Floyd inexperienced, I disagree compared to some of you yes, but if we are comparing like that then I'm also inexperenced and should be able to get out of lynched/posting. He has played what four games know? Two as scum I believe? If this is the case then he has two game including his first with more experienced players to help him and answer questions and then another scum game same thing and two civ games. No cutting slack for the "nooby" especially since this isn't game 1 for him. Also for the BTSC thought ik this for afact since my first game I was a lover and having a chat was helpful and I'd think a mafia chat was extra helpful since more then one player to help you and have a vested interest in you.

#998

Ewwww Epi teaches English reason enough to lynch him imo

#999

a2thezebra wrote:Wilgy, I suppose this makes us even from Pet Sounds.

Just stay beautiful qt pie *Wink* ~<3

#1000

DrWilgy wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:Wilgy, I suppose this makes us even from Pet Sounds.
Just stay beautiful qt pie *Wink* ~<3

You too handsome

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

What say you?