Tree Mafia [GAME OVER]

#1201

I have 50% shot at being right at this point. No one will lynch Floyd. So motel room it is.

#1202

Epignosis wrote:I have 50% shot at being right at this point. No one will lynch Floyd. So motel room it is.

I could be convinced to lynch Floyd man. He's totally not trying at all. Hell it'd be less anxious because if we're wrong we can just blame him.

#1203

MacDougall wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I have 50% shot at being right at this point. No one will lynch Floyd. So motel room it is.
I could be convinced to lynch Floyd man. He's totally not trying at all. Hell it'd be less anxious because if we're wrong we can just blame him.

U bad?

#1204

MacDougall wrote:So lylo huh. This is pretty fucked hahaha.

No he said we weren't at lylo, that means we have another phase before that. I need to think some things over I really thought 3J was mafia.

#1205

Epignosis wrote:
MacDougall wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I have 50% shot at being right at this point. No one will lynch Floyd. So motel room it is.
I could be convinced to lynch Floyd man. He's totally not trying at all. Hell it'd be less anxious because if we're wrong we can just blame him.
U bad?

No just honest lol.

#1206

MacDougall wrote:
Epignosis wrote:And I'm voting motel room.
Me too.

No to both of you im not scum get in the sea

Its busy at work today but this being potentially lylo i'll be back to fight cos I'm not keen on being the goat that gets lynched and loses it for town. Again.

#1207

motel room wrote:
MacDougall wrote:
Epignosis wrote:And I'm voting motel room.
Me too.
No to both of you im not scum get in the sea

Its busy at work today but this being potentially lylo i'll be back to fight cos I'm not keen on being the goat that gets lynched and loses it for town. Again.

You sound honest. Changing my vote.

#1208

sig wrote:
TheFloyd73 wrote:
Diiny wrote: Floyd, say something game relevant please
Because this is surely game relevant.

Diiny wrote:If a tree wins a poll in the forest but nobody is around to hear it, does it get lynched?
Dinny
I don’t understand this post at all. Youranswer to Dinny asking you to make a game post is to give a sarcastic answer and vote for him?

You're kidding, right? I gave a more detailed reason to vote for Diiny than some players (both in this game and in other games).

For example:

a2thezebra wrote:
Diiny wrote:If a tree wins a poll in the forest but nobody is around to hear it, does it get lynched?
I don't know, Diiny.

I'm not pinging Zebra as scum, but I clarifying that voting in this way is alright with some players, but not me apparently.

sig wrote:Quick thought Mac is calling Floyd inexperienced, I disagree compared to some of you yes, but if we are comparing like that then I'm also inexperenced and should be able to get out of lynched/posting.

Have I ever mentioned that I should get out of being lynched? I understand that even with my lack of skill, if I get lynched, wether it's day one or day twelve, it's the way of the game. What the fuck are you implying?

Diiny wrote:
TheFloyd73 wrote:Diiny
This man has voted for me three times. Once for alleged hypocrisy. Once for a self preservation vote despite me explaining to him why townies self preserve. And here again. Who knows why?

Floyd, why don't you explain your votes? Why do you have so little content on anyone else? Why are you so reluctant to play mafia? Don't give me anything about you being bad at mafia, because you're not incapable of explaining yourself. I'd be willing to believe you were a struggling townie if I saw any real struggle or drive from you to grapple with the game.

Why doesn't everyone explain their votes? When did I ever vote for you as self preservation? I've voted for you again because it's simple, you're scum.

I'm not reluctant to play Mafia, have I not explained this before?

What is that meant to mean?

Isn't it funny that Diiny has voted for the three civilians that have been lynched?

MovingPictures07 wrote:Day 2 EOD MP rainbow list:

No strong town reads

Epignosis
MacDougall
DrWilgy

Diiny
motel room

TheFloyd73
DFaraday
JaggedJimmyJay

a2thezebra
FZ.

No strong mafia reads

Players are NOT arranged alphabetically within groups; they are arranged by read.

Ugh, there was some movement, but my strong reads at both ends of the spectrum are gone. I'm not sure what to do with zebra; I didn't move her for now since I have no reason to, but I still find FZ. more suspicious than her.

MP's ranked Zebra the lowest out of anyone. This was day two. Plus, MP's comment after Triple J was lynched (whom he voted for, with pretty good intent) was less than sentimental.

MovingPictures07 wrote:Well, that sucks ass. RIP JJJ.

In other news for those of you who aren't in Star Wars, I destroyed my final.

does anyone reckon Mp might be scum?

I loathe these long posts, I agree with Epi on that one.

#1209

Uh perhaps also quote where yours was more detailed than theirs. You only quoted a blatant no u.

#1210

Okay, this sucks. I'm going to reevaluate my suspicions completely, since with zebra's death I was obviously wrong about her.

Going to be grading all of my students' final exams, but then I'm free to analyze to my heart's content.

#1211

TheFloyd73 wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:
Diiny wrote:If a tree wins a poll in the forest but nobody is around to hear it, does it get lynched?
I don't know, Diiny.
I'm not pinging Zebra as scum, but I clarifying that voting in this way is alright with some players, but not me apparently]

Gee I hope not.

#1212

Epignosis wrote:I have 50% shot at being right at this point. No one will lynch Floyd. So motel room it is.

I've thought Floyd was bad for a while, I could vote him. He's a better choice than motel.

#1213

MacDougall wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I have 50% shot at being right at this point. No one will lynch Floyd. So motel room it is.
If we're wrong we can just blame him.

I laughed, but I do want to know how strong your read of floyd is.

#1214

Diiny wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I have 50% shot at being right at this point. No one will lynch Floyd. So motel room it is.
I've thought Floyd was bad for a while, I could vote him. He's a better choice than motel.

Why is he a better choice than motel room?

#1215

TheFloyd73 wrote:
sig wrote:
TheFloyd73 wrote:
Diiny wrote: Floyd, say something game relevant please
Because this is surely game relevant.

Diiny wrote:If a tree wins a poll in the forest but nobody is around to hear it, does it get lynched?
Dinny
I don’t understand this post at all. Youranswer to Dinny asking you to make a game post is to give a sarcastic answer and vote for him?
You're kidding, right? I gave a more detailed reason to vote for Diiny than some players (both in this game and in other games).

For example:
a2thezebra wrote:
Diiny wrote:If a tree wins a poll in the forest but nobody is around to hear it, does it get lynched?
I don't know, Diiny.
I'm not pinging Zebra as scum, but I clarifying that voting in this way is alright with some players, but not me apparently.

You voted for realises. Zebra was baiting. If I believed that Zebra's vote for me was genuine and designed to stay there instead of a regular ol' day 1 shitfling I would've taken issue. You gave a horrible reason and stuck with it despite it being proven wrong. Also lmao at italics. Stop trying to deflect from the valid accusations that your votes are shallow and bad and actually attempt to refute them please.

Diiny wrote:
TheFloyd73 wrote:Diiny
This man has voted for me three times. Once for alleged hypocrisy. Once for a self preservation vote despite me explaining to him why townies self preserve. And here again. Who knows why?

Floyd, why don't you explain your votes? Why do you have so little content on anyone else? Why are you so reluctant to play mafia? Don't give me anything about you being bad at mafia, because you're not incapable of explaining yourself. I'd be willing to believe you were a struggling townie if I saw any real struggle or drive from you to grapple with the game.
Why doesn't everyone explain their votes? When did I ever vote for you as self preservation? I've voted for you again because it's simple, you're scum.

I'm not reluctant to play Mafia, have I not explained this before?

What is that meant to mean?

Isn't it funny that Diiny has voted for the three civilians that have been lynched?

Your votes require explanation. Stop deflecting and do it. If you think there's any scummy votes that require explanation from anyone still alive, point them out, please. AFTERWARDS.

You never voted for me in self preservation. You voted for me for voting Enrique, and THAT was a self preservation vote. Remember? I'm not scum. floyd, and you've yet to explain properly why you think I am. For bonus points, try to do it without piggybacking. Yes, I've voted for three townies. Well done. I've voted for Wilgy because I thought he was scum. So did other townies. I've HAD to vote for the other two townies, one of whom (JJJ) I actually thought was town to save my own skin because YOU'VE put me in a situation when I have to with your stupid votes.

You've attempted to justify not playing mafia because you're new etc. Should that give you any kind of pass for your scummy behaviour? No, and certainly not at this stage.

The green means exactly what it means. It's as if you haven't read the thread half of the time. You barely post, and when you do you deflect, misstate and don't make me feel any better about you.

I'm going to look at MP and see if you've just picked another player to deflect to or if you actually are playing mafia.

#1216

Epignosis wrote:
Diiny wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I have 50% shot at being right at this point. No one will lynch Floyd. So motel room it is.
I've thought Floyd was bad for a while, I could vote him. He's a better choice than motel.
Why is he a better choice than motel room?

The stuff that looks bad about aokiji floyd does worse in my book. aokiji has more than a near-insignificant amount of content in his posts.

#1217

sig wrote:
MacDougall wrote:So lylo huh. This is pretty fucked hahaha.
No he said we weren't at lylo, that means we have another phase before that. I need to think some things over I really thought 3J was mafia.

We don't have another round after this one if we mislynch, I don't think. Do we? I think it's just because of the 'hypothetical' doctor thing which means that there's a chance the doc could block the NK if they bother enough to exist

#1218

TheFloyd73 wrote: MP's ranked Zebra the lowest out of anyone. This was day two.

I want to hear from you why this makes him bad, please.

#1219

Diiny wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
Diiny wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I have 50% shot at being right at this point. No one will lynch Floyd. So motel room it is.
I've thought Floyd was bad for a while, I could vote him. He's a better choice than motel.
Why is he a better choice than motel room?
The stuff that looks bad about aokiji floyd does worse in my book. aokiji has more than a near-insignificant amount of content in his posts.

What stuff? And how does a near-insignificant amount of content make anyone bad?

#1220

Floyd was online when I left. No comment? Alright, bro.

Epignosis wrote:
Diiny wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
Diiny wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I have 50% shot at being right at this point. No one will lynch Floyd. So motel room it is.
I've thought Floyd was bad for a while, I could vote him. He's a better choice than motel.
Why is he a better choice than motel room?
The stuff that looks bad about aokiji floyd does worse in my book. aokiji has more than a near-insignificant amount of content in his posts.
What stuff? And how does a near-insignificant amount of content make anyone bad?

Content as opposed to bullshit, of which he has enough. But anyway I do think there's a point when a small amount of content becomes suspicious; moreso when it isn't well explained, justified, and when you get the feeling that the guy whose content it is just wants to survive another day and doesn't engage with the thread. He's attempted to justify it by saying he's inexperienced and bad etc. Plus, if that were the case I think I'd see a different floyd. A floyd who wants to get better and engages with the thread but asks lots of questions. I think that whole confession was just to get some pressure off of him because iirc he used that point in a reply to a question of mine which he didn't answer.

I've accused aokiji of coasting as well, but it's nothing like floyd. His posts have substance and they engage with the thread. He brings things up that he doesn't like. It just feels like sometimes he's not as involved as he could be while it's constant with floyd and to a much bigger degree.

Why are you voting motel over floyd?

#1221

MovingPictures07 wrote:I'm going to reevaluate my suspicions completely

Sloonei said this in Moomin and it pinged me. He was scum.

Jay said this in talking heads iirc and he was town.

MP, do you 'read reset' a lot/have you done so before? Because it pings me out when people say that. It's so easy for scum to 'reset' and get read fluidity again, and that's particularly troublesome in lylo.

#1222

My vote's on floyd. This guy has no business being alive.

#1223

Diiny wrote:Why are you voting motel over floyd?

I'm not.

#1224

Kek, my bad. Why aren't you keen on floyd anymore? I seem to recall a fascination with typing the word floyd in bold on your part

#1225

And supposing you're not baiting me right now, why do you want to throw this game away to type the word diiny in bold

#1226

Diiny
3
TheFloyd73 (4), Enrique (5), a2thezebra (8)
19%

Enrique
5
JaggedJimmyJay (11), DrWilgy (12), MovingPictures07 (13), MacDougall (15), Diiny (16)
31%

Epignosis
1
sig (10)
6%

sig
2
motel room (6), Sorsha (7)
13%

TheFloyd73
1
Epignosis (3)
6%

++++

DFaraday
1
motel room (3)
7%

Diiny
2
TheFloyd73 (5), DrWilgy (8)
13%

DrWilgy
3
Diiny (6), sig (9), a2thezebra (12)
20%

Epignosis
1
MacDougall (13)
7%

sig
2
MovingPictures07 (11), JaggedJimmyJay (15)
13%

MacDougall
1
Epignosis (14)
7%

++++

Diiny
4
a2thezebra (2), TheFloyd73 (5), JaggedJimmyJay (11), motel room (12)
31%

JaggedJimmyJay
5
sig (3), MovingPictures07 (4), Epignosis (6), MacDougall (7), Diiny (13)
38%

++++

On two of three occasions, MP and MacDougall both voted in a way that could keep Diiny from being lynched.

Ordinarily, one might think Mafia MP would throw Diiny under the bus, but without knowing the state of the existence of a doctor, the Mafia would surmise that lynching 3J would put them on the fast track to the final stage.

Four confirmed civilians have voted Diiny over the span of three Days.

TheFloyd73 has voted Diiny early every Day. I am struggling to understand how Floyd, with a team, would continue to do that- because if we're going by Talking Heads, I did not see that kind of voting from him. For that reason, and the fact that 3J ended up civilian, I don't see Floyd being on a team. I see him coasting in a genuine manner.

More later. Supper and band practice now.

#1227

I'm bad because people think I'm bad? Civilians vote for other civilians. It's probably why I'm alive right now. Why do you think I'm bad based on my content? Because this is lylo, and I'm going to be a bit pissed off if you vote for me and end up losing town this game without even reading my content.

What prevented you from thinking that floyd was 'coasting in a genuine manner' when you saw him as scummy enough that you were demanding his lynch exclusively? Floyd's votes last game weren't anything to write home about either. He had a team then. They weren't as disgustingly tunnely but they were just as shallow and meaningless.

#1228

sig wrote:
MacDougall wrote:So lylo huh. This is pretty fucked hahaha.
No he said we weren't at lylo, that means we have another phase before that. I need to think some things over I really thought 3J was mafia.

It's basically lylo ffs.

#1229

Epignosis wrote:I have 50% shot at being right at this point. No one will lynch Floyd. So motel room it is.

Where did you pull this percentage from? Especially now that I see your vote is elsewhere anyway.

Also, why do you think no one will lynch Floyd?

#1230

a townie at this point has a 50% chance of voting for scum if they don't vote for themselves is the idea I think

#1231

TheFloyd73 wrote:Why doesn't everyone explain their votes? When did I ever vote for you as self preservation? I've voted for you again because it's simple, you're scum.

^ @Diiny, then

TheFloyd73 wrote:does anyone reckon Mp might be scum?

You seem dead certain that Diiny is scum but floating the idea at no one in particular that MP might be scum based off a isolated rainbow MP did on Day 2 where he puts zebra low. I remember doing a thing like this as scum when I was newer because you can be rock solid on a scum read when you Know you're right but then have to drum up a case so that it looks like you have more than one in the works. Like if anyone is accusing you of not shifting your reads since page 2.

i agree Diiny seems scummy but why are you so sure? I don't know what your reason is. Humour me here

#1232

Diiny wrote:a townie at this point has a 50% chance of voting for scum if they don't vote for themselves is the idea I think

I see.

Why are you answering for him?

#1233

i dont trust my read of MP right now he feels like a blind spot

#1234

Diiny wrote:Civilians vote for other civilians. It's probably why I'm alive right now.

what

#1235

motel room wrote:
Diiny wrote:a townie at this point has a 50% chance of voting for scum if they don't vote for themselves is the idea I think
I see.

Why are you answering for him?

because it's obvious

#1236

motel room wrote:
Diiny wrote:Civilians vote for other civilians. It's probably why I'm alive right now.
what

I assume I've not been NK'd because people suspect me and have voted for me and scum hope they will again. What's not to get?

#1237

Lynch Floyd. It's our best chance at continuing the game. If he turns out to be a civilian well that's tough.

#1238

Epignosis wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:I would prefer a Diiny lynch over JJJ because I think that JJJ is more likely to be misunderstood (and extremely unlucky) this game, but I'm content with either lynch and I'm willing to switch to JJJ if there's a CFD on a player I'm less confident about than the two currently leading the votes.
I don't see how 3J is more likely to be misunderstood. Diiny has been in the hot seat for a while now. I understand 3J a hell of a lot better than I understand Diiny. You were, after all, comfortable enough a moment ago to call 3J Diiny's teammate, yet you'd only switch to 3J under certain circumstances?

That has me wondering about you now.

page later

Epignosis wrote: On two of three occasions, MP and MacDougall both voted in a way that could keep Diiny from being lynched.

Ordinarily, one might think Mafia MP would throw Diiny under the bus, but without knowing the state of the existence of a doctor, the Mafia would surmise that lynching 3J would put them on the fast track to the final stage.

Four confirmed civilians have voted Diiny over the span of three Days.

TheFloyd73 has voted Diiny early every Day. I am struggling to understand how Floyd, with a team, would continue to do that- because if we're going by Talking Heads, I did not see that kind of voting from him. For that reason, and the fact that 3J ended up civilian, I don't see Floyd being on a team. I see him coasting in a genuine manner.

More later. Supper and band practice now.

fucking cirque du soleil. And none of that second part is actually anti-Diiny. It's a defence of Floyd and a soft suggestion of a MP\Mac suspicion.

Epi rising.

#1239

Epi started the day lamenting the fact that nobody would lynch Floyd with him and now we have two voters on Floyd and he is not one of them. Perhaps he wasn't being honest about his feelings on Floyd at all.

#1240

MacDougall wrote:Lynch Floyd. It's our best chance at continuing the game. If he turns out to be a civilian well that's tough.

maybe later

Epi

#1241

motel room wrote:
MacDougall wrote:Lynch Floyd. It's our best chance at continuing the game. If he turns out to be a civilian well that's tough.
maybe later

Epi

Hmmm

#1242

You just found a really round about way to put your vote on someone who is almost certain not to get lynched. You are 100% definitely bad.

#1243

Which of them are you trying to save though...

#1244

I think Diiny. So there's my vote.

#1245

MacDougall wrote:You just found a really round about way to put your vote on someone who is almost certain not to get lynched. You are 100% definitely bad.

why is he not getting lynched? and why do you think its staying there? sometimes you just have to try a thing

#1246

motel room wrote:
MacDougall wrote:You just found a really round about way to put your vote on someone who is almost certain not to get lynched. You are 100% definitely bad.
why is he not getting lynched? and why do you think its staying there? sometimes you just have to try a thing

There's an hour left, 2 other players on 2 votes and you put your vote on Epignosis. Bad look. I'd love to lynch you but I'm not voting you right now because there's nobody else here to vote you with me. I think we owe it to the many dead civilians to lynch Diiny anyway. He live too long.

#1247

There's about 24 hours left

#1248

Diiny wrote:
TheFloyd73 wrote: MP's ranked Zebra the lowest out of anyone. This was day two.
I want to hear from you why this makes him bad, please.

I saw no one else with any motivation for Zebra to be exterminated or lynched. I'm not claiming for certain MP is scum, it's only a theory that I've created.

#1249

motel room wrote:There's about 24 hours left

I like that aokiji is exploring his options. this is LYLO. There's no reason not to give everyone a bit of pressure for anything that bugs you. Although yeah I'd be mad if it was as near the deadline as you thought

#1250

TheFloyd73 wrote:
Diiny wrote:
TheFloyd73 wrote: MP's ranked Zebra the lowest out of anyone. This was day two.
I want to hear from you why this makes him bad, please.
I saw no one else with any motivation for Zebra to be exterminated or lynched. I'm not claiming for certain MP is scum, it's only a theory that I've created.

Why does having someone as a suspect that nobody else does make someone bad

What say you?