Tree Mafia [GAME OVER]

[motel room]

How could you say that it's a scum win with one vote on you already while at the same time accusing me of being bad?

If I'm bad, you only need to accuse Floyd that I'm bad and the scum haven't won.



Yahhhhhhhh.

Because that's one locked in vote with days worth of you "tunnelling" me behind it. Obviously we went into this day with me as the main lynch candidate. Hence scum win.

[MacDougall]

motel if you are a civ, and it's possible though very unlikely, you put your vote on the wrong wagon on a previous lylo day and it was only Floyd not showing up that didn't lose us the game on that day anyway.

If you are a civ, that sucks but I was never voting for anyone but you today.

[TheFloyd73]

Nah it's gotta be motel room, but there is a small niggle. It's small but it's there. How did Floyd get so good at reading the scum?

Diiny made a scum slip here:

Floyd, say something game relevant please

Because this is surely game relevant.

If a tree wins a poll in the forest but nobody is around to hear it, does it get lynched?

Dinny

Plus, he also posted this:

You put it on yourself, man. I have no idea what you've got against me, but whatever it is, just share it.

Am I not permitted to call you Epi? Give me a reason not to.

My statement refers to he fact that pointed out that Mac gone against his word but you still want me gone.

this is floyd's best post.

I wouldn't have been happy with anything but a similar response thing to Epi's comment about being called Epi, and he questions epi's stance on him as you'd expect. I'd like to see a bit more ferocity, but going on a per-post makes it better. Not that I'm condoning his low post count and that he seems to still be focusing almost entirely on himself. I doubt he'd have questioned epi if he wasn't crusading against him.

Still a scum read.

The text highlighted in blue is completely out of Diiny's normal style. If anything, it's sounds more like something Triple J would say.

Anyway, with MP, I was perplexed with Zebra's extermination, where I couldn't find anyone to show any reason to have Zebra lynched. MP's rainbow displaying Zebra towards the bottom was a very minor detail and I almost passed it off as nothing. But I did feel it was something I should express.

Now, with Sig's recent untimely death, it appears that whoever the remaining scum is, they very intelligently thought through the consequences of a certain lynch.

Mac and Motel clearly show convincing statuses upon one another, leading myself, personally to believe that one or the other is scum. If one of the two mentioned was night killed, myself and Sig would have voted for the remaining player.

Night killing me would have brought more-experienced Sig in my seat of contention (with Mac and Motel at one another) of the last remaining vote.

Night killing Sig would have more manipulative me in this seat.

Mac's ordering towards me can either express two things:
1. He's town with desperation to win (which he has shown in other games).
2. He's scum trying to take advantage of me for a scum win.

Motel is, at this stage, trying to defend himself, no matter what his role is.

Reading both of you're plays this game now.

[TheFloyd73]

In the polls thread, there's no Day 3. Why's that Marsh?

[MacDougall]

Floyd put your vote on motel room.

Need I remind you that motel room voted against the Diiny wagon on lylo day. There's no alternative here. If I was the bad guy I'd have changed my vote to Epi on that day and it would have been a scum win.

Think about it.

[MacDougall]

If you are scum, put us out of our misery and put your vote on motel room.

It seems like you're trying to figure it out so that means you're a civ because there's nothing else to do but vote motel if you're bad.

Since you are a civilian, read my posts against motel if you have to. I've read him bad for a long portion of the game, and have made cases against him. My opinion of him has been consistent. Motel killed sig instead of us because he wanted to convince me that you were bad, not the other way around. He can't possibly convince you that I am bad because he has no case against me at all except for the half cocked bullshit he's spouted in the last hour out of desperation. I've read him scum with genuine casing for days and days. Whereas you saw yourself that I had questions about your alignment even today, but I still had to vote for him because I'd read it that way for days and he put his vote on Epi on the day that lynching Epi wins the scum the game.

[Marmot]

In the polls thread, there's no Day 3. Why's that Marsh?

Sorry about this, I will attempt to reconstruct it.

[MacDougall]

Hell look at the way I interacted with MP yesterday. Does that look like a scum talking to scum to you?

[motel room]

Floyd put your vote on motel room.

Need I remind you that motel room voted against the Diiny wagon on lylo day. There's no alternative here. If I was the bad guy I'd have changed my vote to Epi on that day and it would have been a scum win.

Think about it.

You weren't around either. You were just as likely to be scum as Floyd from this point and I went into Day whatever it was thinking that cos I knew there was a busser on the Diiny wagon.

Mac your reason for voting Diiny that day was that weird elaborate thing where you thought I was avoiding the main lynch wagons (Diiny or Floyd) so you went with Diiny over Floyd. But then after being told there was still a day left you had 24 hours to change your vote but didn't

Yeah sorry that certainly changes things.

Then again I have had a motel room neg read forever.

I have to admit I dunno shit.

but then later used it as an example of your towniness

Me - I voted early for the confirmed scum on a day that if I simply voted for Epignosis (who I had scum read more than I had read Diiny tbh so I could have easily done so), the scum would have won the game.

Diiny and MP jumped on my Epi lynch late in the day. There's no evidence of you in the thread. You just weren't around to switch off him before EOD.

[Marmot]

DAY 5

Who chopped Epignosis down?

Poll ended at Mon Dec 14, 2015 6:56 pm

MacDougall
0
No votes

motel room
1
MovingPictures07 (8)
8%

MovingPictures07
4
motel room (6), TheFloyd73 (7), MacDougall (9), sig (10)
33%

sig
0
No votes

TheFloyd73
0
No votes

Epignosis (Hosts and stuff)
7
Metalmarsh89 (1), a2thezebra (2), HamburgerBoy (3), Enrique (4), S~V~S (5), Turnip Head (11), Epignosis (12)
58%


Total votes : 12

[MacDougall]

Floyd put your vote on motel room.

Need I remind you that motel room voted against the Diiny wagon on lylo day. There's no alternative here. If I was the bad guy I'd have changed my vote to Epi on that day and it would have been a scum win.

Think about it.

You weren't around either. You were just as likely to be scum as Floyd from this point and I went into Day whatever it was thinking that cos I knew there was a busser on the Diiny wagon.

Mac your reason for voting Diiny that day was that weird elaborate thing where you thought I was avoiding the main lynch wagons (Diiny or Floyd) so you went with Diiny over Floyd. But then after being told there was still a day left you had 24 hours to change your vote but didn't

Yeah sorry that certainly changes things.

Then again I have had a motel room neg read forever.

I have to admit I dunno shit.

but then later used it as an example of your towniness

Me - I voted early for the confirmed scum on a day that if I simply voted for Epignosis (who I had scum read more than I had read Diiny tbh so I could have easily done so), the scum would have won the game.

Diiny and MP jumped on my Epi lynch late in the day. There's no evidence of you in the thread. You just weren't around to switch off him before EOD.

I was here posting in other games. You can check the timestamps in Star Wars if you want.

It should be obvious to you that Floyd is civ since he hasn't voted you yet motel. So why isn't your vote on me already?

Funny that you only just now, when you have no other alternative, are finding reasons to doubt my alignment.

[TheFloyd73]

Motel Room

Mac's extroverted desperation is what gets me and it's not out of character. If Motel Room was town, he'd be doing the same.

Spoiler: show

If Mac is scum, he's played very well.

[MacDougall]

Aokiji, we've played many times on RYM.

Tell me, do you think I am the kind of scum player to not take the opportunity to lynch a civ at the last minute to win a game?

Have I ever missed an opportunity to do that?

Isn't that actually one of my trademarks?

[motel room]

uh is that it then?

[Marmot]

Well now I'm not going to bother.

Post incoming.

[TheFloyd73]

uh is that it then?

Too calm of a response to my vote.
I think I've made the right decision.

[motel room]

uh is that it then?

Too calm of a response to my vote.
I think I've made the right decision.

yeah mate you did

[MacDougall]

Congrats on the win either way Floyd.

[TheFloyd73]

Good game, well done everyone.

[MacDougall]

uh is that it then?

Too calm of a response to my vote.
I think I've made the right decision.

yeah mate you did

Really!? No fooling.

Kick ass. Well done Floyd.

[Marmot]

GAME OVER

motel room has been lynched. He was Sequoia.

And he was ...

Spoiler: show

Mafia. His real role is actually Hatchet.

Mafia has been eliminated, Hatchet, Axe, and Saw. The Civilians have won.

Congratulations to a2thezebra, Dfaraday, DrWilgy, Enrique, Epignosis, JaggedJimmyJay, MacDougall, sig, Sorsha, TheFloyd73 on the win.


Also, thank you everyone for playing. It's been a pleasure.

[TheFloyd73]

uh is that it then?

Too calm of a response to my vote.
I think I've made the right decision.

yeah mate you did

Really!? No fooling.

Kick ass. Well done Floyd.

Cheers Mac
Are you still interested in the Tame Impala game I'm trying to eventually set up?
And anyone else, for that matter?

[TheFloyd73]

Sweet, good game everyone.

Any MVP voting, Marsh?

[Tangrowth]

Well played, civilians.

This was a really tough game for me, especially while trying to be mafia in Star Wars and trying to finish up the semester, and you all were really applying some good pressure. You all deserved the win.

[MacDougall]

Very nice. Thanks guys.

[motel room]

well thank fuck thats over.

Sorry I couldn't pull out a win scum dudes but ehhh I feel so gross.

Congrats town

[Golden]

Well played, especially floyd, you held your nerve, I might have buckled and gone Mac (even though it would have been stupid) just because of how strange it would be for the whole team to reveal itself. And epi. And also Diiny!

Ultimately the baddies might have won that if they didn't try to save Diiny. Best comeback ever?

[Tangrowth]

This was a great learning experience for me though. Haven't played many small games with this kind of setup. I almost never defend a teammate like that; I was so nervous from the very beginning.

It was worth the risk, despite the loss, I think.

[Marmot]

Also, MacDougall was Hazel, a Vanilla Civilian.

And TheFloyd73 was Sycamore, a Vanilla Civilian.

This game had one cop and no doctor. Unfortunately, it had a standard setup from the getgo, but the possibility of doctor still made things interesting.

[Tangrowth]

well thank fuck thats over.

Sorry I couldn't pull out a win scum dudes but ehhh I feel so gross.

Congrats town

You and Diiny were amazing teammates. Well done, both of you, we gave it a good attempt.

[MacDougall]

Yeah three consecutive correct lylo lynches is pretty excellent. Proud of y'all!

[TheFloyd73]

Well played, especially floyd, you held your nerve, I might have buckled and gone Mac (even though it would have been stupid) just because of how strange it would be for the whole team to reveal itself. And epi. And also Diiny!

Ultimately the baddies might have won that if they didn't try to save Diiny. Best comeback ever?

Goodness, you don't know how long I was contemplating for.

[Tangrowth]

Well played, especially floyd, you held your nerve, I might have buckled and gone Mac (even though it would have been stupid) just because of how strange it would be for the whole team to reveal itself. And epi. And also Diiny!

Ultimately the baddies might have won that if they didn't try to save Diiny. Best comeback ever?

Yeah, that was a mistake, but I really got stuck in a position after I mostly defended Diiny on Day 1. It went against every fiber of my being, and Diiny told us to bus him throughout the game, but I just couldn't justify bussing him without it feeling manufactured.

[Marmot]

Sweet, good game everyone.

Any MVP voting, Marsh?

Yes! Everyone who played, please send me a PM with your vote for the MVP of the game. I will announce the winner sometimes in the next couple of days.

The MVP will earn a place in the future Heist All-Star Game

[Tangrowth]

Yeah three consecutive correct lylo lynches is pretty excellent. Proud of y'all!

Indeed, you guys really earned the win. I'm glad you got it in the end.

[MacDougall]

Well played, especially floyd, you held your nerve, I might have buckled and gone Mac (even though it would have been stupid) just because of how strange it would be for the whole team to reveal itself. And epi. And also Diiny!

Ultimately the baddies might have won that if they didn't try to save Diiny. Best comeback ever?

Goodness, you don't know how long I was contemplating for.

I can't imagine how nervous you must have been.

Way to go Floyd. Congrats.

[Tangrowth]

Well played, especially floyd, you held your nerve, I might have buckled and gone Mac (even though it would have been stupid) just because of how strange it would be for the whole team to reveal itself. And epi. And also Diiny!

Ultimately the baddies might have won that if they didn't try to save Diiny. Best comeback ever?

Goodness, you don't know how long I was contemplating for.

I can't imagine how nervous you must have been.

Way to go Floyd. Congrats.

+1

Floyd, I feel as though you started showing some comfort this game. Keep it up, you're definitely developing your style.

[TheFloyd73]

Yeah three consecutive correct lylo lynches is pretty excellent. Proud of y'all!

Indeed, you guys really earned the win. I'm glad you got it in the end.

Diiny really had too much of a nerve about him from the start, that was really his downfall IMO.

My first assumption of you, MP, was purely me trying to offer some reason why Zebra was night killed and someone like myself wasn't.

Nevertheless, well done Mafia, made us work hard.

[TheFloyd73]

Well played, especially floyd, you held your nerve, I might have buckled and gone Mac (even though it would have been stupid) just because of how strange it would be for the whole team to reveal itself. And epi. And also Diiny!

Ultimately the baddies might have won that if they didn't try to save Diiny. Best comeback ever?

Goodness, you don't know how long I was contemplating for.

I can't imagine how nervous you must have been.

Way to go Floyd. Congrats.

+1

Floyd, I feel as though you started showing some comfort this game. Keep it up, you're definitely developing your style.

Cheers MP, and Mac

[Marmot]

It's nice to see the civilians team up and finish a game like this though. Too often here on the Syndicate, the civilians will start poorly, and finish even more poorly. Well played everyone.

Civilians have now won as many Heists here as mafia now. :P

[TheFloyd73]

It's nice to see the civilians team up and finish a game like this though. Too often here on the Syndicate, the civilians will start poorly, and finish even more poorly. Well played everyone.

I won't listen to Pet Sounds the same after that.

[Tangrowth]

It's nice to see the civilians team up and finish a game like this though. Too often here on the Syndicate, the civilians will start poorly, and finish even more poorly. Well played everyone.

I won't listen to Pet Sounds the same after that.

[motel room]

the game would have gone differently if wedidnt somehow lynch the cop on Day 1. Enrique was on to me. And Wilgy was awesome with his cop gambit and picking two of us immediately also. Diiny had nothing but heat on him all game and mac smelled my ashes. Lotsa good shit. Thanks for the game MM!

[MacDougall]

the game would have gone differently if wedidnt somehow lynch the cop on Day 1. Enrique was on to me. And Wilgy was awesome with his cop gambit and picking two of us immediately also. Diiny had nothing but heat on him all game and mac smelled my ashes. Lotsa good shit. Thanks for the game MM!

Haha your posts were grey and smelled like ashes.

[MacDougall]

Pretty sure Floyd voted for scum every single day.

[Marmot]

DAY 6

Who tore poor old sig down?

Poll runs till Thu Dec 17, 2015 6:01 pm

MacDougall
0
No votes

motel room
3
MacDougall (3), TheFloyd73 (9), motel room (10)
30%

TheFloyd73
0
No votes

Why did the willow cross the road? (Host, uprooted, etc.)
7
Metalmarsh89 (1), Enrique (2), MovingPictures07 (4), Sorsha (5), Turnip Head (6), sig (7), a2thezebra (8)
70%


Total votes : 10

[motel room]

oh oh and this

RYM final 3! Woo go us.

was also cos all three of us were australians so if there was arguing going down there was a better chance I'd be around for it.

[TheFloyd73]

oh oh and this

RYM final 3! Woo go us.

was also cos all three of us were australians so if there was arguing going down there was a better chance I'd be around for it.

Wait, you're Australian too?

[MacDougall]

oh oh and this

RYM final 3! Woo go us.

was also cos all three of us were australians so if there was arguing going down there was a better chance I'd be around for it.

Oh you killed sig so that we'd all be timezone friendly?

Cool!

[Marmot]

oh oh and this

RYM final 3! Woo go us.

was also cos all three of us were australians so if there was arguing going down there was a better chance I'd be around for it.

That's... pretty clever.

I don't think anybody is in my time zone though funnily enough (PST), except for nutella.

Maybe on Canucklehead, Long Con, and Black Rock, but I'm not certain.