Lost Again Mafia (season 1) - Day 6

#601

Hmmm...

#602

Over a day until the day ends. Yikes.

#603

Voted fer Matt.

Matt, who is definitely not on your team other than Zebra?

Matt, what do you think of my friend Scotty?

Scotty, what do you think of SVS?

**http://www.last.fm/user/nutella23** · #604

a2thezebra wrote:There's a number of things wrong with that rainbow list of mine, yet it takes more than a quick glance to notice all of them.

1. Epignosis, who I'm currently voting for, is fairly high among the civilian reads.
2. DFaraday, Floyd, and Long Con (who is a neutral gun-to-head scum read) are all dead.
3. Ricochet isn't playing this game.
4. Rain Man does not exist.
5. Golden is the host.
6. I have a very strong scum read of myself.

Scotty only noticed (or at least only made note of noticing) Number 3.
nutella only noticed (or at least only made note of noticing) Number 6.

Everyone else made no mention of the list at all, which I find interesting.

I noticed most of the other stuff (including the fact that I was placed above the dead confirmed civs!

), but chose to ignore it at first and then made a general "wtf" comment.

#605

a2thezebra wrote:
Everyone else made no mention of the list at all, which I find interesting.

Why would you expect anyone to respond to a clearly nonsense list?

Can we keep the votes on Matt for today please? It would make sense that Floyd would check him and vote him based on that... so I'm voting Matt.

SVS, you do realize that if you lied about trying to kill me, I will never, ever, trust you in a mafia game again.

#606

I know

#607

ebwop, which is why I would not say such a thing lightly.

#608

DrWilgy wrote:Voted fer Matt.

Matt, who is definitely not on your team other than Zebra?

Matt, what do you think of my friend Scotty?

Scotty, what do you think of SVS?

I think SVS has been slinking through the past few days. I haven't rea d back on her because I've been a little preoccupied today, but I don't remember her other suspicions taking flight besides for Matt. Which is why I really think discovering Matt's alignment is important.

#609

a2thezebra wrote:There's a number of things wrong with that rainbow list of mine, yet it takes more than a quick glance to notice all of them.

1. Epignosis, who I'm currently voting for, is fairly high among the civilian reads.
2. DFaraday, Floyd, and Long Con (who is a neutral gun-to-head scum read) are all dead.
3. Ricochet isn't playing this game.
4. Rain Man does not exist.
5. Golden is the host.
6. I have a very strong scum read of myself.

Scotty only noticed (or at least only made note of noticing) Number 3.
nutella only noticed (or at least only made note of noticing) Number 6.

Everyone else made no mention of the list at all, which I find interesting.

You are a conundrum, my friend. Was that some sort of test? Did I pass? Do I graduate Mafia community college?

What is your opinion on Floyd's initial post at the beginning of day 2 where he votes Matt? Do you think it's damning at all?

#610

Typhoony wrote: SVS, you do realize that if you lied about trying to kill me, I will never, ever, trust you in a mafia game again.

The semantics of this is astounding to me, because if Typh was targeted and SVS does turn out to be bad, it would come completely out of left field.

On one hand, SVS seems like a woman of her word when it comes to promises and such, but IMO if you are barred by these imaginary rules of semantics as a mafia, you are giving yourself more opportunities to fail. I have been Mafia exactly once and as Mafia I may make promises that I won't be able to fulfill. This is getting meta, but on the surface SVS doesn't seem like the type of person that would break a pre-game vow like that. I would like to think she wouldn't.

But.

Hypothetical:
If she were bad, what better way to build civ cried than being involved in Typh's death? Notice I said involved, not committed. Maybe if she didn't want to go through with the kill, and chose one of the other Mafia members to do it, she would be absolved of any wrong doing.

I could be reading too much into that, but when people make statements that "oh, I would never do that" or "I'm an honest and noble person as a baddie, I hate being Mafia" it makes me tense up. Could just be a personal play style but if I am ever Mafia again I think anything is fair game.

Again, SVS, I think highly of you as a person, but I don't buy for a second if you were bad that you wouldn't do what you have to do to win.

#611

Typh is someone I admire alot, and have a Mafia history with. He has been a teammate on almost all of my Mafia best games.

And you don't know me well; winning can be good, but I don't particularly play to win other than becasue it makes the team experience better. I play harder & try harder when I have a team, and that's just a fact. And if I don;t have a team,some people are, to sentimental me, my perma team. There are maybe two, maybe 3 (tranq is such a bitch sometimes, it is hard to not want to kill him) people I won't kill night one. One does not play any more, Typh is the other.

Like I said days ago, total wifom. But total truth, too.

I was totally on the plane, and I have killed peoplein the past and might again. but I have not killed anyone here on this beach (or tried to

), and won't be doing so in the future.

**http://www.last.fm/user/nutella23** · #612

Was surprised to come back and not find a lynch post, and then I realized there's another whole day on the poll. Lame.

#613

nutella wrote:Was surprised to come back and not find a lynch post, and then I realized there's another whole day on the poll. Lame.

Interested in the lynch result...

...not interested in the direction of the lynch.

Noted, Breakfast Killer.

#614

Anyone care to talk about how if Matt flips civ, Zebra is Scum?

#615

#616

Scotty wrote: Again, SVS, I think highly of you as a person, but I don't buy for a second if you were bad that you wouldn't do what you have to do to win.

I would.

And if you believe that I was attacked, then you should trust my word on this. I 100% believe SVS on this and have no intention of lynching her.

on you Scotty.

The only way that she is bad is if I was not the target in some weird way and I think that has a very low probability now that we know Floyd was a powerrole as well.

**http://www.last.fm/user/nutella23** · #617

DrWilgy wrote:Anyone care to talk about how if Matt flips civ, Zebra is Scum?

#618

DrWilgy wrote:Anyone care to talk about how if Matt flips civ, Zebra is Scum?

How about how Zebra was defending Matt on day 1 and pushed against his lynch on day 2 despite having initially said he was bad? Zebra is more likely to be bad if Matt is bad than if he isn't, IMO.

#619

Matt

Long Con, MY DUDE, just know I did request that we leave you alone Night 1 for precisely the reason I stated earlier, i.e. "why I wouldn't kill Long Con".

Floyd, no hard feeling my bro. I know your relatively new so I'm not sure you knew what you were doing with that last post. The reason I'm not freaking out at you right now is because I've also accidentally said too much before, though never after I was dead. Oh, and also because your role reveal almost guaranteed my lynch today anyway.

I won't be posting any further but I did have a blast peeps. Oh, and Wilgy requested I tell you all he's my teamie because wifom.

#620

So now he's basically admitted it can we finally let this guy get lynched?

#621

Matt why did you try to kill me nub

#622

Hmmm... That is what I would have a mafia temmie do... Well played Matt, well played.

#623

This is like a freaking comedy routine in here.

#624

S~V~S wrote:This is like a freaking comedy routine in here.

when I was in high school, I tried stand up for the talent show day. And the only reason they let me in to perform was because I made one of the auditors laugh at my joke about Dubya Bush. I don't even remember what it was. But when I went out there and performed, I bombed. Sort of like how Dubya bombed Iraq searching for WMDs. It was traumatizing and embarrassing, and I'll never do stand up again.

Typhoony wrote:
Scotty wrote: Again, SVS, I think highly of you as a person, but I don't buy for a second if you were bad that you wouldn't do what you have to do to win.
I would.

And if you believe that I was attacked, then you should trust my word on this. I 100% believe SVS on this and have no intention of lynching her. on you Scotty.

The only way that she is bad is if I was not the target in some weird way and I think that has a very low probability now that we know Floyd was a powerrole as well.

Sorsha says she chose to save you on N1, which is the only info we have on that failed attempt. That doesn't clear you, but it is a strong possibility that is what happened. So I would like to believe that is what happened, and if you are positive that she wouldn't do that, I'll keep that in mind.
The other possibility is that you weren't the target on N1, and something else was at play here (like a block or a missed Mafia kill, though that seems less likely)

#625

Matt wrote:Matt

Long Con, MY DUDE, just know I did request that we leave you alone Night 1 for precisely the reason I stated earlier, i.e. "why I wouldn't kill Long Con".

Floyd, no hard feeling my bro. I know your relatively new so I'm not sure you knew what you were doing with that last post. The reason I'm not freaking out at you right now is because I've also accidentally said too much before, though never after I was dead. Oh, and also because your role reveal almost guaranteed my lynch today anyway.

I won't be posting any further but I did have a blast peeps. Oh, and Wilgy requested I tell you all he's my teamie because wifom.

Let's skip to the end phase, then. Nothing more I see here folks. Thanks for playing, Matt, and I hate that I backed you up on day 2.

#626

I'll bring the end of day forward an hour or so. No point me bringing it forward any more than that.

**http://www.last.fm/user/nutella23** · #627

lmao this game is ridiculous. it's pretty clear that the baddies in fact know which characters are in the game and golden has totally fucked with us and especially messed with me because I stupidly assumed there must be a Sun. Sneaky tricky :\

#628

#629

Where is Sorsha? Would like to hear her opinions on people.

#630

nutella wrote:lmao this game is ridiculous. it's pretty clear that the baddies in fact know which characters are in the game and golden has totally fucked with us and especially messed with me because I stupidly assumed there must be a Sun. Sneaky tricky :\

Though with your vote still on zebra, it appears you are still holding out hope that Matt is just a friendly civ liar.

#631

Day 3 has ended.

Spoiler: show

It is now night 3.

#632

Zebra 1 nutella (5)
DrWilgy 0
Sorsha 0
Nutella 0
Scotty 0
Bullzeye 0
Typhoony 0
Matt 8 Epignosis (4), Sorsha (7), Bullzeye (8), Scotty (9), S~V~S (10), DrWilgy (11), Typhoony (12), Matt (14)
S~V~S 0
Epignosis 1 a2thezebra (3)
Golden (host/np) 4 Golden (1), MovingPictures07 (2), TheFloyd73 (6), Enrique (13)

#633

RIH Epi.

#634

ok I think you'll all get a kick out of this: on my plane adventures the past few days, one of my connecting flights went through LAX. And I kid you not, swear to god the following is true.
There was a man sitting next to me that was coming from a funeral for his dad in Sydney. He was Australian, but was almost a spitting image of Locke. His wife, sitting next to him on the aisle, was a paraplegic. There was a man behind me that was probably as husky as a sea lion talking about the powerball and how he chose to use the numbers from that show "Lost". Lastly was a dude with a thick and hick-y accent, long hair, and a hunter's cap in first class. Like, wtf. I was extremely nervous that flight, tbh

Linki: good show, lads

#635

Finally! Sorry to see you go Matt but you were so obviously bad I'm shocked it's taken us this long to get rid of you. Was worried we'd see a repeat of your survival in Beatles.

#636

a2thezebra wrote:

RIH Epi.

Just kidding!

RIH Matt.

**http://www.last.fm/user/nutella23** · #637

So the fake role claim thing is confirmed. Well that's pretty fucked up. But great that we're one baddie down!

I bet the other two are Wilgy and Zebra. And if by some crazy chance that's not the case, I'd entertain that crazy theory about Sorsha and Typh.

**http://www.last.fm/user/nutella23** · #638

also, Scotty, that is cray cray. *twilight zone music*

#639

nutella wrote:So the fake role claim thing is confirmed. Well that's pretty fucked up. But great that we're one baddie down!

I bet the other two are Wilgy and Zebra. And if by some crazy chance that's not the case, I'd entertain that crazy theory about Sorsha and Typh.

Wilgy, yes. Myself, no.

"CAW! CAW! I AM A BIRD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

#640

I am shocked about that fake identity thing.

#641

#642

What is shocking about it?

#643

It is the last thing I would have expected from Golden, that's all. When people were bringing it up, I was like, "Nooooo, no way. You silly, lulz".

Not too much in Mafia really surprises me anymore (delights, yes, surprises, not too much) and this surprises me.

#644

Just because it's a Golden game?

#645

Thats part of it, but I have never heard of such a thing. Perhaps becasue on the sites many of us came from, role claiming is really seriously taboo. Giving baddies fake roles to claim is just something cray cray lol.

#646

I see.

#647

Nub svs

#648

I guess so ha ha

I really was like "pffft" when people were discussing that option. I feel a fool.

#649

Who do you think are the last two baddies svs?

#650

Wilgy & Nutella seemed most faux with their recent sentiments, and you are scaring the crap out of me. I can't forget that vote you & Sorsha dropped on me, but that is just paranoia speaking.

You?

Who wasn't on the plane?