Lost Again Mafia (season 1) - Day 6

#751

a2thezebra wrote:
DrWilgy wrote:But I dont have btsc to say that in.

That would also imply that we both have btsc... Making him bad. Vote for scotty today and me tomorrow. It's a Wilgy promise that I'm civ.
Nice try, but you expect me to forget that names are mentioned outside of BTSC that aren't in BTSC? You go today.

If you are civ, you are going to be so dissapointed

@epi - my vote was only for survival that made it not Wilgy vs. Scotty. Since I don't need to prevent a Wilgy vs. Scotty anymore there's no need to vote for you!

#752

a2thezebra wrote:Way to quote a bunch of my posts while giving no reason as to why you think they make me bad. You're next, Epi.

My reason for suspecting you is that you jumped on my Floyd issue and said you didn't blame me, and then you said I knew exactly what I was doing.

#753

Epignosis wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:Way to quote a bunch of my posts while giving no reason as to why you think they make me bad. You're next, Epi.
My reason for suspecting you is that you jumped on my Floyd issue and said you didn't blame me, and then you said I knew exactly what I was doing.

In retrospect, no shit.

#754

Seriously Epi, when you're making a disingenuous case against someone by twisting their words, you might not want to quote the part that demonstrates how badly you're twisting them.

a2thezebra wrote:(a foolish mistake on my part considering I am now fairly certain Epi knew exactly what he was doing with his disingenuous Floyd vote)

#755

Zebra, if I am bad, who is on my team?

#756

DrWilgy wrote:Zebra, if I am bad, who is on my team?

Since you're bad, you tell me.

#757

I'm currently leaning Epi since I'm pretty sure he just pulled a case out of his ass to justify not voting for you before the day ends and in turn cause another civ (Scotty) to be lynched.

Let's hope things don't turn out that way.

#758

a2thezebra wrote:I'm currently leaning Epi since I'm pretty sure he just pulled a case out of his ass to justify not voting for you before the day ends and in turn cause another civ (Scotty) to be lynched.

Let's hope things don't turn out that way.

I spent two days reading everybody during exam week. I saved that post twice before publishing it. I didn't pull anything out of anywhere.

#759

During exam week??? DIOS MIO! I take it all back, you're civilian Epi, lead us to victory plz.

#760

No, gotta be serious this time. If you can't answer this question with a list of suspects, then I'm not bad.

Linki - So you think I'm bad, with Epi, even though I tried to start a survival wagon on him? What interactions do I have with him to make him my teammate?

#761

DrWilgy wrote:No, gotta be serious this time. If you can't answer this question with a list of suspects, then I'm not bad.

Linki - So you think I'm bad, with Epi, even though I tried to start a survival wagon on him? What interactions do I have with him to make him my teammate?

This is one of the laziest attempts at defense/misdirection I've ever seen.

Your being bad is not dependent on being a teammate with any particular person. My answer was serious because I know it will be easier for you to defend against teammate implications than against you actually be civilian based on your own alignment's in-thread merit. We've seen this to be true based on your previous defenses.

#762

a2thezebra wrote:During exam week??? DIOS MIO! I take it all back, you're civilian Epi, lead us to victory plz.

Yes, exam week, i.e., the busiest time of the year for me second to the middle of June, during which I have to finalize grades for 90+ students, which involves grading their research papers and exams.

#763

The next time I play scummy for four days worth of a game and get called out for it, I'll be sure to say to them "Oh yeah? Well if I'm bad, then who am I bad with?! HA. Got you there, I'm not bad."

linki - You mean to tell me that you're a busy person? I'VE NEVER HEARD YOU USE THIS TACTIC BEFORE TO DEFEND AGAINST UNRELATED ACCUSATIONS

#764

a2thezebra wrote:I'm currently leaning Epi since I'm pretty sure he just pulled a case out of his ass to justify not voting for you before the day ends and in turn cause another civ (Scotty) to be lynched.

Let's hope things don't turn out that way.

What makes you so sure Scotty is civ? Is it the same thing that caused you to trust Matt so much that you pushed Floyd's lynch to save him?

#765

Bullzeye wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:I'm currently leaning Epi since I'm pretty sure he just pulled a case out of his ass to justify not voting for you before the day ends and in turn cause another civ (Scotty) to be lynched.

Let's hope things don't turn out that way.
What makes you so sure Scotty is civ? Is it the same thing that caused you to trust Matt so much that you pushed Floyd's lynch to save him?

Feigned confidence in frequently mistaken opinions? Yes.

#766

As for why I think Scotty is civ, I just have yet to be pinged by him and I feel that a lot of the cases made against him throughout the game have been either fake or simply mistaken.

#767

a2thezebra wrote:
linki - You mean to tell me that you're a busy person? I'VE NEVER HEARD YOU USE THIS TACTIC BEFORE TO DEFEND AGAINST UNRELATED ACCUSATIONS

Keep talkin' slick.

#768

It's also worth noting that in his latest TWO DAY ANALYSIS DURING MAJOR BUSY EXAM WEEK, Epi noted having a town read of Scotty (yet was rather waffly about the idea that he may just be town-reading him for agreeing with him often

) but has yet to demonstrate that he is willing to put his vote on Wilgy - whose alignment he clearly does not view as favorably - and possibly save Scotty himself.

linki - I'm sorry, is me talking slick suspicious?

#769

a2thezebra wrote:It's also worth noting that in his latest TWO DAY ANALYSIS DURING MAJOR BUSY EXAM WEEK, Epi noted having a town read of Scotty (yet was rather waffly about the idea that he may just be town-reading him for agreeing with him often ) but has yet to demonstrate that he is willing to put his vote on Wilgy - whose alignment he clearly does not view as favorably - and possibly save Scotty himself.

linki - I'm sorry, is me talking slick suspicious?

Hey, lookie at what I found on somebody's lapel.

#770

Epi you make a prophet out of me.

a2thezebra wrote:I'm currently leaning Epi since I'm pretty sure he just pulled a case out of his ass to justify not voting for you before the day ends and in turn cause another civ (Scotty) to be lynched.

Let's hope things don't turn out that way.

#771

If I voted for Scooter, it would only be because three people I think were on that plane voted him, not because of my own opinion. At the same time, I'm unwilling to undermine the effort of those three I trust by tying it up.

#772

But you haven't tied it up. You're giving the lynch to Scotty to save Wilgy. You're voting for Ralph Nader so George W. gets elected.

#773

I'm pretty sure I'm speaking English here.

#774

If you wanted to tie it up, you would vote for Wilgy.
If you felt good about Scotty, you would vote for Wilgy.
If you felt just slightly worse about Wilgy than Scotty, you would vote for Wilgy.
If you felt bad about Wilgy and thought we were teammates, you would vote for Wilgy.

#775

Instead you're voting for me to save Wilgy's ass.

#776

Epignosis wrote:I'm pretty sure I'm speaking English here.

#777

a2thezebra wrote:If you wanted to tie it up, you would vote for Wilgy.
If you felt good about Scotty, you would vote for Wilgy.
If you felt just slightly worse about Wilgy than Scotty, you would vote for Wilgy.
If you felt bad about Wilgy and thought we were teammates, you would vote for Wilgy.

a2thezebra wrote:Instead you're voting for me to save Wilgy's ass.

#778

I trust Ty Fighter, who has voted Scooter. I trust Sassafras, who has voted Scooter. I trust Bully Boy, who has voted Scooter.

I don't trust Nutter, who has voted Mr. Wiggles. I don't trust The Striped Crusader, who has voted Mr. Wiggles.

I am willing to defer to the judgment of the three I trust even if it conflicts with the opinion I have and let them have their result rather than tie it up by voting alongside two people I don't trust.

Comprende?

#779

If you trust them over your own opinion then own it and vote for Scotty. If not, then vote for Wilgy. Voting for me - and in doing so, lynching Scotty - just looks like what it is. Saving Wilgy.

Comprende?

#780

a2thezebra wrote:If you trust them over your own opinion then own it and vote for Scotty. If not, then vote for Wilgy. Voting for me - and in doing so, lynching Scotty - just looks like what it is. Saving Wilgy.

Comprende?

If I voted Scotty, it would be disingenuous. So nope.

#781

Epignosis wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:If you trust them over your own opinion then own it and vote for Scotty. If not, then vote for Wilgy. Voting for me - and in doing so, lynching Scotty - just looks like what it is. Saving Wilgy.

Comprende?
If I voted Scotty, it would be disingenuous. So nope.

Because your suspicion of me is 100% genuine. Bullshit.

#782

The room gets darker, the only light that can now be seen is coming through a window. Pink fog can be seen through the window building up rather quickly. Before anyone can question this environment Wilgy jumps through the window! he lands on the ground on one knee, arms in the air and head down. His hair hangs down covering his face quite effectively. The pink fog pours in behind him and flashing lights begin to surround Wilgy! A spotlight sets down upon him as he stands, looks up, and puts on sunglasses. The stage is set, Wilgy is in the spotlight, he has also finally eaten and is feeling alittle better.

a2thezebra wrote:
DrWilgy wrote:No, gotta be serious this time. If you can't answer this question with a list of suspects, then I'm not bad.

Linki - So you think I'm bad, with Epi, even though I tried to start a survival wagon on him? What interactions do I have with him to make him my teammate?
This is one of the laziest attempts at defense/misdirection I've ever seen.

Your being bad is not dependent on being a teammate with any particular person. My answer was serious because I know it will be easier for you to defend against teammate implications than against you actually be civilian based on your own alignment's in-thread merit. We've seen this to be true based on your previous defenses.

So you get it! I have no defense! I'M CIV! me being bad is dependent on having a team, baddies have teammates! I can't make an arguable defense because you aren't willing to implicate me on anything defend-able. Your argument for me has been "He's bad because I think so!" how can I defend that home dawg skillet? You are entitled to think whatever you want. The moment I ask for something I can defend against, you strife away from the question. Now, if you want to lynch me for being a lurker, that's fine, If you want to lynch me for voting wrong, that's also fine, but if you are going to lynch me for those reasons while not looking at the others who have done just the same then BLUMBLEBUG!

The way I see things right now -
Scotty and Nutella are probably a team
Scotty and Zebra could be a team
Scotty and Epi could be a team

Zebra and Nutella could be a team

Wilgy and Typhoony are a team!

#783

Don't even pretend I haven't given you anything to defend against, Wilgy. I gave (by my standards of course) a mammoth to defend against. You tried, you failed. Get lynched, amigo.

#784

╰( ⁰ ਊ ⁰ )━☆ﾟ.*･｡ﾟ

#785

a2thezebra wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:If you trust them over your own opinion then own it and vote for Scotty. If not, then vote for Wilgy. Voting for me - and in doing so, lynching Scotty - just looks like what it is. Saving Wilgy.

Comprende?
If I voted Scotty, it would be disingenuous. So nope.
Because your suspicion of me is 100% genuine. Bullshit.

Think what you like. Anything I would do at this stage except vote Mr. Wiggler would be me saving him, according to you. Yet another reason I think you should be lynched.

#786

Epignosis wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:If you trust them over your own opinion then own it and vote for Scotty. If not, then vote for Wilgy. Voting for me - and in doing so, lynching Scotty - just looks like what it is. Saving Wilgy.

Comprende?
If I voted Scotty, it would be disingenuous. So nope.
Because your suspicion of me is 100% genuine. Bullshit.
Think what you like. Anything I would do at this stage except vote Mr. Wiggler would be me saving him, according to you. Yet another reason I think you should be lynched.

When he has three votes and one of your civilian reads has four, yeah. Yeah I think so.

#787

ᕕ( ՞ ᗜ ՞ )ᕗ

#788

Your pitiful attempt to pressure me into saving Scotty is hilarious.

#789

Hey guys, I would very much like to not die today. thanks!

I'm out glacier hiking all day and will not have service before the deadline. But if I die, please actually look at Nutella next. Just let that be my dying wish.

Bullz, I don't like your vote for me and think it is quite lazy. I wouldn't think of you any less if you would be so kind as to move it.

Chau guys, and just remember: It's Not Penny's Bost.

#790

Also lol at "yet another reason" because you've given SO many reasons to vote for me. Wait what are they again? I can't recall even one.

linki - Sorry for trying to save a civ?

linki - Oh hi Scotty!

#791

☆*:. o(≧▽≦)o .:*☆

#792

What happened this last page?

#793

I hope this last page answered your question from earlier, Typhoony.

Typhoony wrote:So it it Scotty + Epi or Wilgy + Epi?

#794

We've got two hours to lynch a baddie.

#795

It didn't.

Epi seems genuine, albeit mistaken at times. Wilgy seems clinically insane.

#796

So if Epi seems genuine to you (wow) then who do you figure for Scotty's teammate?

#797

Still Epi or Wilgy :P

#798

To Epi: You say you were surprised about Michael or Boone being in the game, but remember this is a S1 game.

The 13 claimed players have all had flashbacks in Season 1, making them most likely roles to appear in the game.

#799

Also do you really think Zebra would have pulled that D2 stunt with saying Matt was 100% bad, getting all the votes on him and then lynching Floyd as a baddie? It's one hell of a play if so.

Note that that is not the only reason I think Zebra is civ, but it's an example.

#800

Typhoony wrote:Still Epi or Wilgy :P

...but you're more confident about Scotty being bad than either. Arghhhh

Who wasn't on the plane?