Lost Again Mafia (season 1) - Day 6

#801

I'm more confident that Scotty is bad than that Wilgy is bad, hence my vote on Scotty.

#802

Typhoony wrote:Also do you really think Zebra would have pulled that D2 stunt with saying Matt was 100% bad, getting all the votes on him and then lynching Floyd as a baddie? It's one hell of a play if so.

Note that that is not the only reason I think Zebra is civ, but it's an example.

I don't know what stunts The Striped Crusader would PULL. He did some crazy ass things in Star Wars. He eventually outed himself and his team still won.

#803

#804

Typhoony wrote:Also do you really think Zebra would have pulled that D2 stunt with saying Matt was 100% bad, getting all the votes on him and then lynching Floyd as a baddie? It's one hell of a play if so.

Note that that is not the only reason I think Zebra is civ, but it's an example.

Yeah, apparently Epi thinks too highly of me. Never thought I would say that.

linki @ Typh - Damn. Well, I hope you're right. But I don't think you are.

linki @ Epi - But outing myself in that game was the best strategy there. If I were bad here than what I did with Matt wasn't just risky, it was unnecessary.

linki - Haters gonna hate

#805

I'm not gonna change my vote on my last day alive on the Island, sorry

I don't know if I'm right. At the very least this Day will give a lot of info to work with for tomorrow, regardless of the outcome.

#806

how much time is left?

You may or may not be correct about the insanity.

#807

61 minutes.

#808

*crosses fingers*

#809

*changes vote to Wilgy*

#810

Typhoony wrote:*changes vote to Wilgy*

╰(ಥдಥ)ノ

#811

Apologies for lame phone posts for the rest of the game. Copy paste of image URLs is something I don't know how to do.

Scott has been lynched. He was:

Spoiler: show

It is now night 4.

#812

s( ^ ‿ ^)-b

#813

Typhoony...

I think you are the last scum! It's the only possible answer. You're getting my vote tomorrow.

#814

Boom. Thank god. After Pikmin I was wondering if I was ever going to be able to lynch a baddie again.

Linki: Not if I kill you first nub.

#815

So... Y'know what'd be cool? If mafia left you alive for next level WIFOM!

Then we'd lynch you...

But after we lynch you Typh, who's next?

#816

You're making me want to lynch you next, Wilgy.

#817

Typhoony wrote:You're making me want to lynch you next, Wilgy.

It would be easier to bandwagon me if you weren't so scummy.

This is my prediction. You'll kill Zebra and then bandwagon me. Next you'll kill SVS and then bandwagon Nutella. Epi would join you, then it's GG.

#818

Good result. So when are we gonna do something about the person who has strongly defended both lynched baddies? Because I feel like we can make this a pretty short game.

#819

Nah, I'd rather talk about how if Typhoony chose not to submit a kill early game so Sorsha would mistakenly clear him, settin him up for an easy game.

#820

Bullzeye wrote:Good result. So when are we gonna do something about the person who has strongly defended both lynched baddies? Because I feel like we can make this a pretty short game.

Do you want to do something about me or do you want to win?

#821

Epignosis wrote:
Bullzeye wrote:Good result. So when are we gonna do something about the person who has strongly defended both lynched baddies? Because I feel like we can make this a pretty short game.
Do you want to do something about me or do you want to win?

Not everything is about you :P

Sometimes it's about other people, like Zebra.

#822

DrWilgy wrote:Typhoony...

I think you are the last scum! It's the only possible answer. You're getting my vote tomorrow.

What?

#823

I appreciate you trying to keep me alive Wilgy

#824

Bullzeye wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
Bullzeye wrote:Good result. So when are we gonna do something about the person who has strongly defended both lynched baddies? Because I feel like we can make this a pretty short game.
Do you want to do something about me or do you want to win?
Not everything is about you :P

Sometimes it's about other people, like Zebra.

Well hell.

#825

Typh, it was a great game, but I think you should concede.

Linki... It's your plan right... That's how your going to win right...

#826

(ಥ_ʖಥ)

#827

#828

Hi Nutella.

**http://www.last.fm/user/nutella23** · #829

Wow I missed a lot of interesting content today o.O As I was reading through everyone's posts from earlier I became less convinced Wilgy was bad and more convinced Scotty was, but alas I was too late to change my vote. Glad to see another baddie got lynched. And lol you guys are going to pick me apart and roast me for saying that I so conveniently but unhelpfully changed my mind yet again, but it's just the truth

I really just flip-flop on my opinions a lot and it always looks suspicious but it's always just me being honest with my indecisive thought process. This has been a problem for me in so many games and is always what gets me in trouble as a civ. This game I've been using a combination of gut feelings and process of elimination, along with recently trusting the opinions of Typh and Zebra since they seem so confident, and through all this I felt I had narrowed down the baddies to 2 of Scotty, Epi, or Wilgy. Now that scotty is down I am more inclined for now to pursue Epi. I know my voting record is absolute shit but I just keep rethinking things every day. :\

#830

I think we should discuss optimal lynch order at this point.

I'm thinking Zebra, Nutella, Epi

Thoughts?

#831

I don't think that's optimal lynch order

#832

What do you think is optimal then?

#833

DrWilgy wrote:What do you think is optimal then?

Good question.

You
Epi
Nutella
Bullz/Zebra
SVS

Something like that.

#834

Golden wrote:Day 2

Zebra 4 DrWilgy (2), Scotty (6), Matt (10), nutella (11)
Long Con 0
DrWilgy 0
Sorsha 0
Floyd 5 Epignosis (12), a2thezebra (13), Typhoony (14), Long Con (15), S~V~S (16)
Nutella 0
Scotty 0
Bullzeye 0
Typhoony 0
Matt 2 TheFloyd73 (3), Bullzeye (4)
S~V~S 1 Sorsha (9)
Epignosis 0
Golden (host/np) 5 Golden (1), MovingPictures07 (5), Metalmarsh89 (7), Turnip Head (8), G-Man (17)

This is the Day 2 poll, where we lynched the role checker

Both of the known baddies voted for Zeebs. The Floyd train did not start until after that pile up. Since there are only 3 baddies, I doubt Epi would start a counter train if two of his teammates had already piled up that way.

I think, based on this, that my order would be

Wilgy
Nutella
Epi
Zeebs
Bullz/Typh

I think one of Wilgy or LA has to be the third.

#835

Scotty named Zebra and nutella as his main suspects. His main case yesterday was on nutella.

#836

He was also in the first half of the Matt voters the day Matt died.

What's weird is that in every poll, Scotty, Wilgy & Matt all voted together (until Matt died, lol). Then yesterday Wilgy was the deciding vote on Scotty. Not sure if that is a something or a noithing,lol.

#837

The day Matt died was when people used Floyds info to lynch him, that doesn't mean much.

And yesterday Wilgy was the other one up for lynch, so that doesn't mean much other. He was very hesitant to lynch Scotty and tried to get me to make a triple tie.

#838

What you are saying is true about the triple tie, but I don't think you should make anything of it. I feel like I was a decent advocator of Scotty being bad, even though I wouldn't vote for him. When I realized that I could vote for him without breaking promises I happily did so.

Look at Zebra who defended both Matt and Scotty at different points, so far to the extent of trying to convince Epi to almost save Scotty yesterday.

I'll look over Scotty now for anything I may have missed.

#839

a2thezebra wrote:*crosses fingers*

YAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY

No idea what the optimal lynch order should be. Given that the two players I've defended the hardest are the two lynched baddies, I feel like I should just keep my mouth shut and follow who I trust. Problem is, because of how off my reads have been in this game, I don't even know who I trust anymore. Enter lurk mode.

**http://www.last.fm/user/nutella23** · #840

My order is Epi > Wilgy > SVS > Bullz > Zebra > Typh

#841

nutella wrote:My order is Epi > Wilgy > SVS > Bullz > Zebra > Typh

What puts SVS ahead of Bullz? What puts Zebra behind everyone?

a2thezebra wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:*crosses fingers*
YAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY

No idea what the optimal lynch order should be. Given that the two players I've defended the hardest are the two lynched baddies, I feel like I should just keep my mouth shut and follow who I trust. Problem is, because of how off my reads have been in this game, I don't even know who I trust anymore. Enter lurk mode.

GTH rainbow list plz, now isn't the time to enter lurk mode Zebra.

#842

I'll need to ISO Scotty first.

#843

Who murdered Sorsha?

Poll ended at Sat Jan 16, 2016 10:40 am

Zebra
1
Epignosis (14) 7%
DrWilgy
3
nutella (3), a2thezebra (6), Scotty (9) 21%
Nutella
0
No votes
Scotty
4
Typhoony (2), S~V~S (4), Bullzeye (8), DrWilgy (12) 29%
Bullzeye
0
No votes
Typhoony
0
No votes
S~V~S
0
No votes
Epignosis
0
No votes
Golden (host/nons)
6
Golden (1), MovingPictures07 (5), TheFloyd73 (7), Turnip Head (10), Sorsha (11), Matt (13) 43%
Total votes : 14

#844

Night 4 has ended.

Spoiler: show

It is now Day 5. You have 48 hours from when the poll goes up to lynch someone.

#845

a2thezebra wrote:I'll need to ISO Scotty first.

Me first. Take your time when you get the part where I was saving Mr. Wiggler.

#846

Zebra, what are your immediate thoughts on me at this point?

...I should order a pizza... and fix my non-eating habits

#847

Revisiting Day 1 knowing that Matt and Scotty are bad makes nutella and Epi look a lot worse than anyone else still alive. Especially nutella, surprisingly (to me at least).

Please help me sort out whether Epi or nutella is bad, folks.

linki - RIP Typhoony
linki 2 - Shush
linki 3 - Based on going through Day 1 (I'm pretty much rereading the entire game rather than ISO Scotty, which I might do anyway afterwards) knowing who's bad, you look pretty good actually.

#848

How do Matt and Scotty typically treat their teammates in-thread anyway?

#849

a2thezebra wrote:Revisiting Day 1 knowing that Matt and Scotty are bad makes nutella and Epi look a lot worse than anyone else still alive. Especially nutella, surprisingly (to me at least).

Please help me sort out whether Epi or nutella is bad, folks.

linki - RIP Typhoony
linki 2 - Shush
linki 3 - Based on going through Day 1 (I'm pretty much rereading the entire game rather than ISO Scotty, which I might do anyway afterwards) knowing who's bad, you look pretty good actually.

That's bull. According to you, I was saving Wilgy and throwing Scotty to the smoke monster. I ain't going down without a scrap.

As it turns out though, I want to lynch Old Nutty.

#850

That's...convenient.

Who wasn't on the plane?