
It is now Night 5. You have 24 hours to send in your PMs.
Moderator: Community Team
Yep. I'm thinking reywaS, A Person and Dharma most likely...in that order.Nevinera wrote:I'm voting for Jack, because he's the only name in the list that has any experience with the Dharma Initiative.
I wish there were more to read for her history.
Voting wise, she only voted for a decommissioning once, for DP.
Andrew, Mongoose, Snow, DP, and Hedge voted for her on the successful decommissioning -
That's especially solid evidence for DP and Hedge's being civ, since they were the swing votes.
Mongoose and Lizzy (and simon of course) voted for her in the other vote that almost caught her -
that's twice Mongoose has tried to catch her, and Lizzy was a swing vote that time (though only in a 2v2).
The suspect pool is diminishing rapidly :-D
I'm impressed with your sleuthing!Nevinera wrote:I'm voting for Jack, because he's the only name in the list that has any experience with the Dharma Initiative.
I wish there were more to read for her history.
Voting wise, she only voted for a decommissioning once, for DP.
Andrew, Mongoose, Snow, DP, and Hedge voted for her on the successful decommissioning -
That's especially solid evidence for DP and Hedge's being civ, since they were the swing votes.
Mongoose and Lizzy (and simon of course) voted for her in the other vote that almost caught her -
that's twice Mongoose has tried to catch her, and Lizzy was a swing vote that time (though only in a 2v2).
The suspect pool is diminishing rapidly :-D
Mmm indeed.Snow Dog wrote:Or maybe A Person first as he dropped the pretense of being insanified.
He did? Where?Mongoose wrote:Mmm indeed.Snow Dog wrote:Or maybe A Person first as he dropped the pretense of being insanified.
Turnip Head wrote: We need to lynch Pennsylvania Bitch.
Owl - After seeing your comment, I went back through AP's latest and greatest.Hedgeowl wrote:He did? Where?Mongoose wrote:Mmm indeed.Snow Dog wrote:Or maybe A Person first as he dropped the pretense of being insanified.
This is a silly reason. I am glad we got a baddie finally from group voting though!DharmaHelper wrote:Based on that and because Lizzy sort of sounds like Krissy, I will vote for Lizzy.
Turnip Head wrote: We need to lynch Pennsylvania Bitch.
If you reread the other insanified people you may notice that as well. Some of it almost makes sense.Mongoose wrote:Owl - After seeing your comment, I went back through AP's latest and greatest.Hedgeowl wrote:He did? Where?Mongoose wrote:Mmm indeed.Snow Dog wrote:Or maybe A Person first as he dropped the pretense of being insanified.
Well now that I reread his/her last few posts, I wonder if s/he lucked into them sounding cogent. I misinterpreted them into being coherent speech.
Turnip Head wrote: We need to lynch Pennsylvania Bitch.
He did? Which post? They all look vaguely insane to me.Snow Dog wrote:Or maybe A Person first as he dropped the pretense of being insanified.
Turnip Head wrote: We need to lynch Pennsylvania Bitch.
A Person wrote:I know, but now we have a little faith in the theory.Mongoose wrote:A Person wrote:Thank you for those who care.
While I may not have understand one thing you've written this game, I do care. What are your thoughts on the latest elim?
Or maybe it doesn't make sense? Am I going mad?Snow Dog wrote:For those interested here is A Person talking coherently during the day phase. It's right at the top of this page.
A Person wrote:I know, but now we have a little faith in the theory.Mongoose wrote:A Person wrote:Thank you for those who care.
While I may not have understand one thing you've written this game, I do care. What are your thoughts on the latest elim?
Based on a lack of further suspects rey. It is a shame you have no voting record to refer to, but my gut feeling, and it is a suspicion only, is that you are a diesel.reywaS wrote:oh for crying out loud! I say I'm not going to miss another vote and then I promptly miss the next vote.
@Snow Dog: I'm not a baddie. I'm your number one suspect based on what exactly? That I've missed votes?
I agree that DH is probably bad though.
It's like those Magic Picture images. You keep looking at them longer and longer, think you see the sailboat, but then your eye goes wonky and you lose it all again.Snow Dog wrote:Or maybe it doesn't make sense? Am I going mad?Snow Dog wrote:For those interested here is A Person talking coherently during the day phase. It's right at the top of this page.
A Person wrote:I know, but now we have a little faith in the theory.Mongoose wrote:A Person wrote:Thank you for those who care.
While I may not have understand one thing you've written this game, I do care. What are your thoughts on the latest elim?![]()
![]()
It seems cogent only I think. Sorry AP. My bad.
Snow Dog wrote:Based on a lack of further suspects rey. It is a shame you have no voting record to refer to, but my gut feeling, and it is a suspicion only, is that you are a diesel.reywaS wrote:oh for crying out loud! I say I'm not going to miss another vote and then I promptly miss the next vote.
@Snow Dog: I'm not a baddie. I'm your number one suspect based on what exactly? That I've missed votes?
I agree that DH is probably bad though.
(That was about Reywas - sorry, I should have quoted someone)Nevinera wrote:I couldn't find anything that suspicious in his thread posts, though there was rather a shortage of them.
I'd lean toward people who have voted more first, really -
I don't see a huge advantage to be gained from skipping most of the votes as a baddie.
I mean, I guess diesels can be forgetful too..
but I'd rather do some more analysis of voting and finger-pointing before we convict someone just for being too quiet.
Or you know, have hedge do it ;-)
Nevinera wrote:I couldn't find anything that suspicious in his thread posts, though there was rather a shortage of them.
I'd lean toward people who have voted more first, really -
I don't see a huge advantage to be gained from skipping most of the votes as a baddie.
I mean, I guess diesels can be forgetful too..
but I'd rather do some more analysis of voting and finger-pointing before we convict someone just for being too quiet.
Or you know, have hedge do it ;-)
Turnip Head wrote: We need to lynch Pennsylvania Bitch.
I may give you the benefit of the doubt. I'm not 100% convinced you are bad just yet.reywaS wrote:Well, you can go ahead and lynch me....I probably deserve it based on my lack of participation alone....but in doing so you will NOT be lynching a diesel. You will just be getting rid of a civvie late in the game.
Yay Florida.Mongoose wrote:We are about blown away down here in Tampa Bay (Tropical Storm Andrea)! I used an umbrella to get to work, but the sideways rain soaked my slacks.
Awesome! I'm obsessed with so many restaurants in Orlando.Elohcin wrote:Yay Florida.Mongoose wrote:We are about blown away down here in Tampa Bay (Tropical Storm Andrea)! I used an umbrella to get to work, but the sideways rain soaked my slacks.
I'm from Orlando!
Are you in some particular hurry?Mongoose wrote:I voted A Person for reasons that have been discussed thoroughly previously.
Yes - power is out at my house, so I gotta vote before I leave work.Nevinera wrote:Are you in some particular hurry?Mongoose wrote:I voted A Person for reasons that have been discussed thoroughly previously.
Care to name a few? The Melting Pot is my absolute favorite. However the one nearest Orlando has closed, but there is a newer one in Atamonte.Mongoose wrote:Awesome! I'm obsessed with so many restaurants in Orlando.Elohcin wrote:Yay Florida.Mongoose wrote:We are about blown away down here in Tampa Bay (Tropical Storm Andrea)! I used an umbrella to get to work, but the sideways rain soaked my slacks.
I'm from Orlando!
Ah, that makes sense. Sorry, I forgot you mentioned that.Mongoose wrote: Yes - power is out at my house, so I gotta vote before I leave work.