[SPECTATOR CHAT] Mafia of Montreal

[sprityo]

then again, we cant all have over 11 thousand posts

heehee

[Typhoony]

Don't take it the wrong way btw, you guys were great too I was just hoping for a tighter fight The Gay Parade baddies are having it too easy.

They don't have it that easy. One of them has practically been outed in the thread as a Gay Parade baddie, yet somehow none of the remaining civs have noticed that. It's quite baffling

[S~V~S]

then again, we cant all have over 11 thousand posts

heehee

iirc I am member #2, lol. Plus I talk alot

[Black Rock]

Spoiler: show

I kinda wish people had listened to ekeknat and gone after the Gay Parade Sorry BR, I was (secretly) rooting for you to pull through. If you survived today there's a very good chance you would've won.

Thanks Enrique. I was screwed from the beginning. Also there was nothing to work with in the thread. I hope the civs win.

[Black Rock]

Well they were better off with me in the game.

Spoiler: show

I already figured two of them out and I was not going to throw them under the bus (till I got pissed off) or kill them.

Now they only have a kill once every other night. *sigh*

[Marmot]

then again, we cant all have over 11 thousand posts

heehee

iirc I am member #2, lol. Plus I talk alot

[Marmot]

The amazing thing is that of the 6 lynches so far, only 1 has been of a civilian. 2 Indy lynches (3 if you count Scotty's survival), 2 Coquelicot baddie lynches, and just the single Coquelicot civvie lynch.

[S~V~S]

Aw leave poor Dana alone, you baddie meanies

The only GP baddie I am sure about is LC. He is always so obvious IMO. I waffle on Zebra. No idea on the third.

[Ricochet]

Rose Robert, I'd like to welcome you to...

[Ricochet]

Wait, is Rose Robert a he?

[S~V~S]

OK, after that "Lovely distancing" comment re someone I feel good about, I have firmly moved Zebra into the McBadderson column.

[Typhoony]

I assume BR mimi'd Zebra which is why she was so certain about her in the thread... Can you confirm that BR?

[Scotty]

welcome black rock! Sorry you guys didn't pull it out.
I'm 2/2 in called out baddies Day 1! That's a new high score for me!

Now if only I could last into day 2.

[Typhoony]

Let that be a lesson. Never joke about killing me!

[Black Rock]

I assume BR mimi'd Zebra which is why she was so certain about her in the thread... Can you confirm that BR?

Nah, I was trying to Boomslang her. I think she's obvious anyways.

[Black Rock]

welcome black rock! Sorry you guys didn't pull it out.
I'm 2/2 in called out baddies Day 1! That's a new high score for me!

Now if only I could last into day 2.

If you didn't die night 1 you would have died night 2.

[Scotty]

Let that be a lesson. Never joke about killing me!

I stopped learning after middle school. Some might say I even stopped learning after setting fire to my neighbor's cat while in pre-K.

welcome black rock! Sorry you guys didn't pull it out.
I'm 2/2 in called out baddies Day 1! That's a new high score for me!

Now if only I could last into day 2.

If you didn't die night 1 you would have died night 2.

Well, no. Because I would have been exempt from being NK'd on even nights
And think of all the hundreds of posts I could have made by then to defame you! Just think, Charlie! A world of pure imagination!

[Black Rock]

Let that be a lesson. Never joke about killing me!

I stopped learning after middle school. Some might say I even stopped learning after setting fire to my neighbor's cat while in pre-K.

welcome black rock! Sorry you guys didn't pull it out.
I'm 2/2 in called out baddies Day 1! That's a new high score for me!

Now if only I could last into day 2.

If you didn't die night 1 you would have died night 2.

Well, no. Because I would have been exempt from being NK'd on even nights
And think of all the hundreds of posts I could have made by then to defame you! Just think, Charlie! A world of pure imagination!

You were just annoying and had nothing. I forgot about your role. You would have never survived long anyways. SVS at least had a reason to chase after me.

[Scotty]

Annoying, eh?

I'd like to think my reasoning for suspecting you and Nutella made sense in the scheme of things, though I can see where you're coming from with no one believing me or my presumptions. Though svs' logic initially mirrored mine, she was more trustworthy for sure.

[Black Rock]

Annoying, eh?

I'd like to think my reasoning for suspecting you and Nutella made sense in the scheme of things, though I can see where you're coming from with no one believing me or my presumptions. Though svs' logic initially mirrored mine, she was more trustworthy for sure.

I assumed SVS used her power on me, I imagined the same night I targeted her. I may be wrong but it seemed that way.

[S~V~S]

I wasn't trustworthy, I had info and not much to make a case with, I think you had missed 2 votes when I was NKed, BR? I combed through the posts but there was nothing there that could not be said about others, except for the never mentioning Nutella bit. I lied about you telling me that, but I needed a hook

So I made a shitty case. SVS making a shitty case = info 9 times out of 10

Linki, yeah, that was a weird coincidence.

[S~V~S]

Wow, Zebras reply to Made, mega mega bad.

Now I recall how I used to read her when she was Keterman, when she is bad, she is not unlike boo. They both say a lot of sensible things, and are pretty on point, BUT the snark is notched just a tad higher, and then, after I am mostly agreeing with everything they say, or at least seeing theor point, they will suddenly say something totally & violently diametrically opposed to everything I know/believe to be true, and start pushing suspicion based on it.

Yeah.

[Marmot]

Wow, Zebras reply to Made, mega mega bad.

Now I recall how I used to read her when she was Keterman, when she is bad, she is not unlike boo. They both say a lot of sensible things, and are pretty on point, BUT the snark is notched just a tad higher, and then, after I am mostly agreeing with everything they say, or at least seeing theor point, they will suddenly say something totally & violently diametrically opposed to everything I know/believe to be true, and start pushing suspicion based on it.

Yeah.

I agree. Made is so obviously civ, I think a civ zebra would have picked up on it by now.

Plus, that post from Made is not waffly at all. I dunno how zebra concluded that.

[Enrique]

Wait, is Rose Robert a he?

Doesn't the song use female pronouns? I'm not sure actually but I always assumed that.

[Ricochet]

Wait, is Rose Robert a he?

Doesn't the song use female pronouns? I'm not sure actually but I always assumed that.

Actually, it never does, it's always calling by name or "my RR". "mon chere" is simply my dear.

It was that + stuff like "The gentlemen don't know whether to bow their heads
or tip their hats" + "You draw on your mustache while I powder my nose." that made me wonder aloud.

Then again, that last line could be just roleplay fun antics.

Maybe I'm just reading too much into it. The song others seems like a regular, hipsy, witty love song, in which two souls just connect in their own way.

[Ricochet]

Oh, forgot to mention, but of course the thing that threw me off was googling Rose Robert and only males coming up.

[Enrique]

Hm yeah I always thought of it as a couple of (heterosexual) crossdressers, so you'd have the male singer wearing lipstick and RR wearing a moustache or whatever. But yeah, it's probably ambiguous because the interpretation doesn't matter and all you're supposed to get is that they're having fun roleplaying.

[Epignosis]

I don't know anything about Of Montreal, but this is my favorite song about gay prostitution:

[Ricochet]

Hm yeah I always thought of it as a couple of (heterosexual) crossdressers, so you'd have the male singer wearing lipstick and RR wearing a moustache or whatever. But yeah, it's probably ambiguous because the interpretation doesn't matter and all you're supposed to get is that they're having fun roleplaying.

Ah good point. That could explain the gentlemen part, too.

[Marmot]

I don't know anything about Of Montreal, but this is my favorite song about gay prostitution:

Or there's this dandy.

Spoiler: show

[sig]

Black Rock/nutella why'd you kill me night 2?

[Typhoony]

This thread is becoming more active than the actual game

[Enrique]

eesh wouldn't that be something

Not quite gay prostitution, but how about transexual promiscuity? I like this one.

Spoiler: show

[S~V~S]

This thread is becoming more active than the actual game

Well, they killed all the people who actually want to play lol.

[sprityo]

Ironically

[Enrique]

This is depressing.

[S~V~S]

Rezz us Maybe make them dead and make us alive?

Well, you can't actually rezz us.But force them to post. Contest maybe?

[nutella]

I don't know anything about Of Montreal, but this is my favorite song about gay prostitution:

Love this song


Sorry to BR/others for being such an obvious baddie and not putting much effort in to not be :\ You'd think after 8 years I'd be good at mafia but I'm not

[Black Rock]

I wasn't trustworthy, I had info and not much to make a case with, I think you had missed 2 votes when I was NKed, BR? I combed through the posts but there was nothing there that could not be said about others, except for the never mentioning Nutella bit. I lied about you telling me that, but I needed a hook

So I made a shitty case. SVS making a shitty case = info 9 times out of 10

Linki, yeah, that was a weird coincidence.

Thats why I couldn't remember ever saying that. Saying LA to avoid nutella? Bunch of bull if I ever saw it.

[Black Rock]

Black Rock/nutella why'd you kill me night 2?

No good reason.

[Black Rock]

This thread is becoming more active than the actual game

i found it hard to be active in the thread, there was nothing to say.

[Black Rock]

I don't know anything about Of Montreal, but this is my favorite song about gay prostitution:

Love this song


Sorry to BR/others for being such an obvious baddie and not putting much effort in to not be :\ You'd think after 8 years I'd be good at mafia but I'm not

Sorry I voted for you. I felt real dirty. I don't like doing that to teammates. I was just trying to distance myself. It wasn't worth it. I'll never do it to you again.

[S~V~S]

I felt very certain about Nutella, since then I'm finding it hard to feel as confident about someone else. I suspected Long Con of being her partner, clearly I was wrong on that. The thing that changed my mind about him might not preclude him from being gay parade, but it felt more like a civ move than anything else. I won't preclude him from being bad, but I'd be interested in hearing cases on others too...

Hmmmmm... interesting. I think a bit of a re-read might be helpful for me. I am super curious about what that thing was, so hopefully I can find it on a re-read. I don't know you can or feel comfortable going into more detail, but I'll see what I can find. I don't think I saw what you saw, but I am always Teh Suck at role hints, etc.

But, if it didn't preclude him from being GP in your mind... and they're the only team left... I think that's something too. Ya dig?

Here are my nominations for GP mafia: Long Con, Made, ekeknat, in that order. I'm more than willing to hear opposition as long as whoever opposes has an idea of who to lynch instead and why. I believe that civs should stand with civs as well, and if anyone displays words or behavior that implies they disagree, I'm calling them out. Looking at you indiglo.

Look all you want, dearie! I'll even twirl! I have nothing to hide, I would say "nothing to see here"... but that's not entirely true, I am faboo. I think we're coming to a crossroads of the game, and it's time to shore up our sidelines, so to speak. I 100% think civs should win with civs, a nagging concern was bothering me, so I mentioned it. I think it's really important to try to coordinate the best we can, and we only have the thread to do it in, and we don't have a ton of time to do all that.


Mega linki...

Depending on how the nightkills have gone, it looks like up to a third of the players alive have already won. It's good to see that the idea of Civs winning with Civs is popular, and the fact that someone I suspect is Coq says it warms my heart. I really think a Made vote is the way to go today.

I think these are the baddies. Trying to demonize civvies for trying to meet their win cons however with this "civs for civs" business. LC, Indi & Zebra. Using the civvies win cons against them as it were to make themselves look super civ.

Smart, but they sound a bit smarmy to me, faux, you know?

I am beginning to think I like spectrating better than playing

[Typhoony]

I am going to be absolutely baffled if any of the civs follow in voting Made.

Linki:

If indiglo is bad, that would make my last post before my lynch amazing

[Typhoony]

This one:

Well I'm gonna get lynched.

So... I think tonight some protection for Ekeknat would be nice.
Tomorrow you guys should lynch LC if you want a Gay Parade baddie.

What else...

I want BR to explain what team she thinks Zebra is on and if she thinks LC is bad.
I don't think DF/ekeknat/Made/SD/sprityo are bad.
I don't think Dana is nutellas teammate, but could very well be LCs teammate.
Leaves BR/Zebra/Indiglo. No read on Indiglo. I'll let BR and Zebra fight it out and figure out which one of them is bad.

Linki with DF:
Nope.

[S~V~S]

Indi just sounds smarmy & fake to me, like she is *trying* to sound as noble as possible. Look at all of those smilies!

And yeah re Made, that post was very straightforward and the total opposite of waffly.

And yeah, that is pretty amazing. But I think those are our baddies right there, LC, Zeebs & Indi.

[Typhoony]

I'm not even talking about Made's posts, the fact that she was insanified twice is a huge hint to her identity.

[S~V~S]

Yeah there is that too :P

[Marmot]

I'm not even talking about Made's posts, the fact that she was insanified twice is a huge hint to her identity.

I think he faked a silence too.

Oh hey! SVS, there's a good reason to fake being silenced if Made managed to get himself insanified 3 days in a row.

[Typhoony]

I don't know whether to applaud the baddies or to boo the civvies.