Arkham Mafia [ENDGAME]

#1801

sprityo wrote:
Turnip Head wrote: Are you talking to me? What is your question?

sprityo wrote:
1. Why Wilgy?

2. Why Scotty?
i mean it's not directly at you TH, but if you want to answer. I was just looking for input. (also i dont remember if anyone DID reply to that aside from your sassy comment)

Because dank memes are pretty sweet. Have you seen that one with the sad frog? Really makes me have some the feels mang.

#1802

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:@MM Why would someone opt not to vote instead of voting for someone with zero votes or casting a suspicious vote?

The Penguin
As a powerful informant, The Penguin learns the role of the person he votes for, and may blackmail his victim. The victim has a choice to either do whatever The Penguin says or have his or her role sent to a rival person. The Penguin wins by surviving.
Ok. Why would the Penguin forfeit its vote and ability?

So as not to out himself or risk blowback from a sketchy vote.

IDK, I don't really have the energy or the patience to pursue anymore of the SVS suspicion. lol.

#1803

DH can I NK you?

#1804

DrWilgy wrote:DH can I NK you?

I don't know, can you?

#1805

Hi, everyone!

I'm... 35 pages behind.

Honestly, I don't have the time to read it all.

#1806

MovingPictures07 wrote:Hi, everyone!

I'm... 35 pages behind.

Honestly, I don't have the time to read it all.

Such a nub

#1807

DharmaHelper wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:Hi, everyone!

I'm... 35 pages behind.

Honestly, I don't have the time to read it all.
Such a nub

No u

Seriously, you all are nubs for posting so much.

#1808

Normally, I wouldn't be able to live with myself for not having at least read every post skimming, let alone full-on, let alone analyze each post, but realistically I just don't have the time and I cannot sacrifice PhD time. Maybe I'll skim them SUPER quick or something later tonight. What's the most important stuff?

#1809

This is fun; I've never been that guy before. Maybe I'll randomize my Day 2 vote.

#1810

MovingPictures07 wrote:Normally, I wouldn't be able to live with myself for not having at least read every post skimming, let alone full-on, let alone analyze each post, but realistically I just don't have the time and I cannot sacrifice PhD time. Maybe I'll skim them SUPER quick or something later tonight. What's the most important stuff?

Depends who you ask :P

#1811

Turnip Head wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:Normally, I wouldn't be able to live with myself for not having at least read every post skimming, let alone full-on, let alone analyze each post, but realistically I just don't have the time and I cannot sacrifice PhD time. Maybe I'll skim them SUPER quick or something later tonight. What's the most important stuff?
Depends who you ask :P

Well, since you were nice enough to respond first, what are your thoughts?

#1812

This is where I'm at right now. Anything else will be expanded upon as we go forward.

#1813

Turnip Head wrote:This is where I'm at right now. Anything else will be expanded upon as we go forward.

#1814

MovingPictures07 wrote:This is fun; I've never been that guy before. Maybe I'll randomize my Day 2 vote.

Random votes always go to MM. Thats like the Syndicate rule.

I can't imagine being in your position. I think, though, that at least some skimming might give you some ideas.

It might be worth picking on a couple of isos.

#1815

@MP Mafia is defiantly more important then your PhD I mean you can go back and get that whenever there will only be one Epi n LC Arkham Asylum game :P

#1816

MovingPictures07 wrote:This is fun; I've never been that guy before. Maybe I'll randomize my Day 2 vote.

Says the guy who votes people for random-voting.

#1817

I vote you start near EoD and go back to read anything you want to know more about.

#1818

Golden wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:This is fun; I've never been that guy before. Maybe I'll randomize my Day 2 vote.
Random votes always go to MM. Thats like the Syndicate rule.

I can't imagine being in your position. I think, though, that at least some skimming might give you some ideas.

It might be worth picking on a couple of isos.

Yeah, I'll see what I can do this weekend. I'll try, at least, don't get me wrong. I won't be apathetic.

There are some ISOs?

#1819

sig wrote:@MP Mafia is defiantly more important then your PhD I mean you can go back and get that whenever there will only be one Epi n LC Arkham Asylum game :P

Hmmm... good point.

#1820

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:This is fun; I've never been that guy before. Maybe I'll randomize my Day 2 vote.
Says the guy who votes people for random-voting.

Yep.

#1821

Turnip Head wrote:I vote you start near EoD and go back to read anything you want to know more about.

Good plan, I'll do that.

#1822

Golden wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:This is fun; I've never been that guy before. Maybe I'll randomize my Day 2 vote.
Random votes always go to MM. Thats like the Syndicate rule.

I can't imagine being in your position. I think, though, that at least some skimming might give you some ideas.

It might be worth picking on a couple of isos.

That's fine. I nightkill players that random vote me.

#1823

sig wrote:@MP Mafia is defiantly more important then your PhD I mean you can go back and get that whenever there will only be one Epi n LC Arkham Asylum game :P

Sig, this is why I have bad grades.

#1824

All right, I believe I have everything sorted. This has been an unusual Night 1 in more ways than fourteen hundred. Results forthcoming.

#1825

Gotham more like GOD DAMN

#1826

That can't be good.

#1827

People died and there were not many left.

Day 2 begins, you may all lynch Sockface now.

#1828

I'm gonna be so mad if there isn't a Kiss from a Rose reference in this night post you guys.

#1829

A MURDER IN GOTHAM

Commissioner Gordon stepped over the fluttering police tape, his shoes splashing down in a puddle on the rain-soaked street.

"Hey, watch it, Commish!" barked Bullock, shielding himself from the water. "As if we ain't wet enough out here already!"

"What have you got for me, Bullock?" asked the Commissioner evenly, surveying the scene.

"One victim, goes by the name of, uh-" Bullock checked the report he had been writing. "DrWilgy. Yeah, poor guy, all slashed up. Probably not even a doctor. Looks like an episode of Dexter in there."

"All right, canvas the area, look for witnesses." Gordon ordered. "I want the suspect's name on my desk ton--"

"Victor Zsasz." The grim voice from behind him cut Commissioner Gordon off, and he turned to see Batman emerge from the darkness, quiet as a shadow. "A local wino told me he saw a man with a bunch of tally mark scars all over his body at the scene."

"That man is an absolute sociopath," said Gordon grimly.

"I'll find him for you, Jim," promised Batman. "I'll find them all, and bring them down."

A gust of wind drove the rain hard into Commissioner Gordon's face, and he held up a hand to shield his eyes. "You do that. And when you--"

He stopped, realizing Batman had already vanished silently. He ran a hand down the length of his face, brushing rain droplets away and shaking his head. "Someday, I'll have to get him to tell me how he does that."

DrWilgy has been killed by the Falcone family.
It is now Day 2. You have 48 hours to lynch someone.

#1830

Good morning.

I understand we're all on edge.
In our line of work, it is not unusual to work privately in pockets, to take leads as you get them, only to regroup at the station with information gleaned from the day.

I would now advise strongly against that.

Our department has been breached. I found a crumpled fax receipt in the waste bin this morning to one Salvatore Maroni, whom we all know is the head of Maroni crime organization.

To the one that sent this fax, I urge you strongly to reconsider the implications of your actions. I know not all of you may trust my judgment, but this is not a fight you want to fight. You will receive your comeuppance one way or another, rest assured.

In lieu of the myriad of high-profile criminals running amok, and some of our own willing to jump ship, I am patently urging all of you to hold your information close to your chest; be careful placing trust in those around you. This is not the Gotham I envisioned for my kids, and it is not the Gotham I intend for them to inherit. We must remain strong and apprehend these crime families and super villains- even if that means allying with The Bat vigilante once again.

Last night, I went with several other investigators to the scene of the crime. Catfoot Regan, the jewel thief, was adamant that the Bat was seen just 15 minutes after the recent breakout, heading north. That's the only lead I have, I'm afraid.

Keep your heads down. Be smart. Hopefully tomorrow I'll have some good news.

-Gordon

#1831

To which location will you travel this evening?

Poll ended at Fri Feb 19, 2016 8:53 pm

Arkham Asylum
3
DrWilgy (18), Matt (22), sabie12 (26)
10%

Wayne Manor
4
Metalmarsh89 (4), Turnip Head (7), juliets (10), MovingPictures07 (21)
13%

Wayne Enterprises
2
S~V~S (8), LoRab (24)
6%

Fish Mooney's
3
Dom (23), Golden (28), ekeknat (29)
10%

The Docks
0
No votes

Gotham City Police Department
4
sig (9), sprityo (13), bea (19), Nerolunar (25)
13%

City Hall
4
Black Rock (12), Scotty (16), DFaraday (17), Bubbles (30)
13%

Park Row
3
DharmaHelper (1), a2thezebra (5), Sorsha (6)
10%

Blackgate Penitentiary
3
MacDougall (11), Typhoony (15), Bullzeye (20)
10%

Gotham City General Hospital
2
Enrique (2), Glorfindel (14)
6%

Slaughter Swamp (The Hosts, the Non, Dead)
3
Epignosis (3), Long Con (27), nijuukyugou (31)
10%

Total votes : 31

#1832

RIPIYWG Wiggles

#1833

Awesome write-up Epi

#1834

Glorfindel wrote:Awesome write-up Epi

Long Con wrote that one.

#1835

Only had 300 posts left to catch up on, big post and everything half written too

#1836

RIP DrWilgy! Odd choice of kill.

So I've been skimming so far and wanted to at least acknowledge that Dom and Golden are apparently suspicious of me. If either of you have anything you wanted me to address that I've missed, just let me know. Dom, I'm not sure how much stock you've put into my explanation of my original post where you claim I was "hedging" suspicion of you, but I don't know what else to say about it. I think anyone who "hedges" like that would be a terrible baddie if they later use a "I always read so and so wrong" joke as justification for changing their mind on someone without anything else substantiated. Trust me, if I do that, by and means, question me on it and lynch me for it.

#1837

/going to keep reading

I'll provide a gut-based rainbow based on at least what I've read when I get done. Probably will be a while though.

#1838

MovingPictures07 wrote:RIP DrWilgy! Odd choice of kill.

So I've been skimming so far and wanted to at least acknowledge that Dom and Golden are apparently suspicious of me. If either of you have anything you wanted me to address that I've missed, just let me know. Dom, I'm not sure how much stock you've put into my explanation of my original post where you claim I was "hedging" suspicion of you, but I don't know what else to say about it. I think anyone who "hedges" like that would be a terrible baddie if they later use a "I always read so and so wrong" joke as justification for changing their mind on someone without anything else substantiated. Trust me, if I do that, by and means, question me on it and lynch me for it.

In what was is the Dr. Wilgy kill odd in your estimation?

#1839

In what way*

#1840

DharmaHelper wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:RIP DrWilgy! Odd choice of kill.

So I've been skimming so far and wanted to at least acknowledge that Dom and Golden are apparently suspicious of me. If either of you have anything you wanted me to address that I've missed, just let me know. Dom, I'm not sure how much stock you've put into my explanation of my original post where you claim I was "hedging" suspicion of you, but I don't know what else to say about it. I think anyone who "hedges" like that would be a terrible baddie if they later use a "I always read so and so wrong" joke as justification for changing their mind on someone without anything else substantiated. Trust me, if I do that, by and means, question me on it and lynch me for it.
In what was is the Dr. Wilgy kill odd in your estimation?

Well, he was tied for the most votes d1, so I just think that's odd. There were plenty of other players who didn't receive any votes.

#1841

Would anyone who was around for Day 1, particularly EoD, say that Wilgy had a relatively high or higher propensity to be a lynch candidate for d2?

#1842

Epignosis wrote:Good morning.

I understand we're all on edge.
In our line of work, it is not unusual to work privately in pockets, to take leads as you get them, only to regroup at the station with information gleaned from the day.

I would now advise strongly against that.

Our department has been breached. I found a crumpled fax receipt in the waste bin this morning to one Salvatore Maroni, whom we all know is the head of Maroni crime organization.

To the one that sent this fax, I urge you strongly to reconsider the implications of your actions. I know not all of you may trust my judgment, but this is not a fight you want to fight. You will receive your comeuppance one way or another, rest assured.

In lieu of the myriad of high-profile criminals running amok, and some of our own willing to jump ship, I am patently urging all of you to hold your information close to your chest; be careful placing trust in those around you. This is not the Gotham I envisioned for my kids, and it is not the Gotham I intend for them to inherit. We must remain strong and apprehend these crime families and super villains- even if that means allying with The Bat vigilante once again.

Last night, I went with several other investigators to the scene of the crime. Catfoot Regan, the jewel thief, was adamant that the Bat was seen just 15 minutes after the recent breakout, heading north. That's the only lead I have, I'm afraid.

Keep your heads down. Be smart. Hopefully tomorrow I'll have some good news.

-Gordon

For my money, this post gives me pause to look more critically at those players advocating open discussion of the clues from our night time destinations.

#1843

Controversial opinion (maybe): I feel pretty good about S~V~S based on what I'm reading (EoD).

#1844

MovingPictures07 wrote:Would anyone who was around for Day 1, particularly EoD, say that Wilgy had a relatively high or higher propensity to be a lynch candidate for d2?

From my perspective and at that time, I'd not have thought so but being unfamiliar with his playstyle, I'd not place much stock in my opinions on this one MP.

#1845

MovingPictures07 wrote:Controversial opinion (maybe): I feel pretty good about S~V~S based on what I'm reading (EoD).

Would you care to elaborate on that please MP?

#1846

Glorfindel wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:Controversial opinion (maybe): I feel pretty good about S~V~S based on what I'm reading (EoD).
Would you care to elaborate on that please MP?

I don't have much backing up that opinion, but from a tone-based perspective I'd say she's reading pretty genuine to me. Usually I find myself questioning S~V~S's intentions more than most players even, but I haven't done that yet.

#1847

Glorfindel I'm almost convinced your a baddie at this point. Gordon a player with no additional information said to not share evidence okay cool, NOT we should look at the players who where for it. Which was mainly me, Zebra, and Dfraday. This seems like your trying to start the wheels of my lynch especially since the only argument used against me yesterday to justify my lynch was me advocating for us to share map information. If he wanted us to look more closely at certain players I'd think he'd have said it. He is going along with the general thoughts in the thread no map sharing, and Team Bat are good.
I'm also curious you seemed to have ignored zebra sharing information in an attempt to "trap" me?

Could wilgy's death have anything to do with him being on the right track about a player? He didn't have many posts, but I agree with MP he seemed like a random choice for the first NK, unless they thought he was the other mafia team and so far in my experience here on TS the mafia don't gun for each other this early. Thoughts?

#1848

Epignosis wrote:
Glorfindel wrote:Awesome write-up Epi
Long Con wrote that one.

I thought I recognized his style.

DrWilgy wrote:Only had 300 posts left to catch up on, big post and everything half written too

So sad. I took a break from catching up and waited for the post.

#1849

I don't understand the Breaking Bad hype? The characters are annoying though I'd like to play a mafia game based around it so I could help get rid of the annoying characters :P

So I skimmed over Wilgy's posts. One possibly role hint which I doubt and then his rainbow list.

DrWilgy wrote:Based soley on result of yesterdays lynch, I wouldn't try to lynch Scotty again btw. (Still 900 posts behind. Still think TH is a badewd.)

I suppose a "thoughts at this point rainbow" may be needed before EoN. I may not be here.
Scotty
Zebra
Mac
Everyone else
Dom
Bea
TH

So he might not have been a priority player to be lynched again today, but what are the chances he was killed for being on the right track? I'm not putting much stake in this at all and I wouldn't even use this as a reason to vote for someone but I think it is worth bringing up.
What I find really interesting is that he was almost lynched then NK'd. I think someone really wanted to get rid of Wilgy.

Which also adds to the idea he at some point mentioned a mafia member and that they are hoping that in killing him it will be forgotten.

#1850

sig wrote:Glorfindel I'm almost convinced your a baddie at this point. Gordon a player with no additional information said to not share evidence okay cool, NOT we should look at the players who where for it. Which was mainly me, Zebra, and Dfraday. This seems like your trying to start the wheels of my lynch especially since the only argument used against me yesterday to justify my lynch was me advocating for us to share map information. If he wanted us to look more closely at certain players I'd think he'd have said it. He is going along with the general thoughts in the thread no map sharing, and Team Bat are good.
I'm also curious you seemed to have ignored zebra sharing information in an attempt to "trap" me?

Could wilgy's death have anything to do with him being on the right track about a player? He didn't have many posts, but I agree with MP he seemed like a random choice for the first NK, unless they thought he was the other mafia team and so far in my experience here on TS the mafia don't gun for each other this early. Thoughts?

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

Who killed no one?