
Arkham Mafia [ENDGAME]
Moderator: Community Team
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
I'm with Mac in that Wilgy could've simply assumed Scotty was Robin, but I don't suspect Scotty either way so it's moot.









- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 454
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
Dom asked the thread about it.sig wrote:You mentioned Wilgy again MP.

- Dom
- mayor of gaytown
- Posts in topic: 513
- Posts: 9997
- Joined: Mon Jan 14, 2013 11:36 pm
- Location: Wherever Niall is TBH
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
Hmm...MovingPictures07 wrote:Dom, the theory is that:
1) DrWilgy is Robin.
2) Because DrWilgy was in danger of being lynched, he stopped the lynch.
3) However, despite he and Scotty being publicly tied, somehow Scotty was the one that was supposed to die.
4) Because of that, Robin "saves" Scotty by stopping the lynch. If you look at Robin's role, you'll see he can stop the lynch once for himself and one other time for someone else. When stopping for someone else, he "saves" that person and learns their role.
5) DrWilgy then comes into the thread, after the lynch is over, and strongly implores us not to lynch Scotty, implying that, if he was Robin, he must have saved Scotty and got a civilian check from him.
6) Therefore, Scotty is a civilian, as long as DrWilgy was Robin.
My confusion comes in in step 3. Why do we think that's true?
Spoiler: show
- juliets
- Dancing Pancake
- Posts in topic: 336
- Posts: 16430
- Joined: Mon Dec 24, 2012 3:16 pm
- Location: Moobyworld
- Gender: Female
- Preferred Pronouns: she/her/hers
- Aka: jules
- Contact:
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
Oh dang, I read the role wrong. Thanks sig.sig wrote:Enrique, i lost you here. Why would someone who is insanified know who the Joker is and why does it narrow down their possible roles?[/quotejuliets wrote:Enrique wrote: I'm assuming this is what happened
You know what's great about that? Not only do crazy people know who the Joker is, but it narrows down their possible roles by a lot.Anyone who targets The Joker will be made insane by the toxic flower on his lapel. He needs Batman, Gordon, Falcone, and Maroni dead. *Secrets*
So it's not a good look for Matt either way, but I was hoping he could give us a better lynch option for today.
@Juliets.
"The Joker
Anyone who targets The Joker will be made insane by the toxic flower on his lapel. He needs Batman, Gordon, Falcone, and Maroni dead. *Secrets*"
MP, I have a lot of people in no man's land right now. I do read zebra as civ as well as DH and Mac and Dom. It must be said though that Mac and DH fooled the crap out of me in GOC so my civ reads are necessarily wobbly on them. I have a warning sign for Bass but then he hasn't been around lately for me to get a better feel for and it was a weak warning sign.
Spoiler: show
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 454
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
Hey sig, why don't you explain this for me? How am I hunting for Robin?MovingPictures07 wrote:Yeah, but IIRC you kept pressing the topic. I'll go back and look when I get the chance to see if I'm misremembering how much you talked about it. And I'm not sure how one could say that; elaborate for me.sig wrote:I mentioned it yes, but so did you? In fact one could say your role hunting for robin if he is still alive.MovingPictures07 wrote:
Re: sig, I get a nervous feeling from some of sig's posts, and I felt like he was dwelling a lot on the "why did Wilgy die?", seemed like unnecessary WIFOM to me. I also think Turnip Head's observation regarding why sig didn't mention the suspicion was an astute point.
@Matt do you think you where cursed by someone or you did something like target someone and that got you cursed?
linki: Stop posting when I'm trying to submit.
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 454
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
Well, it's inferred based on Wilgy's behavior in Step 5. Without that, then I wouldn't say I necessarily think 3) is true.Dom wrote:Hmm...MovingPictures07 wrote:Dom, the theory is that:
1) DrWilgy is Robin.
2) Because DrWilgy was in danger of being lynched, he stopped the lynch.
3) However, despite he and Scotty being publicly tied, somehow Scotty was the one that was supposed to die.
4) Because of that, Robin "saves" Scotty by stopping the lynch. If you look at Robin's role, you'll see he can stop the lynch once for himself and one other time for someone else. When stopping for someone else, he "saves" that person and learns their role.
5) DrWilgy then comes into the thread, after the lynch is over, and strongly implores us not to lynch Scotty, implying that, if he was Robin, he must have saved Scotty and got a civilian check from him.
6) Therefore, Scotty is a civilian, as long as DrWilgy was Robin.
My confusion comes in in step 3. Why do we think that's true?
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
By potentially outing him to the thread for no practical purpose?MovingPictures07 wrote:Hey sig, why don't you explain this for me? How am I hunting for Robin?MovingPictures07 wrote:Yeah, but IIRC you kept pressing the topic. I'll go back and look when I get the chance to see if I'm misremembering how much you talked about it. And I'm not sure how one could say that; elaborate for me.sig wrote:I mentioned it yes, but so did you? In fact one could say your role hunting for robin if he is still alive.MovingPictures07 wrote:
Re: sig, I get a nervous feeling from some of sig's posts, and I felt like he was dwelling a lot on the "why did Wilgy die?", seemed like unnecessary WIFOM to me. I also think Turnip Head's observation regarding why sig didn't mention the suspicion was an astute point.
@Matt do you think you where cursed by someone or you did something like target someone and that got you cursed?
linki: Stop posting when I'm trying to submit.









- Turnip Head
- Root Vegetable
- Posts in topic: 592
- Posts: 11432
- Joined: Thu Dec 05, 2013 6:37 am
- Preferred Pronouns: they/their
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
sig please address my recent post addressed to you. You mischaracterized my play, I deserve to know that you have at least acknowledged my response.
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 454
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
But if Wilgy was Robin, he's dead. It doesn't matter. I'm speculating that Scotty could be a civilian, which is of practical purpose, given he almost fucking died yesterday, and clearly had lynch momentum to go forward. I could have just saved us a mislynch.Enrique wrote:By potentially outing him to the thread for no practical purpose?MovingPictures07 wrote:Hey sig, why don't you explain this for me? How am I hunting for Robin?MovingPictures07 wrote:Yeah, but IIRC you kept pressing the topic. I'll go back and look when I get the chance to see if I'm misremembering how much you talked about it. And I'm not sure how one could say that; elaborate for me.sig wrote:I mentioned it yes, but so did you? In fact one could say your role hunting for robin if he is still alive.MovingPictures07 wrote:
Re: sig, I get a nervous feeling from some of sig's posts, and I felt like he was dwelling a lot on the "why did Wilgy die?", seemed like unnecessary WIFOM to me. I also think Turnip Head's observation regarding why sig didn't mention the suspicion was an astute point.
@Matt do you think you where cursed by someone or you did something like target someone and that got you cursed?
linki: Stop posting when I'm trying to submit.
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
Knock knock.
Enrique - Who's there?
Matt - Enrique
Enrique - Enrique who?
Matt - Enrique, he who goes for the easy lynch target, and just in case that doesn't work, target paints the hell out of them.

Linki
Knock knock.
Who's there?
LOL
LOL who
LOL @ Enrique accusing MP of what Enrique quite literally just did to me.
Enrique - Who's there?
Matt - Enrique
Enrique - Enrique who?
Matt - Enrique, he who goes for the easy lynch target, and just in case that doesn't work, target paints the hell out of them.


Linki
Knock knock.
Who's there?
LOL
LOL who
LOL @ Enrique accusing MP of what Enrique quite literally just did to me.





Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
Except you're not a civvie so I don't care?Matt wrote:Knock knock.
Enrique - Who's there?
Matt - Enrique
Enrique - Enrique who?
Matt - Enrique, he who goes for the easy lynch target, and just in case that doesn't work, target paints the hell out of them.![]()
Linki
Knock knock.
Who's there?
LOL
LOL who
LOL @ Enrique accusing MP of what Enrique quite literally just did to me.









Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
I mentioned Wilgy's death three times. You've mentioned him and your robin theory naming him directly seven times.
Yes Enriques got it MP, you keep mentioning him about lynch saving it seems like you are fishing.
@TH okay let me find it.
Yes Enriques got it MP, you keep mentioning him about lynch saving it seems like you are fishing.
@TH okay let me find it.




Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
Renee(possibly Matt) targeted the Joker, becoming insane. I don´t know if the ability still works on the Joker or not, but if it doesn´t and nobody is silenced then Matt has to be Renee. It all depends on whether or not the Joker is still hit by the ability, but his role description doesn´t explain it.
This could go for any other role where the effect is easy to spot, though I don´t recall any other role where that is the case.
Im going to ask:
@Hosts: Is the Joker still hit by the ability that targeted him, even if he made the source insane?
Christ this linki.
This could go for any other role where the effect is easy to spot, though I don´t recall any other role where that is the case.
Im going to ask:
@Hosts: Is the Joker still hit by the ability that targeted him, even if he made the source insane?
Christ this linki.


Regardless, I think Nero should be lynched on grounds that he's my partner, your partner, Enrique's partner, the Joker, the Riddler, the Gingerbread Man, and Toto.
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 454
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
Fishing for what? What the hell are you talking about?sig wrote:I mentioned Wilgy's death three times. You've mentioned him and your robin theory naming him directly seven times.
Yes Enriques got it MP, you keep mentioning him about lynch saving it seems like you are fishing.
@TH okay let me find it.
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
Not true? There are three different role blocking instances every night, and nothing to indicate the Joker is immune to everything.Nerolunar wrote:Renee(possibly Matt) targeted the Joker, becoming insane. I don´t know if the ability still works on the Joker or not, but if it doesn´t and nobody is silenced then Matt has to be Renee. It all depends on whether or not the Joker is still hit by the ability, but his role description doesn´t explain it.
This could go for any other role where the effect is easy to spot, though I don´t recall any other role where that is the case.
Im going to ask:
@Hosts: Is the Joker still hit by the ability that targeted him, even if he made the source insane?
Christ this linki.









Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
Knock knock.
Who's there?
Everyone.
Everyone who?
Everyone, including Enrique and Nero, stop target painting the fuck out of me, please.
Who's there?
Everyone.
Everyone who?
Everyone, including Enrique and Nero, stop target painting the fuck out of me, please.





- Dom
- mayor of gaytown
- Posts in topic: 513
- Posts: 9997
- Joined: Mon Jan 14, 2013 11:36 pm
- Location: Wherever Niall is TBH
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
Hm... I'll have to think about it. That IS the only lynch save we know of.MovingPictures07 wrote:Well, it's inferred based on Wilgy's behavior in Step 5. Without that, then I wouldn't say I necessarily think 3) is true.Dom wrote:Hmm...MovingPictures07 wrote:Dom, the theory is that:
1) DrWilgy is Robin.
2) Because DrWilgy was in danger of being lynched, he stopped the lynch.
3) However, despite he and Scotty being publicly tied, somehow Scotty was the one that was supposed to die.
4) Because of that, Robin "saves" Scotty by stopping the lynch. If you look at Robin's role, you'll see he can stop the lynch once for himself and one other time for someone else. When stopping for someone else, he "saves" that person and learns their role.
5) DrWilgy then comes into the thread, after the lynch is over, and strongly implores us not to lynch Scotty, implying that, if he was Robin, he must have saved Scotty and got a civilian check from him.
6) Therefore, Scotty is a civilian, as long as DrWilgy was Robin.
My confusion comes in in step 3. Why do we think that's true?
Spoiler: show
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 454
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
Someone explain to me how speculating on Wilgy being Robin is a bad thing, because if no one had said anything, and we lynched Scotty today and he flipped civilian, then what are we doing? We're handing the game away, that's what we're doing.
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
Matt absolutely no one is gonna kill you for having the option of being one civ vs a trillion baddies.









Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
I don't see anyone going after Scotty like... at all.MovingPictures07 wrote:Someone explain to me how speculating on Wilgy being Robin is a bad thing, because if no one had said anything, and we lynched Scotty today and he flipped civilian, then what are we doing? We're handing the game away, that's what we're doing.









Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
Knock knock.Enrique wrote:Matt absolutely no one is gonna kill you for having the option of being one civ vs a trillion baddies.
Who's there?
He bad.
He bad who?
Enrique obvi. Target painting mofo.






Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
Oh I thought you focused on Wilgy then voted for Scotty? Sorry about that. No I don't think it was disingenuous, I used poor wording there. What do you think of MP bringing up your case on me?Turnip Head wrote:We cleared up our misunderstanding sig and I dropped it, do you think that was a disingenuous move on my part (by characterizing it as "didn't pan out")? And I never switched to Scottysig wrote:I'm not sure about TH first he tried to get me lynched and that didn't pan out, so he switched to Scotty on flimsy reasons.If you're talking about Wilgy, you can call my reasons flimsy if you want to. I don't see anyone else coming out with bulletproof cases on Day 1.
linki: Fishing for Robin's identity. If Wilgy isn't Robin, then someone else is and you are thinking they stopped the lynch so either it is Scotty or a third unknown who stopped the lynch. You seem to be talking about it an awful lot and fishing for information about Robin. If Robin is a third person and neither Scotty or Wilgy then he might be inclined to hint such in the thread even if they didn't do anything. It seems to be like your focusing just a little bit to much on Robin. While at the same time accusing me of focusing on Wilgy's death to much even though you are doing the same and attempting to figure out a pro civ roles.
linki: I don't think Scotty is on the table as a major lynch candidate at all today?




- Turnip Head
- Root Vegetable
- Posts in topic: 592
- Posts: 11432
- Joined: Thu Dec 05, 2013 6:37 am
- Preferred Pronouns: they/their
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
This thread is nuts today.
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
Im still just brainstorming. I can´t claim this to be true at all, but exercising ideas can´t possibly hurt.
Im not trying to stir up trouble or anything, I don´t want you guys to interpret it that way.
Im not trying to stir up trouble or anything, I don´t want you guys to interpret it that way.


Regardless, I think Nero should be lynched on grounds that he's my partner, your partner, Enrique's partner, the Joker, the Riddler, the Gingerbread Man, and Toto.
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 454
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
And what's your point? If I'm right, then he almost died yesterday, and would have if it wasn't for Robin. Does that mean I shouldn't have said anything? I'm not running any risks. Civilians should lay everything out there; what good can we do if we keep everything to ourselves?Enrique wrote:I don't see anyone going after Scotty like... at all.MovingPictures07 wrote:Someone explain to me how speculating on Wilgy being Robin is a bad thing, because if no one had said anything, and we lynched Scotty today and he flipped civilian, then what are we doing? We're handing the game away, that's what we're doing.
You of all people should agree with this, I would think.
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
We don't know for sure if it was robin or not though, and laying out the information is different then the amount of focus your putting on Robin imo.




- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 454
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
How can you misuse the word "disingenuous"? That's a bad look.sig wrote:Oh I thought you focused on Wilgy then voted for Scotty? Sorry about that. No I don't think it was disingenuous, I used poor wording there. What do you think of MP bringing up your case on me?Turnip Head wrote:We cleared up our misunderstanding sig and I dropped it, do you think that was a disingenuous move on my part (by characterizing it as "didn't pan out")? And I never switched to Scottysig wrote:I'm not sure about TH first he tried to get me lynched and that didn't pan out, so he switched to Scotty on flimsy reasons.If you're talking about Wilgy, you can call my reasons flimsy if you want to. I don't see anyone else coming out with bulletproof cases on Day 1.
linki: Fishing for Robin's identity. If Wilgy isn't Robin, then someone else is and you are thinking they stopped the lynch so either it is Scotty or a third unknown who stopped the lynch. You seem to be talking about it an awful lot and fishing for information about Robin. If Robin is a third person and neither Scotty or Wilgy then he might be inclined to hint such in the thread even if they didn't do anything. It seems to be like your focusing just a little bit to much on Robin. While at the same time accusing me of focusing on Wilgy's death to much even though you are doing the same and attempting to figure out a pro civ roles.
linki: I don't think Scotty is on the table as a major lynch candidate at all today?
I'm not speculating on anyone else other than Wilgy, and I'm not fishing for any information other than my theory. You're the one fishing. Right now.

You're looking pretty bad to me now, sig.
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
I think the rest of us are just as capable of making connections, not to mention, Scotty only got 4 votes yesterday. That's a far cry from a majorityMovingPictures07 wrote:And what's your point? If I'm right, then he almost died yesterday, and would have if it wasn't for Robin. Does that mean I shouldn't have said anything? I'm not running any risks. Civilians should lay everything out there; what good can we do if we keep everything to ourselves?Enrique wrote:I don't see anyone going after Scotty like... at all.MovingPictures07 wrote:Someone explain to me how speculating on Wilgy being Robin is a bad thing, because if no one had said anything, and we lynched Scotty today and he flipped civilian, then what are we doing? We're handing the game away, that's what we're doing.
You of all people should agree with this, I would think.

Nero, if Matt flips Mafia I'm gonna remember you.









- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 454
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
You think I'm bad for this? Then vote for me. You haven't accused me once; you just keep saying over and over that I'm dwelling too much on it. Yeah, I'm dwelling on it, because I believe it's true, and I think we have strong reason to believe that it's true. And I think you're being manipulative right now.sig wrote:We don't know for sure if it was robin or not though, and laying out the information is different then the amount of focus your putting on Robin imo.
I'm voting you.
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 454
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
I think sig was saved yesterday. Let's lynch him.
- Turnip Head
- Root Vegetable
- Posts in topic: 592
- Posts: 11432
- Joined: Thu Dec 05, 2013 6:37 am
- Preferred Pronouns: they/their
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
I think it's clear that he didn't read any of the follow-up to that case but I can't judge him for that, I'm the one who told him not to waste his time reading the whole thread.sig wrote:Oh I thought you focused on Wilgy then voted for Scotty? Sorry about that. No I don't think it was disingenuous, I used poor wording there. What do you think of MP bringing up your case on me?Turnip Head wrote:We cleared up our misunderstanding sig and I dropped it, do you think that was a disingenuous move on my part (by characterizing it as "didn't pan out")? And I never switched to Scottysig wrote:I'm not sure about TH first he tried to get me lynched and that didn't pan out, so he switched to Scotty on flimsy reasons.If you're talking about Wilgy, you can call my reasons flimsy if you want to. I don't see anyone else coming out with bulletproof cases on Day 1.
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
MP do we even need this conversation at all when no one cares for Scotty anymore? I think sig has a point.









- Turnip Head
- Root Vegetable
- Posts in topic: 592
- Posts: 11432
- Joined: Thu Dec 05, 2013 6:37 am
- Preferred Pronouns: they/their
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
Read the posts you're replying to, MP. "Disingenuous" was MY word.MovingPictures07 wrote:How can you misuse the word "disingenuous"? That's a bad look.sig wrote:Oh I thought you focused on Wilgy then voted for Scotty? Sorry about that. No I don't think it was disingenuous, I used poor wording there. What do you think of MP bringing up your case on me?Turnip Head wrote:We cleared up our misunderstanding sig and I dropped it, do you think that was a disingenuous move on my part (by characterizing it as "didn't pan out")? And I never switched to Scottysig wrote:I'm not sure about TH first he tried to get me lynched and that didn't pan out, so he switched to Scotty on flimsy reasons.If you're talking about Wilgy, you can call my reasons flimsy if you want to. I don't see anyone else coming out with bulletproof cases on Day 1.
linki: Fishing for Robin's identity. If Wilgy isn't Robin, then someone else is and you are thinking they stopped the lynch so either it is Scotty or a third unknown who stopped the lynch. You seem to be talking about it an awful lot and fishing for information about Robin. If Robin is a third person and neither Scotty or Wilgy then he might be inclined to hint such in the thread even if they didn't do anything. It seems to be like your focusing just a little bit to much on Robin. While at the same time accusing me of focusing on Wilgy's death to much even though you are doing the same and attempting to figure out a pro civ roles.
linki: I don't think Scotty is on the table as a major lynch candidate at all today?
I'm not speculating on anyone else other than Wilgy, and I'm not fishing for any information other than my theory. You're the one fishing. Right now.![]()
You're looking pretty bad to me now, sig.
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 454
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
That's ridiculous logic, Enrique. If "the rest of us" are capable at making connections, then why should civilians share their thoughts on any connections, even suspicious? The rest of us can figure it out, right? Give me a break.Enrique wrote:I think the rest of us are just as capable of making connections, not to mention, Scotty only got 4 votes yesterday. That's a far cry from a majorityMovingPictures07 wrote:And what's your point? If I'm right, then he almost died yesterday, and would have if it wasn't for Robin. Does that mean I shouldn't have said anything? I'm not running any risks. Civilians should lay everything out there; what good can we do if we keep everything to ourselves?Enrique wrote:I don't see anyone going after Scotty like... at all.MovingPictures07 wrote:Someone explain to me how speculating on Wilgy being Robin is a bad thing, because if no one had said anything, and we lynched Scotty today and he flipped civilian, then what are we doing? We're handing the game away, that's what we're doing.
You of all people should agree with this, I would think.![]()
Nero, if Matt flips Mafia I'm gonna remember you.
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
Wait your voting for me since I was saved? This is rich for what reasons? Since I mentioned Wilgy less then you or since I said you are fishing for information? Why are you freaking out so much that your threatening to vote for me and saying I should vote for you simply since I voiced some suspicion of you?
You are sounding unhinged. Also please explain how I was "saved" when nobody minus two players suspected me? You tried to run TH case against me that didn't work so know your making up other reasons.
You are sounding unhinged. Also please explain how I was "saved" when nobody minus two players suspected me? You tried to run TH case against me that didn't work so know your making up other reasons.




- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 454
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
I stand corrected, thanks.Turnip Head wrote:Read the posts you're replying to, MP. "Disingenuous" was MY word.MovingPictures07 wrote:How can you misuse the word "disingenuous"? That's a bad look.sig wrote:Oh I thought you focused on Wilgy then voted for Scotty? Sorry about that. No I don't think it was disingenuous, I used poor wording there. What do you think of MP bringing up your case on me?Turnip Head wrote:We cleared up our misunderstanding sig and I dropped it, do you think that was a disingenuous move on my part (by characterizing it as "didn't pan out")? And I never switched to Scottysig wrote:I'm not sure about TH first he tried to get me lynched and that didn't pan out, so he switched to Scotty on flimsy reasons.If you're talking about Wilgy, you can call my reasons flimsy if you want to. I don't see anyone else coming out with bulletproof cases on Day 1.
linki: Fishing for Robin's identity. If Wilgy isn't Robin, then someone else is and you are thinking they stopped the lynch so either it is Scotty or a third unknown who stopped the lynch. You seem to be talking about it an awful lot and fishing for information about Robin. If Robin is a third person and neither Scotty or Wilgy then he might be inclined to hint such in the thread even if they didn't do anything. It seems to be like your focusing just a little bit to much on Robin. While at the same time accusing me of focusing on Wilgy's death to much even though you are doing the same and attempting to figure out a pro civ roles.
linki: I don't think Scotty is on the table as a major lynch candidate at all today?
I'm not speculating on anyone else other than Wilgy, and I'm not fishing for any information other than my theory. You're the one fishing. Right now.![]()
You're looking pretty bad to me now, sig.
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
... my point is that Scotty wasn't/isn't in any danger. Don't take this as an attack, I'm disagreeing with you and telling you why the case against you right now is valid.









Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
Knock knock.sig wrote:How is he target painting?
Who's there?
Enrique
Enrique who?
The easy lynch target guy who is accusing me, and if that doesn't pan out, has target painted me by pointing out who else I could be and either way, he obvi wants me gone regardless.







- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 454
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
You received attention and votes d1, but both Wilgy and Scotty received more votes than you. It's possible that you were saved.sig wrote:Wait your voting for me since I was saved? This is rich for what reasons? Since I mentioned Wilgy less then you or since I said you are fishing for information? Why are you freaking out so much that your threatening to vote for me and saying I should vote for you simply since I voiced some suspicion of you?
You are sounding unhinged. Also please explain how I was "saved" when nobody minus two players suspected me? You tried to run TH case against me that didn't work so know your making up other reasons.
If you think I'm bad, vote for me. I'm not making up reasons; now you're the one making stuff up and I feel better about my vote.
And as to casting my vote now, I'm going to be busy the rest of today and have a pretty full day tomorrow, so I'm not even sure when I'd have been back to vote. I feel good enough about voting for you.
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
How exactly is talking about Robin "laying our information"? Most people advocate that Wilgy was Robin and he is dead. What happened last night is still a mystery and it´s not going to solve itself. Every lynch and NK should be used to gather information and to eventually arrive at conclusions. Being stale and avoiding burning subjects is far worse.sig wrote:We don't know for sure if it was robin or not though, and laying out the information is different then the amount of focus your putting on Robin imo.
Linki @Enrique I understand your concern.
Lots of linki.


Regardless, I think Nero should be lynched on grounds that he's my partner, your partner, Enrique's partner, the Joker, the Riddler, the Gingerbread Man, and Toto.
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 454
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
But you don't even know that. No one can predict who is going to be "in danger" at any given time. That's ridiculous.Enrique wrote:... my point is that Scotty wasn't/isn't in any danger. Don't take this as an attack, I'm disagreeing with you and telling you why the case against you right now is valid.
- Turnip Head
- Root Vegetable
- Posts in topic: 592
- Posts: 11432
- Joined: Thu Dec 05, 2013 6:37 am
- Preferred Pronouns: they/their
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
Do you think it's at all possible that we live in a world where Enrique genuinely thinks you're bad?Matt wrote:Knock knock.sig wrote:How is he target painting?
Who's there?
Enrique
Enrique who?
The easy lynch target guy who is accusing me, and if that doesn't pan out, has target painted me by pointing out who else I could be and either way, he obvi wants me gone regardless.![]()
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
I don't even necessarily agree that Scott/Wilgy had to be Robin, but after what happened, Scotty was NOT more likely to be lynched.
@MP: Scotty and Wilgy had 3 votes when Zebra and I voted sig. Then they each received one more. I tried to get some momentum against sig but the thread at large didn't care. I think he's really stubborn and goes great lengths to justify bad logic, but he's not wrong right now.
@MP: Scotty and Wilgy had 3 votes when Zebra and I voted sig. Then they each received one more. I tried to get some momentum against sig but the thread at large didn't care. I think he's really stubborn and goes great lengths to justify bad logic, but he's not wrong right now.









- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 454
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
Enrique, I have to leave in a few minutes, and I barely will be back the rest of the day. I didn't even know I'd be here this morning. When I had my thought last night, who's to say Scotty wouldn't have been lynched today? What benefit would I have had to keep that theory to myself?
And now I feel like I've said what I need to say on the matter. If anyone thinks I'm suspicious for it, so be it. But I'm fine with my vote being on sig for reasons I previously stated, as well as his behavior today regarding this Wilgy stuff. Go back and read it, he really wanted to talk about it, and now he's saying I'm talking too much about it, but he won't commit to it with a vote, or even an accusation of me. He's a fine vote for today in my opinion.
I don't really have any more time, so I'll be back at some point. Not sure when.
And now I feel like I've said what I need to say on the matter. If anyone thinks I'm suspicious for it, so be it. But I'm fine with my vote being on sig for reasons I previously stated, as well as his behavior today regarding this Wilgy stuff. Go back and read it, he really wanted to talk about it, and now he's saying I'm talking too much about it, but he won't commit to it with a vote, or even an accusation of me. He's a fine vote for today in my opinion.
I don't really have any more time, so I'll be back at some point. Not sure when.
Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
Knock knock.Turnip Head wrote:Do you think it's at all possible that we live in a world where Enrique genuinely thinks you're bad?Matt wrote:Knock knock.sig wrote:How is he target painting?
Who's there?
Enrique
Enrique who?
The easy lynch target guy who is accusing me, and if that doesn't pan out, has target painted me by pointing out who else I could be and either way, he obvi wants me gone regardless.![]()
Who's there?
Easy lynch!
Easy lynch who?
Easy lynch, target painting!










Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
Knock knock.Turnip Head wrote:Do you think it's at all possible that we live in a world where Enrique genuinely thinks you're bad?Matt wrote:Knock knock.sig wrote:How is he target painting?
Who's there?
Enrique
Enrique who?
The easy lynch target guy who is accusing me, and if that doesn't pan out, has target painted me by pointing out who else I could be and either way, he obvi wants me gone regardless.![]()
Who's there?
Yes
Yes who?
Yes I believe it's a possibility but he was also clearly target painting me in case I'm not lynched, THEN accuses MP of doing the same thing he's doing to me, ergo Enrique bad.





Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 2]
You see, TH, I'm making sure the baddies kill him by capitalizing on how easily he can get lynched. It makes perfect sense.








