Arkham Mafia [ENDGAME]

#4101

There is something I'm not allowed to say (and I don't really mind anyway it's pretty lame) but this part of it is just speculation. Are you guys itching for another of my conspiracy theories?

#4102

Why are we hunting penguins again?

#4103

MacDougall wrote:Why are we hunting penguins again?

I've heard they taste good?

#4104

I've concluded something, Enrique lets here the crazy theory.

#4105

sig wrote:
MacDougall wrote:Why are we hunting penguins again?
I've heard they taste good?

No but really what's the need for hunting the Penguin?

#4106

MacDougall wrote:
sig wrote:
MacDougall wrote:Why are we hunting penguins again?
I've heard they taste good?
No but really what's the need for hunting the Penguin?

I seriously don't know Spirtyo brought it up and then Enrique, in theory this could start the Inmate argument again. I am personally not happy with the Penguin since I think he made MP lynch me today.

The only mentioning of the Penguin before this from me was about why MP was voting for me and who it could be and how that effects the Mr.Freeze thing.

#4107

Nah, it's about Poison Ivy. Something doesn't add up today.

#4108

Enrique, while you are waiting to confirm your theory, I think you said you would be presenting a case on sig this afternoon or when you got out of class. Is that still on the docket for today? Or would you rather do your conspiracy case now?

I have read and read and read - hours even - Mac's iso and the only two things i find suspect are him saying he cheerleaded the lynch (and to be fair he did say in his opinion he was cheerleading) and his comment about DH telling everyone to vote Nero. Otherwise I feel like he has made some good points this game and reads as civ to me. I realize the two things I called out are at the crux of TH's case so I have to simmer with what I re-read and those two points from the game before i can make a sure decision on which way to go with Mac.

I thought the BR case was good but i haven't read her iso which I will do tonight or tomorrow morning. Tbh I don't relish the thought of reading another set of posts from another person but I think BR has had less to say than Mac.

#4109

dammit i did say that

I'm leaving school right now and I have a doctors appointment from 7-8, but I'll see if I can whip up something real quick as soon as I'm home.

#4110

Enrique wrote:dammit i did say that

I'm leaving school right now and I have a doctors appointment from 7-8, but I'll see if I can whip up something real quick as soon as I'm home.

Kinky.

#4111

Quick little theory maybe poisoned players are forced to do something or they will die. This could explain Matt's knock knock joke thing yesterday.

#4112

getting set back up to have some free time later tonight and tomorrow. I know you're all anxious for me to get my post count up.

MacDougall wrote:Equivocate and bass have not posted since day 1. Floyd has not posted since day 0.

Do we have a kidnapper role of some kind? Unfortunately bass and Floyd do have a history of vanishing like this but bass seemed very invested early and just up and disappeared.

sig also mentioned recently that Bass was around and online yesterday. So it's not like he hopped in his Delorian to the future or something.

#4113

sig wrote:Quick little theory maybe poisoned players are forced to do something or they will die. This could explain Matt's knock knock joke thing yesterday.

or maybe that's what they want you to think

*X-Files theme music*

#4114

This thread has my head spinning and my brain hurting. So many posts and ideas and theories. And I'm way too tired to fully consider them all. I need to think more before I figure out what I think.

Also, in case she is searching her name, I still want Bubbles to explain her post about Dom a few days ago. (not trying to push anything, but really want an answer, and figuring she might be name searching, since she is not reading fully).

#4115

LoRab wrote:This thread has my head spinning and my brain hurting. So many posts and ideas and theories. And I'm way too tired to fully consider them all. I need to think more before I figure out what I think.

Also, in case she is searching her name, I still want Bubbles to explain her post about Dom a few days ago. (not trying to push anything, but really want an answer, and figuring she might be name searching, since she is not reading fully).

She did just sub out of the other game so I don't think it is an alignment indicator.

@Scotty yep same with Floyd, I don't know what to make of it. Neither are silenced this round and I doubt there is a game role which stops them from being able to post at all.

#4116

sig wrote:
LoRab wrote:This thread has my head spinning and my brain hurting. So many posts and ideas and theories. And I'm way too tired to fully consider them all. I need to think more before I figure out what I think.

Also, in case she is searching her name, I still want Bubbles to explain her post about Dom a few days ago. (not trying to push anything, but really want an answer, and figuring she might be name searching, since she is not reading fully).
She did just sub out of the other game so I don't think it is an alignment indicator.

@Scotty yep same with Floyd, I don't know what to make of it. Neither are silenced this round and I doubt there is a game role which stops them from being able to post at all.

How do you know that?

#4117

We already know Glorfindel is silenced.

#4118

Turnip Head wrote:We already know Glorfindel is silenced.

Ah ok... How?

#4119

Because the hosts told us lol

#4120

Turnip Head wrote:Because the hosts told us lol

#4121

Must of missed that...

Okay so that's fine to make the assumption that by Glorf being silenced others would not be, but I don't think you really can? There could be multiple silence mechanisms. Hostage taking/kidnapping/freezing it's all fairly run of the mill for a Mafia of this theme innit?

#4122

*must have jeez malfunctioning brain there

#4123

I'm sorry, I'll be free at like 8-9 to make the sig post I promised this morning. I have a bunch of places to go and stuff to solve right now.

#4124

MacDougall wrote:Must of missed that...

Okay so that's fine to make the assumption that by Glorf being silenced others would not be, but I don't think you really can? There could be multiple silence mechanisms. Hostage taking/kidnapping/freezing it's all fairly run of the mill for a Mafia of this theme innit?

I guess that could be true, but for multiply days? Without being able to double target it would be weird for those players to be silenced etc by two different powers in a row.

#4125

Enrique wrote:I'm sorry, I'll be free at like 8-9 to make the sig post I promised this morning. I have a bunch of places to go and stuff to solve right now.

I wasn't trying to push you Enrique, just clarify if you would still be able to do it tonight.

#4126

sig wrote:
MacDougall wrote:Must of missed that...

Okay so that's fine to make the assumption that by Glorf being silenced others would not be, but I don't think you really can? There could be multiple silence mechanisms. Hostage taking/kidnapping/freezing it's all fairly run of the mill for a Mafia of this theme innit?
I guess that could be true, but for multiply days? Without being able to double target it would be weird for those players to be silenced etc by two different powers in a row.

I posted my favourite role I created in the favourite game mechanisms thread and it literally is a role where each night an independent takes a player out of the game and acquires their role power to use for themselves. They return when that player dies.

Just sayin'.

#4127

Not here for long, but I've cleared this with the Hosts and just wanted to say:

I was poisoned Night 1, which is part of the reason I stopped caring about living.

Also, sig is my number one suspect!

#4128

Well

unless he's lying, debunked lol. But it still doesn't quite add up.

#4129

MovingPictures07 wrote:Not here for long, but I've cleared this with the Hosts and just wanted to say:

I was poisoned Night 1, which is part of the reason I stopped caring about living.

Also, sig is my number one suspect!

Did you find the antidote?

#4130

MP are you still poisoned?

#4131

Sorsha wrote:Dom- what do you think of TH's case on BR?

I'm lukewarm about it if only that I'd like her to explain her thoughts more before making a judgment on it. Ya feel?

#4132

MacDougall wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:Not here for long, but I've cleared this with the Hosts and just wanted to say:

I was poisoned Night 1, which is part of the reason I stopped caring about living.

Also, sig is my number one suspect!
Did you find the antidote?

No.

Not that I've been made aware, anyway.

sig is my number one suspect; he should be yours as well.

#4133

Did you do something wrong yesterday MP?

#4134

MovingPictures07 wrote:
MacDougall wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:Not here for long, but I've cleared this with the Hosts and just wanted to say:

I was poisoned Night 1, which is part of the reason I stopped caring about living.

Also, sig is my number one suspect!
Did you find the antidote?
No. Not that I've been made aware, anyway.

sig is my number one suspect; he should be yours as well.

Guess I had better vote for sig then.

#4135

Dom wrote:
Sorsha wrote:Dom- what do you think of TH's case on BR?
I'm lukewarm about it if only that I'd like her to explain her thoughts more before making a judgment on it. Ya feel?

Yes. I'd like her to explain also.

#4136

MovingPictures07 wrote:
MacDougall wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:Not here for long, but I've cleared this with the Hosts and just wanted to say:

I was poisoned Night 1, which is part of the reason I stopped caring about living.

Also, sig is my number one suspect!
Did you find the antidote?
No. Not that I've been made aware, anyway.

sig is my number one suspect; he should be yours as well.

Why have you not made an attempt to visit the hospital if you are poisoned?

#4137

He doesn't have health insurance

#4138

Sorsha wrote:
Dom wrote:
Sorsha wrote:Dom- what do you think of TH's case on BR?
I'm lukewarm about it if only that I'd like her to explain her thoughts more before making a judgment on it. Ya feel?
Yes. I'd like her to explain also.

I have read her posts but didn't see anything else to bring to the table to add to or refute TH's case. I hope her busyness doesn't keep her from making a thorough response.

#4139

Enrique wrote:Did you do something wrong yesterday MP?

What do you mean?

sig is my number one suspect.

#4140

DharmaHelper wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:
MacDougall wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:Not here for long, but I've cleared this with the Hosts and just wanted to say:

I was poisoned Night 1, which is part of the reason I stopped caring about living.

Also, sig is my number one suspect!
Did you find the antidote?
No. Not that I've been made aware, anyway.

sig is my number one suspect; he should be yours as well.
Why have you not made an attempt to visit the hospital if you are poisoned?

That's a good question. I received a message telling me to go to Arkham Asylum again to get the antidote, so that's why I did it, but it turns out it was probably Poison Ivy trolling me.

sig is my number one suspect.

#4141

So I'll vote for sig then?

#4142

MacDougall wrote:So I'll vote for sig then?

Well, he is my number one suspect.

#4143

MP are you poisoned and cursed? Or is the sig thing something else?

#4144

MovingPictures07 wrote:
Enrique wrote:Did you do something wrong yesterday MP?
What do you mean?

sig is my number one suspect.

When did you get the message?

#4145

"A pointless question you probably can't legally answer"

#4146

He can say he got a message to go to Arkham but not say when? What kind of assumption is that?

#4147

MacDougall wrote:So I'll vote for sig then?

MP is cursed or something why else say it every post this phase when he didn't suspect me before (last night) and disputed his previous vote of me in other posts.

So why would you vote for me?

#4148

Sorsha wrote:MP are you poisoned and cursed? Or is the sig thing something else?

I did get poisoned. The sig thing? What sig thing?

sig is my number one suspect.

#4149

Enrique wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:
Enrique wrote:Did you do something wrong yesterday MP?
What do you mean?

sig is my number one suspect.

When did you get the message?

Start of Night 2. I figure I can say this...

sig is my number one suspect.

#4150

MovingPictures07 wrote:
Sorsha wrote:MP are you poisoned and cursed? Or is the sig thing something else?
I did get poisoned. The sig thing? What sig thing?

sig is my number one suspect.

As well as saying there isn't a thing since he can't for whatever reason.

Who killed no one?