Arkham Mafia [ENDGAME]

#4601

That last minute save is sketchy as hell.

#4602

Metalmarsh89 wrote:That last minute save is sketchy as hell.

YOU VOTED FOR HER WHO ARE YOU ACCUSING EXACTLY?

#4603

Metalmarsh89 wrote:That last minute save is sketchy as hell.

Didn't you just vote last minute?

#4604

But seriously unless you're the Joker and that's why you were so passionately shooting down discussion about what his role does, I'm not seeing anything.

#4605

Lazy last minute voters. I am literally the least harmful to this game. Vote Dom tomorrow. He is bad. I am not.

#4606

Who mourns for Nerolunar?

Poll ended at Wed Feb 24, 2016 9:25 pm

Bass_the_Clever
0
No votes

bea
0
No votes

Black Rock
7
Scotty (7), Turnip Head (10), juliets (11), Sorsha (19), sig (21), Metalmarsh89 (22), MacDougall (23)
30%

Bubbles
0
No votes

Bullzeye
0
No votes

DharmaHelper
0
No votes

DFaraday
0
No votes

Dom
1
Black Rock (12)
4%

ekeknat
0
No votes

Enrique
0
No votes

Equivocate
0
No votes

Golden
0
No votes

Glorfindel
0
No votes

juliets
0
No votes

Lorab
0
No votes

MacDougall
5
Typhoony (5), Matt (14), Bullzeye (15), S~V~S (16), Dom (18)
22%

Matt
0
No votes

MetalMarsh89
0
No votes

MovingPictures07
2
DharmaHelper (9), sabie12 (20)
9%

sabie12
0
No votes

Scotty
0
No votes

sig
2
MovingPictures07 (2), Enrique (13)
9%

Sorsha
0
No votes

sprityo
0
No votes

S~V~S
0
No votes

TheFloyd73
2
Golden (6), sprityo (17)
9%

Turnip Head
0
No votes

Typhoony
0
No votes

Epignosis (The Hosts, the Dead, the Non)
4
Long Con (1), Epignosis (3), a2thezebra (4), JaggedJimmyJay (8)
17%

Total votes : 23

#4607

Bullzeye wrote:But seriously unless you're the Joker and that's why you were so passionately shooting down discussion about what his role does, I'm not seeing anything.

I literally can't quote it because it would be role outing.

Suffice to say if you use your grey matter there are only three possible roles I could be insinuating I am.

#4608

Sorry Black Rock, I have played probably over 100 Mafia games and I have never had to self preservation vote before. I don't like it.

#4609

Black Rock wrote:Lazy last minute voters. I am literally the least harmful to this game. Vote Dom tomorrow. He is bad. I am not.

guys she's claiming Alfred!

#4610

MacDougall wrote:Sorry Black Rock, I have played probably over 100 Mafia games and I have never had to self preservation vote before. I don't like it.

Did you not suspect her?

#4611

Well, I do think TH & BR circle each other alot, and know each others games. so fingers crossed there.

And even if you did defend against it Mac, obviously if you were left facing a lynch mod with only your role hint in your hand, it was not enough.

Looking forward to that answer in the AM, sprityo, shower & bed. Bai.

#4612

Turnip Head wrote:
MacDougall wrote:Sorry Black Rock, I have played probably over 100 Mafia games and I have never had to self preservation vote before. I don't like it.
Did you not suspect her?

I suspected her yes because I think your case has merit. It still doesn't make me like having to self pres vote her. I would have preferred to vote for quite a few before her.

#4613

Guys... It was a joke.

#4614

Enrique wrote:
Black Rock wrote:Lazy last minute voters. I am literally the least harmful to this game. Vote Dom tomorrow. He is bad. I am not.
guys she's claiming Alfred!

I am not claiming anything. I am not Alfred. You won't be sad, but I wouldn't hurt you either. I played as a civ.

#4615

S~V~S wrote:Well, I do think TH & BR circle each other alot, and know each others games. so fingers crossed there.

And even if you did defend against it Mac, obviously if you were left facing a lynch mod with only your role hint in your hand, it was not enough.

Looking forward to that answer in the AM, sprityo, shower & bed. Bai.

I didn't need to quote the post because sig told me he was going to vote her and I always had my vote. I'd rather not get mod-killed if I don't have to. You saying "why not refute the case" when I already had to the point where it was enough for TH to leave me alone is very annoying SVS.

#4616

MacDougall wrote:
Turnip Head wrote:
MacDougall wrote:Sorry Black Rock, I have played probably over 100 Mafia games and I have never had to self preservation vote before. I don't like it.
Did you not suspect her?
I suspected her yes because I think your case has merit. It still doesn't make me like having to self pres vote her. I would have preferred to vote for quite a few before her.

Who?

linki: @MM dw I got it.

#4617

That sucks Black Rock. You just might make a cop very happy, though

Mac you're saved you probably don't need to keep pointing at your role.

#4618

sig wrote:
MacDougall wrote:
Turnip Head wrote:
MacDougall wrote:Sorry Black Rock, I have played probably over 100 Mafia games and I have never had to self preservation vote before. I don't like it.
Did you not suspect her?
I suspected her yes because I think your case has merit. It still doesn't make me like having to self pres vote her. I would have preferred to vote for quite a few before her.
Who?

linki: @MM dw I got it.

Black Rock wrote:
Enrique wrote:
Black Rock wrote:Lazy last minute voters. I am literally the least harmful to this game. Vote Dom tomorrow. He is bad. I am not.

Bullzeye, MP, Turnip Head, Floyd, Dom, bea ... quite a few.

#4619

Enrique wrote:That sucks Black Rock. You just might make a cop very happy, though

Mac you're saved you probably don't need to keep pointing at your role.

Really? I haven't pointed at it since the day ended other than in discussion with SVS as to why I didn't bother quoting the post.

#4620

MacDougall wrote:
Bullzeye wrote:But seriously unless you're the Joker and that's why you were so passionately shooting down discussion about what his role does, I'm not seeing anything.
I literally can't quote it because it would be role outing.

Suffice to say if you use your grey matter there are only three possible roles I could be insinuating I am.

I mean...

#4621

That was before the day ended wasn't it?

At least I was typing it before the day ended.

#4622

Do You Want to Know How I Got These Scars?

"My uncle was a stripper abuser, and a fiend. He once made a girl eat a twenty dollar bill! One night, he saw me trying to sneak into one of those joints, you know? Curious to see what was going on and why ugly men would give up their money to look at women they could never have...anyway, I digress. Excuse me. Um. He caught me, and he dragged me home and he pulled out a knife. And do you know what he said? He said, 'Why so nosy?' And he started to push the blade into my septum, you know, right here. Right here. I could smell the liquor on his breath as I squirmed underneath him. I always smile when I think back on it though. I can't help it."

Black Rock has been lynched. She was The Joker.

It is now Night 3. You have until 8:00pm EST to submit your PMs.

#4623

I'm fine with this

#4624

#4625

#4626

I wanna see those role secrets before I celebrate. I don't feel bad about it but I can't see why we'd be thrilled either. The Joker might not have been very anti-town for all we know. She said herself was playing pro-town.

#4627

@Host, do the two crime families HAVE to recruit their cop the first chance they get?

#4628

sprityo wrote:@Host, do the two crime families HAVE to recruit their cop the first chance they get?

Yes. No holding off.

#4629

Thanks

#4630

MacDougall wrote:I wanna see those role secrets before I celebrate. I don't feel bad about it but I can't see why we'd be thrilled either. The Joker might not have been very anti-town for all we know. She said herself was playing pro-town.

Either way she had to kill one townie and one pro town role, so I'm quite happy with these results.

#4631

Pretty good result. From her last few posts I thought she might flip Bane or Two Face.

#4632

Turnip Head wrote:Pretty good result. From her last few posts I thought she might flip Bane or Two Face.

Yeah the way she was speaking made me feel that way too but I also don't think she was lying either so maybe The Joker was a fair bit more anti-mafia than anti-town. Which kind of suits The Joker right?

#4633

Given her win condition required Gordon and Batman to be dead I can live with this result. BR, you know i luv you.

Bunches of linki

#4634

Black Rock wrote:Lazy last minute voters. I am literally the least harmful to this game. Vote Dom tomorrow. He is bad. I am not.

No I'm not.

Good job TH!

#4635

MacDougall wrote:
Turnip Head wrote:Pretty good result. From her last few posts I thought she might flip Bane or Two Face.
Yeah the way she was speaking made me feel that way too but I also don't think she was lying either so maybe The Joker was a fair bit more anti-mafia than anti-town. Which kind of suits The Joker right?

When I think of the Joker I think he's anti-everyone :P

#4636

#4637

I forgot to raise my glass to TH

#4638

Turnip Head wrote:
MacDougall wrote:
Turnip Head wrote:Pretty good result. From her last few posts I thought she might flip Bane or Two Face.
Yeah the way she was speaking made me feel that way too but I also don't think she was lying either so maybe The Joker was a fair bit more anti-mafia than anti-town. Which kind of suits The Joker right?
When I think of the Joker I think he's anti-everyone :P

Well yeah but he kind of considering himself an anti-hero at least. Hates organised crime.

Eh you could literally pull a name out of a hat and nail a random Arkham player with ease in this game. Good job TH if the Joker was more dangerous than Mafia. Sorry if I sound bitter but I'm calling a spade a spade.

#4639

You think someone who needs Gordon dead is pro-town?

#4640

I mean we've already congratulated TH aplenty, but again, good job on that one!

#4641

Dom wrote:You think someone who needs Gordon dead is pro-town?

You don't think someone who needs two Mafia dead couldn't be focusing on scum hunting?

I'm not upset by The Joker being lynched, I just think if we make a habit of celebrating the lynch of Arkham escapees we're missing the point. We are going to hit Arkham Inmates nearly half the time if we pick a random lynch candidate.

#4642

And if Black Rock post certain lynch says she was playing for the civs, I have no reason to think she'd just lie for the hell of it.

#4643

MacDougall wrote:
Dom wrote:You think someone who needs Gordon dead is pro-town?
You don't think someone who needs two Mafia dead couldn't be focusing on scum hunting?

I'm not upset by The Joker being lynched, I just think if we make a habit of celebrating the lynch of Arkham escapees we're missing the point. We are going to hit Arkham Inmates nearly half the time if we pick a random lynch candidate.

Yeah, but it was not a civvie, so I'm not exactly crying.

#4644

Dom wrote:
MacDougall wrote:
Dom wrote:You think someone who needs Gordon dead is pro-town?
You don't think someone who needs two Mafia dead couldn't be focusing on scum hunting?

I'm not upset by The Joker being lynched, I just think if we make a habit of celebrating the lynch of Arkham escapees we're missing the point. We are going to hit Arkham Inmates nearly half the time if we pick a random lynch candidate.
Yeah, but it was not a civvie, so I'm not exactly crying.

Not crying, but I look at it as a day where the Mafia got off pretty much scot free on account of Joker and me being the primary candidates. Doesn't bode well for future days imo.

#4645

If someone could tell me what ISO means so i can go look for whatever Mac is trying to say, that'd be great

#4646

sprityo wrote:If someone could tell me what ISO means so i can go look for whatever Mac is trying to say, that'd be great

Just means all my posts.

#4647

MacDougall wrote:
sprityo wrote:If someone could tell me what ISO means so i can go look for whatever Mac is trying to say, that'd be great
Just means all my posts.

Click on "In Topic" under his avatar and it will bring up all his posts.

#4648

S~V~S wrote: I might also vote for sprityo; that one post where in the same post he says, meh, I could vote Typhoony (inexplicable Penguin suspect), as well as saying he agrees that locating the Penguin isn't as important as locating the Mafia. So cocoa & brb.

In truth SVS, i dont care much for the penguin. At least personally i dont. My logic being either yay, we got rid of a town liability (no shows) or, there's a half decent case for possible penguin. I was really just gonna leave it up to the numbers and vote for whichever was in the lead (as you can see, i did vote floyd). Im not one for high risks, and im certainly not about to have a wall post fight with someone (mostly because all i could do is defend myself and not make any counters). But needless to say, the whole penguin theory was shoddy at best.

Linki: oh okay, that really narrows it down. maybe i can start to clear myself some space if i find it, Mac

#4649

I don't get the doom and gloom. It's Night 3 and we've lynched 1 baddie and 1 anti-townie.

#4650

I got no message straight away so me and MP have that not in common.

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

Who killed no one?