Arkham Mafia [ENDGAME]

[Typhoony]

- THs bonus Meta point
- You going "hur dur I hinted at my role look for it peeps" when you're in danger of getting lynched

Are the two points that I think make you MacBaddie

[MacDougall]

Yes, post it.

Okay since you insist...

Sorry if I get mod-killed for role outing...

Spoiler: show

http://screencast.com/t/rAf4GUhlc

[Turnip Head]

No, the comment is there and I am considering posting it now because I'm over discussing it. You reckon I should?

Don't do it Shaquille Bro Neil

[MacDougall]

- THs bonus Meta point
- You going "hur dur I hinted at my role look for it peeps" when you're in danger of getting lynched

Are the two points that I think make you MacBaddie

Could you please show me a game where a mafia player defended themselves the way I did at EOD? Ever?

[Typhoony]

I'm not going to search for that Mac. All I need is to believe that you are the kind of player who would pull that sort of shit as a baddie just to laugh about it at end game, and I definitely believe you are.
I don't have time to get into endless discussions with you, even though I would really enjoy those. Best I can do is keep you in people's minds and hope they vote you at the end of the day. Sorry to disappoint my friend.

[MacDougall]

Lmao ok.

[Matt]

[MacDougall]

Matt's strike rate against me as opponent:

TH - Concocted bullshit theory I was serial killer - I was mafia
Star Wars - Cast crucial vote against me as civ teammate
Here - Pushing mislynch wagon again

Matt you cannae read me for turds.

[Matt]

Matt's strike rate against me as opponent:

TH - Concocted bullshit theory I was serial killer - I was mafia
Star Wars - Cast crucial vote against me as civ teammate
Here - Pushing mislynch wagon again

Matt you cannae read me for turds.

I can't really read anyone. But I try.

[Typhoony]

Damn you Matt I was going to point to that as a rolehint for when I was about to be lynched but you ruined it

[LoRab]

Posting now while I'm still catching up because my battery is starting to get low and I left my charger in Jerusalem when I left for Tel Aviv and can't really do anything about it until morning.

So sorry for missing the vote. Fell asleep while reading the thread. And barely had time today to catch up. Reading up now.

Voted Asylum.

[Marmot]

- THs bonus Meta point
- You going "hur dur I hinted at my role look for it peeps" when you're in danger of getting lynched

Are the two points that I think make you MacBaddie

To be fair, I have done this quite a few times before myself. I have never done it as a Baddie, occasionally done it as an Indy, and usually done it as a Civ.

So I'm not buying the Mac is bad theory from this accusation.

[S~V~S]

I have seen several people do that when bad, MM. That whole "OMG gonna get modkilled" thing sealed the deal for me.

[MacDougall]

Brutally wrong.

[Marmot]

I have seen several people do that when bad, MM. That whole "OMG gonna get modkilled" thing sealed the deal for me.

Can you give any examples?

I remember the times I've done it, but off the top of my head, I don't remember when others have done it.

[Glorfindel]

Am I correct in assuming that we only have another four and three-quarter hours until dawn?

[S~V~S]

I have seen several people do that when bad, MM. That whole "OMG gonna get modkilled" thing sealed the deal for me.

Can you give any examples?

I remember the times I've done it, but off the top of my head, I don't remember when others have done it.

Not really, back in the day at RM, or maybe even LP. I have not seen anyone from our culture (or perhaps I should say *my* culture, you are not really from there) do that in a really long time. I did it in at least one game myself. I want to say RM Mafia or maybe one where I had a sock called Hazle Nutt, lol, Superheroes, I think. Role hints were fairly everyday there, so it was easier to pull that kind of stunt.

[sig]

@Glorfidnel can you give me your thoughts on what happened yesterday? Anything that stuck out, theories ect.

[Marmot]

Am I correct in assuming that we only have another four and three-quarter hours until dawn?

If you live in Sri Lanka, sure.

[S~V~S]

Am I correct in assuming that we only have another four and three-quarter hours until dawn?

From what Epi said, I am thinking 3.5 hours from now. They wanted to bring it back to about 9 PM US Eastern time. It is currently 5:30 US Eastern time.

[MacDougall]

I have seen several people do that when bad, MM. That whole "OMG gonna get modkilled" thing sealed the deal for me.

Can you give any examples?

I remember the times I've done it, but off the top of my head, I don't remember when others have done it.

Not really, back in the day at RM, or maybe even LP. I have not seen anyone from our culture (or perhaps I should say *my* culture, you are not really from there) do that in a really long time. I did it in at least one game myself. I want to say RM Mafia or maybe one where I had a sock called Hazle Nutt, lol, Superheroes, I think. Role hints were fairly everyday there, so it was easier to pull that kind of stunt.

Lmao ok SvS.

[juliets]

Am I correct in assuming that we only have another four and three-quarter hours until dawn?

From what Epi said, I am thinking 3.5 hours from now. They wanted to bring it back to about 9 PM US Eastern time. It is currently 5:30 US Eastern time.

I just went back and looked. He said have your PMs in by 8:00 EST so I don't know what that means for the post - 8:30 maybe or is he posting an hour after PMs are due?

[S~V~S]

Glad you are OK with it

I have seen it done, but not for years.

[S~V~S]

That was at Matt, not Jules.

[S~V~S]

Grrrr, MAC not Matt

[MacDougall]

Glad you are OK with it

I have seen it done, but not for years.

Anything to keep up the narrative. A few years ago in a Mafia game I swear I saw someone post a picture of a walrus in a game and they were totally Mafia. Legit.

[Marmot]

Glad you are OK with it

I have seen it done, but not for years.

Well, since you admitted it's not really done in the Syndicate mafia culture, saying that Mac would do it maliciously doesn't hold much weight.

[MacDougall]

I now know why everyone loves the Marmot so much. He is a beautiful creature.

[S~V~S]

Actually,this guy Merlin did it in a game in the Piano. Nutella hosted it, it had a Fairy Tale theme. I was the role checker. Merlin was bad, and I checked him. I did a clumsy case on him, he false role claimed in the last few hours of the day, and *I* got lynched. He was an amazing player.

But yeah, it happened EOD like this. I even role claimed my role (I was a nub) and BR did not believe me, lol. It was maybe my third game.

Linki @ MM he is not form our culture lol. How do you know what he would and would not do?

[Marmot]

I now know why everyone loves the Marmot so much. He is a beautiful creature.

Could you help me untangle the fur under my tail? My paws can't quite reach that spot.

[S~V~S]

Glad you are OK with it

I have seen it done, but not for years.

Well, since you admitted it's not really done in the Syndicate mafia culture, saying that Mac would do it maliciously doesn't hold much weight.

I just linkied this, but he is not from the Syndicate culture either. Epi, you, Llama, some others are, but like many of us Mac is from a different culture.

[Marmot]

Actually,this guy Merlin did it in a game in the Piano. Nutella hosted it, it had a Fairy Tale theme. I was the role checker. Merlin was bad, and I checked him. I did a clumsy case on him, he false role claimed in the last few hours of the day, and *I* got lynched. He was an amazing player.

But yeah, it happened EOD like this. I even role claimed my role (I was a nub) and BR did not believe me, lol. It was maybe my third game.

Linki @ MM he is not form our culture lol. How do you know what he would and would not do?

My experience at RYM is that folks don't leave breadcrumbs about their role. They either roleclaim or don't roleclaim. Pretty black and white.

But Mac's been playing for ages, so I can't speak for the Stone Age games he's played.

Linki: I've played here for a couples years now true, but like many Syndicate members, I played many a game somewhere else beforehand.

[LoRab]

Why would dropping breadcrumbs even mean that you're civ? The great thing about role hints is that they can be false...I didn't go back yet to read your posts, but just wanted to point out that having hinted does NOT mean that you are civ. In fact, it isn't proof at all, or even evidence.

I told everyone on RYM I had a literal notebook with documentation of situations and junk that I never had and they took it seriously and thought I was some meta expert. They probably all still think I have it.

A player that used to play around our mafia realm used to keep a rather intense spread sheet with info on every game and every player, including role. In games he was really into, it would include vote history. It almost always included his own targets. I may have a copy of it. But, especially with few of those players still playing, it's not nearly as useful as one might think.

Has anybody actually tried to look at my ISO for the crumb here? It's not hard to find. All these people who have voted for me without looking better not be civilians because that's terrible.

I got it! He's Lex Luthor!!!!

You think someone who needs Gordon dead is pro-town?

You don't think someone who needs two Mafia dead couldn't be focusing on scum hunting?

I'm not upset by The Joker being lynched, I just think if we make a habit of celebrating the lynch of Arkham escapees we're missing the point. We are going to hit Arkham Inmates nearly half the time if we pick a random lynch candidate.

Is random lynch candidate determined as someone that you don't find suspicious? Just want to be clear on definitions.

And you're the guy that gets to decide what is and what isn't huh MacNubby

Linki: That's an old joke

Sarcastic retorts are a traditional scum tell on every Mafia forum I've ever played on. "Backtracking can be" was a comment that revealed Bullzeye was just trying to paint me bad by any means necessary. If he had have said "what's with the overuse of the word thumbtack?" and I said "discussing household fastening objects isn't alignment indicative" he'd have said "oh but repeatedly using the word thumbtack can be *stinkeye*".

I've got plenty of you attacking me already so it's cool of you to pick the player with the most people attacking him for your next attempt to pretend to involve yourself in the game. Your credibility in this game is so shot to bits that you're probably doing me a favour by attacking me tbh.

Unless you're going to bring legitimate alignment indicative cases against me I'm not going to bother replying. What are you trying to do here aside from rile me up? You just trying to get me goat? Give me the collywobbles? Certainly no case making or attempts to solve the game in here.

You don't get to be the arbiter of tells. Something that another player notices as a tell for mafia in general or for a particular player may or may not be the same as what you notice. That doesn't mean that they are wrong or ridiculous or stupid. And even if they aren't considered tells on the many sites you've played on in the 100's of games that you've been in, they might be considered tells in the games we play here and on the related forums to this site. No need to insult the way that others play.

[sabie12]

Heading over to Park Row. Off to go play some D and D tonight!

[Dom]

And you're the guy that gets to decide what is and what isn't huh MacNubby

Linki: That's an old joke

Sarcastic retorts are a traditional scum tell on every Mafia forum I've ever played on. "Backtracking can be" was a comment that revealed Bullzeye was just trying to paint me bad by any means necessary. If he had have said "what's with the overuse of the word thumbtack?" and I said "discussing household fastening objects isn't alignment indicative" he'd have said "oh but repeatedly using the word thumbtack can be *stinkeye*".

I've got plenty of you attacking me already so it's cool of you to pick the player with the most people attacking him for your next attempt to pretend to involve yourself in the game. Your credibility in this game is so shot to bits that you're probably doing me a favour by attacking me tbh.

Unless you're going to bring legitimate alignment indicative cases against me I'm not going to bother replying. What are you trying to do here aside from rile me up? You just trying to get me goat? Give me the collywobbles? Certainly no case making or attempts to solve the game in here.

We got a salty one here.

- THs bonus Meta point
- You going "hur dur I hinted at my role look for it peeps" when you're in danger of getting lynched

Are the two points that I think make you MacBaddie

This.

Matt's strike rate against me as opponent:

TH - Concocted bullshit theory I was serial killer - I was mafia
Star Wars - Cast crucial vote against me as civ teammate
Here - Pushing mislynch wagon again

Matt you cannae read me for turds.

Sounds like Matt read you plenty fine in TH.
Sounds like a baddie saying, "No you don't want to lynch me for the right reasons!"

Glad you are OK with it

I have seen it done, but not for years.

Anything to keep up the narrative. A few years ago in a Mafia game I swear I saw someone post a picture of a walrus in a game and they were totally Mafia. Legit.

You asked for a game. She gave you one. Now it doesn't matter.

Glad you are OK with it

I have seen it done, but not for years.

Well, since you admitted it's not really done in the Syndicate mafia culture, saying that Mac would do it maliciously doesn't hold much weight.

Would you say Mac is of syndicate culture?

[Golden]

Since I'm entirely non-contributory at the moment, I thought I would at least let everyone know what happens when Metalmarsh dies.



I'll have a chance to get up to date and start contributing again later today or tomorrow.

[MacDougall]

We are at the point where everything I post is being thrown back at me as though I am Mafia. The only way to solve this is to lynch me. So do it if I live. I'm sick of defending myself. Move on with the game.

[MacDougall]

Just apologise to me when you mislynch me despite me giving you every opportunity to believe the truth and I'll be okay with it.

[Enrique]

You're getting ahead of yourself Mac, the Day hasn't even started. Let's see how this goes.

[MacDougall]

You're getting ahead of yourself Mac, the Day hasn't even started. Let's see how this goes.

Dom, Matt, SVS, Typhoony have all made their mind up on me and I'm not really seeing any other possible lynches. I'll have my hands full trying to prevent my lynch with a four person headstart and no alternative candidate that has any lynch momentum.

[MacDougall]

Oh Bullzeye too. So 5. Lol I'm boned.

[MacDougall]

In case I die I think Bass is a cop despite my earlier read so if you end up lynching a lurker don't make it he.

[DharmaHelper]

You're getting ahead of yourself Mac, the Day hasn't even started. Let's see how this goes.

Dom, Matt, SVS, Typhoony have all made their mind up on me and I'm not really seeing any other possible lynches. I'll have my hands full trying to prevent my lynch with a four person headstart and no alternative candidate that has any lynch momentum.

I made a pretty good case for MP's lynch and Typhoony is obviously not a townie so there you go.

[Glorfindel]

OK, Guys - before I get silenced or cursed or have some other dire fate befall me next Day phase, there's a few things I'd like to put on the record for now.

I'll admit that I'm struggling with so much about this game but there are some things I AM certain of. Sig has been laying the foundation of my lynch since almost the beginning of this game (if you don't believe me, check yourselves) his suspicions of me have become his mantra. He claims (rightly so) to know my game and yet claims that I'm not Town. The thing is, I actually AM so why would he say otherwise? Could he be mistaken? I don't believe that to be the case. I think his frequently stated accusations of me are a deliberate attempt to have me eliminated from this game.

Likewise, I'm very familiar with his game and I don't like what I see. There is NO WAY he is Town. Someone said earlier that they thought his performance this game was 'thorough' and indeed it is - his game is demonstrably more polished and thorough when he's bad (and if you don't believe me, go look at his rather chaotic performance as a Townie in Pikmin Mafia). I am suspicious of his constant questioning of players as to their opinions of other players. I understand that in itself, this is considered to be an accepted tactic in these games but there is something in the tone of those questions here that doesn't sound genuine to me.

Whilst it appears poor Zebs may not have been a Townie after all, I still believe her loyalty was to us and she seemed very insistent on Sig's lynching - and now she's gone...

I also don't like Sig's reaction Day 2 when he was gunning for Matt, seemed to get agitated with Enrique after Enrique's change of heart on Matt, but eventually capitulated with a vote on Magnus (Nerolunar) and then casually returned to his modus operandi of throwing shade at me.

I honestly don't know what to make of this - whether he's Mafia or perhaps more likely a third party but I can't see him being Town. I do know that I get a bad feeling about him and I'd prefer to see him gone this Day phase.

[MacDougall]

Whilst it appears poor Zebs may not have been a Townie after all, I still believe her loyalty was to us and she seemed very insistent on Sig's lynching - and now she's gone...

Killed by a civ, so what's this supposed to demonstrate?

[Enrique]

You're getting ahead of yourself Mac, the Day hasn't even started. Let's see how this goes.

Dom, Matt, SVS, Typhoony have all made their mind up on me and I'm not really seeing any other possible lynches. I'll have my hands full trying to prevent my lynch with a four person headstart and no alternative candidate that has any lynch momentum.

I made a pretty good case for MP's lynch and Typhoony is obviously not a townie so there you go.

Why is Typhoony obviously not a townie?

[DharmaHelper]

You're getting ahead of yourself Mac, the Day hasn't even started. Let's see how this goes.

Dom, Matt, SVS, Typhoony have all made their mind up on me and I'm not really seeing any other possible lynches. I'll have my hands full trying to prevent my lynch with a four person headstart and no alternative candidate that has any lynch momentum.

I made a pretty good case for MP's lynch and Typhoony is obviously not a townie so there you go.

Why is Typhoony obviously not a townie?

Because he is the only one of the 3 MP voters that makes sense as Penguin?

[Turnip Head]

Glorfindel.... any thoughts on which player might have wanted to silence you? You don't have to speculate in the thread, I just want you to think about it.

[Epignosis]

To which location will you travel this evening?

Arkham Asylum
3
MacDougall (4), Dom (7), LoRab (23)
13%

Wayne Manor
1
Metalmarsh89 (10)
4%

Wayne Enterprises
3
MovingPictures07 (13), bea (16), Turnip Head (17)
13%

Fish Mooney's
3
juliets (5), Sorsha (11), Glorfindel (15)
13%

The Docks
2
Matt (20), S~V~S (22)
8%

Gotham City Police Department
1
Golden (19)
4%

City Hall
2
sprityo (3), DharmaHelper (6)
8%

Park Row
4
DFaraday (12), Bullzeye (18), Typhoony (21), sabie12 (24)
17%

Blackgate Penitentiary
2
sig (8), Scotty (9)
8%

Gotham City General Hospital
1
Enrique (2)
4%

Gotham's Best Strip Club (The Hosts, the Non, the Dead)
2
Epignosis (1), a2thezebra (14)
8%


Total votes : 24

[Glorfindel]

Glorfindel.... any thoughts on which player might have wanted to silence you? You don't have to speculate in the thread, I just want you to think about it.

I've actually been thinking about that a lot and not only who but their possible motives... And no clue yet... I'm actually at work right now which will severely hamper my capacity to post for the next few hours... Sorry!