Arkham Mafia [ENDGAME]

#6451

Lorab
MacDougall
Matt

#6452

MacDougall wrote:Lorab
MacDougall
Matt

Good
Good
Good

#6453

MacDougall wrote:Lorab
MacDougall
Matt

Good
Good
Bad

#6454

MacDougall wrote:Lorab
MacDougall
Matt

Bad
Good
Good

#6455

Bad
BLERK
Bad

#6456

MetalMarsh89
MovingPictures07
Sorsha

#6457

MacDougall wrote:MetalMarsh89
MovingPictures07
Sorsha

Good
Good
Indy

#6458

MacDougall wrote:MetalMarsh89
MovingPictures07
Sorsha

Bad
Robin
Good

#6459

Bad
Good
Bad

#6460

MacDougall wrote:MetalMarsh89
MovingPictures07
Sorsha

tbgm
Good
Bad

#6461

TFW I participate in or influence the lynch of both mafia killers yet still get "Bad" GTH reads

#6462

DharmaHelper wrote:TFW I participate in or influence the lynch of both mafia killers yet still get "Bad" GTH reads

Lol let's talk about this later. Gimme your reads.

#6463

sprityo
S~V~S
TheFloyd73
Turnip Head
Typhoony

#6464

MacDougall wrote:sprityo
S~V~S
TheFloyd73
Turnip Head
Typhoony

Bad
Bad
Bad
Good
Good

#6465

MacDougall wrote:sprityo
S~V~S
TheFloyd73
Turnip Head
Typhoony

Indy
Bad
Bad
Good
Bad

#6466

DharmaHelper wrote:TFW I participate in or influence the lynch of both mafia killers yet still get "Bad" GTH reads

DH: Inmate

Linki:

MacDougall wrote:sprityo
S~V~S
TheFloyd73
Turnip Head
Typhoony

Bad
Bad
Bad
Good
Good

Linki: :O

#6467

MacDougall wrote:sprityo
S~V~S
TheFloyd73
Turnip Head
Typhoony

Good/Indy/lazy schmuck
Good
Good
Good
Bad

#6468

Metalmarsh89 wrote:Linki: :O

:high5:

#6469

Bass_the_Clever No read
Bubbles No Read
Bullzeye No Read
DharmaHelper Good
DFaraday Bad
Dom Barely Good
ekeknat Huuuuh
Enrique Good
Equivocate Would love to meet him one day
Golden False
Glorfindel Good
juliets Might be good
Lorab Good
MacDougall Good
Matt Bad
MetalMarsh89 Good or Bad or Indy
MovingPictures07 Good
sabie12 Bad
Sorsha Good?
sprityo Dunno
S~V~S Might be bad
TheFloyd73 Would love to meet him one day
Turnip Head Good
Typhoony Bad

#6470

To be clear I think sprityo is either a cop who's already nabbed his inmate or an inmate who's already won the game and now he's just chillin.

#6471

Turnip Head wrote:To be clear I think sprityo is either a cop who's already nabbed his inmate or an inmate who's already won the game and now he's just chillin.

How would a cop know if they have nabbed their inmate? Unless they are cop number one, I guess.

#6472

Golden wrote:
Turnip Head wrote:To be clear I think sprityo is either a cop who's already nabbed his inmate or an inmate who's already won the game and now he's just chillin.
How would a cop know if they have nabbed their inmate? Unless they are cop number one, I guess.

Yeah I was thinking Joker...

#6473

Upon further consideration I think Floyd might be an inmate. I don't know to what extent the hosts tweaked the roles, but I know Epignosis did not appreciate Floyd's lack of effort in previous games he's hosted. I could see him handing Floyd an indy role here so no one would have to be unfairly affected by his absence.

#6474

@Hosts: Does Ra's al Ghul learn when his win conditions have been met?

#6475

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:TFW I participate in or influence the lynch of both mafia killers yet still get "Bad" GTH reads
DH: Inmate

Linki:

MacDougall wrote:sprityo
S~V~S
TheFloyd73
Turnip Head
Typhoony
Bad
Bad
Bad
Good
Good

Linki: :O

Damn Daniel.

#6476

@Hosts: How does the Lazarus Pit work? Who comes back from it?

#6477

Enrique wrote:@Hosts: Does Ra's al Ghul learn when his win conditions have been met?

No.

Enrique wrote:@Hosts: How does the Lazarus Pit work? Who comes back from it?

DharmaHelper wrote:Damn Daniel.

I have to listen to this shit all day long.

#6478

BACK AT IT AGAIN WITH THE HOST POOOOOSTS

#6479

Typhoony wrote:
MacDougall wrote:
Typhoony wrote:@ Golden: baddie SVS does not vent in the thread. Maybe a little bit, but she would keep most if not all of it in the chat.
So she wouldn't, but she would.

And who's to say she didn't?
Hello I'm Mac and I'm not gonna listen to people who know what they are talking about

Ok, humor aside, you didn't really address his point.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Golden wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:What's the word on SVS/sabie being teammates? Golden, I saw you mention something about that.
Timing of SVS vote for Mac, mostly. I feel almost like doing a patented G-Man Balaam voting analysis. It doesn't hurt that I already felt like SVS was bad before that.
How about this little conspiracy theory then (which I realize goes against my previous declaration about SVS).

SVS likes to nightkill inactives when she is bad. Not always, but she does. Frisky Dingo is an example of this.

Bea was nightkilled by the Maroni's on Night 4, the team sabie was on. I asked this when it happened. SVS replied immediately "I don't know".

This reminder is really what makes me think SVS might not be bad, despite evidence for it. I think SVS would have killed more inactives by now.

#6480

@Dom - in your bullets over broadway, in which SVS was bad, how many inactives did she kill?

#6481

#6482

Golden wrote:@Dom - in your bullets over broadway, in which SVS was bad, how many inactives did she kill?

Good question. I forgot she was bad in that game.

#6483

Dom wrote:
Golden wrote:@Dom - in your bullets over broadway, in which SVS was bad, how many inactives did she kill?
Good question. I forgot she was bad in that game.

Misleading AF. She was lynched earlier in the game before she could kill, if my memory serves me right.

#6484

Dom wrote:
Dom wrote:
Golden wrote:@Dom - in your bullets over broadway, in which SVS was bad, how many inactives did she kill?
Good question. I forgot she was bad in that game.
Misleading AF. She was lynched earlier in the game before she could kill, if my memory serves me right.

No. She was lynched on day one as a serial killer, then subbed in to a mafia team, and was still alive to give them the win at end game, while all of the inactives continued to be alive.

#6485

The plot thickens.

#6486

What plot?

#6487

Golden wrote:
Dom wrote:
Dom wrote:
Golden wrote:@Dom - in your bullets over broadway, in which SVS was bad, how many inactives did she kill?
Good question. I forgot she was bad in that game.
Misleading AF. She was lynched earlier in the game before she could kill, if my memory serves me right.
No. She was lynched on day one as a serial killer, then subbed in to a mafia team, and was still alive to give them the win at end game, while all of the inactives continued to be alive.

Thissun

#6488

It's not like it makes SVS bad. But some of the theories for why she is not bad don't really check out, in my opinion.

#6489

Golden wrote:It's not like it makes SVS bad. But some of the theories for why she is not bad don't really check out, in my opinion.

What does this mean? Is she guilty until proven innocent? Why does it seem like you want her to be bad?

#6490

Turnip Head wrote:
Golden wrote:It's not like it makes SVS bad. But some of the theories for why she is not bad don't really check out, in my opinion.
What does this mean? Is she guilty until proven innocent? Why does it seem like you want her to be bad?

I'm getting this exact vibe. Like what does make her bad?

#6491

Enrique wrote:
Turnip Head wrote:
Golden wrote:It's not like it makes SVS bad. But some of the theories for why she is not bad don't really check out, in my opinion.
What does this mean? Is she guilty until proven innocent? Why does it seem like you want her to be bad?
I'm getting this exact vibe. Like what does make her bad?

#6492

Turnip Head wrote:
Golden wrote:It's not like it makes SVS bad. But some of the theories for why she is not bad don't really check out, in my opinion.
What does this mean? Is she guilty until proven innocent? Why does it seem like you want her to be bad?

I think she IS bad. I don't want her to be anything. And this isn't a court of law, there is no such thing as 'innocent until proven guilty'.

What, should I ignore terrible arguments? Do you think it is good logic to say "SVS is not bad because no inactives have died, and SVS would have killed inactives by now" when I can point to an example of why this is demonstrably false?

You and Enrique seem to be implying that I should make no effort to disprove bad arguments for why she isn't bad.

#6493

Enrique wrote:
Turnip Head wrote:
Golden wrote:It's not like it makes SVS bad. But some of the theories for why she is not bad don't really check out, in my opinion.
What does this mean? Is she guilty until proven innocent? Why does it seem like you want her to be bad?
I'm getting this exact vibe. Like what does make her bad?

What makes her good?

#6494

Golden wrote:Do you think it is good logic to say "SVS is not bad because no inactives have died, and SVS would have killed inactives by now" when I can point to an example of why this is demonstrably false?

No, I don't, but I also don't see a single person arguing this point.

#6495

To be fundamentally clear here...

I think SVS endeavoured to save sabie by getting a train on Mac yesterday. I think SVS is sabie's teammate. I think it is about the best lead we have on who is bad.

I'm not sure why everyone else is approaching it as though there isn't any reason to think she was bad?

linki @TH

Dom wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:SVS likes to nightkill inactives when she is bad. Not always, but she does.
This reminder is really what makes me think SVS might not be bad, despite evidence for it. I think SVS would have killed more inactives by now.

Well, there are two for you. So, look better.

#6496

Dom said he was reminded that SVS killed inactives when bad. I reminded him of a game he hosted where that didn't happen.

That's literally all that it was, until you and Enrique expressly questioned it.

#6497

An odd pattern in this game so far has been

Player 1: Who do you guys think is bad?
Player 2: I think X is bad and here's why.
Player 1: I don't think that's right, I'm gonna go ahead and dismiss that.
Player 3: Yeah get dismissed homie
Player 2: Who do you guys think is bad, then?
Player 3: Get dismissed homie.
Player 1: Dismissed.

#6498

And yet we still haven't lynched a pro-town player.

#6499

No-one would want SVS to be mislynched for the wrong reasons.

I don't understand what is so difficult about taking that a step further and realising we don't want her to be saved from lynch for the wrong reasons either.

#6500

I just feel like you're not giving the other side of this any consideration. The side where SVS is civ and voted for Mac because she suspected him and it had nothing to do with sabie. You yourself said you did not suspect or engage with sabie. You could just as easily be in the same position as SVS right now.

Here's a thought: if SVS is bad and is killing active players, why didn't she just kill Mac?

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

Who killed no one?