Arkham Mafia [ENDGAME]

[sprityo]

thanks mac, but i mean. i havent claimed so youre all guessing this yourselves

@TH i thought saying "overthink" was riddler-esque.

[DharmaHelper]

Let's lynch DharmaHelper.

Lets not.

[MacDougall]

Let's lynch DharmaHelper.

Lets not.

Nah let's.

[MacDougall]

thanks mac, but i mean. i havent claimed so youre all guessing this yourselves

@TH i thought saying "overthink" was riddler-esque.

"See mods, I'm not roleclaiming don't mod kill me".

[Turnip Head]

Let's lynch DharmaHelper.

Lets not.

Nah let's.

Why do you want to lynch Derpa Helper?

[Marmot]

Who wants my vote today?

[MacDougall]

Let's lynch DharmaHelper.

Lets not.

Nah let's.

Why do you want to lynch Derpa Helper?

Everyone in the GTH read him as bad. He was the only unanimous scum read between the four of us.

[DharmaHelper]

Let's lynch DharmaHelper.

Lets not.

Nah let's.

Why do you want to lynch Derpa Helper?

Everyone in the GTH read him as bad. He was the only unanimous scum read between the four of us.

Which means the four of you are wrong as fuck.

[Golden]

How wrong is fuck?

[Turnip Head]

Pretty sure I marked him down as Good though. Why do you think you GTH read him as bad?

[MacDougall]

Pretty sure I marked him down as Good though. Why do you think you GTH read him as bad?

Ah that you did. I had it written down as bad in me spreadsheet.

Well then, no unanimous scum reads. Great.

He just reminds me of the exact same DharmaHelper from GoC. Well, towards the later part of the game DharmaHelper started supatowning, but he is reminding me of pre-supatown GoC DharmaHelper.

[DharmaHelper]

How wrong is fuck?

Depends on the state.

[MacDougall]

Based on GTH majorities.

Bubbles, Bullzeye, Enrique, Juliets, Mac, MP and Turnip Head all = Good

DH, SVS and Floyd = Bad

The rest there was no clear lean one way or the other.

[MacDougall]

So since SVS and DH are contributing. Let's lynch Floyd. I'm sure we can all agree. A Floyd lynch, is a good lynch.

[DharmaHelper]

Based on GTH majorities.

Bubbles, Bullzeye, Enrique, Juliets, Mac, MP and Turnip Head all = Good

DH, SVS and Floyd = Bad

The rest there was no clear lean one way or the other.

Maybe we should lynch Mac for relying on his gut feels six days into a game.

[Golden]

It is true that the best time to rely on Mac's gut feels is zero days into a game.

[Dom]

Dom said he was reminded that SVS killed inactives when bad. I reminded him of a game he hosted where that didn't happen.

That's literally all that it was, until you and Enrique expressly questioned it.

....what?

She literally didn't have a chance to kill in that game. She was lynched Day 1. Why are you presenting misleading evidence?

Go read your own game, Dom. SVS convinced me and ninja to vote with her on the last day to ensure her mafia team won the game, after having plenty of opportunities to kill.

Did she replace back in? I'm sorry, but I remember her being your partner.

[Golden]

Dom said he was reminded that SVS killed inactives when bad. I reminded him of a game he hosted where that didn't happen.

That's literally all that it was, until you and Enrique expressly questioned it.

....what?

She literally didn't have a chance to kill in that game. She was lynched Day 1. Why are you presenting misleading evidence?

Go read your own game, Dom. SVS convinced me and ninja to vote with her on the last day to ensure her mafia team won the game, after having plenty of opportunities to kill.

Did she replace back in? I'm sorry, but I remember her being your partner.

Yes, I lynched her accidentally on day 1, and then she subbed back into a baddie team, and was their sole survivor who won them the game.

[DharmaHelper]

Dom said he was reminded that SVS killed inactives when bad. I reminded him of a game he hosted where that didn't happen.

That's literally all that it was, until you and Enrique expressly questioned it.

....what?

She literally didn't have a chance to kill in that game. She was lynched Day 1. Why are you presenting misleading evidence?

Go read your own game, Dom. SVS convinced me and ninja to vote with her on the last day to ensure her mafia team won the game, after having plenty of opportunities to kill.

Did she replace back in? I'm sorry, but I remember her being your partner.

Yes, I lynched her accidentally on day 1, and then she subbed back into a baddie team, and was their sole survivor who won them the game.

Possibly the least false thing you've said.

[Dom]

I vaguely remember that.

[MacDougall]

Turnip Helper, would you mind voting for DharmaHead?

[Turnip Head]

Maybe.

[Typhoony]

Can we lynch Golden? He bad yo

[DharmaHelper]

Maybe.

Maybe you'd mind? I'm touched.

[Matt]

Let's lynch DharmaHelper.

Lets not.

Nah let's.

Mac's totally Boomslangin' DH right here. Classic.

Mac

[DharmaHelper]

He's whatting me?

[Matt]

Nah I'm kidding. He's really not Boomslanging you at all, but I wanted to use Boomslang as a verb, and I used it prematurely it seems.

[DharmaHelper]

You *weren't* kidding about voting for him tho.

[Matt]

Early on in the comics, Harvey Bullock was a crooked cop

[MacDougall]

Matt...

Matt. Aww buddy.

[MacDougall]

Cmon Matt. Why would you go do something like that?

[Matt]

Cmon Matt. Why would you go do something like that?

Because you were making Lorab sad

[MacDougall]

Cmon Matt. Why would you go do something like that?

Because you were making Lorab sad

No, but really.

[sprityo]

Maybe I should make a rainbow list

[juliets]

I will be out of the thread from 9:30 am until somewhere around 5 - 5:30 pm this afternoon. I hope there are not 10 pages to catch up on before I can vote but I know there are no promises. See ya'll then.

[Turnip Head]

We could always lynch Matt.

[Sorsha]

So last I checked there was some cross referencing of sabies night locations to other players. Anything come of that?

[Turnip Head]

So last I checked there was some cross referencing of sabies night locations to other players. Anything come of that?

Yeah we figured out you were bad

[DharmaHelper]

So last I checked there was some cross referencing of sabies night locations to other players. Anything come of that?

A pretty convincing piece of evidence against either Lorab or SVS, but not necessarily both.

[Dom]

We could always lynch Matt.

Why?


Also, TH, were you serious the other night about making a case on Mac?

[Turnip Head]

We could always lynch Matt.

Why?

Joking :P

Also, TH, were you serious the other night about making a case on Mac?

No. The case I had in mind was against Glorfy, but rather than making a bullet point case I tried to just have a discussion about him.

[Marmot]

Maybe I should make a rainbow list

I would ride it to the pot of gold.

[Dom]

We could always lynch Matt.

Why?

Joking :P

Also, TH, were you serious the other night about making a case on Mac?

No. The case I had in mind was against Glorfy, but rather than making a bullet point case I tried to just have a discussion about him.

I wanted to make sure.


Anyway, I'd be down to vote either Glorfindel or sprit.

[Matt]

Turnips, what do you think of MP?

[Matt]

Btw I'm not trying to be tricky. Since everyone thinks you're supatowning, guess I will conform and ask you about my latest suspect, he who isn't Robin.

[Turnip Head]

Turnips, what do you think of MP?

I think Wilgy is much more likely to have been "lying" about being Robin than MP is. Wilgy came out after the lynch stop and vouched for Scotty: this is exactly what I'd expect a non-Robin Wilgy would do, because the implication is that it discourages anyone from trying to lynch him. If you remember in GoC, when LC pulled Wilgy into the chatroom, Wilgy claimed he had a lynch pardon when of course he didn't. I can see the same principle applying here.

MP read genuine to me before he ever survived a lynch and he still reads genuine to me now.

Lastly, one of our hosts is not a fan of giving the mafia the ability to survive lynches, a sentiment he has also expressed to me in other conversations we've had. There is no lynch survival stated in the roles of the mafia and I see no reason to assume that one would be included.

[Marmot]

Turnips, what do you think of MP?

I think Wilgy is much more likely to have been "lying" about being Robin than MP is. Wilgy came out after the lynch stop and vouched for Scotty: this is exactly what I'd expect a non-Robin Wilgy would do, because the implication is that it discourages anyone from trying to lynch him. If you remember in GoC, when LC pulled Wilgy into the chatroom, Wilgy claimed he had a lynch pardon when of course he didn't. I can see the same principle applying here.

MP read genuine to me before he ever survived a lynch and he still reads genuine to me now.

Lastly, one of our hosts is not a fan of giving the mafia the ability to survive lynches, a sentiment he has also expressed to me in other conversations we've had. There is no lynch survival stated in the roles of the mafia and I see no reason to assume that one would be included.

Do you think that says anything about Scotty?

[Marmot]

Guess that doesn't matter. I just remembered he was nightkilled.

[Bullzeye]

Haven't caught up yet, will do so shortly. However TH is, has always been, and forever shall be, my greatest suspect and therefore that's who I'll be voting for.

[Turnip Head]

Lol this is shaping up to be a dumb day