Arkham Mafia [ENDGAME]

#6751

Epignosis wrote:
Enrique wrote:@Hosts: If a Mafia team is killed off, does the other start killing every night?
No. That's always been a terrible policy. If you eliminate a kill, you eliminate a kill.

Maybe.

#6752

TheFloyd73 was working (working, Jesus, it kills me to even use that verb) for Maroni, in case the post wasn't plain.

#6753

DharmaHelper wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
Enrique wrote:@Hosts: If a Mafia team is killed off, does the other start killing every night?
No. That's always been a terrible policy. If you eliminate a kill, you eliminate a kill.

Maybe.

I didn't mean that. I meant like, the Don of the same family should inherit it.

#6754

It is worth noting that Epignosis said that "maybe" the kill would die with the role BEFORE the Joker lynch. And the Joker is a role with secrets.

#6755

Enrique wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
Enrique wrote:@Hosts: If a Mafia team is killed off, does the other start killing every night?
No. That's always been a terrible policy. If you eliminate a kill, you eliminate a kill.

Maybe.
I didn't mean that. I meant like, the Don of the same family should inherit it.

It's not mentioned explicitly in the role that the Don is in the line of succession.

#6756

Epignosis wrote:TheFloyd73 was working (working, Jesus, it kills me to even use that verb) for Maroni, in case the post wasn't plain.

#6757

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Enrique wrote:I'm assuming it goes straight to Marone/Falcone?

We also don't know what team he was in, he could be one of tomorrow's killers.

Naw, Epignosis already said the kill isn't inherited.

No, what he said was this:

Epignosis wrote:
Enrique wrote:@Hosts: If a Mafia team is killed off, does the other start killing every night?
No. That's always been a terrible policy. If you eliminate a kill, you eliminate a kill.

Maybe.

Linki @ DH

That "Maybe.

" kinda of makes the answer a bit ambivalent

#6758

Although actually now I see it says "inherits the kill first" which yeah ok Maroni has the kill now lol

#6759

S~V~S wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Enrique wrote:I'm assuming it goes straight to Marone/Falcone?

We also don't know what team he was in, he could be one of tomorrow's killers.

Naw, Epignosis already said the kill isn't inherited.
No, what he said was this:

Epignosis wrote:
Enrique wrote:@Hosts: If a Mafia team is killed off, does the other start killing every night?
No. That's always been a terrible policy. If you eliminate a kill, you eliminate a kill.

Maybe.
Linki @ DH

That "Maybe. " kinda of makes the answer a bit ambivalent

True. Off the top of my head I remembered the first part, but not the disclaimer.

Let's lynch Maroni and find out.

#6760

Wow, another lurker actually would make a lot of sense.

#6761

Epignosis wrote:It is now Night 7.

Epignosis is drunk.

#6762

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Epignosis wrote:It is now Night 7.
Epignosis is drunk.

No, Long Con is an asshole and a troll.

#6763

Good result! If there's no kill tonight it would lend credence to the third member being inactive too, although they did get one kill in, so I'm thinking probably not Equivocate or Bass.

#6764

YAS¡¡¡

MacDougall wrote:So...

Floyd was recruited and just decided to stop playing and nobody on his team was interested enough to try to reach out to him to get him to keep playing despite him having been on the site.

Is his last partner a lurker too?

I'm confused, then who was sending in the
pm?

#6765

Hahahaha. Beautiful.

#6766

Dom wrote:YAS¡¡¡

MacDougall wrote:So...

Floyd was recruited and just decided to stop playing and nobody on his team was interested enough to try to reach out to him to get him to keep playing despite him having been on the site.

Is his last partner a lurker too?
I'm confused, then who was sending in the
pm?

Well Floyd was logging in right? He just wasn't posting...

#6767

So um Arkham and GCPD? Anyone think we should be sharing? I kinda really wanna solve this lol (and it's info that the Mafias should have already).

#6768

Fuck it I'm gonna get the ball rolling.

The info in Arkham is that Harley Quinn didn't kill 9 people.

#6769

Only one Maroni to go.

#6770

DharmaHelper wrote:So, no kill tonight?

Maroni is still alive, though, right?

#6771

Epignosis wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Epignosis wrote:It is now Night 7.
Epignosis is drunk.
No, Long Con is an asshole and a troll.

Oopsie! I'm not either of those things, I'm just a bad co-host. Well, maybe that makes me an asshole.

Seriously though, for the record, Epi is running most of this game, I'm like this free spirit who sometimes shows up to help. If you like what you are experiencing, it's 99% likely that you owe your thanks to him.

#6772

Long Con wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Epignosis wrote:It is now Night 7.
Epignosis is drunk.
No, Long Con is an asshole and a troll.
Oopsie! I'm not either of those things, I'm just a bad co-host. Well, maybe that makes me an asshole.

Seriously though, for the record, Epi is running most of this game, I'm like this free spirit who sometimes shows up to help. If you like what you are experiencing, it's 99% likely that you owe your thanks to him.

And if you like what you are reading, that's LC. Him is a gud righter.

#6773

Arkharm Mafia: where lynching the lurkers actually gets things done aside from clearing space

#6774

RIH Floyd.

I see Lorab's spirits seem to be up so I suppose I will not be voting Mac again tomorrow.

Funny tho, I'm pretty sure both Turnips and MP are liar liars but everyone seems to think they're civvie.

Is MM playing this game? I'm pretty sure he is. MM - What's up bud?

#6775

Matt wrote:RIH Floyd.

I see Lorab's spirits seem to be up so I suppose I will not be voting Mac again tomorrow.

Funny tho, I'm pretty sure both Turnips and MP are liar liars but everyone seems to think they're civvie.

Is MM playing this game? I'm pretty sure he is. MM - What's up bud?

Yeah dude! I'm totally playing. That's why I'm posting on topic and voting in the polls (usually) and stuff.

Are you playing this game?

#6776

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Matt wrote:RIH Floyd.

I see Lorab's spirits seem to be up so I suppose I will not be voting Mac again tomorrow.

Funny tho, I'm pretty sure both Turnips and MP are liar liars but everyone seems to think they're civvie.

Is MM playing this game? I'm pretty sure he is. MM - What's up bud?
Yeah dude! I'm totally playing. That's why I'm posting on topic and voting in the polls (usually) and stuff.

Are you playing this game?

I'm trying.

I think you listed me as bad in your G2H reads. Why Marmot why?

#6777

Guess zebra wasn't maroni.

#6778

Yeah...

#6779

Matt wrote:Funny tho, I'm pretty sure both Turnips and MP are liar liars but everyone seems to think they're civvie.

Hold the phone there, Matt! Yes, I did state that I thought that both were good but I'd certainly consider seriously anything you had to say on the matter. I thought the case for MP being confirmed Town was conclusive and widely accepted. May I impose upon you to state your thoughts on either/both of them?

Matt wrote:Is MM playing this game? I'm pretty sure he is. MM - What's up bud?

There's never a 'facepalm' smilie around when you need one...

#6780

My fav:

#6781

Sorry I missed the vote!! I fell asleep early watching tv and by the time I woke up to get into bed, the vote had already finished.

Well done on Floyd. RIH bad cop!

#6782

Ricochet wrote:My fav:

Thanks, Man

#6783

Wow, imagine being really excited to get your recruit only for it to be someone who isn't even playing...

#6784

Do you have any experience with that Bullzeye?

#6785

Fortunately not.

#6786

Glorfindel wrote: Compare that to 'A World Reborn' (where he was Town) and you'll find pretty much the opposite.

No, he wasn't. He was neutral who was incidentally protecting a baddie. Did you mean a different game?

Glorfindel wrote:
Turnip Head wrote:
Golden wrote:
Turnip Head wrote:You could always join #TeamLynchGlorfindel. We'd be happy to have you.
You seem to be on #TeamLynchDharmaHelper
Yeah but I'm a free agent soon and #TeamLynchGlorfindel has a juicier benefits package
Well you'd better start work right now on how you're going to justify your leading a lynch against an obvious Townie because I can promise you, you're going to need it my friend...

I really don't see how you're "obvious" civ at all...

#6787

LoRab wrote:
Glorfindel wrote: Compare that to 'A World Reborn' (where he was Town) and you'll find pretty much the opposite.
No, he wasn't. He was neutral who was incidentally protecting a baddie. Did you mean a different game?

And they killed him

LoRab wrote:
Glorfindel wrote:
Turnip Head wrote:
Golden wrote:
Turnip Head wrote:You could always join #TeamLynchGlorfindel. We'd be happy to have you.
You seem to be on #TeamLynchDharmaHelper
Yeah but I'm a free agent soon and #TeamLynchGlorfindel has a juicier benefits package
Well you'd better start work right now on how you're going to justify your leading a lynch against an obvious Townie because I can promise you, you're going to need it my friend...
I really don't see how you're "obvious" civ at all...

Since he was the first person I actually suspected in this game, I would concur. Especially since the thing I suspected him for was a wholesale semi-vouch for Zebra, who I am not sure was straight up civ.

#6788

Was anyone riddled last night?
I'm wondering if bea could have been the Riddler since I haven't heard anything at all

#6789

Based on who was Riddled, I don't think she was the Riddler, it did not match her suspicions, other than possibly Matt? If she had an Indy role, I think she would play it as a civ.

#6790

Glorfindel wrote:As for me, at the end of the last Day phase I put before you my case on MetalMarsh89 and I revisited it last night. At the time that I conducted my analysis he had 190 posts this game at an average of 16.6 words per post. In fact, the post where he defended my accusation was his second longest for him for the entire game. Whilst I both admire and appreciate his sense of humour, most of his posts were just that - very little substance, next to no analysis - which I think makes Golden's comment about not being aware that he was even playing so telling. If you compare this performance to Pikmin Mafia where he was Mafia, you'll see that it is very similar. Compare that to 'A World Reborn' (where he was Town) and you'll find pretty much the opposite. Whilst not describing his posting as prolific, they were very different - lots of analysis, incisive questioning of other players... MM is clearly a very accomplished player and to me, it looks like he's coasting this game and doing a fine job of it.

I know I don't need to say this but I do like and respect the guy and it gives me no pleasure at all to vote for him but I'm as certain as I can be of anyone that something is up with him. Having said that, not one of you (with the possible exception of Golden) was even willing to give my proposition the time of day. If you (TH, MP, Golden, Mac, Bulls, etc.) are indeed Town, it appears to me that you have lost your objectivity and in that (more than just your judgement on me) you are letting our team down.

Did you go back and read the A World Reborn thread?

#6791

Hooray we got another!! And just checking in to say I have not been riddled Typh.

#6792

S~V~S wrote:Based on who was Riddled, I don't think she was the Riddler, it did not match her suspicions, other than possibly Matt? If she had an Indy role, I think she would play it as a civ.

We don't know anything about the Riddler though, so who knows what it's win con is.

#6793

Matt wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Matt wrote:RIH Floyd.

I see Lorab's spirits seem to be up so I suppose I will not be voting Mac again tomorrow.

Funny tho, I'm pretty sure both Turnips and MP are liar liars but everyone seems to think they're civvie.

Is MM playing this game? I'm pretty sure he is. MM - What's up bud?
Yeah dude! I'm totally playing. That's why I'm posting on topic and voting in the polls (usually) and stuff.

Are you playing this game?
I'm trying.

I think you listed me as bad in your G2H reads. Why Marmot why?

Because I think you are more likely to be bad then civ. That's why. :nicenod

I don't feel strongly about it, but that's how I feel.

#6794

Typhoony wrote:Was anyone riddled last night?
I'm wondering if bea could have been the Riddler since I haven't heard anything at all

Nah pretty sure Zeebs or sig was the Riddler. Which means I have no clue what you and Turnips have been talkin' about. Especially Turnips.

#6795

It sounds like you could be wrong, Matt.

#6796

Dom wrote:It sounds like you could be wrong, Matt.

No.

From the impression I got, I very well should've been posting funny on Days 4, 5, and 6 as well, until I got the riddle correct. Suddenly though, nothin'.

But everyone's keen on Turnips, so what can I do? Guess I'll move on.

#6797

Matt wrote:
Dom wrote:It sounds like you could be wrong, Matt.
No.

From the impression I got, I very well should've been posting funny on Days 4, 5, and 6 as well, until I got the riddle correct. Suddenly though, nothin'.

But everyone's keen on Turnips, so what can I do? Guess I'll move on.

I think there is a false conclusion you jumped to at some point, matt. I think moving on is a good idea.

#6798

Movin' on up...to the east side...

#6799

Dom wrote:It sounds like you could be wrong, Matt.

Matt? Wrong? What are you high??

#6800

Why do people think TH is the Riddler? Did I miss it?

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

Who killed no one?