Arkham Mafia [ENDGAME]

[sprityo]

ive been waiting on this lynch for days now, and mafia feel im too suspicious to kill anyways. one of my main questions is through all the "i dont like sprityo" it's never gotten past that. Unless youre DFaraday or Bullzeye

I welcome death with open arms friends, or is that just me messing with you again?

oh and i guess i was on the block yesterday?

oh, and wait, im dead. yes? hmm let me check again

[Golden]

I like you sprityo!

[Turnip Head]

DH why did you kill Sorsha?

[sprityo]

AHHH thank you my friends, i put the game into your hands now. Finish off the families if you would kindly <3

im sorry for not being as active as some of you, but yeah. This was super fun!

[DharmaHelper]

DH why did you kill Sorsha?

[sprityo]

oh and here is that "crumb", for you all, that is my last words for this game

Spoiler: show

I mean we've already congratulated TH aplenty, but again, good job on that one!

it was so obscure that no one would notice. (this was following the death of the joker btw)

[LoRab]

DH is an obvious baddie for NKing sorsha

So, to be extra clear, I won't be voting SVS today. I won't even be making any cases on SVS. I've come to the point on my own thought processes where I genuinely think I may have been wrong about her. I think I've done enough to explain why in previous posts, so I'm moving on.

I also think my annoyance at the lynch yesterday, was in part because I was able to recognise that I had let myself be too focussed on SVS. (It was also partly because the meme generators were hard work and pissing me off).

I recognise today may well be about lynching Glorfindel. If it is, I understand. I agree with Typhoony that lynching an inmate isn't a bad outcome, but I prefer to lynch someone who is really bad, and even more than that I feel as though Glorfindel is making genuine efforts to help the town, not playing both sides as some other people might do with that role. It's also possible that he is actually GCPD. I don't think Glorfindel is bad, and I can't vote that way.

But, I'm not going to focus on Glorfindel. I want to start looking at some new people. People who possibly haven't been looked at enough.

There are a number of people I feel like have flown under the radar this game. Perhaps I have been one until very recently. Typhoony, Dom, DF, DH, LoRab... remarkably even Matt to some extent. Some of these people have taken heat, but I don't really feel like I or any one else has analysed anything much about them. I'd throw me in there - I'd invite anyone to really investigate my game.

At this point, I think I have identified town-leaning roles for SVS, MP, TH and Mac. Unless anyone actually is any of the roles I think these people are and wants to state my theories as being wrong. I have probable town reads on Enrique, bullz and juliets.

That really leaves me looking in that group of six, plus the inactives, for where my vote would go today.

I admit I haven't been as active as I usually am this game--travel and a sinus infection I realize don't excuse being quiet, but they really are the main reason. I know I'm civ, but I don't know how to prove that or even demonstrate it other than saying to read my posts and realize that they're from a civ perspective.

Still figuring out my own thinking on this lynch...

[DharmaHelper]

Sprityo, noo.

[Epignosis]

oh and here is that "crumb", for you all, that is my last words for this game

Spoiler: show

I mean we've already congratulated TH aplenty, but again, good job on that one!

it was so obscure that no one would notice. (this was following the death of the joker btw)

sprityo, you cannot post on topic because you are dead. Please save your comments that are related to the game for the end.

[Golden]

Yeah, LoRab, that's not a criticism. I meant to say, but forgot, that by 'flying under the radar' I don't even mean post count. Dom, Matt, DH, these guys have high post counts. So do I.

[DharmaHelper]

Have I been under the radar though?

[Enrique]

dh who should we vote for

[LoRab]

Yeah, LoRab, that's not a criticism. I meant to say, but forgot, that by 'flying under the radar' I don't even mean post count. Dom, Matt, DH, these guys have high post counts. So do I.

I know what you mean, totally. But my lower than usual participation has been the biggest difference between my game play this game than usual, was really what I meant. In another iteration, I'd say eye me all you want, lol.

[Marmot]

oh and here is that "crumb", for you all, that is my last words for this game

Spoiler: show

I mean we've already congratulated TH aplenty, but again, good job on that one!

it was so obscure that no one would notice. (this was following the death of the joker btw)

sprityo, you cannot post on topic because you are dead. Please save your comments that are related to the game for the end.

Rezz please so I can post on topic.

[DharmaHelper]

dh who should we vote for

Baddies.

[Glorfindel]

ive been waiting on this lynch for days now, and mafia feel im too suspicious to kill anyways. one of my main questions is through all the "i dont like sprityo" it's never gotten past that. Unless youre DFaraday or Bullzeye

I welcome death with open arms friends, or is that just me messing with you again?

oh and i guess i was on the block yesterday?

oh, and wait, im dead. yes? hmm let me check again

I am genuinely sorry for having voted for you my friend. I do wish you'd been around a little more as had you been, I don't think I'd doubted you as I did. The last thing we needed is to lose a cop. I'd like to think we might get the chance to play together again - one day...

[Dom]

RIP Sorsh.

Glorfindel, are you still looking at a Typhoony lynch?

[Dom]

dh who should we vote for

Baddies.

Like who?

[DharmaHelper]

dh who should we vote for

Baddies.

Like who?

The bad ones.

[Dom]

Golden maybe flown under the radar isn't the best way to put it. Do you mean avoided scrutiny? Because I don't feel like neither Matt nor myself have exactly flown under the radar.

[Enrique]

dh who should we vote for

Baddies.

name 1

[DharmaHelper]

dh who should we vote for

Baddies.

name 1

Falcone.

[Matt]

I wonder what Matt will be afflicted with today.

Nah I'm good.

Lol @ Mac still being alive.

[Dom]

Enrique, can you name one suspect?

[Sorsha]

Thank you!

[Glorfindel]

RIP Sorsh.

Glorfindel, are you still looking at a Typhoony lynch?

There's a couple of things I'd like to re-assess but I certainly believe there is a case to be made for Typhoony. We are well in the mid-game now and after seven Day and Night phases, the core group of experienced and influential players from this site remains for all intents and purposes, intact. Some of you (e.g. yourself, DH, MP and many others) would've I thought, made first rate NK choices by a Mafia team and yet, they've not taken out any really vocal and as I say influential players - I think that is indicative and what Matt has been trying to tell us the last few Days. Having said that, I think I wouldn't be doing my job if I turned a blind eye to a player that I believe has been flying under the radar for the last seven days and nights.

I know a good many of you are suspicious of me and I'm yet to fully understand why but I have no intention of abandoning my brothers in arms to the Mafia in this game.

[Matt]

Thank you!

You're welcome.

Linki - I think I've changed my mind. Let's lynch Glorfy.

[Enrique]

glarfondel

d'oh

[LoRab]

RIP Sorsh.

Glorfindel, are you still looking at a Typhoony lynch?

There's a couple of things I'd like to re-assess but I certainly believe there is a case to be made for Typhoony. We are well in the mid-game now and after seven Day and Night phases, the core group of experienced and influential players from this site remains for all intents and purposes, intact. Some of you (e.g. yourself, DH, MP and many others) would've I thought, made first rate NK choices by a Mafia team and yet, they've not taken out any really vocal and as I say influential players - I think that is indicative and what Matt has been trying to tell us the last few Days. Having said that, I think I wouldn't be doing my job if I turned a blind eye to a player that I believe has been flying under the radar for the last seven days and nights.

I know a good many of you are suspicious of me and I'm yet to fully understand why but I have no intention of abandoning my brothers in arms to the Mafia in this game.

I'm confused by this post. Are you saying that the mafia hasn't made good kill choices? And how are you defining what good choices would be? You seem to be indicating that experienced players would take out vocal/influencial players? But I don't think that's how experienced mafia usually chooses kills, so I'm not sure. Like I said, I'm confused. Could you clarify?

[Enrique]

RIP Sorsh.

Glorfindel, are you still looking at a Typhoony lynch?

There's a couple of things I'd like to re-assess but I certainly believe there is a case to be made for Typhoony. We are well in the mid-game now and after seven Day and Night phases, the core group of experienced and influential players from this site remains for all intents and purposes, intact. Some of you (e.g. yourself, DH, MP and many others) would've I thought, made first rate NK choices by a Mafia team and yet, they've not taken out any really vocal and as I say influential players - I think that is indicative and what Matt has been trying to tell us the last few Days. Having said that, I think I wouldn't be doing my job if I turned a blind eye to a player that I believe has been flying under the radar for the last seven days and nights.

I know a good many of you are suspicious of me and I'm yet to fully understand why but I have no intention of abandoning my brothers in arms to the Mafia in this game.

I'm confused by this post. Are you saying that the mafia hasn't made good kill choices? And how are you defining what good choices would be? You seem to be indicating that experienced players would take out vocal/influencial players? But I don't think that's how experienced mafia usually chooses kills, so I'm not sure. Like I said, I'm confused. Could you clarify?

Well, surely it tells us he couldn't have made those kills.

[LoRab]

RIP Sorsh.

Glorfindel, are you still looking at a Typhoony lynch?

There's a couple of things I'd like to re-assess but I certainly believe there is a case to be made for Typhoony. We are well in the mid-game now and after seven Day and Night phases, the core group of experienced and influential players from this site remains for all intents and purposes, intact. Some of you (e.g. yourself, DH, MP and many others) would've I thought, made first rate NK choices by a Mafia team and yet, they've not taken out any really vocal and as I say influential players - I think that is indicative and what Matt has been trying to tell us the last few Days. Having said that, I think I wouldn't be doing my job if I turned a blind eye to a player that I believe has been flying under the radar for the last seven days and nights.

I know a good many of you are suspicious of me and I'm yet to fully understand why but I have no intention of abandoning my brothers in arms to the Mafia in this game.

I'm confused by this post. Are you saying that the mafia hasn't made good kill choices? And how are you defining what good choices would be? You seem to be indicating that experienced players would take out vocal/influencial players? But I don't think that's how experienced mafia usually chooses kills, so I'm not sure. Like I said, I'm confused. Could you clarify?

Well, surely it tells us he couldn't have made those kills.

That was a little bit orange...yes?

[Glorfindel]

RIP Sorsh.

Glorfindel, are you still looking at a Typhoony lynch?

There's a couple of things I'd like to re-assess but I certainly believe there is a case to be made for Typhoony. We are well in the mid-game now and after seven Day and Night phases, the core group of experienced and influential players from this site remains for all intents and purposes, intact. Some of you (e.g. yourself, DH, MP and many others) would've I thought, made first rate NK choices by a Mafia team and yet, they've not taken out any really vocal and as I say influential players - I think that is indicative and what Matt has been trying to tell us the last few Days. Having said that, I think I wouldn't be doing my job if I turned a blind eye to a player that I believe has been flying under the radar for the last seven days and nights.

I know a good many of you are suspicious of me and I'm yet to fully understand why but I have no intention of abandoning my brothers in arms to the Mafia in this game.

I'm confused by this post. Are you saying that the mafia hasn't made good kill choices? And how are you defining what good choices would be? You seem to be indicating that experienced players would take out vocal/influencial players? But I don't think that's how experienced mafia usually chooses kills, so I'm not sure. Like I said, I'm confused. Could you clarify?

No, my friend. I'm saying the Mafia are making strategic choices. In one of the first games I played, we got to rather late in the game where a similar thing had happened - all of the less vocal and influential players had been killed off. The reason was that the Mafia were all very experienced players. If they'd removed the more influential players they would've been exposed and I get a sense that is what I'm seeing here (no offence to MM and Sorsha ).

[DharmaHelper]

As frustrating as it was to basically be told I am an affliction I don't like that Sorsha was NKed.

[Matt]

As frustrating as it was to basically be told I am an affliction I don't like that Sorsha was NKed.

Seeing as how you and Sorsha seemed to have some kind of real off topic probs, I don't think you killed her btw. Unless you're just a total dick.

[Dom]

RIP Sorsh.

Glorfindel, are you still looking at a Typhoony lynch?

There's a couple of things I'd like to re-assess but I certainly believe there is a case to be made for Typhoony. We are well in the mid-game now and after seven Day and Night phases, the core group of experienced and influential players from this site remains for all intents and purposes, intact. Some of you (e.g. yourself, DH, MP and many others) would've I thought, made first rate NK choices by a Mafia team and yet, they've not taken out any really vocal and as I say influential players - I think that is indicative and what Matt has been trying to tell us the last few Days. Having said that, I think I wouldn't be doing my job if I turned a blind eye to a player that I believe has been flying under the radar for the last seven days and nights.

I know a good many of you are suspicious of me and I'm yet to fully understand why but I have no intention of abandoning my brothers in arms to the Mafia in this game.

Let's keep going in this vein. Where are you looking? Why?

[DharmaHelper]

As frustrating as it was to basically be told I am an affliction I don't like that Sorsha was NKed.

Seeing as how you and Sorsha seemed to have some kind of real off topic probs, I don't think you killed her btw. Unless you're just a total dick.

I wouldn't call it that extreme. I was just offended to be referred to in the same way as one might refer to a cold sore.

[DharmaHelper]

Or waterboarding.

[Golden]

Golden maybe flown under the radar isn't the best way to put it. Do you mean avoided scrutiny? Because I don't feel like neither Matt nor myself have exactly flown under the radar.

Maybe avoided scrutiny is right. Not avoided suspicion, just... Avoided meaningful analysis, maybe.

[Matt]

Golden maybe flown under the radar isn't the best way to put it. Do you mean avoided scrutiny? Because I don't feel like neither Matt nor myself have exactly flown under the radar.

Maybe avoided scrutiny is right. Not avoided suspicion, just... Avoided meaningful analysis, maybe.

Why you suss of me Golden? I thought we were two peas in a pod this game.

[Dom]

Matt what're you up to?

[Matt]

Chillin'. You?

[DFaraday]

I kind of get what Glorfindel is saying. Players like Mac, Golden, and MP are typically the most vocal players, and tend to spearhead lynches and the general direction of the thread. If a baddie team wants to manipulate the thread it would make sense to take out players who might lead a lynch on them. I don't think that's a reason to suspect any of those players are bad though.

Glorf, why do you suspect Typh? I feel like he hasn't been trying to help the civ cause very much, but I haven't seen anything specifically suspicious about him.

I still think one of the Mac voters is probably bad. Aside from SVS, whom I still think could be bad, I'll look over the others tomorrow.

[Dom]

Chillin'. You?

Wondering why you haven't been doing much lately.

I kind of get what Glorfindel is saying. Players like Mac, Golden, and MP are typically the most vocal players, and tend to spearhead lynches and the general direction of the thread. If a baddie team wants to manipulate the thread it would make sense to take out players who might lead a lynch on them. I don't think that's a reason to suspect any of those players are bad though.

Glorf, why do you suspect Typh? I feel like he hasn't been trying to help the civ cause very much, but I haven't seen anything specifically suspicious about him.

I still think one of the Mac voters is probably bad. Aside from SVS, whom I still think could be bad, I'll look over the others tomorrow.

Well two of the three players you named there outed themselves or gave strong enough role hints that they've dropped off the face of discussion.

[Matt]

I'm tryin' to get things done, Dom. I'm tryin'.

You still like Turnips? I've never seen such a bad and/or indy player shove in my face how bad and/or indy they are, yet nobody wants to get behind a Turnips lynch. Does everyone still think he's Alfred or something?

Going back to another "confirmed civ", why isn't Mac dead? Sorry, but that doesn't make any sense for him to still be breathing. Derp.

[Dom]

I'm tryin' to get things done, Dom. I'm tryin'.

You still like Turnips? I've never seen such a bad and/or indy player shove in my face how bad and/or indy they are, yet nobody wants to get behind a Turnips lynch. Does everyone still think he's Alfred or something?

Going back to another "confirmed civ", why isn't Mac dead? Sorry, but that doesn't make any sense for him to still be breathing. Derp.

Why do you think TH is bad and who thinks he is Alfred? The case was that he wasn't Alfred.

[DFaraday]

Chillin'. You?

Wondering why you haven't been doing much lately.

I kind of get what Glorfindel is saying. Players like Mac, Golden, and MP are typically the most vocal players, and tend to spearhead lynches and the general direction of the thread. If a baddie team wants to manipulate the thread it would make sense to take out players who might lead a lynch on them. I don't think that's a reason to suspect any of those players are bad though.

Glorf, why do you suspect Typh? I feel like he hasn't been trying to help the civ cause very much, but I haven't seen anything specifically suspicious about him.

I still think one of the Mac voters is probably bad. Aside from SVS, whom I still think could be bad, I'll look over the others tomorrow.

Well two of the three players you named there outed themselves or gave strong enough role hints that they've dropped off the face of discussion.

I know, and I don't suspect any of the above. I was just indicating the general reason one might expect those guys to get NKed. I'm not sure why Glorfindel is specifically calling them out in this game though.

Linki: I'm kind of unclear about TH too. Everybody seems to be taking it for granted that he's civ and I feel like I missed why.

[Matt]

I'm tryin' to get things done, Dom. I'm tryin'.

You still like Turnips? I've never seen such a bad and/or indy player shove in my face how bad and/or indy they are, yet nobody wants to get behind a Turnips lynch. Does everyone still think he's Alfred or something?

Going back to another "confirmed civ", why isn't Mac dead? Sorry, but that doesn't make any sense for him to still be breathing. Derp.

Why do you think TH is bad and who thinks he is Alfred? The case was that he wasn't Alfred.

I assumed people thought he was Alfred and that's why literally nobody is sussing him.

As for why I think he's bad, not to pull a Zebra, but it's all over my ISO. Basically, he's a liar liar pants on fire.

[Dom]

Your ISO is also 11 pages long. Can you either summarize or give a bit more specifics in where to look?

[Golden]

I'm tryin' to get things done, Dom. I'm tryin'.

You still like Turnips? I've never seen such a bad and/or indy player shove in my face how bad and/or indy they are, yet nobody wants to get behind a Turnips lynch. Does everyone still think he's Alfred or something?

Going back to another "confirmed civ", why isn't Mac dead? Sorry, but that doesn't make any sense for him to still be breathing. Derp.

Why do you think TH is bad and who thinks he is Alfred? The case was that he wasn't Alfred.

Despite dropping many hints in that direction over the last few days, there have been a distinct lack of TH or SVS (or anyone else) rejecting my assertion that SVS could be Batman.

[Glorfindel]

I kind of get what Glorfindel is saying. Players like Mac, Golden, and MP are typically the most vocal players, and tend to spearhead lynches and the general direction of the thread. If a baddie team wants to manipulate the thread it would make sense to take out players who might lead a lynch on them. I don't think that's a reason to suspect any of those players are bad though.

Glorf, why do you suspect Typh? I feel like he hasn't been trying to help the civ cause very much, but I haven't seen anything specifically suspicious about him.

I still think one of the Mac voters is probably bad. Aside from SVS, whom I still think could be bad, I'll look over the others tomorrow.

Finally! Someone who I think gets what I'm trying to say... You're correct too, I think - if you're Mafia, you hardly want to find yourself up against a 'Mac' or a 'Dom' or a 'TH' (or yes, even a 'Matt' ) leading a lynch mob against you and I think you'd probably prefer to take those players out of the equation.

As for Typhoony, I look over his posts this game (I think he has marginally more than I do) but like MM, it's difficult to recall any part he's played in the game. Look more closely at his posts and you see much the same as was the case with MM. Lot's of one liners, nothing too controversial, votes with little if any justification, throwing out the odd question now and then... I'd like too look at it a little more closely but that was my general first (and second) impression. If I wanted to fly under the radar this game as Mafia, I think that's exactly what I would've done.