Arkham Mafia [ENDGAME]

#8251

DH was also a pretty unanimous baddie read back on GTH day 6.

#8252

WHOA

Light bulb.

Enrique/Bullzeye's back and forth on the low posters...

Since we established that the hosts let DF send in the kills while Floyd was alive (presumably), we can also assume that the hosts would also allow Falcone to send in the kills even if their theoretical no show partner was alive, as well, right?

#8253

Matt wrote:
Bullzeye wrote:
Golden wrote:
S~V~S wrote:
Enrique wrote:Does anyone think DH is good at all?
Bizarrely enough, I do.

Linki @ Golden, once again, I am talking about her posts in this game. Not every game. Someone corrected her out of the thread about Lorabs gender, imo.

I think you underestimate bubbles wildly if you think she is silly enough to have the gender corrected in btsc and then come in and post about it.
Also there's one minute between her referring to LoRab as male and then apologising if she used the wrong pronoun.
Questions...

1) What did you mean when you said "This should be interesting" in response to my G2H'ing you Town/indy?

2) Can you please post your reads even if most are civ?

I'm the only person you labelled outright indy as opposed to a civ friendly indy, which implies you don't think I'm civ-friendly and have gone 10 full days without saying so.

Basically the only people I don't think are probable civs are Bubbles, DH, Dom, SVS, and Typh. All but Bubbles I think are varying shades of indy and could easily be swayed to civ or bad. I've completely disregarded the existence of Bass, Ekeknat and Equivocate. They aren't here.

I don't like to make G2H reads because quite frankly I'm awful at doing them and don't like trying to make them. Most of my opinions on people change daily, I don't keep like a list of who I think is what that I update with new info.

#8254

Matt wrote:WHOA

Light bulb.

Enrique/Bullzeye's back and forth on the low posters...

Since we established that the hosts let DF send in the kills while Floyd was alive (presumably), we can also assume that the hosts would also allow Falcone to send in the kills even if their theoretical no show partner was alive, as well, right?

Yes, Matt. We already established that many times over, as per Dom pointing out rule 12 at the start of day 10.

#8255

Relax Bullz, lol, I labeled you as "Town/indy". And I didn't label you civ friendly because something in the back of my mind is hounding me, saying "Would Bullz put up that display of 'oh poor me' if he were bad?" and I keep coming back to "yes, yes he would" haha.

#8256

Golden wrote:
Matt wrote:WHOA

Light bulb.

Enrique/Bullzeye's back and forth on the low posters...

Since we established that the hosts let DF send in the kills while Floyd was alive (presumably), we can also assume that the hosts would also allow Falcone to send in the kills even if their theoretical no show partner was alive, as well, right?
Yes, Matt. We already established that many times over, as per Dom pointing out rule 12 at the start of day 10.

Lol. Okey dokey, well consider me caught up then.

#8257

Matt wrote:
Golden wrote:
Matt wrote:WHOA

Light bulb.

Enrique/Bullzeye's back and forth on the low posters...

Since we established that the hosts let DF send in the kills while Floyd was alive (presumably), we can also assume that the hosts would also allow Falcone to send in the kills even if their theoretical no show partner was alive, as well, right?
Yes, Matt. We already established that many times over, as per Dom pointing out rule 12 at the start of day 10.
Lol. Okey dokey, well consider me caught up then.

#8258

Matt wrote:Relax Bullz, lol, I labeled you as "Town/indy". And I didn't label you civ friendly because something in the back of my mind is hounding me, saying "Would Bullz put up that display of 'oh poor me' if he were bad?" and I keep coming back to "yes, yes he would" haha.

I don't really know what to say in response to this other than I wasn't putting on a display. I hate people going on about me "overreacting" to everything and it genuinely makes me want to just walk out for good if that's all people think of me.

If you want some pure WIFOM, if I were bad I'd have just bitched about it in btsc and not had to say anything in the thread. Anyone who's ever had btsc with me knows how much I love a good bitching session.

#8259

Bullzeye wrote:
Matt wrote:Relax Bullz, lol, I labeled you as "Town/indy". And I didn't label you civ friendly because something in the back of my mind is hounding me, saying "Would Bullz put up that display of 'oh poor me' if he were bad?" and I keep coming back to "yes, yes he would" haha.
I don't really know what to say in response to this other than I wasn't putting on a display. I hate people going on about me "overreacting" to everything and it genuinely makes me want to just walk out for good if that's all people think of me.

If you want some pure WIFOM, if I were bad I'd have just bitched about it in btsc and not had to say anything in the thread. Anyone who's ever had btsc with me knows how much I love a good bitching session.

Um okay Bullz. You react weird to being called "town/indy", I'll tell you that.

Who is your top suss today? DH?

#8260

Matt wrote:
Bullzeye wrote:
Matt wrote:Relax Bullz, lol, I labeled you as "Town/indy". And I didn't label you civ friendly because something in the back of my mind is hounding me, saying "Would Bullz put up that display of 'oh poor me' if he were bad?" and I keep coming back to "yes, yes he would" haha.
I don't really know what to say in response to this other than I wasn't putting on a display. I hate people going on about me "overreacting" to everything and it genuinely makes me want to just walk out for good if that's all people think of me.

If you want some pure WIFOM, if I were bad I'd have just bitched about it in btsc and not had to say anything in the thread. Anyone who's ever had btsc with me knows how much I love a good bitching session.
Um okay Bullz. You react weird to being called "town/indy", I'll tell you that.

Who is your top suss today? DH?

That's not a reaction to being called town/indy, that's a reaction to your comment about would I act the way I did if I were bad. I should think it was obvious.

I wouldn't call anyone my top suspect today but I'm leaning towards a Bubbles vote if I can't be convinced any particular person is Scarecrow. I don't see how you'd get "DH is my top suspect" from what I've said about him so far.

#8261

Voting DharmaHelper because I really got more important shit to do and I wanna get this out of the way ASAP. He is one of my top Scarecrow candidates, has a vote already, and only SVS has a civvie read on him. Good enough for me.

#8262

Cuz earlier you said he was one of your only non-civ reads. And that was before you listed 1/3 of the players as non civ reads.

Derp.

I'd be down with a vote for Bubbles or Dom. Even though I view her as bad, I wouldn't want to vote Lorab because I think Bubbles' vote is weird and I don't like it.

#8263

Enrique wrote:Voting DharmaHelper because I really got more important shit to do and I wanna get this out of the way ASAP. He is one of my top Scarecrow candidates, has a vote already, and only SVS has a civvie read on him. Good enough for me.

Convince me DH is Scarecrow. I already think he's probably an inmate. What makes him one of your top candidates?

#8264

I don't have a civ read onhim, I don't think he is Scarecrow. When DH thinks I am bad, and he thought so for some portion of the game, he targets me. I am untargeted by Scarecrow. I don't think he is Scarecrow.

#8265

S~V~S wrote:I don't have a civ read onhim, I don't think he is Scarecrow. When DH thinks I am bad, and he thought so for some portion of the game, he targets me. I am untargeted by Scarecrow. I don't think he is Scarecrow.

How do you know he didn't target you and he was blocked or you were protected?

I'm not sold on DH being Scarecrow btw, just wondering why you hadn't thought of that.

#8266

Bullzeye wrote:
Enrique wrote:Voting DharmaHelper because I really got more important shit to do and I wanna get this out of the way ASAP. He is one of my top Scarecrow candidates, has a vote already, and only SVS has a civvie read on him. Good enough for me.
Convince me DH is Scarecrow. I already think he's probably an inmate. What makes him one of your top candidates?

Process of elimination pretty much. Could also see it being Typh but I don't really have time to overthink this atm.

#8267

Lets vote Dom?

#8268

Golden wrote:Lets vote Dom?

Why?

#8269

Golden wrote:Lets vote Dom?

Where's Dom been? Don't tell me he's been silenced today.

#8270

Earlier in this game, he made a remark about how he thought I was bad, and about how no one listened to him in Recruitment, and he had to kill me becasue no one listened to him. If he was Scarecrow, or any malicious power, he would have targeted me that night, imo, if he did not tareget me Night One.

And that is as far as I will go defending DH. That is my supa sincere opinion.

Linki, well, I think there are only baddie blockers, but secrets, true. I guess it is possible. But I honestly think he would have targeted me Night One.

#8271

Matt wrote:
Golden wrote:Lets vote Dom?
Where's Dom been? Don't tell me he's been silenced today.

Nope

#8272

As mentioned by me in response to you when I said he points out rule 12... about 10 minutes ago

#8273

Matt wrote:
Golden wrote:Lets vote Dom?
Where's Dom been? Don't tell me he's been silenced today.

Dom has posted today. He asked me who was bad and I told him he was.

S~V~S wrote: Linki, well, I think there are only baddie blockers, but secrets, true. I guess it is possible. But I honestly think he would have targeted me Night One.

I don't see how the alignment of the blockers influences whether or not they blocked DH and/or Scarecrow.

#8274

Good point. I never think of bad blockers blocking bad people

But totally based on my knowledge of DH, I don't think he would have targeted Golden night one, I thinkit would have been me or maybe Typh. Based on history.

#8275

S~V~S wrote:Good point. I never think of bad blockers blocking bad people

But totally based on my knowledge of DH, I don't think he would have targeted Golden night one, I thinkit would have been me or maybe Typh. Based on history.

I think DH would have just as easily targetted me night one. I feel like he is one of the more likely candidates in that regard.

#8276

I thinkit was Juliets, tbh, but there is no proving it either way. I think, based on our history together, mega adversarial, that he would have targeted me.

I think we should lynch Bubbles becasue she is very very very bad, imo.

#8277

I think I actually will *Vote DH*. Pretty much nobody thinks he's civ and the only argument I've heard against him being Scarecrow is SVS' insistence he'd definitely have targeted her first.

#8278

Guess I'm voting for whoever has the better chance of beating me in a lynch lol

#8279

DharmaHelper wrote:Guess I'm voting for whoever has the better chance of beating me in a lynch lol

Well, how do you feel about a Dom lynch?

And Matt, how do you feel about a Dom lynch?

#8280

I'll be voting DH if it comes down to DH vs Bubbles.

#8281

Golden wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:Guess I'm voting for whoever has the better chance of beating me in a lynch lol
Well, how do you feel about a Dom lynch?

And Matt, how do you feel about a Dom lynch?

Matt thought I was Maroni and he was wrong. Wouldn't it be pants-shittingly fantastic if Dom was Scarecrow.

#8282

DharmaHelper wrote:
Golden wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:Guess I'm voting for whoever has the better chance of beating me in a lynch lol
Well, how do you feel about a Dom lynch?

And Matt, how do you feel about a Dom lynch?
Matt thought I was Maroni and he was wrong. Wouldn't it be pants-shittingly fantastic if Dom was Scarecrow.

It would be pretty hilarious.

I really do believe Dom is bad.

#8283

I voted so pointless hanging around. Hasta, good luck DH, and BUBBLES IS BAD BAD BAD BAD BAD.

#8284

I'm not Scarecrow by the way, you nerds who're voting for me because you don't feel like baddie hunting.

#8285

I'm trying to fix a mistake i made in character creation for one of my players, but I'll vote for either Dom, Bubbles, or whoever the people who like me decide to chuck under the bus.

#8286

Matt, get your stuff together.

#8287

Wait, it can't be Matt...

#8288

I dun understand why da Prisoner is in this thread

#8289

This doesn't make sense at all. Why is there a prisoner in this thread?

#8290

Looking at the Bubbles voters from last time, I would guess it is Juliets

Her & I both have a talent for sockpuppet crossposting

#8291

S~V~S wrote:Looking at the Bubbles voters from last time, I would guess it is Juliets

Her & I both have a talent for sockpuppet crossposting

But she hasn't been arrested/lynched in the Sockface game.

#8292

I am going by what has happened in this game. It is me (no) jules, faraday (he is dead here & unlikely to vote) or MP (he is hosting. What happenes over there stay over there.

#8293

Blackgate needs to step their game up this is getting kinda ridiculous.

#8294

I hate it when people sound so sure, like SVS. Makes me think their case is a cover for info, and so makes me paranoid, and wonder if I am just being too stubborn and not listening.

I think the case on Bubbles is poor. But SVS being so certain and writing it in capitals makes me think I could be wrong.

#8295

Golden wrote:I hate it when people sound so sure, like SVS. Makes me think their case is a cover for info, and so makes me paranoid, and wonder if I am just being too stubborn and not listening.

I think the case on Bubbles is poor. But SVS being so certain and writing it in capitals makes me think I could be wrong.

Please don't vote for me. I said please.

#8296

Golden wrote:I hate it when people sound so sure, like SVS. Makes me think their case is a cover for info, and so makes me paranoid, and wonder if I am just being too stubborn and not listening.

I think the case on Bubbles is poor. But SVS being so certain and writing it in capitals makes me think I could be wrong.

I don't have info. I did not make a crappy case. I just really really believe it just like I really don't believe it about DH being Scarecrow.

#8297

Sometimes I just really believe things to be true in my gut that I can't prove. You know this to be true.

#8298

S~V~S wrote:Sometimes I just really believe things to be true in my gut that I can't prove. You know this to be true.

I do. You and I are alike that way.

#8299

I feel like if I vote Bubbles, then Golden might get an itchy trigger finger and vote DH, which I don't necessarily want to happen. Hrm.

#8300

I won't hold votes to ransom

But how about a Dom vote?

Who killed no one?