Arkham Mafia [ENDGAME]

#8801

also - I just want to add that all things concidered Dom played an amazing game.

#8802

I just want to add I agree about Dom. Amazing game for a head baddie. I would have suspected others for that role before suspecting Dom.

#8803

Isn't he like a baddie role magnet, lately?

#8804

Sorry, Bea, I didn't realize it would bother you that much.

In Mafia I don't consider anybody off limits, I wouldn't feel like I'm playing fair that way.

You did suspect me a bit, but my main fear at that point was Scotty, since he'd come up with that accurate case on me. But I figured it would be much too obvious to take him out. You were just the right mix of not voicing support for me but also not having gone hard after me.

#8805

Typhoony wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote: If Typhoony's guess is incorrect, the first letter of the first word in each sentence of his posts for the next day must spell "E-N-Y-G-M-A" and once he's spelled that out, he cannot add anything to his post.

For example:

Everything is awesoome. Now, what time is it? You'd think I'd know the answer to this riddle, wouldn't you? Not the case, I assure you! Anyway, off I go.

I never guessed, I still got cursed. Also you example does not spell out Enygma nub[/quote]
Not guessing is the same as getting it wrong. Nub.

#8806

MacDougall wrote:Oh I didn't win because I needed Robin dead. Oh well. I'm a true hero blah blah blah.

I didn't google your riddle, I just saw three and hands and was like ... that's a watch.

Hah

#8807

bea wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:Here's my first riddle, and probably my best tbqh.

Send this to Matt:

Here's a riddle for you! No cheating now, or you'll end up a corpse. I'll be keeping tabs on you, so solve it quickly. Remember, you're in my house now so we're playing by my rules.

I've got wings like a bat, but don't wait.
I've got the walk of a cat, but no gait.

What am I?
Answer:
Spoiler: show
The answer to the riddle is "A stage" The wings of a stage are where actors and tech crew "wait". Most stages also have a cat walk (walk of a cat). It's also important that you send the WHOLE message, because there are several hints in the first half of the message (cheating, corpse, tabs, house, and playing are all technical terms associated with theatre)

For Matt's curse since he failed to solve this riddle, I made him quote Shakespeare plays. Which was intended to be a hint as to the answer of the riddle.

That is brilliant!!!

As far as a flat out curse goes, I loved it as I read it. OMG - so much Shakespeare fun. For realizies. BEST curse ever. As opposed to your brother's "quote all the ghosts in A Christmas Carol in sequential order." WORST curse ever.

awe...fuck. I should have known. Both of you be damn literate.

Don't know what matt was going on about how we had to help him continue on to be able to solve it, looks like you gave him everything he needed. If only he had eyes to see.

You were a good ed nigma.

[/quote]

Thanks.

I forgot to mention I also added that if anyone guessed the play he was quoting he had to switch plays and vote for the person who got him all the way through all 30 something plays :P

#8808

Dom why did you guys kill me. After the moment we shared in Star Wars you should've let me live. :P

Also thanks for the game Epi and LC it was fun.

#8809

So Sorsha's the one who poisoned me Night 1...

Revenge is a bitch, Sorsha.

Just kidding, I don't really revenge target. But still... that was a jerk move. :P

#8810

You guys do realize that the poisoning was fake, right?

#8811

Yes, that was cruel Epi!! I was so afraid of getting poisoned.

#8812

bea wrote:Don't know what matt was going on about how we had to help him continue on to be able to solve it

You could read any one of my posts this game and know it is pure, pure, pure bs. Okay, maybe that's not true.

I thought TH was bad because I lied in thread and said Riddler targeted me twice (knock knock and shakespeare), which he didn't. Again, I'm not entirely sure what happened on Night 1/Day 2 regarding the knock knocks.

Anyway, so then TH was cursed two days in a row, and I think he blamed Riddler, and I thought "Well I'm lying, so TH must be lying?" Derp.

Oh yeah, when SVS went after me for Derps, I was trippin' out. Gotta watch that, I think you may be right SVS haha.

Bullz, again, I feel bad dude. I actually thought by targeting you with me, that'd be cool so you could still win even if I was NK'd. Shoulda done that for everyone, tbh.

#8813

Matt were you not allowed to pick Harvey Bullock?

#8814

Matt wrote:
bea wrote:Don't know what matt was going on about how we had to help him continue on to be able to solve it
You could read any one of my posts this game and know it is pure, pure, pure bs. Okay, maybe that's not true.

I thought TH was bad because I lied in thread and said Riddler targeted me twice (knock knock and shakespeare), which he didn't. Again, I'm not entirely sure what happened on Night 1/Day 2 regarding the knock knocks.

Anyway, so then TH was cursed two days in a row, and I think he blamed Riddler, and I thought "Well I'm lying, so TH must be lying?" Derp.

Oh yeah, when SVS went after me for Derps, I was trippin' out. Gotta watch that, I think you may be right SVS haha.

Bullz, again, I feel bad dude. I actually thought by targeting you with me, that'd be cool so you could still win even if I was NK'd. Shoulda done that for everyone, tbh.

You did nothing wrong. I knew I could win with Scarecrow NK'd tbh I just wanted to help the others who specifically needed him lynched. I did think about saying in the thread that I only needed Scarecrow to die so I'd be happy for the baddies to kill him and set me up if nobody wanted to lynch Dom. Obviously that wouldn't have worked out but since I'd have survived a lynch I thought it was a risk worth taking.

#8815

MovingPictures07 wrote:Also, hell of a game played by Dom.

You were my first town read, but then you kept nagging at the back of my brain as if I made a mistake so I started questioning your motives, but then you would seem super genuine again, etc. I could never nail you down.

Thank you! My goal, civ or bad, is to have people never be sure enough of me to lynch me nor sure enough to not lynch me.

Bullzeye wrote:
Dom wrote:Wow! Amazing game! Thank you Epi for creating such a fun world. Civvies you kicked ass. Made it very hard for me to see a path to victory. Disappointing that I didn't win, but very good game.

Golden I think it's very clear why I felt so comfortable bussing my team.

DH awesome job with those riddles. My next guess was either gonna be eyeliner or a theater. I blocked you because I suspected you were the riddler but didn't want you to start killing as Epi has hinted might start happening.
I'm sorry you lost. I thought the info I had was pretty straightforward in saying you were Scarecrow. Basically what I was thinking was you, as the Scarecrow, would name a target and name the player they need dead. Then Batman redirects your target to you, and obviously you can't make yourself need yourself dead, so Epi and LC decided to make your target (me) need you dead instead of presumably MP. I just didn't want to be a dick about it so I waited for you to say something I could leap on.

LOL
I appreciate that you waited.
Ya just started a lynch train on the lead baddie, that's all

bea wrote: Ya'll should chalk her play up this game as a case study of how a 'nilla civ should play. I kept trying to keep up but couldn't. svs is amazing.

This.

Ricochet wrote:Isn't he like a baddie role magnet, lately?

I was civ in Game of Champioins

sig wrote:Dom why did you guys kill me. After the moment we shared in Star Wars you should've let me live. :P

Also thanks for the game Epi and LC it was fun.

I thought you were civ and I had my work cut out for me if I wanted to eliminate all the civs. As soon as I got a civ read on someone, I killed them.
I was wrong plenty of times, but it was the strategy.

#8816

DharmaHelper wrote:Matt were you not allowed to pick Harvey Bullock?

He picked it for me.

#8817

Dom wrote:
Ricochet wrote:Isn't he like a baddie role magnet, lately?

I was civ in Game of Champioins

So once in your last four games, is it? Wow rad debunked mythbusted.

Game of Champignons? I'd play that.

#8818

Golden wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:Matt were you not allowed to pick Harvey Bullock?
He picked it for me.

I had Golden pegged as a civ Day One. He was oozing civviness, I thought haha.

Also, I wasn't able to target people with dead roles. At some point, someone asked in thread "Why doesn't Scarecrow just target people with dead roles?" I think, but if I did, the target wouldn't have gone through.

Lol. For about 5 days or so (yes, again, even after Joker was revealed dead), I was convinced Golden was Joker. And because I did the knock knocks, I was convinced he knew I was Scarecrow. That whole time I thought we were working in collusion against the thread haha, but nope apparently not.

#8819

I did leave one clue to the fact I was a cop, which I could point back to if I ever really needed to. Being cop 10, and having the opponent of Ra's, I quickly realised the cop numbers related directly to the order of the inmates on the thread.

The reason I forgot that I had theorised sprit was cop one (which TH found so suspicious) is that I genuinely never really thought sprit was cop one and it wasn't why I said it. I only said it to demonstrate my understanding that the cop equivalent of the joker WAS cop one, and before anyone else had ever mentioned the concept in the thread.

#8820

Btw, here's something ironic...

Dom was going after Golden quite a bit, and I thought Golden *might* be mafia after his stubborn defense of Bubbles, and I didn't want Golden to die yet because I knew I didn't have enough victims. So I target Dom in the hopes that Dom goes after Scarecrow instead of Golden. Dom reveals he was Scarecrow'd. Everyone lynches Dom for being Scarecrow, game ends, I lose.

#8821

Epignosis wrote:You guys do realize that the poisoning was fake, right?

Yes, but it still freaked me out. :P

#8822

Matt wrote:Btw, here's something ironic...

Dom was going after Golden quite a bit, and I thought Golden *might* be mafia after his stubborn defense of Bubbles, and I didn't want Golden to die yet because I knew I didn't have enough victims. So I target Dom in the hopes that Dom goes after Scarecrow instead of Golden. Dom reveals he was Scarecrow'd. Everyone lynches Dom for being Scarecrow, game ends, I lose.

Yall shoulda listened to me and voted LoRab

#8823

Matt wrote:Btw, here's something ironic...

Dom was going after Golden quite a bit, and I thought Golden *might* be mafia after his stubborn defense of Bubbles, and I didn't want Golden to die yet because I knew I didn't have enough victims. So I target Dom in the hopes that Dom goes after Scarecrow instead of Golden. Dom reveals he was Scarecrow'd. Everyone lynches Dom for being Scarecrow, game ends, I lose.

I wasn't going to be lynched, Matt! You should have had more faith in me. Even though I'd offered my head up I was pretty sure no-one was going to take me up on it.

Did you target someone on day 5 or did you always skip that day with the idea of keeping the lie in your back pocket?

#8824

I don't think I would have been lynched either. I was dipping my toes in the pool of "intentionally" getting lynched for a second there but I think I would have lasted a few phases if I wanted to.

#8825

Golden wrote:
Matt wrote:Btw, here's something ironic...

Dom was going after Golden quite a bit, and I thought Golden *might* be mafia after his stubborn defense of Bubbles, and I didn't want Golden to die yet because I knew I didn't have enough victims. So I target Dom in the hopes that Dom goes after Scarecrow instead of Golden. Dom reveals he was Scarecrow'd. Everyone lynches Dom for being Scarecrow, game ends, I lose.

I wasn't going to be lynched, Matt! You should have had more faith in me. Even though I'd offered my head up I was pretty sure no-one was going to take me up on it.

Did you target someone on day 5 or did you always skip that day with the idea of keeping the lie in your back pocket?

Actually, I accidentally forgot to send in a PM on Night 5. Then, when coming up with who I was "Scarecrow'd" with, I noticed my first post on Day 6 I was going after MP out of nowhere, and thought "Perfection". I don't even know why I went after MP. Again, anything I posted was pretty much bs (as usual

)

#8826

DharmaHelper wrote:
Matt wrote:Btw, here's something ironic...

Dom was going after Golden quite a bit, and I thought Golden *might* be mafia after his stubborn defense of Bubbles, and I didn't want Golden to die yet because I knew I didn't have enough victims. So I target Dom in the hopes that Dom goes after Scarecrow instead of Golden. Dom reveals he was Scarecrow'd. Everyone lynches Dom for being Scarecrow, game ends, I lose.

Yall shoulda listened to me and voted LoRab

No y'all shoudn't have!!

#8827

Matt wrote:
Golden wrote:
Matt wrote:Btw, here's something ironic...

Dom was going after Golden quite a bit, and I thought Golden *might* be mafia after his stubborn defense of Bubbles, and I didn't want Golden to die yet because I knew I didn't have enough victims. So I target Dom in the hopes that Dom goes after Scarecrow instead of Golden. Dom reveals he was Scarecrow'd. Everyone lynches Dom for being Scarecrow, game ends, I lose.

I wasn't going to be lynched, Matt! You should have had more faith in me. Even though I'd offered my head up I was pretty sure no-one was going to take me up on it.

Did you target someone on day 5 or did you always skip that day with the idea of keeping the lie in your back pocket?
Actually, I accidentally forgot to send in a PM on Night 5. Then, when coming up with who I was "Scarecrow'd" with, I noticed my first post on Day 6 I was going after MP out of nowhere, and thought "Perfection". I don't even know why I went after MP. Again, anything I posted was pretty much bs (as usual )

#8828

DFaraday wrote:Sorry, Bea, I didn't realize it would bother you that much. In Mafia I don't consider anybody off limits, I wouldn't feel like I'm playing fair that way.

You did suspect me a bit, but my main fear at that point was Scotty, since he'd come up with that accurate case on me. But I figured it would be much too obvious to take him out. You were just the right mix of not voicing support for me but also not having gone hard after me.

It's all good sweets. Just mafia trash talking.

#8829

So, Matt, was i right about you or nah?

#8830

Fuck now I have to come out of retirement for the champs game...

#8831

DharmaHelper wrote:Fuck now I have to come out of retirement for the champs game...

If you are serious about that retirement shit, then you better come out of it on occasion. A mafia world with no DH would suck. I wanted you in my BSG game

#8832

DharmaHelper wrote:Fuck now I have to come out of retirement for the champs game...

Game of Champignons 2017: Retired Only

Current list:

1. DharmaHelper
2. Heiots
3. moi

#8833

DharmaHelper wrote:Fuck now I have to come out of retirement for the champs game...

I think you should come out for Mortal Kombat.

#8834

I think he should send me a horrible PM and just not retire

#8835

You should come on and slam, Dharmahelper

#8836

Like the great Michael Jordan, I think I should stick to retirement this time around.

#8837

Dom wrote:So, Matt, was i right about you or nah?

Funny thing, I really didn't think you were bad at all. Shows what I know. Thanks for not killing me

DH and Dom retiring sounds lame.

#8838

Thanks for killing me. Because of the extra time you gave me back to my life I managed to get promoted to Marketing Director of a major Australian real estate business. So ... I am retired because my life is over.

#8839

MacDougall wrote:Thanks for killing me. Because of the extra time you gave me back to my life I managed to get promoted to Marketing Director of a major Australian real estate business. So ... I am retired because my life is over.

See you again in a month, Mac.

#8840

Congrats on financial upgrade!

#8841

S~V~S wrote:Congrats on financial upgrade!

What's that?

#8842

Mac got a promotion, generally that means $$

#8843

S~V~S wrote:Mac got a promotion, generally that means $$

No, I mean, "What's a financial upgrade?" I've never heard of such a thing.

#8844

Just a way of saying "a raise" that's all. It sounds better than "Yay more money", lol.

#8845

S~V~S wrote:Just a way of saying "a raise" that's all. It sounds better than "Yay more money", lol.

Still a foreign concept to me.

#8846

I'm very sad that I did not win this game

Thanks Epi and LC for the good time. Thanks hosts for being evil enough to include false info in the logic puzzle. I was so fucking close, yet so far.

Thanks Mac for coming after me Day 1

Thanks Matt for saying I lied about my first curse not being the Riddler's doing, and then thinking I was lying about saying it WAS the Riddler, when I really said the complete opposite. Like what the hell

Thanks Enrique for making me think you were Alfred the first couple of days, only to suddenly accuse me of being Alfred and I was all like WTF! Thanks MM for eventually making me realize you were Alfred, only for you to be NK'ed.

Thanks Sorsha for poisoning me and never "curing" me, I can't believe you did that, I knew your secret the whole game

Thanks DH for giving me an impossible riddle and the worst punishment of all time. Chrysanthemums warming fuck you.

I guess we were too good at lynching mafiosos while the inmates were too difficult to get lynched. The only one I managed to get rid of was BR, and she won while I didn't lol.

#8847

Oh TH reminds me...

Sorsha accidentally sent her PM to me and TH instead of me and LC.

I had to rewrite TH's role to accommodate this unexpected "info."

#8848

I was originally supposed to get Batman BTSC with someone. Following in the grand tradition of LC, I intended to use it on Mac first.

#8849

Turnip Head wrote:I'm very sad that I did not win this game

Thanks Epi and LC for the good time. Thanks hosts for being evil enough to include false info in the logic puzzle. I was so fucking close, yet so far.

Thanks Mac for coming after me Day 1

Thanks Matt for saying I lied about my first curse not being the Riddler's doing, and then thinking I was lying about saying it WAS the Riddler, when I really said the complete opposite. Like what the hell

Thanks Enrique for making me think you were Alfred the first couple of days, only to suddenly accuse me of being Alfred and I was all like WTF! Thanks MM for eventually making me realize you were Alfred, only for you to be NK'ed.

Thanks Sorsha for poisoning me and never "curing" me, I can't believe you did that, I knew your secret the whole game

Thanks DH for giving me an impossible riddle and the worst punishment of all time. Chrysanthemums warming fuck you.

I guess we were too good at lynching mafiosos while the inmates were too difficult to get lynched. The only one I managed to get rid of was BR, and she won while I didn't lol.

The anagram website I gave you allowed you to build you own anagrams. You didn't have to keep using chrysanthemums

#8850

I input the phrase you gave me, and every solution that it generated involved chrysanthemums. I didn't realize I could change it

Who killed no one?