Battlestar Galactica Mafia - GAME OVER

[Golden]

And if Nero comes in last-second like and outs himself, we need another option. I'm gonna go with my gut on this one.

Vote = Glorfindel

There are 7 votes left to be placed, so at this point, you would need every other player available to follow suit in order to push Glorfindel into the lead.

I'll probably vote for Nerolunar. If he's a Cylon, eliminating his amnesty would still be a good result, even if no one is lynched.

Linki: Never mind. Now it's mathematically impossible for Glorfindel to be lynched outright.

To be abundantly clear - immunity does not equate to no lynch if an immune person is the lynch leader. It equates to none of the votes against the immune person being worth anything, and so them not being the top vote getter.

Does amnesty get used up if the self-declared Cylon doesn't get the most votes?

Yes.

[Long Con]

A new law has been passed.

Cylon Amnesty Act: Any person may publicly admit to being a cylon and, if the declaration is true, they will have immunity from the lynch for that day. Once a person has outed themselves as a cylon, they cannot do it a second time.

Nah, I think that it only works the day the say it, the first time that they say it.

Hmm, I guess you could be right, looking at it again. I'll await Goldama's answer, but I guess I'm fine with "using it up" for your plan. I'm not a Cylon though.

[DrumBeats]

So basically right now it comes down to who would we rather have in front, Nero or Lorab.

Pros of Nero ahead:
-Human!Lorab would not die

Pros of Lorab:
-We would know for sure if Lorab is a cylon.

I'm personally leaning more towards putting Nero ahead. Would've preferred Glorfindel or Bea, but sadly that's not a choice.

Vote: Nerolunar

[Glorfindel]

Well we would need a ton of people if we wanted to counter the Nero wagon so maybe not.

Idea time! What if we pushed the Nero wagon past the Lorab wagon?

My thoughts on that is that if Lorab is human, he would be lynched regardless, if he is cyclon it would default to Nero. If we push Nero past, then we save a human Lorab if that is the case. It would make no difference if Lorab is a cylon. Only thing here is we would be uncertain in the end if Lorab is cylon or human. I'm not sure how you guys feel about it, but it's a possibility imo. We need to come up with a group consensus on that though, so nobody jumps the gun and does it anyway.

And @Glorfindel - G-man has a convincing case on you imo and I do not like Bea's interactions with nutella

If you consider that case 'convincing', it clearly doesn't take a lot to pursuade you...

[Long Con]

And if Nero comes in last-second like and outs himself, we need another option. I'm gonna go with my gut on this one.

Vote = Glorfindel

There are 7 votes left to be placed, so at this point, you would need every other player available to follow suit in order to push Glorfindel into the lead.

I'll probably vote for Nerolunar. If he's a Cylon, eliminating his amnesty would still be a good result, even if no one is lynched.

Linki: Never mind. Now it's mathematically impossible for Glorfindel to be lynched outright.

To be abundantly clear - immunity does not equate to no lynch if an immune person is the lynch leader. It equates to none of the votes against the immune person being worth anything, and so them not being the top vote getter.

Does amnesty get used up if the self-declared Cylon doesn't get the most votes?

I am a Cylon, I declare this to be so, so that I may be immune to lynch today if it's true.
Yes.

[ObscureAllure]

So basically right now it comes down to who would we rather have in front, Nero or Lorab.

Pros of Nero ahead:
-Human!Lorab would not die

Pros of Lorab:
-We would know for sure if Lorab is a cylon.

I'm personally leaning more towards putting Nero ahead. Would've preferred Glorfindel or Bea, but sadly that's not a choice.

Vote: Nerolunar

[Marmot]

So basically right now it comes down to who would we rather have in front, Nero or Lorab.

Pros of Nero ahead:
-Human!Lorab would not die

Pros of Lorab:
-We would know for sure if Lorab is a cylon.

I'm personally leaning more towards putting Nero ahead. Would've preferred Glorfindel or Bea, but sadly that's not a choice.

Vote: Nerolunar

As Golden just cleared up, Lorab effectively has 0 votes (unless she lied).

Thus, Nerolunar would be the lynch leader regardless of your vote. But that's alright.

[Golden]

And if Nero comes in last-second like and outs himself, we need another option. I'm gonna go with my gut on this one.

Vote = Glorfindel

There are 7 votes left to be placed, so at this point, you would need every other player available to follow suit in order to push Glorfindel into the lead.

I'll probably vote for Nerolunar. If he's a Cylon, eliminating his amnesty would still be a good result, even if no one is lynched.

Linki: Never mind. Now it's mathematically impossible for Glorfindel to be lynched outright.

To be abundantly clear - immunity does not equate to no lynch if an immune person is the lynch leader. It equates to none of the votes against the immune person being worth anything, and so them not being the top vote getter.

Does amnesty get used up if the self-declared Cylon doesn't get the most votes?

I am a Cylon, I declare this to be so, so that I may be immune to lynch today if it's true.
Yes.

Unclear if LC is declaring he is a cylon, or trying to declare that I am a cylon

[Polo]

Are you a Cylon, Golden?

[S~V~S]

22 19 more minutes, Cylon Claimers.

Linki, OMG Golden is a cylon

[Epignosis]

DrWilgy's vote is illegal. That was the point I was making earlier.

[Marmot]

Are you a Cylon, Golden?

He is on the poll.

[Golden]

Are you a Cylon, Golden?

My magic number 8 ball says "Better not tell you now".

[DrumBeats]

So basically right now it comes down to who would we rather have in front, Nero or Lorab.

Pros of Nero ahead:
-Human!Lorab would not die

Pros of Lorab:
-We would know for sure if Lorab is a cylon.

I'm personally leaning more towards putting Nero ahead. Would've preferred Glorfindel or Bea, but sadly that's not a choice.

Vote: Nerolunar

As Golden just cleared up, Lorab effectively has 0 votes (unless she lied).

Thus, Nerolunar would be the lynch leader regardless of your vote. But that's alright.

That was the point of it. If Lorab was lying and was a human, there would be a tie vote.

[Long Con]

Oops, quote error.

I am a Cylon, I declare this to be so, so that I may be immune to lynch today if it's true.

[ObscureAllure]

Pros of Lorab:
-We would know for sure if Lorab is a cylon.

[Polo]

Things can get even more interesting if Ellen Tigh has cast her vote:

"Ellen Tigh - Ellen is the wife of Saul Tigh, and despite her destructive ways and their broken relationship she still loves him deeply. When she has been drinking, Ellen is prone to fracking up. When Ellen casts her vote, it has a 1/3 chance of actually counting towards her target or the person above or below her target on the poll. Any vote she casts against Saul will not count."

[Long Con]

DrWilgy's vote is illegal. That was the point I was making earlier.

I missed the point, I don't understand.

[Long Con]

I'd still prefer Lorab to have the most votes.

[Polo]

DrWilgy's vote is illegal. That was the point I was making earlier.

I missed the point, I don't understand.

Wilgy needs to type his vote in dead red in the thread.

[Black Rock]

Voting Lorab

I don't think Lorab is a good Cylon, and I want her to keep having the most votes.

[Spacedaisy]

Ok.... So I have to choose between voting Nero or Lorab?

Clearly Lorab would've a poor choice for a vote since she likely has amnesty. I need to go read back through Nero's posts.

I must say I am shocked more people aren't suspecting me, because I am well aware how bad my post about Nutella looked after her flip. I would ask that my emotional instability at that moment not keep you all from suspecting me as normal, I assure you I'm fine now.

Not much time; going to go check out Nero. Regarding Lorab though, I am trying to think what colons might be civ aligned other than Athena and frankly I'm not sure, anyone have a thought on whether there are those that might be?

Linki: I have no problem declaring I am a cylon in order to follow this plan, I think it's a decent idea. So I am a Cylon.

Also, in case Lorab is trying a ploy to save herself by convincing others votes for her are useless, I am putting my vote on Lorab. If the math prevents anyone but Nero getting the second most votes at this point I don't see any other worthwhile place to put my vote. It will ensure we know for certain her claim is true and avoid any shenanigans she might be trying to pull. So instead of reading Nero before voting (which is apparently pointless) I'm going to vote Lorab.

Vote: Lorab

[Marmot]

Other players who haven't voted:

Black Rock
Silverwolf
Spacedaisy



Spacedaisy, what sort of havoc should we wreak?

Linki: Black Rock, you missed and voted LC.

Linki: Well, I guess SD voted too huh

[Long Con]

DrWilgy's vote is illegal. That was the point I was making earlier.

I missed the point, I don't understand.

Wilgy needs to type his vote in dead red in the thread.

Oh I see, thank you. Wilgy, what's up?

[DrumBeats]

Ok.... So I have to choose between voting Nero or Lorab?

Clearly Lorab would've a poor choice for a vote since she likely has amnesty. I need to go read back through Nero's posts.

I must say I am shocked more people aren't suspecting me, because I am well aware how bad my post about Nutella looked after her flip. I would ask that my emotional instability at that moment not keep you all from suspecting me as normal, I assure you I'm fine now.

Not much time; going to go check out Nero. Regarding Lorab though, I am trying to think what colons might be civ aligned other than Athena and frankly I'm not sure, anyone have a thought on whether there are those that might be?

Linki: I have no problem declaring I am a cylon in order to follow this plan, I think it's a decent idea. So I am a Cylon.

Also, in case Lorab is trying a ploy to save herself by convincing others votes for her are useless, I am putting my vote on Lorab. If the math prevents anyone but Nero getting the second most votes at this point I don't see any other worthwhile place to put my vote. It will ensure we know for certain her claim is true and avoid any shenanigans she might be trying to pull. So instead of reading Nero before voting (which is apparently pointless) I'm going to vote Lorab.

Vote: Lorab

All colons are civ aligned. Toasters don't have internal organs as far as I know

[Polo]

Ok.... So I have to choose between voting Nero or Lorab?

Clearly Lorab would've a poor choice for a vote since she likely has amnesty. I need to go read back through Nero's posts.

I must say I am shocked more people aren't suspecting me, because I am well aware how bad my post about Nutella looked after her flip. I would ask that my emotional instability at that moment not keep you all from suspecting me as normal, I assure you I'm fine now.

Not much time; going to go check out Nero. Regarding Lorab though, I am trying to think what colons might be civ aligned other than Athena and frankly I'm not sure, anyone have a thought on whether there are those that might be?

Linki: I have no problem declaring I am a cylon in order to follow this plan, I think it's a decent idea. So I am a Cylon.

Also, in case Lorab is trying a ploy to save herself by convincing others votes for her are useless, I am putting my vote on Lorab. If the math prevents anyone but Nero getting the second most votes at this point I don't see any other worthwhile place to put my vote. It will ensure we know for certain her claim is true and avoid any shenanigans she might be trying to pull. So instead of reading Nero before voting (which is apparently pointless) I'm going to vote Lorab.

Vote: Lorab

I'm cracking up at the thought of a colon wearing a pinstripe suit.

[Long Con]

Other players who haven't voted:

Black Rock
Silverwolf
Spacedaisy



Spacedaisy, what sort of havoc should we wreak?

Linki: Black Rock, you missed and voted LC.

Linki: Well, I guess SD voted too huh

Dead red vote is the one that counts.

[ObscureAllure]

I'd still prefer Lorab to have the most votes.

[Marmot]

I'd still prefer Lorab to have the most votes.

Didn't you vote for Nerolunar though?

[Spacedaisy]

Also, I have a question. Is it a valid claim if one says "I'm a cyclon, lol even though I'm not!" Could this wink nudge kind of statement be a workaround you think? Because I've seen a few people do it and it seems I dunno, like a sort of but not really kind of claim. Am I making sense?

Linki: LOL I missed that typo. too funny!

[Polo]

Voting Lorab

I don't think Lorab is a good Cylon, and I want her to keep having the most votes.

Uh, you voted Long Con on the poll.

[ObscureAllure]

I'd still prefer Lorab to have the most votes.

Didn't you vote for Nerolunar though?

[Marmot]

I'd still prefer Lorab to have the most votes.

Didn't you vote for Nerolunar though?

[ObscureAllure]

I'd still prefer Lorab to have the most votes.

Didn't you vote for Nerolunar though?

[Spacedaisy]

Any remaining voters, it would be a better bet to vote Lorab. If she survives it will confirm her as a cylon. If it is a lie to try to get people to vote elsewhere it will be revealed when she actually flips. If she is a cylon Nero is a goner either way, at least we will learn something about another player in the process.

A tie is a bad idea. Lorab should get the most votes...

[DrWilgy]

Oh...

Nerolunar

#Tiiiiieeeeezzzzz!!!

[Spacedaisy]

Is there anyone still holding a vote?

[Marmot]

Vote Nerolunar

[Polo]

Vote Nerolunar

If Nerolunar flips civ, you're my next lynch.

[Marmot]

Is there anyone still holding a vote?

We learned something if we lynch Nero too. I don't think Lorab would have said she was a Cylon if she wasn't.

[ObscureAllure]

Vote Nerolunar

[Long Con]

Your vote in the THREAD is the vote that counts for timing and vote order purposes, however it will ultimately only count if you also vote in the poll.

Ok, so Black Rock's vote won't count.

[Golden]

FREEFORM

Having had so many successes against the cylons recently, the Admiral allowed many of the key figures in the fleet to have a rest evening aboard Cloud 9. They dispersed amongst the many pleasures that were to be had aboard the ship.

Sig and Metalmarsh went in search of companions.

Bea went straight for the bar. No-one was surprised.

S~V~S and DrumBeats were seen heading for the black market.

Daisy went to the doctor. She needed advice on whether or not her colon was civ aligned.

However, many members of the fleet decided to head for the open mic, where they had heard LoRab was going to break out some of her famed rhymes.

First, they sat through Scotty doing a well known monologue from the great Caprican playwright, Dominic Sheath. No-one remembered what the play was called, so they came to call it ‘the Scotty play’. SokothQultuq was impressed with the performance. “majQa’” he cried. Silverwolf was in tears at the beauty of the prose. Epignosis was asleep.

Then it was LoRab’s turn to take the stage.

”Yo, the Admiral might not network
But you can shove your CPU glitches
I’m not gonna take any more of your frakking crap
Cos I’m a cylon, bitches.”

LoRab dropped the mic and walked off the stage.

Shortly afterwards, an explosion rocked Cloud 9. It became apparent that it was an assassination attempt… and the assassination was entirely successful.

Nerolunar has been lynched. He was Saul Tigh. You have 24 hours to send in your night actions.

[Marmot]

Vote Nerolunar

If Nerolunar flips civ, you're my next lynch.

Why?

1) I don't do ties if I can help it.
2) If Lorab is a Cylon (which I believe she is), then Nero is lynched no matter where I vote.
3) I don't understand why you come to this conclusion.

[Long Con]

BOOOO Metalmarsh, BOOO lynch result!

BOOOOOOOOO!!!!

[Long Con]

2) If Lorab is a Cylon (which I believe she is), then Nero is lynched no matter where I vote.

Then WHY did you take away the frakking chance to prove it??

[Polo]

2) If Lorab is a Cylon (which I believe she is), then Nero is lynched no matter where I vote.

Then WHY did you take away the frakking chance to prove it??

Because he's mafia.

MM is getting my vote on D4.

[Spacedaisy]

Is there anyone still holding a vote?

We learned something if we lynch Nero too. I don't think Lorab would have said she was a Cylon if she wasn't.

MM, you are bad, aren't you? If you were right and she was telling the truth Nero would have died anyway, your logic makes no civ sense here.

[DrWilgy]

Vote Nerolunar

If Nerolunar flips civ, you're my next lynch.

Why?

1) I don't do ties if I can help it.
2) If Lorab is a Cylon (which I believe she is), then Nero is lynched no matter where I vote.
3) I don't understand why you come to this conclusion.

Metal Marmot Friend is a cyclon, but civvie aligned. We shouldn't lynch him.

[Marmot]

Well I'm sorry Nerolunar.

Y'all are going to have to deal with it. I said earlier I'd prefer a Long Con or Glorfindel lynch, but the tie was created between Lorab and Nerolunar. I'm not going to place a worthless vote elsewhere if there at tie between the top wagons.

If you've got a problem with it, tough shit.