Jessica Jones S1 Mafia - Day 5 (ENDGAME)

[a2thezebra]

[Marmot]

\o/

[Scotty]

Well that was a fortuitous set of events.

Bye bye timmer

timmer

[DFaraday]

Going with Timmer. I guess unless his teammates busses for that cred, we're at a 50% chance right now.

[Spacedaisy]

Sorry for the delay, first chance to really get here. I'm voting Timmer

[DharmaHelper]

TFW Jill Stien can't even win a lynch poll

[Scotty]

Wait, isn't this game 2v2 right now? How is this game still going? Didn't we already lose?

No more PRs. We lynch timmer, assuming the other baddie in DF and SD don't choose to Make it a 2-2 tie and flip a coin. Then it's 1-1 tomorrow. Is this all predicated on missing the night kill?

As far as I know there's no possible way Jessica Jones and Kilgrave haven't died, since all kills are revealed.

[DFaraday]

Wait, isn't this game 2v2 right now? How is this game still going? Didn't we already lose?

No more PRs. We lynch timmer, assuming the other baddie in DF and SD don't choose to Make it a 2-2 tie and flip a coin. Then it's 1-1 tomorrow. Is this all predicated on missing the night kill?

As far as I know there's no possible way Jessica Jones and Kilgrave haven't died, since all kills are revealed.

The way I see it going:

We lynch Timmer
Baddie kills one of us tonight
Last baddie vs. last civvie next day

I'm not sure why the baddies aren't going for a tie this time though. It seems like that would afford them the best defense since then they'd have a 50% chance of winning in this phase, whereas lynching Timmer means they definitely have to wait until next day phase.

[Scotty]

Wait, isn't this game 2v2 right now? How is this game still going? Didn't we already lose?

No more PRs. We lynch timmer, assuming the other baddie in DF and SD don't choose to Make it a 2-2 tie and flip a coin. Then it's 1-1 tomorrow. Is this all predicated on missing the night kill?

As far as I know there's no possible way Jessica Jones and Kilgrave haven't died, since all kills are revealed.

The way I see it going:

We lynch Timmer
Baddie kills one of us tonight
Last baddie vs. last civvie next day

I'm not sure why the baddies aren't going for a tie this time though. It seems like that would afford them the best defense since then they'd have a 50% chance of winning in this phase, whereas lynching Timmer means they definitely have to wait until next day phase.

Ok but

1 civ and 1 baddie means it's a coin flip in Endgame. How is that fair for either party? Is that a thing that happens?

[DFaraday]

Wait, isn't this game 2v2 right now? How is this game still going? Didn't we already lose?

No more PRs. We lynch timmer, assuming the other baddie in DF and SD don't choose to Make it a 2-2 tie and flip a coin. Then it's 1-1 tomorrow. Is this all predicated on missing the night kill?

As far as I know there's no possible way Jessica Jones and Kilgrave haven't died, since all kills are revealed.

The way I see it going:

We lynch Timmer
Baddie kills one of us tonight
Last baddie vs. last civvie next day

I'm not sure why the baddies aren't going for a tie this time though. It seems like that would afford them the best defense since then they'd have a 50% chance of winning in this phase, whereas lynching Timmer means they definitely have to wait until next day phase.

Ok but

1 civ and 1 baddie means it's a coin flip in Endgame. How is that fair for either party? Is that a thing that happens?

I think so? I don't know as I've ever seen a game where it literally comes down to one civ and one baddie for the lynch (mainly because I tend not to follow games after I'm dead). I think that's typically how it's resolved, but I guess that's up to the host.

[timmer]

What madness is this?

[timmer]

I would like to request that the day be extended as multiple pm'd requests for information and clarification of rules went unanswered. Thank you!

[a2thezebra]

The request is granted. Another 24 hours with a reset poll will begin now.

[timmer]

Thanks.

[Marmot]

I require a rezz.

[DFaraday]

*votes Timmer again*

[timmer]

*votes Timmer again*

Natch.

[Spacedaisy]

DFaraday

[Scotty]

DFaraday

Of course you were bad the whole time. I'm glad I was paranoid enough to suspect you a few phases ago.

Well.

Coin flip it is.

timmer

[a2thezebra]

DFaraday has been lynched in a coin flip. He was Claire Temple, town-aligned.

The civs are now outnumbered so the mafia has won. Congratulations to Spacedaisy, Elohcin, and timmer.

Had timmer been lynched instead, I had a sudden death mode planned for the 1v1 final day in which all the dead players would be able to vote, with mafia players having their votes count twice and civilian players having their votes count once. Spacedaisy more or less outing herself today would have given the civilians an unfair advantage, however.

Now that the game is over I would like to apologize for half-(even quarter)assing my hosting of this game. I could fall back on stress or recent personal issues but in reality there's no excuse. It wouldn't have taken significantly more effort or energy to spice up this game and give it some life and attention, but I didn't. I hope you all enjoyed it all the same and I thank you for playing.

[insertnamehere]

congrats baddies!

I also totally 2/3rd's called it.

BADDIE TEAM GUESSES:
timmer/daisy/scotty
ALT:
timmer/daisy/luffy
timmer/daisy/elo
timmer/scotty/luffy

I'd say I did pretty well in this game. Shame about everyone else though.

[Ricochet]

Folks, we need to talk about the Browns.

Top FEBs

Wins	Players
7	Elohcin, Epignosis, Metalmarsh89

[timmer]

Yay!!!!

Thanks to thezebra for a fun game, I haven't had a game where I've been partially or entirely outed for days on end in awhile, lol.

Thanks to my team, we had some fun but mostly brief BTSC.

And I'd really love to know how different this game would have been had Wilgy not inadvertently drawn everyone's attention to my being a power role on Day 1!

[Epignosis]

Folks, we need to talk about the Browns.

Top FEBs

Wins	Players
7	Elohcin, Epignosis, Metalmarsh89

I count eight Mafia wins on this site for me.

[Ricochet]

Uhh what's the eighth?

[Epignosis]

Uhh what's the eighth?

I don't know. I just counted. Jobs 1, 13, 28, and 31. Sides 9, 12, 19, and 27.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Holy shit my scumdar was terrible this game.

Well ggwp mafia.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Nice job baddies. Y'all maintained control just long enough to finish it off. Well played to the civilians as well for ensuring the game ended as tight as it did. It was a good game to follow and I appreciate everyone+Zebra for keeping my MoD task very simple.

[Ricochet]

Uhh what's the eighth?

I don't know. I just counted. Jobs 1, 13, 28, and 31. Sides 9, 12, 19, and 27.

Checked. I think Doctor Who is the questionable one. I have you as indy winner, according to the host post, but Metalmarsh, in handling the Full game spraying, coloured you Mafia. I'll double check tomorrow, but even Hedgeowl is written as Mafia, which doesn't make much sense, if she was the recruiter/indy mastermind.

[/off topic]

[Marmot]

Players I want to lynch at this moment: Epignosis.

Players I don't want to lynch at this moment: DrWilgy, insertnamehere

So I said this on Night 2, then you guys proceed to lynch DrWilgy and insertnamehere over the next two days.

Well at least you guys got my Epignosis hint right.

[Marmot]

Uhh what's the eighth?

I don't know. I just counted. Jobs 1, 13, 28, and 31. Sides 9, 12, 19, and 27.

Checked. I think Doctor Who is the questionable one. I have you as indy winner, according to the host post, but Metalmarsh, in handling the Full game spraying, coloured you Mafia. I'll double check tomorrow, but even Hedgeowl is written as Mafia, which doesn't make much sense, if she was the recruiter/indy mastermind.

[/off topic]

I'll take a look at it, though some input from Epignosis would be helpful as well.

[DrWilgy]

/salt

Good game nonetheless!