Monkey Island [ENDGAME]

#1501

rip myself

#1502

Hopefully there's some cross-team baddie kill mojonation going on. RIP guys.

#1503

Sorry to see you go guys. You were the best of us!

#1504

im sorry for my lack of participation. I thought about asking for a sub but I told myself I would never sub out in a game unless it's absolutely necessary. I'm not quite at that point, but I'm also not where I want to be in the game

Catching up

#1505

Ok!! So we have one confirmed pirate, and one confirmed cannibal dead! I did not see that coming in ninja, but it doesn't surprise me I guess. There's some fun voting analysis to do!

Long Con wrote:
Scotty wrote:
Long Con wrote:
Scotty wrote:
Long Con wrote:No more spreading out votes. I agree with zebra's analysis of Soneji, and he is now one of my suspects.
Wait what? But you just voted zebra. Zebra, this is a true waffle if I ever saw it.
Not when there are two baddie teams.
Which baddie team are you on?
Is that supposed to be clever?

No, it was supposed to be direct

#1506

RIP motel and sig! Firmly believe sig was civ toward the end. I felt that way back when Mp was alive, and although I never put it to words, zebra put it pretty bluntly: when he looks scummy, he's probably civ. Of his own admission, that philosophy has been my read of him every game for a year now. I particularly felt like I agreed with him towards the end of day 4 and his posts during the night. I see he did a voting breakdown for nijuu which is what I would have done, so thanks for that.

DrWilgy wrote:#BROWAGON!!!

Lol you might go down as either the worst baddie partner to someone or the biggest supatown if you keep it up. I mean, if you keep getting results, then I'm fine with leaving you to your own devices, Wilgy "Blind Date" Nelson.

motel room wrote:Im here. Catching up at work and here soon too.

Womp womp.

#1507

Nachomamma8 wrote:
Scotty wrote:Ok folks's, I've got a lot to do in prep for thanksgiving (happy turkey day, US of A!) including prepping my first tofurkey (wtf). I'm sated for now with soneji's response to the "MP is civ" thing. I think I'd rather vote Boom today, so I'll go ahead and do that. Godspeed, brave adventurers!

boom
Why did you decide to vote for Boomslang here? I don't remember him being one of the targets that you liked to talk about the most, and I'd expect me pushing his lynch to dampen your enthusiasm a bit.

Boomslang was on my list from N1 missed kills. Sure he wasn't one I was talking about the most, but then I talk about candy corn all the time. Doesn't mean I'm gonna make a meal out of it.
Why would your pushing his lynch detract from or attract me to his lynch? I found him more suspicious than you.

Nachomamma8 wrote:
Scotty wrote:
MacDougall wrote:I would like to point out that I am not also Snow Dog.
i feel like zebras are far less quarrelsome in the savannah. Zebras wrestling with dogs and...whatever the hell Mac's avatar is...unheard of!

Also, GTH who would you vote for right now?

mac, what is your avatar?

I want to vote MM. Anyone want to join me?
I don't really understand your case on MM; him voting Black Rock for not doing anything while saying that he wasn't doing anything was the crux of your case against him, correct? Don't you think there was a considerable difference between MM's play and Black Rock's?

Not the crux, no. But I was already suspicious of Epi's random push for BR, and that MM jumped on it without even thinking, and without even mentioning it before made my hair bristle.

#1508

oh dead again, i see

#1509

Snow Dog wrote:
nijuukyugou wrote:
Nachomamma8 wrote:
DrWilgy wrote:Niju's post poll ending post fills me with confidence.
yeah I don't think *twiddles thumbs* comes from town who has just been lynched.
You judge harshly. I twiddle my thumbs in Monday-after-Thanksgiving deadness. Shall I scream in pain and agony instead for your amusement?
I'm putting my money on you being civ.

If I were your bank I would not grant you a loan.

Nachomamma8 wrote:i'm cool w/long con
if you vote soneji tomorrow i won't vote you

What does "cool" mean in this context?

Because LC's agreement with Soneji on zebra and his successive agreement with zebra on soneji is scummy as shit. I'm firmly in the belief that LC is bad.

#1510

Long Con wrote:
sig wrote:@Sonjie/LC Could you give me a rainbow list (or something like it) of your current reads?

Long Con
Nachomamma8
Dr. Wilgy
Vompatti
Scotty
Snow Dog
MacDougall
Metalmarsh89
Soneji
motel room 2.0
Sig
a2thezebra

Why is MM a moderate scumread for you?

#1511

Scotty wrote:
Snow Dog wrote:
nijuukyugou wrote:
Nachomamma8 wrote:
DrWilgy wrote:Niju's post poll ending post fills me with confidence.
yeah I don't think *twiddles thumbs* comes from town who has just been lynched.
You judge harshly. I twiddle my thumbs in Monday-after-Thanksgiving deadness. Shall I scream in pain and agony instead for your amusement?
I'm putting my money on you being civ.
If I were your bank I would not grant you a loan.

Nachomamma8 wrote:i'm cool w/long con
if you vote soneji tomorrow i won't vote you
What does "cool" mean in this context?

Because LC's agreement with Soneji on zebra and his successive agreement with zebra on soneji is scummy as shit. I'm firmly in the belief that LC is bad.

This is why I don't bet in rl :P

#1512

motel room wrote:oh dead again, i see

At least you got shot this time!

#1513

Soneji wrote:
Nachomamma8 wrote:
Soneji wrote:Seems they have gone more the route of letting the activity slow down to a crawl rather than try to take the lead now that most of the top level/most active players are dead. The players I was watching this phase were Long Con and Nacho. As I pointed out in my ISO of Long Con, he backed off of Wilgy due to Nacho's insistence that Wilgy's role PM antics weren't scum indicative. This was odd to me considering LC going after MP for supposed buddying but then allowing someone he has no reason to trust to sway his view on another player, rather than suspecting them of buddying/defending a scummate. That Nacho has fallen off the face of the earth in activity after d1 is a big red flag.

My vote will be on LC or Nacho today.
Why is me falling off in activity suspicious? Do you generally find it pretty common that people who have the ability to post a lot as mafia post a lot Day 1 and then are completely unable to post later in the game? Why would I struggle posting when I could scumhunt legitimately?
It is completely withib the realm of possibility to me that scum could be very active d1 where there is no info to go by and its easy to forgivably mislynch(which you did) then drop off activity later.

This could be due to any combination of a lack of ability to keep up the charade, not wanting to have to be town's leader to then potentially have to be accountable for mislynches, their scummates being suspects and not wanting to seem suspect themselves by putting attention elsewhere, not wanting to be night killed by the other scum team, etc.

Two mafia games make it easier for mafia to legitimately scumhunt but it still hampers their ability. They still have their own teammates to false read, still have to get some mislynches on townies to win.

You never explained why you found it suspicious. You said "hey it could be possible!" but you never said why it was the case. You don't see how a person's activity can tank when they don't have time?

#1514

Scotty wrote:
Nachomamma8 wrote:
Scotty wrote:Ok folks's, I've got a lot to do in prep for thanksgiving (happy turkey day, US of A!) including prepping my first tofurkey (wtf). I'm sated for now with soneji's response to the "MP is civ" thing. I think I'd rather vote Boom today, so I'll go ahead and do that. Godspeed, brave adventurers!

boom
Why did you decide to vote for Boomslang here? I don't remember him being one of the targets that you liked to talk about the most, and I'd expect me pushing his lynch to dampen your enthusiasm a bit.
Boomslang was on my list from N1 missed kills. Sure he wasn't one I was talking about the most, but then I talk about candy corn all the time. Doesn't mean I'm gonna make a meal out of it.
Why would your pushing his lynch detract from or attract me to his lynch? I found him more suspicious than you.

Nachomamma8 wrote:
Scotty wrote:
MacDougall wrote:I would like to point out that I am not also Snow Dog.
i feel like zebras are far less quarrelsome in the savannah. Zebras wrestling with dogs and...whatever the hell Mac's avatar is...unheard of!

Also, GTH who would you vote for right now?

mac, what is your avatar?

I want to vote MM. Anyone want to join me?
I don't really understand your case on MM; him voting Black Rock for not doing anything while saying that he wasn't doing anything was the crux of your case against him, correct? Don't you think there was a considerable difference between MM's play and Black Rock's?
Not the crux, no. But I was already suspicious of Epi's random push for BR, and that MM jumped on it without even thinking, and without even mentioning it before made my hair bristle.

Epignosis ought to be trusted more than he is.

#1515

Scotty wrote:
Nachomamma8 wrote:
Scotty wrote:Ok folks's, I've got a lot to do in prep for thanksgiving (happy turkey day, US of A!) including prepping my first tofurkey (wtf). I'm sated for now with soneji's response to the "MP is civ" thing. I think I'd rather vote Boom today, so I'll go ahead and do that. Godspeed, brave adventurers!

boom
Why did you decide to vote for Boomslang here? I don't remember him being one of the targets that you liked to talk about the most, and I'd expect me pushing his lynch to dampen your enthusiasm a bit.
Boomslang was on my list from N1 missed kills. Sure he wasn't one I was talking about the most, but then I talk about candy corn all the time. Doesn't mean I'm gonna make a meal out of it.
Why would your pushing his lynch detract from or attract me to his lynch? I found him more suspicious than you.

Nachomamma8 wrote:
Scotty wrote:
MacDougall wrote:I would like to point out that I am not also Snow Dog.
i feel like zebras are far less quarrelsome in the savannah. Zebras wrestling with dogs and...whatever the hell Mac's avatar is...unheard of!

Also, GTH who would you vote for right now?

mac, what is your avatar?

I want to vote MM. Anyone want to join me?
I don't really understand your case on MM; him voting Black Rock for not doing anything while saying that he wasn't doing anything was the crux of your case against him, correct? Don't you think there was a considerable difference between MM's play and Black Rock's?
Not the crux, no. But I was already suspicious of Epi's random push for BR, and that MM jumped on it without even thinking, and without even mentioning it before made my hair bristle.

Your continued discussion of candy corn made me think that candy corn was a top candy for you. I'd imagine voting with a top scum suspect is a bit weird unless you're assuming bussing, no? Or do you not care about your other reads when you're voting?

So MM making an impulsive vote on a pirate makes your hair bristle? Why?

#1516

Scotty wrote:
Snow Dog wrote:
nijuukyugou wrote:
Nachomamma8 wrote:
DrWilgy wrote:Niju's post poll ending post fills me with confidence.
yeah I don't think *twiddles thumbs* comes from town who has just been lynched.
You judge harshly. I twiddle my thumbs in Monday-after-Thanksgiving deadness. Shall I scream in pain and agony instead for your amusement?
I'm putting my money on you being civ.
If I were your bank I would not grant you a loan.

Nachomamma8 wrote:i'm cool w/long con
if you vote soneji tomorrow i won't vote you
What does "cool" mean in this context?

Because LC's agreement with Soneji on zebra and his successive agreement with zebra on soneji is scummy as shit. I'm firmly in the belief that LC is bad.

Cool means that I think that he's good.
I don't why the two quotes people pointed out look scummy; break it down for me, please?

#1517

I will hopefully be around in full tomorrow.
Hopefully. But I also got shit to do so I might just be flying by the seat of my pants and voting Sonejii because the case he's provided for having me as a top read is absolute nonsense.

But then again my current attitude seems to be most things are nonsense so I might just sheep someone who seems like they're on fire right now.

#1518

Unfortunately the people I trust right this second are a grand total of 1) Zebra and 2) Snow Dog and that needs some reading and rereading to turn into anything compelling or with a >random chance to be right. And again, hopefully reading time comes tomorrow.

#1519

Nachomamma8 wrote:Unfortunately the people I trust right this second are a grand total of 1) Zebra and 2) Snow Dog

does not compute

#1520

a2thezebra wrote:
Nachomamma8 wrote:Unfortunately the people I trust right this second are a grand total of 1) Zebra and 2) Snow Dog
does not compute

welcome to my life

#1521

you ever heard "the heart want it wants"?
it's like that. i want it not to be the case but it's the case and there's nothing I can do to change it without ignoring my heart and my soul and i simply cannot do that.

#1522

lol k

#1523

Nachomamma8 wrote:Unfortunately the people I trust right this second are a grand total of 1) Zebra and 2) Snow Dog and that needs some reading and rereading to turn into anything compelling or with a >random chance to be right. And again, hopefully reading time comes tomorrow.

iF this is the case I will desist from voting zebra. My last vote for her was hardly meaningful anyway. I just wanted her out of the game.
From now on live and let live for the good of the civ cause.

#1524

I'm continuing to vote Snow Dog for the good of the civ cause. I never vote people because I want them out of the game.

#1525

Nachomamma8 wrote:
Scotty wrote:
Nachomamma8 wrote:
Scotty wrote:Ok folks's, I've got a lot to do in prep for thanksgiving (happy turkey day, US of A!) including prepping my first tofurkey (wtf). I'm sated for now with soneji's response to the "MP is civ" thing. I think I'd rather vote Boom today, so I'll go ahead and do that. Godspeed, brave adventurers!

boom
Why did you decide to vote for Boomslang here? I don't remember him being one of the targets that you liked to talk about the most, and I'd expect me pushing his lynch to dampen your enthusiasm a bit.
Boomslang was on my list from N1 missed kills. Sure he wasn't one I was talking about the most, but then I talk about candy corn all the time. Doesn't mean I'm gonna make a meal out of it.
Why would your pushing his lynch detract from or attract me to his lynch? I found him more suspicious than you.

Nachomamma8 wrote:
Scotty wrote:
MacDougall wrote:I would like to point out that I am not also Snow Dog.
i feel like zebras are far less quarrelsome in the savannah. Zebras wrestling with dogs and...whatever the hell Mac's avatar is...unheard of!

Also, GTH who would you vote for right now?

mac, what is your avatar?

I want to vote MM. Anyone want to join me?
I don't really understand your case on MM; him voting Black Rock for not doing anything while saying that he wasn't doing anything was the crux of your case against him, correct? Don't you think there was a considerable difference between MM's play and Black Rock's?
Not the crux, no. But I was already suspicious of Epi's random push for BR, and that MM jumped on it without even thinking, and without even mentioning it before made my hair bristle.
Your continued discussion of candy corn made me think that candy corn was a top candy for you. I'd imagine voting with a top scum suspect is a bit weird unless you're assuming bussing, no? Or do you not care about your other reads when you're voting?

So MM making an impulsive vote on a pirate makes your hair bristle? Why?

My philosophy and assumption is this:
BR said "hey guys, I don't really have time for this"
Her teammate, Epi, goes, "I'll call you out and start a train for civ cred"
BR gives a blessing and Epi makes a weak case. Granted, there wasn't much to go on besides one baddie team not killing N1. He could have picked anyone, and he picked BR- who did not do anything to defend herself after the fact. That tells me she had given up.

What makes my hair bristle is that MM hadn't talked about BR at all, and have even jokingly listed who he would vote for (vomps or zebra) but decides, on day 2, to blindly put a trusty vote on Br without mentioning her before then.

Now, this could just be MM being MM, and this doesn't necessarily implicate him, but I found it odd with Epi, and I feel how the BR vote started was odd.
Now I say this knowing full well I also voted for her, but she was already on my shortlist at the time and had the most votes as such, so I don't feel like I'm hypocritical in pointing out the voting order here.

I'm saying I don't trust MM implicitly because I'm not willing to lie down and believe Epi was supatown like the rest of you seem to think.

#1526

Per the yellow:

Long Con wrote:I don't really understand why you would think I'm Mafia. Something's wrong with how you're reading me.

sig's whole post is just nonsense to me, as in it doesn't make sense.

"Okay I have no case to back this up what so ever and don't intend to make one tonight, but I'm about 65% sure LC is mafia now." I just don't see how giving a percentage works here, but whatever. "His play style was [neutral(?)] before," what does that mean, my play style was 'neutral' before? You mean your read of my alignment was unsure? Why not say that then? Or was it supposed to be 'natural'? "but I'm becoming increasingly more pinged by his play style and his attack on zebra seems to be what mafia LC used to do to me. " "seems to be what Mafia LC used to do to me" WTF are you serious with this? For starters, no. Again, you are attributing something to me that isn't something I've ever been accused of, and you have no references to back it up. You must be thinking of someone else.

It just plain doesn't make sense. And MM just comes in with "I agree!" When you just smile and agree with a suspicion that doesn't really stand up past being a mid-level gut feel, it just makes you look bad. But hey, cast your votes my way tomorrow, I've played enough Mafia to know that's the fastest way to convince some folks that I'm telling the truth.

Says this guy:

Long Con wrote:
I still don't trust Zebra's antics this game, like posting only in smilies, or being very antagonistic, and the early vote for Snow Dog pings me as well. So, in the interest of not missing my opportunity again, I'll vote zebra now.

*votes a2thezebra*

Then in the very next post:

Long Con wrote:No more spreading out votes. I agree with zebra's analysis of Soneji, and he is now one of my suspects.

#1527

Scotty wrote:Why is MM a moderate scumread for you?

Because he was a Civ read, but then his latest agreement with meaningless and fake accusations against me made me question that.

Scotty wrote:Per the yellow:
Long Con wrote:I don't really understand why you would think I'm Mafia. Something's wrong with how you're reading me.

sig's whole post is just nonsense to me, as in it doesn't make sense.

"Okay I have no case to back this up what so ever and don't intend to make one tonight, but I'm about 65% sure LC is mafia now." I just don't see how giving a percentage works here, but whatever. "His play style was [neutral(?)] before," what does that mean, my play style was 'neutral' before? You mean your read of my alignment was unsure? Why not say that then? Or was it supposed to be 'natural'? "but I'm becoming increasingly more pinged by his play style and his attack on zebra seems to be what mafia LC used to do to me. " "seems to be what Mafia LC used to do to me" WTF are you serious with this? For starters, no. Again, you are attributing something to me that isn't something I've ever been accused of, and you have no references to back it up. You must be thinking of someone else.

It just plain doesn't make sense. And MM just comes in with "I agree!" When you just smile and agree with a suspicion that doesn't really stand up past being a mid-level gut feel, it just makes you look bad. But hey, cast your votes my way tomorrow, I've played enough Mafia to know that's the fastest way to convince some folks that I'm telling the truth.
Says this guy:
Long Con wrote:
I still don't trust Zebra's antics this game, like posting only in smilies, or being very antagonistic, and the early vote for Snow Dog pings me as well. So, in the interest of not missing my opportunity again, I'll vote zebra now.

*votes a2thezebra*
Then in the very next post:
Long Con wrote:No more spreading out votes. I agree with zebra's analysis of Soneji, and he is now one of my suspects.

...and?

#1528

Why is Zebra full civ again? I missed the memo.

#1529

MacDougall wrote:Why is Zebra full civ again? I missed the memo.

Try harder.

#1530

a2thezebra wrote:I'm continuing to vote Snow Dog for the good of the civ cause. I never vote people because I want them out of the game.

I have never done it either. Until now.

#1531

i trust zebra k

#1532

Vompatti wrote:i trust zebra k

Yee

#1533

Vompatti wrote:i trust zebra k

No, not really. Zebra is bad.

#1534

Long Con wrote:
Vompatti wrote:i trust zebra k
No, not really. Zebra is bad.

So?

#1535

DrWilgy wrote:
Long Con wrote:
Vompatti wrote:i trust zebra k
No, not really. Zebra is bad.
So?

She will betray your trust and kill you.

#1536

Long Con wrote:
DrWilgy wrote:
Long Con wrote:
Vompatti wrote:i trust zebra k
No, not really. Zebra is bad.
So?
She will betray your trust and kill you.

You say that as if it was bad.

#1537

Long Con wrote:
Vompatti wrote:i trust zebra k
No, not really. Zebra is bad.

You seem convinced of that. I strongly suspect that she isn't. What makes you so sure other than her wacky playstyle this game?

#1538

Snow Dog wrote:
Long Con wrote:
Vompatti wrote:i trust zebra k
No, not really. Zebra is bad.
You seem convinced of that. I strongly suspect that she isn't. What makes you so sure other than her wacky playstyle this game?

Maybe I'm wrong... she has been somewhat more game-oriented as we get into the midgame than she was at the start. I looked back over her posts, and there's more content than I remember, I was sort of stuck in the emoticons/antagonistic schtick that she started out with, which I see as more indicative of her baddie game.

Maybe everyone else is right and I'm wrong. It certainly wouldn't be the first time.

#1539

Long Con wrote:
Snow Dog wrote:
Long Con wrote:
Vompatti wrote:i trust zebra k
No, not really. Zebra is bad.
You seem convinced of that. I strongly suspect that she isn't. What makes you so sure other than her wacky playstyle this game?
Maybe I'm wrong... she has been somewhat more game-oriented as we get into the midgame than she was at the start. I looked back over her posts, and there's more content than I remember, I was sort of stuck in the emoticons/antagonistic schtick that she started out with, which I see as more indicative of her baddie game.

Maybe everyone else is right and I'm wrong. It certainly wouldn't be the first time.

What about Vompatti then? I would describe him as not game-oriented in play style too.

#1540

I am completely agree with the above.

#1541

Snow Dog wrote:
Long Con wrote:
Snow Dog wrote:
Long Con wrote:
Vompatti wrote:i trust zebra k
No, not really. Zebra is bad.
You seem convinced of that. I strongly suspect that she isn't. What makes you so sure other than her wacky playstyle this game?
Maybe I'm wrong... she has been somewhat more game-oriented as we get into the midgame than she was at the start. I looked back over her posts, and there's more content than I remember, I was sort of stuck in the emoticons/antagonistic schtick that she started out with, which I see as more indicative of her baddie game.

Maybe everyone else is right and I'm wrong. It certainly wouldn't be the first time.
What about Vompatti then? I would describe him as not game-oriented in play style too.

But that's completely consistent with Vompatti's style every single time I have seen him play, so it doesn't even register any more.

#1542

Long Con wrote:
Snow Dog wrote:
Long Con wrote:
Snow Dog wrote:
Long Con wrote:
Vompatti wrote:i trust zebra k
No, not really. Zebra is bad.
You seem convinced of that. I strongly suspect that she isn't. What makes you so sure other than her wacky playstyle this game?
Maybe I'm wrong... she has been somewhat more game-oriented as we get into the midgame than she was at the start. I looked back over her posts, and there's more content than I remember, I was sort of stuck in the emoticons/antagonistic schtick that she started out with, which I see as more indicative of her baddie game.

Maybe everyone else is right and I'm wrong. It certainly wouldn't be the first time.
What about Vompatti then? I would describe him as not game-oriented in play style too.
But that's completely consistent with Vompatti's style every single time I have seen him play, so it doesn't even register any more.

Yes, this is true. Zebra is totally new to me so i don't know what to expect.

#1543

at2thezebra, who would you vote for if you hadn't voted for me?

#1544

Snow Dog wrote:at2thezebra, who would you vote for if you hadn't voted for me?

Either Soneji or Long Con, probably Soneji.

#1545

a2thezebra wrote:
Snow Dog wrote:at2thezebra, who would you vote for if you hadn't voted for me?
Either Soneji or Long Con, probably Soneji.

I agree with that on both counts.

#1546

Snow Dog wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:
Snow Dog wrote:at2thezebra, who would you vote for if you hadn't voted for me?
Either Soneji or Long Con, probably Soneji.
I agree with that on both counts.

And then Mac. He's always this antagonistic but he is NOT always this narrow-focused.

#1547

a2thezebra wrote:
Snow Dog wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:
Snow Dog wrote:at2thezebra, who would you vote for if you hadn't voted for me?
Either Soneji or Long Con, probably Soneji.
I agree with that on both counts.
And then Mac. He's always this antagonistic but he is NOT always this narrow-focused.

Noted.

#1548

Snow dog, go ahead and vote. If you vote the right person I'll not vote for you.

After reviewing Niju's posts, I have come to a conclusion.
...
...
...I'm not a cannibal.

Discuss.

#1549

DrWilgy wrote:Snow dog, go ahead and vote. If you vote the right person I'll not vote for you.

After reviewing Niju's posts, I have come to a conclusion.
...
...
...I'm not a cannibal.

Discuss.

There is still plenty of time.

#1550

a2thezebra wrote:
Snow Dog wrote:at2thezebra, who would you vote for if you hadn't voted for me?
Either Soneji or Long Con, probably Soneji.

Soneji is one of the most bad-seeming on my rainbow list. I'd be willing to go with a Soneji vote, and obviously I prefer this to a Long Con vote.

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

Wow we're really down to the wire now!