Monkey Island [ENDGAME]

[Tangrowth]

*rezzes MP*

I plan to include a role in Mafia: A World Asunder that has the ability to sacrifice its own life in order to resurrect another role... probably a successor to the Soul Elemental and the Essence Elemental from the first two games, respectively. I'll give that role some other abilities too.

Sounds pretty sweet.

[Marmot]

Scotty, I'm having a hard time seeing eye to eye with you on MM. The theory you have just seems rather implausible, for reasons you yourself stated. Epi could have gone after many people with his reasoning, why go after Black Rock, his supposed scummate? From what I have seen modkills don't really happen here so BR not having much time to play isn't very convincing for why they'd pull this, even if modkills were more common using the "inactives didn't send in their kill" logic to lynch anyone outside their faction would have been the more optimal move. All the BR lynch accomplished for them in that case is getting Epi offed.

MM, to my remembrance, seemed fine with the BR lynch based on personal experience of being part of a mafia team that failed to send in their NK.

I did mention something like that. I said a team of 5 with some players who are often fairly active (including myself) managed to miss a nightkill, so really anyone can.

But Epignosis called BR out specifically, so I followed suit.

This a scumslip

Hardly. People (Soneji) were giving me more credit than I deserved.

[Snow Dog]

Oy! Stay in the grave you!

[Marmot]

Why is MM a moderate scumread for you?

Because he was a Civ read, but then his latest agreement with meaningless and fake accusations against me made me question that.

I don't see either of those accusations being fake.

Sig made a gutread that you are bad, and was subsequently nightkilled. That doesn't make him civ, but the odds are in his favor.

Actually, you bringing it up makes it a lot more likely that you are bad. You killed sig in the hopes that everyone would come to the conclusion that I did it because he suspected me. Since that didn't happen, you, slightly frustrated, just tried to push that agenda. We've all seen it before, and here it is happening.

Scotty made a reasonable point.

I don't recall that happening, which point was that? I recall his last point against me having no real point to it at all, and when I asked him to clarify, he didn't - or couldn't - give any reply at all.

I wasn't connecting sig's death to your alignment. I said that sig was killed right after he said a thing, and so since he was nightkilled, there's a decent chance he's a civilian, and that what he says is sincere.

I pointed out that your statement is inaccurate. Rather than prove otherwise, you're attempting to flip this around on me. Do you still think that Scotty and sig made fake and meaningless accusations?

[Scotty]

*rezzes MP*

I plan to include a role in Mafia: A World Asunder that has the ability to sacrifice its own life in order to resurrect another role... probably a successor to the Soul Elemental and the Essence Elemental from the first two games, respectively. I'll give that role some other abilities too.

Just as long as players don't get...hungry. That would just be the worst

[Marmot]

Long Con, what do you think of Scotty?

I'm always hungry.

[Scotty]

Long Con, what do you think of Scotty?

I'm always hungry.

Oh no you don't. You still haven't answered my questions concerning Soneji and voting intentions i posed to you last night, which you conveniently skipped:

Scotty, I'm having a hard time seeing eye to eye with you on MM. The theory you have just seems rather implausible, for reasons you yourself stated. Epi could have gone after many people with his reasoning, why go after Black Rock, his supposed scummate? From what I have seen modkills don't really happen here so BR not having much time to play isn't very convincing for why they'd pull this, even if modkills were more common using the "inactives didn't send in their kill" logic to lynch anyone outside their faction would have been the more optimal move. All the BR lynch accomplished for them in that case is getting Epi offed.

MM, to my remembrance, seemed fine with the BR lynch based on personal experience of being part of a mafia team that failed to send in their NK.

I did mention something like that. I said a team of 5 with some players who are often fairly active (including myself) managed to miss a nightkill, so really anyone can.

But Epignosis called BR out specifically, so I followed suit.

Hey @MM!

-What do you currently think of Soneji? I just went looking through your post history and the most you have mentioned him is to basically say "I am uninterested in lynching him" and "I'm not convinced he is bad".

-Are you currently looking to vote for LC today?

[Marmot]

Long Con, what do you think of Scotty?

I'm always hungry.

Oh no you don't. You still haven't answered my questions concerning Soneji and voting intentions i posed to you last night, which you conveniently skipped:

Scotty, I'm having a hard time seeing eye to eye with you on MM. The theory you have just seems rather implausible, for reasons you yourself stated. Epi could have gone after many people with his reasoning, why go after Black Rock, his supposed scummate? From what I have seen modkills don't really happen here so BR not having much time to play isn't very convincing for why they'd pull this, even if modkills were more common using the "inactives didn't send in their kill" logic to lynch anyone outside their faction would have been the more optimal move. All the BR lynch accomplished for them in that case is getting Epi offed.

MM, to my remembrance, seemed fine with the BR lynch based on personal experience of being part of a mafia team that failed to send in their NK.

I did mention something like that. I said a team of 5 with some players who are often fairly active (including myself) managed to miss a nightkill, so really anyone can.

But Epignosis called BR out specifically, so I followed suit.

Hey @MM!

-What do you currently think of Soneji? I just went looking through your post history and the most you have mentioned him is to basically say "I am uninterested in lynching him" and "I'm not convinced he is bad".

-Are you currently looking to vote for LC today?

I kinda skimmed some posts, but sure I'll address this.

I made a comment about Soneji (in response to motel room) a couple days ago about his post calling MP civ. Soneji offered a reasonable explanation for it.

Other than that, I don't see anything incriminating against him. What about you?

[Marmot]

I want to lynch Long Con, and our only chance today is if DrWilgy joins me in forcing a tie (and someone has a wonderful item to use).

But I don't like ties either. This lynch is the worst.

[Long Con]

@LC no, I made multiple points. Your response was more or less "so?"

LC

No, you highlighted some text, and then laid a couple of quotes from me down, and then did a smiley. I said "...and?", prompting you to make a point somewhere, and you did not.

The point is that it was hypocritical...

What is hypocritical about it?

If the point is that I cast a vote on a third player when two already had a vote, and then told everyone else not to spread it out more... if you call that hypocritical, I guess I can't argue, although I don't think that's such a grievous sin. I was still playing a bit after I voted, and I realized that spreading out the votes is a good way to make it easy for the baddies to control the lynch. Maybe if it had occurred to me before I voted, then I would have stuck with one of the top two contenders instead. This point I would understand, but I don't think that's the point you're making... when you clarify as little as possible, these unsureties tend to crop up.

If the point is that I said I think zebra is bad, and voted her, and then agreed with her on Soneji... that is not hypocritical at all. There are two baddie teams, and they want to kill each other. Even more than that, they really want to hunt down and lynch each other! It looks really good when you spearhead the lynch of a baddie. Baddies want to look good.

When I agreed with zebra's analysis of Soneji, it didn't mean that I suddenly trusted that zebra was Civ, it meant that I looked at the points zebra brought up and analyzed them myself, and found that I agreed they were suspicious.

I'm still nowhere near sure if that's the point you were making, because of the yellow text: "When you just smile and agree with a suspicion that doesn't really stand up past being a mid-level gut feel, it just makes you look bad.". Here's a link to your post for those playing along at home.

The yellow text doesn't connect to anything else you said, I don't know why you would try to act like it does. Are you trying to say that, when I agreed with zebra's analysis of Soneji, I was agreeing with a suspicion that's, at most, a mid-level gut feel? If that's the point, then you're just plain wrong and it's not hard to correct you. Zebra pointed out two specifically contradictory passages in Soneji's recent posts, and thought that was a suspicious thing to do. Zebra's accusation was in no way a gut feel of any level, it was a direct analysis of Soneji's posts.

...and by your own admission suspicious.

I looked through my posts and found no point where I had an admission of suspiciousness. The closest thing I can find is when I agreed that I said an odd thing. Odd doesn't mean suspicious, and if you care to check out the context a little deeper, you'll see that I am not in any way trying to imply that it was suspicious.

That, layered with your flip flopping point I made a few days ago, is suspicious as shit to me.

I think you mean this... "layered with" is an interesting choice of words. I prefer "referring to the same quote in order to say the same faulty thing in a different way", but to each his own. I covered this earlier this post, and to point you right to it, I pinked up "If the point is" at the beginning of the paragraph.

[Marmot]

Despite Scotty's interjection, you can still answer my question Long Con.

In fact, I implore you do.

[Long Con]

Oh, don't worry MM... I already was. I just use more words in order to be sure I communicate with crystal clarity. Something of a lost art to some.

Why is MM a moderate scumread for you?

Because he was a Civ read, but then his latest agreement with meaningless and fake accusations against me made me question that.

I don't see either of those accusations being fake.

Sig made a gutread that you are bad, and was subsequently nightkilled. That doesn't make him civ, but the odds are in his favor.

Actually, you bringing it up makes it a lot more likely that you are bad. You killed sig in the hopes that everyone would come to the conclusion that I did it because he suspected me. Since that didn't happen, you, slightly frustrated, just tried to push that agenda. We've all seen it before, and here it is happening.

Scotty made a reasonable point.

I don't recall that happening, which point was that? I recall his last point against me having no real point to it at all, and when I asked him to clarify, he didn't - or couldn't - give any reply at all.

I wasn't connecting sig's death to your alignment. I said that sig was killed right after he said a thing, and so since he was nightkilled, there's a decent chance he's a civilian, and that what he says is sincere.

My mistake then, I thought you were connecting sig's death to my alignment. I see now your point was that "sig was killed right after he said a thing" (which is fucking odd to say but I'll be the only one to notice that), and that you think that increases the chances of his sincerity. Getting nightkilled, whether one "said a thing" or not, generally increases the likelihood that one is Civ. IF sig was Civ, then his statements still bear the inherent and vital weaknesses that I pointed out, and that just makes him forgetful, presumptive, just plain wrong, or a number of other things that aren't baddie in nature.

YOUR agreement with statements that carry those glaring flaws is what reflects badly on you.

I pointed out that your statement is inaccurate. Rather than prove otherwise, you're attempting to flip this around on me. Do you still think that Scotty and sig made fake and meaningless accusations?

I already discussed those statements: sig here (and further here), and Scotty's accusation I just posted about in adequate detail. To answer your question: yes.

[DrWilgy]

I want to lynch Long Con, and our only chance today is if DrWilgy joins me in forcing a tie (and someone has a wonderful item to use).

But I don't like ties either. This lynch is the worst.

I would like to join you but I don't trust Scotty ;__;

Do I vote Snow Dog, Ji-San or Scotty?

[Snow Dog]

I want to lynch Long Con, and our only chance today is if DrWilgy joins me in forcing a tie (and someone has a wonderful item to use).

But I don't like ties either. This lynch is the worst.

I would like to join you but I don't trust Scotty ;__;

Do I vote Snow Dog, Ji-San or Scotty?

Who is Ji-San?

[Snow Dog]

I think I can guess it is Soneji

[Soneji]

I want to lynch Long Con, and our only chance today is if DrWilgy joins me in forcing a tie (and someone has a wonderful item to use).

But I don't like ties either. This lynch is the worst.

I would like to join you but I don't trust Scotty ;__;

Do I vote Snow Dog, Ji-San or Scotty?

It doesn't matter much. If you're not voting Long Con then the lynch is set in stone on myself.

[Long Con]

I want to lynch Long Con, and our only chance today is if DrWilgy joins me in forcing a tie (and someone has a wonderful item to use).

But I don't like ties either. This lynch is the worst.

I would like to join you but I don't trust Scotty ;__;

Do I vote Snow Dog, Ji-San or Scotty?

It doesn't matter much. If you're not voting Long Con then the lynch is set in stone on myself.

Not so set in stone. Maybe someone will use bananas and/or grog and make me get lynched.

I would totally get revenge on that person.

[Soneji]

Well I'm feeling groggy and can go eat a banana. Maybe it will bring good luck.

[Marmot]

Long Con, have my vote!

[Long Con]

Long Con, have my vote!

[thellama73]

Night 5

It's time for the final trial, the treasure hunt. Below, you'll find a treasure map, only it seems the pirates have forgotten to indicate where the actual treasure is. A minor oversight, but a nettlesome one, as now you'll have to search manually.



You start in the center and can move three spaces horizontally or vertically. For example, you could move: Left-Left-Left-Left or North-East-South-North etc.
Please post your movement in the thread, and the person who lands on, or comes closest to the square with the treasure will win it. If two players are equally close, the player who posted their move first will win it.

Soneji has been lynched. He was Men of Low Moral Fibre.
You have 24 hours to submit your night actions.

[thellama73]

Day 5

Who needs a good splashing with some undead-destroying root beer?

Poll ended at Thu Dec 01, 2016 4:06:28 pm


a2thezebra
0
No votes
Dr. Wilgy
1
MacDougall (13) 6%
Long Con
3
Soneji (11), Scotty (16), Metalmarsh89 (17) 18%
MacDougall
0
No votes
Metalmarsh89
0
No votes
Nachomamma8
0
No votes
Scotty
0
No votes
Snow Dog
1
a2thezebra (3) 6%
Soneji
4
Nachomamma8 (10), Long Con (12), Vompatti (14), Snow Dog (15) 24%
Vompatti
0
No votes
A rubber chicken with a pully in the middle (Host/Mod/Dead/Np)
8
thellama73 (1), MovingPictures07 (2), sig (4), Golden (5), motel room (6), Quin (7), juliets (8), Glorfindel (9) 47%
Total votes : 17

[Marmot]

Nice job you guys!

Not the most ideal, but still good.

[Long Con]

Nice!

I will move east-south, and plop myself down there.

[Scotty]

Well there ya go! Good goin, Soneji voters!

My vote doesn't look great in retrospect unless LC is bad.

I think MM is definitely a pirate based on that flip. His reluctance to acknowledge the case on Soneji seems really wishy washy.

Nice job you guys!

Not the most ideal, but still good.

What would be more ideal than lynching a baddie, hmm?

[Scotty]

I feel like this treasure map is hard wired for the pirates.

Pirate Leaders - In the know about all things piratical on Melee Island.

These guys, if still alive, would fit the bill for knowing exactly where the treasure is buried. And even if that player is dead, I'm assuming dead baddies can still tell the living pirates where it is.

@HOST! I apologize if this has been answered already, but are baddies still able to talk to their partners in BTSC after they die?

LC, do you know where the treasure is buried? You were very quick to scavenge.

[thellama73]

@HOST! I apologize if this has been answered already, but are baddies still able to talk to their partners in BTSC after they die?

yes, that is always allowed.

[Scotty]

I want to lynch Long Con, and our only chance today is if DrWilgy joins me in forcing a tie (and someone has a wonderful item to use).

But I don't like ties either. This lynch is the worst.

I would like to join you but I don't trust Scotty ;__;

Do I vote Snow Dog, Ji-San or Scotty?

Well gee, Wilgy. Why is that?

[Marmot]

Well there ya go! Good goin, Soneji voters!

My vote doesn't look great in retrospect unless LC is bad.

I think MM is definitely a pirate based on that flip. His reluctance to acknowledge the case on Soneji seems really wishy washy.

Nice job you guys!

Not the most ideal, but still good.

What would be more ideal than lynching a baddie, hmm?

Civilians: Kill LeChuck, Bob, and the Cannibals.

It's not part of the quest, ye scallywag.

[Marmot]

I'll take North-North-East for $400.

[Long Con]

LC, do you know where the treasure is buried? You were very quick to scavenge.

I felt like a middlish location would be better than an edge.

[Long Con]

Well there ya go! Good goin, Soneji voters!

My vote doesn't look great in retrospect unless LC is bad.

I think MM is definitely a pirate based on that flip. His reluctance to acknowledge the case on Soneji seems really wishy washy.

Nice job you guys!

Not the most ideal, but still good.

What would be more ideal than lynching a baddie, hmm?

Civilians: Kill LeChuck, Bob, and the Cannibals.

It's not part of the quest, ye scallywag.

I believe that was corrected, old chum. And discussed and referenced since that correction.

[Marmot]

Well there ya go! Good goin, Soneji voters!

My vote doesn't look great in retrospect unless LC is bad.

I think MM is definitely a pirate based on that flip. His reluctance to acknowledge the case on Soneji seems really wishy washy.

Nice job you guys!

Not the most ideal, but still good.

What would be more ideal than lynching a baddie, hmm?

Civilians: Kill LeChuck, Bob, and the Cannibals.

It's not part of the quest, ye scallywag.

I believe that was corrected, old chum. And discussed and referenced since that correction.

I'd love to see where this happened because I honestly had no idea.

[Scotty]

Well there ya go! Good goin, Soneji voters!

My vote doesn't look great in retrospect unless LC is bad.

I think MM is definitely a pirate based on that flip. His reluctance to acknowledge the case on Soneji seems really wishy washy.

Nice job you guys!

Not the most ideal, but still good.

What would be more ideal than lynching a baddie, hmm?

Civilians: Kill LeChuck, Bob, and the Cannibals.

It's not part of the quest, ye scallywag.

Nay, quarrelsome ferret. This was clarified via host on day 1:

Llama:

The role post says the civvies only need Lechuck, Bob, and the Cannibals dead to win. Does that mean the game will end if the other two baddies are still alive?

Also, the civvies need the cannibals dead, but the cannibals can win even if Herman Toothrot and Head of the Navigator are alive. Does this mean that the game will end if any cannibals are alive and only Herman and Head are remaining for the civvies?

I think that's a remnant from an earlier draft of the game. The civvies need the pirates and cannibals dead to win. If only Herman, the Head, and the Cannibals are left alive, the game will end and the cannibals will win.

We need all the pirates dead.

That just makes sense anyway. Why wouldn't we want to strip the pirates from their kill power (I'm assuming this is passed down to the remaining pirates when lechck dies)

[Marmot]

That just makes sense anyway. Why wouldn't we want to strip the pirates from their kill power (I'm assuming this is passed down to the remaining pirates when lechck dies)

You're right, it does. I've just been following what the OP says.

That's an assumption that might not necessarily be the best one. But you do you Scotty-peg-shoe.

[Scotty]

LC, do you know where the treasure is buried? You were very quick to scavenge.

I felt like a middlish location would be better than an edge.

Yeah, that makes sense I guess.

Ok I'm gonna Price is Right this shit and go North-North. On my way, I'm gonna hug Drew.

Linki: peg shoe huh? You callin me a pirate, matey?

[Scotty]

LC, I no longer think you are a pirate, based on you and Soneji's voting today. Congratulations!

That doesn't mean I'm ruling you out from being a cannibal however.

[Scotty]

That just makes sense anyway. Why wouldn't we want to strip the pirates from their kill power (I'm assuming this is passed down to the remaining pirates when lechck dies)

You're right, it does. I've just been following what the OP says.

That's an assumption that might not necessarily be the best one. But you do you Scotty-peg-shoe.

K.

@HOST! If Lechuck dies, does that mean that the power to kill is lost with him, or does it get passed down to the the remaining pirates (or in this case, the Pirate Leaders)?

[Nachomamma8]

YEAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

[DrWilgy]

I want to lynch Long Con, and our only chance today is if DrWilgy joins me in forcing a tie (and someone has a wonderful item to use).

But I don't like ties either. This lynch is the worst.

I would like to join you but I don't trust Scotty ;__;

Do I vote Snow Dog, Ji-San or Scotty?

Well gee, Wilgy. Why is that?

Because you keep changing your mind about me.

Triggering my first girlfriend induced ptsd.

[Scotty]

I want to lynch Long Con, and our only chance today is if DrWilgy joins me in forcing a tie (and someone has a wonderful item to use).

But I don't like ties either. This lynch is the worst.

I would like to join you but I don't trust Scotty ;__;

Do I vote Snow Dog, Ji-San or Scotty?

Well gee, Wilgy. Why is that?

Because you keep changing your mind about me.

Triggering my first girlfriend induced ptsd.

When have I changed my mind? I've been thinking you could be a liability down the road for a while now, and don't feel likenlynching you yet. There's no new info with you.

[Marmot]

Also, boosh and/or kakow.

[Nachomamma8]

Can we move three spaces or four?

[Long Con]

I'm feeling slightly better about a2thezebra now... she was pushing Sloonei for the Lynch.

[Tangrowth]

I'm feeling slightly better about a2thezebra now... she was pushing Sloonei for the Lynch.

SLOONEJI STRIKES AGAIN!!!!

[Marmot]

Who's Sloonei? Is he a pirate character?

[Snow Dog]

Dr Wilgy decided not to vote at all.

[Tangrowth]

Who's Sloonei? Is he a pirate character?

[Long Con]

I'm feeling slightly better about a2thezebra now... she was pushing Sloonei for the Lynch.

SLOONEJI STRIKES AGAIN!!!!

Shit. Sorry Ji-san.

[DrWilgy]

Dr Wilgy decided not to vote at all.

I totes missed it. I have no regrets tho.