Monkey Island [ENDGAME]

[MacDougall]

I meant to vote for Soneji but my finger slipped.

[thellama73]

Attention: I just saw that there is an error in the host post. you have four moves, not three. Apologies for the confusion. Everyone may resubmit their moves if they want.

[Vompatti]

South-South-South-South k

[a2thezebra]

BIH Soneji.

South-south-west.

[a2thezebra]

My activity will be slow because I'm making new friends

[Vompatti]

That sounds like a bad idea.

[DrWilgy]

Right-Up

[Snow Dog]

S-S-S-W

[Snow Dog]

My activity will be slow because I'm making new friends

Will you be voting for me again?

[DrWilgy]

Die wanna wagna

[Snow Dog]

Die wanna wagna

Sprechen Sie Deutsch?

[thellama73]

@HOST! If Lechuck dies, does that mean that the power to kill is lost with him, or does it get passed down to the the remaining pirates (or in this case, the Pirate Leaders)?

Good question, but one that will remain unanswered for now.

[Snow Dog]

@HOST! If Lechuck dies, does that mean that the power to kill is lost with him, or does it get passed down to the the remaining pirates (or in this case, the Pirate Leaders)?

Good question, but one that will remain unanswered for now.

Why?

[thellama73]

@HOST! If Lechuck dies, does that mean that the power to kill is lost with him, or does it get passed down to the the remaining pirates (or in this case, the Pirate Leaders)?

Good question, but one that will remain unanswered for now.

Why?

Because I like keeping you guys guessing. It amuses me.

[a2thezebra]

My activity will be slow because I'm making new friends

Will you be voting for me again?

I'm not sure yet.

[a2thezebra]

Die wanna wagna

never forget

[Scotty]

Looking through the back logs of voting records, I'm gonna do some poor man's reads of who I think looks the most compatible with which team, to organize as we get closer to possibly quenching baddie teams since 3 have flipped already.

Assuming one team hasn't been eliminated yet, and assuming we won't know about it via llama. Or will we? I dunno. Guess we'll see more by the end of tonight.

going in order:

A2thezebra--
has consistently been taking votes for multiple days by nijuu, a confirmed cannibal. Would her teammate do that so often when zebra has actually had a chance of being lynched? Doubtful. I think this is pretty enlightening and I even though zebra never voted for her, I dont feel like it's a strong comparability for Cannibalism. As for a pirate comparability..she's never voted for BR or Soneji. Curiously, Soneji did vote for her on Day 3 in a pivotal tie with Boomslang. If it wasn't for MM and Nacho, she could have been lynched. So that's a +1 in her favor.

She has been attached to Snow Dog for the better part of 5 days and this makes it very hard to gain any analysis from that other than she's been conveniently unaccountable for the baddie lynches. If it wasn't for nijuu voting her consistently in tighter lynch polls, I would say shes very compatible for cannibal alignment.

This is all without knowledge of Snow Dog's alignment. She could either be completely onto a bad Snow Dog or she is pulling a baddie Quin from Mad Max and knowingly going after one innocent all game. She was partners with Quin that game as she pointed out, so that strategy is pretty fresh. But who knows. I don't see strong compatibility for either team, and even less so for cannibal.


DrWilgy--
Wilgy is a giant WIFOM pretzel with extra salt because taking his votes as face value is assuming he hasn't looked at his role card and is attempting to solve the game for better or worse. So it's hard to gauge his alignment, but on paper? His voting is good. Like, he looks civ.

He was voted for by both confirmed baddie teams [nijuu and Soneji] on Day 1 (he missed the vote). This coulddd be explained away since he was talking about not looking at his role card then, which a teammate may vote for him out of spite I guess.

He crucially tied up the vote for nijuu's lynch on day 4. Would a teammate do that? I don't think so. Not knowingly anyway.

Day 2 he puts down the last vote of the day, an insurance vote on BR. Prime bussing opportunity since it was right before EoD and she was looking to get lynched anyway.

That's it. He missed the vote on the Day 5 Soneji lynch, so that's inconclusive.

I think he is a moderate comparability for Pirates, not so much for cannibal. And that's assuming he even knows what role he is..


Long Con---
His votes have been far less entangled in flipped baddies, until this Soneji lynch yesterday.

But on day 4 he planted the first vote on Zebra after nijuu received one. He has had no interaction with nijuu in the polls otherwise.

Day 5 had Soneji voting for him first, and LC following suit to vote second. It would be pretty ballsy to do so to a teammate, so I don't want to say he's that compatible as a pirate.


Macdougall--
looking through the polls i was surprised to find Mac has only voted 2/5 days. How has he gotten away with that?! Regardless of team compatibility, this is sketch as shit.

He has had no voting interactions with anyone confirmed and so has no accountability for most the game. He's totally compatible for both teams and I think he should probably start producing some content.



MM--
As I've discussed before, he voted 2nd for BR before the train really formed on her, and on paper it looks good for him. I'm gonna try and be objective about this, because without context, that alone looks great for him not being a pirate.

On day 4, he was the first to drunkenly vote for nijuu, following Epi's wishes. This also looks great on paper as a non-teammate move. I firmly don't think he would have done this as a cannibal.

Day 5 he makes a push for LC at the end of the day but falls short of saving Soneji.
That isn't to say he attempted to save Soneji, but it could look that way.

I'd say he gets +1 on paper for his BR vote, -1 on paper for his Day 5 vote. He is somewhere in the middle of compatibility for being a pirate, and I don't think he is a cannibal.


Nachomamma8--
Nacho has missed I think 2 lynch votes- both were on days in which nijuu and BR were lynched. When Soneji voted for him on day 4, 3 other people had one vote apiece, so it was fairly spread out. I'm not sure what to make of that besides a slightly good look for him to not be a pirate. But only slightly.

Day 5 looks good for him when he dropped the first vote on Soneji. This is a really good look for him not being a pirate.

Otherwise he didn't have voting interactions with nijuu.

I'd say he doesn't look compatible as a pirate, could be a cannibal


Scotty--
Hi. Yeah I'm gonna do myself I guess.

I put an insurance vote on BR on day 2. This was by no means set in stone, since Snow Dog followed with a vote for zebra to bring it closer. Only slight plus for me. Unfortunately missed the vote on nijuu's lynch, so that's inconclusive.
Tied the vote on day 5 for LC vs Soneji, but we don't know LC's alignment for sure to accurately gauge what kind of decision that was.
Otherwise I don't really have any voting interactions with either side, so I suppose i look pretty compatible with both sides, though slightly less so as a pirate.

Welp my voting record looks piss poor. Can't change it tho.


Snow Dog--
Zebra has been all over this dog. Doesnt mean anything about alignment for either side yet unfortunately.
Day 2 he places the 3rd vote on zebra after 4 were already on BR. Doesn't really mean anything, but it's there.

He places the 3rd vote on zebra when nijuu had 2, on day 4. This is not a great look, and could be seen as a save attempt for nijuu.

On day 5 he places the 4th vote on Soneji when there were only 3 votes left to cast before EoD. This could be bussing a teammate that was already a foregone conclusion.

That's all the voting interactions. Neither are sure things and both raise questions. I'd say he is compatible with either team, and maybe less so with pirates with his extrainsurance vote for Soneji.


Vompatti--
For all the out-of-this-dimension talk vomps does, his record looks good on paper.

He votes elsewhere during the BR lynch (MP) which says nothing, but attempts to start something on Soneji day 3. That train almost took off. Good look for not being a pirate.

On day 4, he ties the vote for nijuu vs zebra, which makes it 2v2. Good look for non-cannibal compatibility.

On day 5, he makes the 3rd vote on soneji, the first insurance vote of the day. This looks really good for vomps.

I would say on paper, vomps is a superstar, and I would invite him over for dinner to meet the parents. I don't think he is bad, but if he were, it would be probably a cannibal. He is the last person I would lynch.



Well that was a fun exercise. I didn't exactly take into account accusations in thread, and was mostly looking at which horse people bet on, and not which horse people talked up. I was most surprised of how shit my voting has been, and even though I know I'm good, I can't run from my record. From my analysis, here is my ranking for both team compatibility from most likely bad to least likely:

Pirates:
Mac
Wilgy
MM
Snow Dog
Nachomamma
LC
Zebra
Vomps


Cannibals:
Mac
LC
Snow Dog
Nachomamma
Wilgy
MM
Zebra
Vomps

[Marmot]

I gather that you're voting for MacDougall tomorrow?

[Scotty]

I gather that you're voting for MacDougall tomorrow?

It makes sense on paper for compatibility but that doesn't mean that I think he is bad. He is just floating in a limbo where he hasn't been involved in the midst of any baddies.

I still really want to lynch you.

[a2thezebra]

I gather that you're voting for MacDougall tomorrow?

It makes sense on paper for compatibility but that doesn't mean that I think he is bad. He is just floating in a limbo where he hasn't been involved in the midst of any baddies.

I still really want to lynch you.

I kinda want to lynch you for wanting to lynch him. I think you and Snow Dog are teammates.

[a2thezebra]

I'll vote for one of Scotty or Snow Dog, whoever has a better chance of getting lynched tomorrow. I won't vote MacDougall, I don't think he would risk missing that many votes and contributing this little in general as a baddie. He's not a risk-taker.

[Marmot]

I'll vote for one of Scotty or Snow Dog, whoever has a better chance of getting lynched tomorrow. I won't vote MacDougall, I don't think he would risk missing that many votes and contributing this little in general as a baddie. He's not a risk-taker.

Except in Romance of the Three Kingdoms, where he missed the vote on Days 8, 9, 10, 11, and averaged less than 10 posts per day phase throughout the game.

Just, ya'know, throwing that out there.

[thellama73]

Day 6

Congratulations, the Three Trials are complete. You're a real pirate now, and ready to sail off to Monkey Island to confront LeChuck. If you can get there without being murdered that is.

Metalmarsh won't get there without being murdered, because he was murdered.

Incidentally, the treasure was West-West-South-South.

Metalmarsh89 has been killed. He was the Shopkeeper. He died clutching his shovel.
You have 48 hours to lynch a baddie., although it will probably be longer than 48 hours since I'm flying to Vermont on Sunday.

[Marmot]

Well goddam.

[thellama73]

Why did I just tell you MM's role? I wasn't supposed to do that. Oh well, it doesn't matter.

[Marmot]

Day 6

Congratulations, the Three Trials are complete. You're a real pirate now, and ready to sail off to Monkey Island to confront LeChuck. If you can get there without being murdered that is.

Metalmarsh won't get there without being murdered, because he was murdered.

Incidentally, the treasure was West-West-South-South.

Metalmarsh89 has been killed. He was the Shopkeeper. He died clutching his shovel.
You have 48 hours to lynch a baddie., although it will probably be longer than 48 hours since I'm flying to Vermont on Sunday.

Oh no! I'm dead.

[Nachomamma8]

I thought deadline was in an hour :'(

[Nachomamma8]

I miss MM already. Let's lynch a bad guy again.

[Marmot]

I miss MM already. Let's lynch a bad guy again.

Our reunion was short and sweet Nacho!

Hope to see you again in a future game.

[a2thezebra]

I thought deadline was in an hour :'(

What deadline?

[Vompatti]

So the baddies are LC and Mac right?

[Snow Dog]

So the baddies are LC and Mac right?

I think LC may be one.

[Snow Dog]

I trusted MM more or less. More,more than less more or more less. What? Aaanyway. Thanks too Llama's slip up we know. One kill tonight, good news. I presume someone got blocked or protected.

I propose a Long Con Lynch. Anyone game?

[DrWilgy]

Marmot Friend...

I'll always remember you. I'll keep you close in my heart as always.

Snow Dog, why should I lynch Scotty instead of you?

Scotty, why should I lynch Snow Dog instead of you?

Snow Dog. I currently oppose a LC lynch. While it may be needed in the future, now is not the time.

[Snow Dog]

BTW, sorry to see you go MM. It was good to play with you again.

[Snow Dog]

Marmot Friend...

I'll always remember you. I'll keep you close in my heart as always.

Snow Dog, why should I lynch Scotty instead of you?

Scotty, why should I lynch Snow Dog instead of you?

Snow Dog. I currently oppose a LC lynch. While it may be needed in the future, now is not the time.

Don'y lynch Scotty or me. I feel he is civ and I know I am.

Why is now not the time?

[a2thezebra]

Marmot Friend...

I'll always remember you. I'll keep you close in my heart as always.

Snow Dog, why should I lynch Scotty instead of you?

Scotty, why should I lynch Snow Dog instead of you?

Snow Dog. I currently oppose a LC lynch. While it may be needed in the future, now is not the time.

Don'y lynch Scotty or me. I feel he is civ and I know I am.

Why is now not the time?

Don't try to fight this. It's you or him, there are no other options.

[a2thezebra]

It is in your best interest to co-operate.

[Snow Dog]

It is in your best interest to co-operate.

[Vompatti]

I wouldn't mind voting for LC.

[DrWilgy]

It is in your best interest to co-operate.

It really is. Now Snow Dog, play devils advocate and throw dirt on Scotty if you have to. I will vote for one of you two as I'm 80% sure that lynching LC will not end a baddie faction.

[Long Con]

Please do not lynch me. There is not even a single good case against me, why the hell are you putting my name out there like I'm a baddie? I can't talk much now because I'm currently driving, and I'm working until another 5 hours are up. Take off your blinders and stop tunnelling me, I'm a Civ goddammit!

[Snow Dog]

It is in your best interest to co-operate.

It really is. Now Snow Dog, play devils advocate and throw dirt on Scotty if you have to. I will vote for one of you two as I'm 80% sure that lynching LC will not end a baddie faction.

I am not voting Scotty without good reason at this stage of the game.

[Vompatti]

Please do not lynch me. There is not even a single good case against me, why the hell are you putting my name out there like I'm a baddie? I can't talk much now because I'm currently driving, and I'm working until another 5 hours are up. Take off your blinders and stop tunnelling me, I'm a Civ goddammit!

> not a baddie
> internets while driving

[Long Con]

Weather bad too. This is what you people do to me.

[Nachomamma8]

I'm gonna vote Mac today

[Snow Dog]

I'm gonna vote Mac today

Really? Because I was thinking him or Long Con.

[Nachomamma8]

Wigly you think pirates got wiped out last night?

[Nachomamma8]

I'm gonna vote Mac today

Really? Because I was thinking him or Long Con.

I don't understand why people are thinking Long Con other than the Soneji thing to be honest.

[a2thezebra]

Please do not lynch me. There is not even a single good case against me, why the hell are you putting my name out there like I'm a baddie? I can't talk much now because I'm currently driving, and I'm working until another 5 hours are up. Take off your blinders and stop tunnelling me, I'm a Civ goddammit!

*votes Long Con*