Jackofhearts2005 wrote:Third, Eloh goes off on Quin for not following the Dom train, which is hilarious to me for several reasons. Eloh doesn't know why we're voting Dom. Several players have expressed concern that the Dom lynch is too easy. Some asked for other suspects (LC) or provided them (Epi) but most just said they were worried and nobody strongly went after anyone. Quin still votes DDL, which I disagree with but it draws unnecessary attention no matter how Dom flips and won't save Dom if they were w/w so I don't see why a scummer would bother. As town, it at least gets an opinion on record and as indy, it might be nightkill insurance. Whatever Quin's reasons for voting DDL, I think Eloh's response is way off mark. It's a bad look.
It is a bad look. So, I chose Eloh to ISO.
Post #1: Checks in on Day 0. Votes for North on the Day 0 poll.
Post #2:First real post. Agrees with Jack that Snow Dog's unread rolecard would be a good ploy for a baddie to use, and disagrees with Zebra, who saw Jack as not being sincere about his Snow Dog opinion.
My opinion here is that Jack was being less-than-serious, which, to me, indicates that he understood what was really going on, on some level, and responded appropriately. "What was really going on" being that Snow Dog was just joking around about not reading his rolecard. Which would also mean that zebra was correct, in a way.
Eloh believes Snow Dog is
lying about not reading his role PM, and agrees with DDL that if Snow Dog is lying, he's likely bad.
Post #3: Curtly reiterates that she believes Snow Dog is lying.
Post #4 and #5: Finds out that Snow Dog's thing was a joke and is dismayed at the time she spent on it.
She still originally intended to press consequences on Snow Dog for lying, for what it's worth. That gives a slight baddie tick mark in my opinion.
Post #6: Gives a list of names, but I'm not totally sure what it represents - "discussing the subject" but which subject? Laments again about wasted time on Snow Dog, and says she will "try to give him a fresh start in my book". (Post #7 clarifies she was talking to Epi in Post #6,
Post #8 she derps,
Post #9 she jokes,
Post #10 she OT's,
Post #11 she corrects).
Post #12: Asks Sorsha about her request for a Day 0 poll record.
What she asks about here is not likely to be very relevant, but that's just my opinion. This is her last post for three days, on Dec 20th.
Post #13: Dec 23rd, comes back with a reasonable explanation for her absence.
Post #14: Dec 25th. Just catchup questions, poor quarantine procedures. Not a suspicious post to me.
Post #15: Joke post.
Post #16: More questions
Post #17: Starting to get into the game a little, asks two game-pertinent questions that can lead to a better read of the game.
... that's where I am so far, I come away from this with a slight baddie lean for Eloh. I believe there are other things along the way, in the future of this ISO, that I found suspicious when I read them. I'm just adding to it when I can, but I have other things to do today as well.