A Mafia of Unfortunate Events [END GAME]

[Elohcin]

Dude, Sir, Dom isn't even on the poll. Do y'all see something I don't?

[Epignosis]

Dude, Sir, Dom isn't even on the poll. Do y'all see something I don't?

Christ.

Are you this ignorant or merely pretending to be this ignorant?

[Elohcin]

oh wait....Sir Epi, who did Dom replace? I have had way too much to drink.

[a2thezebra]

No time to catch up, randomized and got Marco!

[Marmot]

Spacedaisy - I would not vote. I teased Epignosis about her earlier, but I think he's right in trusting her.

DDL - Null. I find some of his arguments genuine, but at times I don't understand his logic.

Elohcin - I'd vote. I don't feel strongly about voting her, but Long Con's ISO (so far) is promising.

Epignosis - I'd vote him. Actually, probably not.

Marcodom - I don't remember anything about this playercombo.

MP - I don't remember anything about this a guy either.

Nacho - I like this guy, will abstain today.

Snow Dog - I would vote, don't really know why. i suppose gut.

Soneji - I would vote, because I don't remember much from him either.

Sig - not voting for him, for sure.

Zebra - If she doesn't come catch up and invest more like I remember her promising, I'd vote her.

[Marmot]

Oh, we're random-voting on Day 4 are we?

There's no such thing as random.

[Elohcin]

Spacedaisy - I would not vote. I teased Epignosis about her earlier, but I think he's right in trusting her.
agree
DDL - Null. I find some of his arguments genuine, but at times I don't understand his logic.
I trust him, wouldn't vote.
Elohcin - I'd vote. I don't feel strongly about voting her, but Long Con's ISO (so far) is promising.
this is a load of shit
Epignosis - I'd vote him. Actually, probably not.
I don't think Sir is bad. Won't vote today.
Marcodom - I don't remember anything about this playercombo.
would vote...even though I don't know much about his deal
MP - I don't remember anything about this a guy either.
who is this guy again?
Nacho - I like this guy, will abstain today.
my thoughts exactly
Snow Dog - I would vote, don't really know why. i suppose gut.
I agree. But I always see him as bad.
Soneji - I would vote, because I don't remember much from him either.
where is this guy?
Sig - not voting for him, for sure.
MM - not sure about him. He's said some questionable stuff here and there
not sure about him
Zebra - If she doesn't come catch up and invest more like I remember her promising, I'd vote her.

Think she's civ, just maybe got busy with holidays. Hopefully she'll get back into it.

[Elohcin]

How weird...I included MM too at the end and it didn't come through....said I think he's said some questionable things....would be yellow on a rainbow list.

sir epi

[Elohcin]

OH....I see what happened....I have to stop posting tonight....It's late and I have had many drinks. I'm not good at this like Sir Epi.

[Marmot]

Are you a member of mafia Elohcin?

Linki: Good night, and happy new year!

[Marmot]

Wert Snow Dog, I had a civ gutread of him in Monkey Island and was right, but he feels different this game. That said, I remember he regretted signing up because of timing on his end. Then again, so did Glorf.

[Elohcin]

I still have to vote though. So I can't say goodnight

sir epi

[Marmot]

I'm running out of phone battery (and personal battery) will vote soon.

Linki: what's holding you back?

[Epignosis]

I would take a Snow Dog lynch over a Marcodom one.

[Marmot]

Went with SnowDog. I considered MP for doint the same tjing.

G'night!

[Elohcin]

I'm running out of phone battery (and personal battery) will vote soon.

Linki: what's holding you back?

afraid players will vote for me at the last minute. But I cannot stay up any longer. I am voting Snow Dog. Others (like Sir Epi) are okay with it....hopefully it will work out.

[Quin]

Been out and about all day, going out again after this post to buy a new desk fan because it's swelteringly hot and my fan finally kicked it today.

Voted Eloh. She's been jumping on existing wagons without an acceptable reason for doing so. She didn't suspect any of the people she voted the past two phases. She comes across as disingenuous in her dealings with me. Posts like this:

Guess who I'm voting for?


Not Dom.

If Dom is bad, this is strike 2 for you.

She's quantifying reasons to point the finger at me without considering the quality of each aspect. Plus, this specific post is just blatantly illogical.

linki: Good thing you waited, huh?

[Elohcin]

and apparently MM was down with it too.


sir epi

[sig]

Why is Zebra voting for an inactive who was just replaced?

[Sorsha]

Why is Zebra voting for an inactive who was just replaced?

He says he randomized

[Epignosis]

I added my vote to Snow Dog. Sorry mate, but you didn't even comment on this Day.

[Sorsha]

Zebra and snow dog have both claimed busy rl and I know it's a definitely the time of year for that kind of stuff but it kinda bothers me that it's coming when they are both under suspicion and possible lynch candidates.

[Sorsha]

I'd like to have Dom catch up and let us know how he feels about what's going on. I really doubt he's going to be able to talk about his findings as the LD as Dom 1.0 but hopefully he can at least say if he genuinely suspects Quin or if it was a heat of the moment outburst before he was lynched. So not voting Dom today.

[sig]

Why is Zebra voting for an inactive who was just replaced?

He says he randomized

Ew dislike that. I don't want him lynched. I cant puost much right now. But im voting Snow dog I guess. The case doesnt seem to bad for my addled mind. :P

linki: I have no reason to believe Marco is mafia so I don't want him lynched.

[Golden]

I thought we had a whole extra day. Ddl soneji and (recently) zebra and eloh are the four I'm most suspicious of and most willing to vote.

It looks like people aren't that willing to go soneji or ddl. They'd be my preferences, but I want my vote to matter.

[Sorsha]

I feel like there's something up between Epi and Eloh, I commented on this last night too but I'll go through it again.

Epi called out Golden, Quin and Eloh as bad. Talked about wanting to lynch Eloh even. Then night happened. Quin and Golden aren't lynch options and so Epi backs off the Eloh suspicion today. Sorry I'm on my phone right now or I'd pull quotes for this.

But I think it's a weird situation.

I could vote for either Epi or Eloh and probably will.

[Golden]

I feel like there's something up between Epi and Eloh, I commented on this last night too but I'll go through it again.

Epi called out Golden, Quin and Eloh as bad. Talked about wanting to lynch Eloh even. Then night happened. Quin and Golden aren't lynch options and so Epi backs off the Eloh suspicion today. Sorry I'm on my phone right now or I'd pull quotes for this.

But I think it's a weird situation.

I could vote for either Epi or Eloh and probably will.

Good observation. Comment, epi or eloh?

[Spacedaisy]

I don't have a lot of time right now, but thankfully I did ISOs earlier. I'm comfortable voting Snow Dog because he left me questioning his alignment.

Voting Snow Dog

And going back to my party.

[Sorsha]

This was his reply to me last night Golden, you can check his or my ISO for the full context of what went on

If I'm good (or independent), and good people accuse me of being bad, I would like the courtesy of them at least attempting to put a civilian context around my actions and reactions.

That's what I'm doing for Eloh.

That isn't backpedaling. That's called thinking.

[Sorsha]

Sig- why are you even on the poll? You visited the doctor last night

[Golden]

This was his reply to me last night Golden, you can check his or my ISO for the full context of what went on

If I'm good (or independent), and good people accuse me of being bad, I would like the courtesy of them at least attempting to put a civilian context around my actions and reactions.

That's what I'm doing for Eloh.

That isn't backpedaling. That's called thinking.

I haven't noticed him extending the same courtesy to me. He's stuck to his guns on his read of me since day one, and I've given him sufficient angle to think about the civilian context of my actions.

The only thing is, what epi does isn't elohs fault...

[Tangrowth]

I'm voting Snow Dog because Daisy told me to.

[sig]

good question sorsha?

Also I forgot to vote oops.

[Golden]

The reason for suspicion of snow dog has eluded me (my phone wanted to call him snow god)

[sig]

With six votes no Snow I doubt he is mafia, but whatever I'll do some indepth scum hunting tomorrow or after this night phase.

[Golden]

Another runaway. I like the people on it but not the fact of it. Pretty hard to keep it close now though.

[Golden]

Elo. The closest I've got to a meaningful vote right now.

[Sorsha]

This was his reply to me last night Golden, you can check his or my ISO for the full context of what went on

If I'm good (or independent), and good people accuse me of being bad, I would like the courtesy of them at least attempting to put a civilian context around my actions and reactions.

That's what I'm doing for Eloh.

That isn't backpedaling. That's called thinking.

I haven't noticed him extending the same courtesy to me. He's stuck to his guns on his read of me since day one, and I've given him sufficient angle to think about the civilian context of my actions.

The only thing is, what epi does isn't elohs fault...

True, Eloh has had suspicion on her besides that though

[Golden]

This was his reply to me last night Golden, you can check his or my ISO for the full context of what went on

If I'm good (or independent), and good people accuse me of being bad, I would like the courtesy of them at least attempting to put a civilian context around my actions and reactions.

That's what I'm doing for Eloh.

That isn't backpedaling. That's called thinking.

I haven't noticed him extending the same courtesy to me. He's stuck to his guns on his read of me since day one, and I've given him sufficient angle to think about the civilian context of my actions.

The only thing is, what epi does isn't elohs fault...

True, Eloh has had suspicion on her besides that though

Yes, and fair in my opinion. That's why I voted her.

[Sorsha]

I went with Eloh also.

[DFaraday]

Post coming later.

[Nachomamma8]

Vitingbisntb workibg

[Nachomamma8]

I kill Sboq sig!!

[Quin]

I kill Sboq sig!!

what

[Quin]

I kill Snow Dog, I think he said.

[sig]

I kill Sboq sig!!

Tell me how killing sig will work out for ya.

[Golden]

I kill Sboq sig!!

what

Snow dog. Sboq sig is snow dog. I think.

[Quin]

I kill Sboq sig!!

what

Snow dog. Sboq sig is snow dog. I think.

Good to know my drunk translation skills are still up to scratch.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Couple minutes late, I see. Probably would have voted Eloh.

More likely townies on the Snow train, though. Hoping that's a good sign.

[a2thezebra]

Would you agree Quin that we are not team mates?

I would.

This is something that I would enjoy doing with a teammate in a game, and I can't be the only one.

I will not vote DDL, Epi, Sig as I view them as town.
I am resistant to voting Nacho and Marco (the later because it will tell us nothing).
I have no strong opinion on Son and MP.
I suspect Zebra but as nobody has mirrored these feelings, I suspect it is more culture clash than anything.
I suspect Daisy and especially Eloh for what looks like vague or poorly thought out arguments not taking the full thread into account.

One of those bottom five will get my vote today unless I see a damn good argument for why it should be elsewhere.

Why resistant to voting Nacho? And why suspect Daisy and Eloh for not liking their arguments? Do you think that is in any way alignment-indicative?

Although zebra's argument for me saying i hadn't read my role was wrong I think her argument was sound for all of that. It is certainly something i might do for the reasons she gave.

Thank you. I don't see why what I was indicating was possible (fishing for opportunistic baddies with ambiguously slimy behavior) was simultaneously far-fetched and wrong-therefore-bad, and I also suspect Jackofhearts for arguing both of those inconsistent positions at once.

In other news, I don't see why Dom replacing back in is such a big deal in terms of tipping the balance. If DFaraday is confident that it won't interfere with the game's outcome in anyone's favor that I don't see why we should doubt that. Moving on...

I think Quin is bad based on his behaviour, and the point Sorsha made is good as well.

What aspects of Quin's behaviour do you find to be alignment-indicative?

Long Con's role analysis here: Golden, I'm looking for your input on this specifically; I was impressed how you looked at his Monkey Island role spec and came away feeling great about it (and was even more impressed when I agreed with your conclusions). I was expecting you to comment on it here because I thought that it was significantly weaker here than it was there (in particular, the part that stood out to me there was his analysis of baddie roles there but I thought it lacked the same depth here); do you not usually comment on his role analysis/do you think this one was particularly neutral/did you decide not to comment on it just so I'd call you out about it later?

This post feels forced and disingenuous to me.

So far I don't find anything suspicious in DDL, he reads extremely civ to me. But I am going to finish it to be sure it doesn't change my opinion.

I strongly disagree with you on just about everything you've said in these pages and I'm reading you as town.

I will write my response to the following pages at a later time...I need to crash now, I just had to deliver some content first.