Felt Mafia 2 [ENDGAME]

#1501

Given that INH and Long Con both claim to have lynch immunities they MIGHT use tonight, I suggest we refrain from discussing who we intend to lynch until the next day phase. Telegraphing our next move will not end advantageously.

#1502

"I'm sorry we lynched you."

"You lynched me? What? I thought it was night!"

I'm not kidding.

#1503

Epignosis wrote:Why would A Person abandon that role? You could do nothing and win.

I was too busy dealing with other things to be able to play, I grieve terribly my lost chance to play a Mongoose game

#1504

Epignosis wrote:"I'm sorry we lynched you."

"You lynched me? What? I thought it was night!"

I'm not kidding.

#1505

This would probably increase the likelihood that the Jean Genie is Denim Mini. With the secret role resolved, those *secrets* appear to be the most applicable source.

#1506

Super Serial Announcement

Guys, I totally confused myself. I need to make the next DAY cycle 48 hours because I will be visiting my grandparents who live in the forest, free of the WiFis.

I'll be in the car by 9pm EST, so please have your night actions to me by 8pm EST. Vote in the location poll by then too.

Spoiler: show

For Clarity: Night Cycle will end at 8pm EST.

#1507

Cool beans. Do ya thang, Mongoose.

#1508

Both Jean Harlow and the Denim Suit don't seem to have used their roles. They are the most productive civ roles, so what's the likelihood that they're just abstaining from using them?

linki: I thought the Jean Genie could be Jeggings. There's no visible secret associated with them but the description of 'Sassiness' is at least compatible with how he's carried himself.

#1509

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:Cool beans. Do ya thang, Mongoose.

Thanks! I truly do appreciate your flexibility on this.

#1510

aren't*

#1511

Scotty wrote:
Scotty wrote:There surely must be a mechanic in the *Secret* Denim Mini that can combat this, like a big shit or something.
...
That should read "vig shot"

I hurled with laughter when I saw the original version.

#1512

juliets wrote:dang, but glad she wasn't civ - silly AP

I would still be here if I could!

PS Mongoose I am still reading your host posts and they are great.

#1513

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
thellama73 wrote:Mongoose tends to not like people dying in her games. It's not impossible.

It's sad for me too, sug.

#1514

Sorsha wrote:
thellama73 wrote:
Sorsha wrote:
thellama73 wrote:
Sorsha wrote:
thellama73 wrote:^ I find it hard to believe that INH would have asked Wilgy if he was down for a Llama lynch in thread. Being teammates, he would already know the answer to that. I feel better about INH from this ISO
Why did you say this but then keep inh on your suspect list?
Because that was a thousand years ago and much has changed since then.
It wasn't a thousand years ago, it was Tuesday night.

A few posts after that one you listed your suspicions and inh was still on it then too.
It was literally a thousand years ago.

I said I felt better about INH, but I never said I didn't suspect him at all. The empirical evidence is quite strong. At the time I made that post (which, to reiterate, was a thousand years ago I was probably least suspicious of INH out of anyone on my suspects list. Things he has said since then, and things others have said since then, and my own continuing ruminations on the state of the game now lead me to believe that he is the most likely suspect.
We are all trapped in the deathless world of Mongoose. Tuesday night really was 1,000 years ago. Mongoose is the Jean Genie and has us all trapped in her bottle. None of the dead players are actually dead, they just escaped.

I would really love this tbh

#1515

A Person wrote:
juliets wrote:dang, but glad she wasn't civ - silly AP
I would still be here if I could!

PS Mongoose I am still reading your host posts and they are great.

Thanks! All but tonight's take like 1 or more hours to draft, so I'm glad they are being read!

#1516

Labyrinths are cool. I picked it again.

#1517

Well, oh well. Sorry Elo.

Mongoose wrote:
Scotty wrote:
Scotty wrote:There surely must be a mechanic in the *Secret* Denim Mini that can combat this, like a big shit or something.
...
That should read "vig shot"

I hurled with laughter when I saw the original version.

One day I'll do a better job of proofreading ym posts but I'm often in a rush.

One day.

#1518

One of my all-time favorite Bowie songs and favorite childhood songs was never more apropos.

#1519

Why would the mafia need to protect a player? There's no vig listed. There must be a mechanic for another killing role, right?

Or am I missing something that would balance it out?

#1520

Scotty wrote:Why would the mafia need to protect a player? There's no vig listed. There must be a mechanic for another killing role, right?

Or am I missing something that would balance it out?

Mongoose really doesn't want people dying.

#1521

Mongoose wrote:Super Serial Announcement

Guys, I totally confused myself. I need to make the next DAY cycle 48 hours because I will be visiting my grandparents who live in the forest, free of the WiFis.

I'll be in the car by 9pm EST, so please have your night actions to me by 8pm EST. Vote in the location poll by then too.

Spoiler: show
For Clarity: Night Cycle will end at 8pm EST.

You could just rezz me, and I'll take care of the night post for you.

#1522

Scotty wrote:Why would the mafia need to protect a player? There's no vig listed. There must be a mechanic for another killing role, right?

Or am I missing something that would balance it out?

I thought it was pretty weird. The only use would be to fake a failed nightkill, but they have a blocker for that as well.

No one has taken a "big shit" yet, so... I have really chalked it up to Mongoose being a silly goose. Maybe there's a secret redirect or killing item that will come up.

So Eloh came back not evil. So she didn't join the baddie team. I feel like it makes Quin slightly less likely to be bad, but there's probably a lot of factors that I'm not considering... most notably, maybe the Host doesn't give a damn what the baddies think. Sorry for the vote, Eloh, I'm 0 for 2 in the last two games reading into the mindset of a Host who is allowing a dead player to replace in.

#1523

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:Labyrinths are cool. I picked it again.

I'm sold.

#1524

Sorsha wrote:We are all trapped in the deathless world of Mongoose. Tuesday night really was 1,000 years ago. Mongoose is the Jean Genie and has us all trapped in her bottle. None of the dead players are actually dead, they just escaped.

This post is fantastic.

#1525

Quin wrote:
JaggedJimmyJay wrote:Do Boomslang's voting record or his survival mean anything to you or no?
His survival doesn't.

Just a thought on this. To suspect Boomslang is bad is to believe in the Roleblock Setup or some similar sinister scheme. A scheme in which part of the plan is to fake a kill on Boomslang on Night 1 for cred. There's no POV where you can suspect Boomslang and not believe in the scheme.

My point being, a) JJJ, of course Boomslang's survival means something to Quin, it's a huge central premise required to accuse Boomslang. It's almost silly to ask. b) Quin, when you say Boomslang's survival doesn't mean anything to you, it feels like you're saying something that's not real, which just makes me consider that you might not be entirely honest with your suspicions, which would of course indicate that you're bad.

#1526

EBWOP: Link to the post I quoted in my last post. I realized I had shaved enough off that quote for focus to make it hard to place in context.

#1527

insertnamehere wrote:
JaggedJimmyJay wrote:
insertnamehere wrote:Me surviving and literally anyone else that I don't know the alignment of surviving benefits the civilians.
A no lynch would hurt the civilians. That's why we need to know.

Separate question: what is your current read on LC and Quin?
I think no one dying is a slightly better outcome than a civilian dying, purely from a numbers perspective.

Quin is in my top three scumreads, along with you and Llama.

I don't like how quick LC was to turn on me in order to avoid blame for having incorrect opinions. Over the course of this day, he went from one of my top townreads to someone I'm on the fence about. I'm trying not to be blinded by his targeting me.

I'm sorry for the sudden turnaround. It was predicated by the sudden revelation that we had lynched another baddie in Wilgy, and reviewing some posts with that in mind. Your post I quoted before really looks pingy, why are you surprised to get suspicion for it? You are sending out the Civ vibes with the posts in a bunch of posts in this area, but I don't know if you're an old champ who can easily turn on the Civ charm when needed.

This game has been tough because of good players. Each person I have suspected has won me over in some way to make me admit "this player is really looking Civ right now". Even JJJ, since I know that was being asked about. For the record, I have never said I don't suspect him anymore. He's just played well enough to make me feel like maybe he's Civ. He could be bad. I may still vote for him at some point.

#1528

It's officially Friday in the States, so Casual Friday Jeans has a message for you:

Alright gang,

It's a relief to make it to another Friday! It's been a bit of a trial but here I am again to share my jean-brained thoughts with you. The Elohcin lynch didn't quite go the way we'd have liked, but we could have done worse. Let's take this opportunity to regroup and redouble our efforts, civilians. Let's bring out the big guns. Gimme those ISOs. Gimme those big analytic cases. Gimme those GTH reads. We're still in the driver's seat in this game and with a little team work I think we'll be just fine. Keep fighting the good fight. Never give up, never surrender. Go team go. Keep your foot on the gas. I am suspicious of Long Con. With a top POE lynch option removed in Elohcin though without an additional dead mafioso, I think we're going to need to reassess our reads vigilantly."

#1529

Long Con wrote:
Quin wrote:
JaggedJimmyJay wrote:Do Boomslang's voting record or his survival mean anything to you or no?
His survival doesn't.

Just a thought on this. To suspect Boomslang is bad is to believe in the Roleblock Setup or some similar sinister scheme. A scheme in which part of the plan is to fake a kill on Boomslang on Night 1 for cred. There's no POV where you can suspect Boomslang and not believe in the scheme.

My point being, a) JJJ, of course Boomslang's survival means something to Quin, it's a huge central premise required to accuse Boomslang. It's almost silly to ask. b) Quin, when you say Boomslang's survival doesn't mean anything to you, it feels like you're saying something that's not real, which just makes me consider that you might not be entirely honest with your suspicions, which would of course indicate that you're bad.

There's a world where his survival makes him a civilian, and a world where his survival means he isn't. Both are possible, both are logical. I won't throw unearned trust at Boomslang because the rest of you insist on calling the alternative a tinfoil. My read is based on his contributions, and his contributions suck.

#1530

I just realised a thing. Not a thing I care to tell anybody about, but a thing none-the-less.

#1531

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:
Long Con wrote:JJJ is my favourite person in this game, because I'd probably be nightkilled by now if it weren't for him.
This is a new point about Long Con I am thinking about. On a couple occasions he has asserted that he's pleased to receive some suspicion because it dissuades his being night killed. In this comment he says he'd have probably been night killed without my aggression.

I don't know why he'd feel that way. Even without me in the equation, his voting record is still bad and there's still no objective evidence in his favor. I don't see why he'd ever be night killed over the people who have been targeted (Boomslang and Marmot were both strongly trusted after the DDL lynch, and Elohcin 1.0 had roleblocker cred).

On some level this reads to me like a bad guy feeling the need to justify his continued survival.

No no no... you of all people should remember, when you were most fervently trying to get people to weigh in and see what you saw, there were three or four people who said some variation of "nah, I get the Civ vibe from him this game". I read them and facepalmed, because it's the people who everyone thinks is Civ that often gets chosen for nightkill. People unlikely to be lynched. But your unwavering disbelief in me kept hope alive, my friend.

#1532

I'm so fucking tired of the JJJ-LC dispute.

#1533

You two are on restriction. You are not allowed to suspect or talk to one another. Go to your rooms and think about other suspects.

-Your mom, Skeletor

#1534

#1535

Epignosis wrote:You two are on restriction. You are not allowed to suspect or talk to one another. Go to your rooms and think about other suspects.

-Your mom, Skeletor

Ok, agreed.

#1536

Epignosis wrote:You two are on restriction. You are not allowed to suspect or talk to one another. Go to your rooms and think about other suspects.

-Your mom, Skeletor

What if my new suspect is you?

#1537

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:
Epignosis wrote:You two are on restriction. You are not allowed to suspect or talk to one another. Go to your rooms and think about other suspects.

-Your mom, Skeletor
What if my new suspect is you?

No dinner for you.

#1538

#1539

Epignosis wrote:By the way, in case in wasn't obvious, I lied about winning a prize.

Epi, it wasn't obvious to me and I have to ask you, why?

I don't know what to talk about with the llama rule in effect (which I totally see the need for). I'm glad to see though that the night is not 48 hours like I thought.

Also AP when I said you were silly I meant that in the best way possible. I'm sorry you had to leave the game.

#1540

Oh yeah, the Llama rule. I'll level with ya - I don't think I'm going to get lynched, I'm probably not going to end up sending it in. Even if I do get lynched, then I guess something awful happened and revealing my role will allow everyone to move on.

#1541

I'm using mine.

#1542

juliets wrote:
Epignosis wrote:By the way, in case in wasn't obvious, I lied about winning a prize.
Epi, it wasn't obvious to me and I have to ask you, why?

He was like "I got a lie detect

"... I never thought it was serious. It seemed like, and was, a joke.

I don't know what to talk about with the llama rule in effect (which I totally see the need for). I'm glad to see though that the night is not 48 hours like I thought.

The Llama rule only seems to cover INH and I. You should still be able to discuss the rest of the players.

Of course, there could be a secretive Winner #8 out there hoarding a Lynch Immunity, but

. I think if you have anything to say, then you should say it.

Towny McTownface · #1543

I knew if I waited around long you lot would screw it up. Now you're not even going to talk about suspects? Time wasters, all of you. No patience. I regret ever giving the civilians credit. I'm officially rooting for the Mafia now.

#1544

I want to go to the waterpark

Take me take me take me take me now

NOW NOW NOW NOW NOW!!

#1545

Button Your Fly Water Park, take me there right now!

#1546

I think I will also go to the waterpark.

#1547

Jean Genie wrote:I knew if I waited around long you lot would screw it up. Now you're not even going to talk about suspects? Time wasters, all of you. No patience. I regret ever giving the civilians credit. I'm officially rooting for the Mafia now.

Jean Genie confirmed for staying in on Friday night :P

#1548

I am out of hot yoga but there's no way I can make the night post being drenched as a rat. You can have a 30 min extension to vote or PM me.

#1549

juliets wrote:Also AP when I said you were silly I meant that in the best way possible. I'm sorry you had to leave the game.

OH ok! I am ok with being that silly

#1550

Night 4

Where to, buckaroos?

You may select 1 option

Jordache Nation-State
1
insertnamehere (2) 8%
Button Your Fly Water Park
4
Quin (4), Scotty (5), nijuukyugou (10), juliets (11) 31%
True Religion Meditation Labyrinth
5
JaggedJimmyJay (3), thellama73 (6), Long Con (8), Jean Genie (9), Boomslang (12) 38%
Bell Bottoms Gardens and Carillon
1
Epignosis (13) 8%
Inside the soothing embrace of the denim backpack (Host et al)
2
Mongoose (1), Metalmarsh89 (7) 15%
Total votes : 13

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

What's the next Felt (pick a material)?