MM6: Sherlock Mafia {THE FINAL PROBLEM}

#51

Right now, I am suspicious of DH, Bullz, and A Person, based on corresponding PMs I've had with them.

Something doesn't add up.

#52

I dunno about Bullz or A Person, but I've not PM'd you.

#53

I know DH.

I've been sending out feelers to see if I could trip anyone up, and right now both Bullz and A Person are claiming to be your partner.

#54

#55

Matt F wrote:I know DH.

I've been sending out feelers to see if I could trip anyone up, and right now both Bullz and A Person are claiming to be your partner.

You've been twice deceived amigo.

#56

Matt F wrote:Right now, I am suspicious of DH, Bullz, and A Person, based on corresponding PMs I've had with them.

Something doesn't add up.

Interesting.

#57

Very interesting.

A Person and Bullz, any opinions on what's happening here?

#58

Matt F wrote:Very interesting.

A Person and Bullz, any opinions on what's happening here?

A Person actually told me you were his partner, FWIW

#59

Now I feel stoopid. I actually told Bullz my role. Egads!

**http://www.last.fm/user/nutella23** · #60

Whoa this went up fast! Don't have time to read through the thread yet, but I'm here to check in. Excited for this game

#61

This is quite hilarious. Did you expect it to get this confusing INH? I am sure this is just the beginning.

#62

Matt F wrote:Very interesting.

A Person and Bullz, any opinions on what's happening here?

Oh no, but I am interested to find out.

#63

A Person wrote:
Matt F wrote:Very interesting.

A Person and Bullz, any opinions on what's happening here?
Oh no, but I am interested to find out.

I don't know what's actually going on but I think you've claimed a role you don't have or something. I've been in contact with both Matt and DH and haven't actually lied to anyone yet so...

#64

I think for the time being, I'm going to keep to myself and not create any alliances. Alliance over, Bullz, sorry if you're telling the truth.

#65

Bullzeye wrote:
A Person wrote:
Matt F wrote:Very interesting.

A Person and Bullz, any opinions on what's happening here?
Oh no, but I am interested to find out.
I don't know what's actually going on but I think you've claimed a role you don't have or something. I've been in contact with both Matt and DH and haven't actually lied to anyone yet so...

I'm not denying that pm(s) may have been received and possibly replied to, but as to the current discussion I must admit I'm confused. I don't know what sort of claim I've supposed to have made though.

#66

Matt F wrote:I think for the time being, I'm going to keep to myself and not create any alliances. Alliance over, Bullz, sorry if you're telling the truth.

FWIW everything I said was true. EVERYTHING

#67

This is already a mad crazy game....

#68

FYI DH and Bullz, if A Person said I am his partner, that is FALSE.

And since he claimed to be DH's partner, I'm guessing he's the one I should be worried about. Either way, gotta get goin' to work, hopefully this gets straightened out by the time I get home.

#69

Elohcin wrote:This is quite hilarious. Did you expect it to get this confusing INH? I am sure this is just the beginning.

Yes.

#70

Bullzeye wrote:
Matt F wrote:I think for the time being, I'm going to keep to myself and not create any alliances. Alliance over, Bullz, sorry if you're telling the truth.
FWIW everything I said was true. EVERYTHING

Isn't ally just a misspelling of a lie? ;D

#71

I dislike greatly when my words are twisted or things are said in regards to me that are not true.

#72

A Person wrote:
Bullzeye wrote:
Matt F wrote:I think for the time being, I'm going to keep to myself and not create any alliances. Alliance over, Bullz, sorry if you're telling the truth.
FWIW everything I said was true. EVERYTHING
Isn't ally just a misspelling of a lie? ;D

I intend to treat my allies well though. I can look out for the people who help me in many ways but I can't look after my self that well so it's in my best interests to be as honest as I can. I've yet to lie to anybody I offered an alliance to. Can you say the same? Well the answer is clearly no.

#73

A Person wrote:
Bullzeye wrote:
Matt F wrote:I think for the time being, I'm going to keep to myself and not create any alliances. Alliance over, Bullz, sorry if you're telling the truth.
FWIW everything I said was true. EVERYTHING
Isn't ally just a misspelling of a lie? ;D

#74

I got a PM from someone saying:

Is it cloak & dagger
Could it be spring or fall
I walk without a cut
Through a stained glass wall
Weaker in my eyesight
The candle in my grip
And words that have no form
Are falling from my lips

These dreams go on when I close my eyes
Every second of the night I live another life
These dreams that sleep when it's cold outside
Every moment I'm awake the further I'm away

These are the lyrics to Heart's These Dreams. At his insistence, I am not sharing his name, but he said I could share the message because it's a clue. The cloak and dagger caught my eye.

#75

So much fun already.

#76

Oh also: he said someone else was getting a similarly-themed but different-content message. So if you got a weird message, will you speak up? I'm super curious to know the content.

</nosy>

#77

The only way I can interpret what Matt F has been saying is that when I told him my role AP claimed the same, and DH claimed the role that mine is partnered with. Apparently AP also claimed to be Matt's partner to DH. I think it's clear that AP is just lying to whoever will talk to him. Or Matt is lying about everything.

Linki - nobody has messaged me. Nobody probably will now though!

#78

I can tell you I didn't role claim to anybody.

#79

I am genuinely ashamed that I never knew that was Heart.

#80

Holy chaos on a schtick! Just the way I like it...

#81

This has already become complex beyond belief. It's going to be a fun game.

#82

thellama73 wrote:This has already become complex beyond belief. It's going to be a fun game.

We're still on Page 3.

#83

insertnamehere wrote:
thellama73 wrote:This has already become complex beyond belief. It's going to be a fun game.
We're still on Page 3.

That depends on your forum settings. You can't trick me, host!

#84

Omg i love this game already

#85

Hedgeowl wrote:Omg i love this game already

That's pretty suspicious. I don't trust you this game!

#86

thellama73 wrote:
Hedgeowl wrote:Omg i love this game already
That's pretty suspicious. I don't trust you this game!

#87

Hedgeowl wrote:
thellama73 wrote:
Hedgeowl wrote:Omg i love this game already
That's pretty suspicious. I don't trust you this game!

Owl be watching you.

#88

A Person wrote:
Hedgeowl wrote:
thellama73 wrote:
Hedgeowl wrote:Omg i love this game already
That's pretty suspicious. I don't trust you this game!

Owl be watching you.

I don't get it, why is it suspicious?

#89

Elohcin wrote:
A Person wrote:
Hedgeowl wrote:
thellama73 wrote:
Hedgeowl wrote:Omg i love this game already
That's pretty suspicious. I don't trust you this game!

Owl be watching you.
I don't get it, why is it suspicious?

I was making a joke, because I have accused Hedgeowl of being suspicious every game and very recently was partially responsible for lynching her when she was a civ.

#90

Wasn't that HILARIOUS?

#91

It made me very sad. That was very spitty.

#92

I don't believe I have ever known A Person to be deceitful. Looking over page 2 again (for the fourth time), I wonder what his sudden motivation for (clearly amateur) deception could be.

#93

Epignosis wrote:I don't believe I have ever known A Person to be deceitful. Looking over page 2 again (for the fourth time), I wonder what his sudden motivation for (clearly amateur) deception could be.

I wasn't going to comment on it but so far I'm not sure how I deceived anyone, I'm not even sure what it is I supposedly was deceitful about?

#94

A Person wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I don't believe I have ever known A Person to be deceitful. Looking over page 2 again (for the fourth time), I wonder what his sudden motivation for (clearly amateur) deception could be.
I wasn't going to comment on it but so far I'm not sure how I deceived anyone, I'm not even sure what it is I supposedly was deceitful about?

So...you have nothing noteworthy to say regarding page 2?

#95

Yeah I'm not saying we are going to start calling you Big Tuna, but something back there was definitely fishy.

#96

Epignosis wrote:
A Person wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I don't believe I have ever known A Person to be deceitful. Looking over page 2 again (for the fourth time), I wonder what his sudden motivation for (clearly amateur) deception could be.
I wasn't going to comment on it but so far I'm not sure how I deceived anyone, I'm not even sure what it is I supposedly was deceitful about?
So...you have nothing noteworthy to say regarding page 2?

Not particularly. I was approached by both DH and then Matt F. Matt F said that DH had said I was his partner, which was odd but I thought it might just be a slight misunderstanding and that he meant he'd only pm'd me. I responded to Matt F's pm and then to DH's, saying I had already responded to Matt F's. There were no other claims/information involved so I'm not sure how there is any sort of confusion. Matt F's post saying something was going on was posted almost immediately after I responded, which is why I was mostly interested in watching.

#97

A Person wrote: Not particularly. I was approached by both DH and then Matt F. Matt F said that DH had said I was his partner, which was odd but I thought it might just be a slight misunderstanding and that he meant he'd only pm'd me. I responded to Matt F's pm and then to DH's, saying I had already responded to Matt F's. There were no other claims/information involved so I'm not sure how there is any sort of confusion. Matt F's post saying something was going on was posted almost immediately after I responded, which is why I was mostly interested in watching.

I got a similar message from Matt F, after which he flat out admitted to trying to trip me up. He is full of tricks, isn't he?

#98

thellama73 wrote:
A Person wrote: Not particularly. I was approached by both DH and then Matt F. Matt F said that DH had said I was his partner, which was odd but I thought it might just be a slight misunderstanding and that he meant he'd only pm'd me. I responded to Matt F's pm and then to DH's, saying I had already responded to Matt F's. There were no other claims/information involved so I'm not sure how there is any sort of confusion. Matt F's post saying something was going on was posted almost immediately after I responded, which is why I was mostly interested in watching.
I got a similar message from Matt F, after which he flat out admitted to trying to trip me up. He is full of tricks, isn't he?

Indeed. If that was his intention I can't blame him for it.

#99

A Person wrote:
thellama73 wrote:
A Person wrote: Not particularly. I was approached by both DH and then Matt F. Matt F said that DH had said I was his partner, which was odd but I thought it might just be a slight misunderstanding and that he meant he'd only pm'd me. I responded to Matt F's pm and then to DH's, saying I had already responded to Matt F's. There were no other claims/information involved so I'm not sure how there is any sort of confusion. Matt F's post saying something was going on was posted almost immediately after I responded, which is why I was mostly interested in watching.
I got a similar message from Matt F, after which he flat out admitted to trying to trip me up. He is full of tricks, isn't he?
Indeed. If that was his intention I can't blame him for it.

I can! I'm not sure if I want people who are going to be so slippery sticking around for too long.

#100

FWIW, I don't see what incentive any of us has to lie at this point in the game unless we have something to hide... something bad! I have resolved to play a straightforward and honest game to the extent that that is possible. I promise to deal fairly with any of you. People who come right out of the gate trying to deceive me have a very good chance of getting my vote.

The Final Problem