The Great Gatsby [Day 5]

#151

Wilgy, your role does sound cool. And I respect you for gow you're working it for you advanrage so neither side can really go after you. Kudos.

I unlike LC HAVE read through everything more than once. I will be taking time to look at vote patterns. The votes for Day 1 were posted in the thread, I believe. I need to check for Day 2.

#152

Wilgy. You voted for boomslang day 2. Does this mean you think he is civ or baddie? This is not a question about your role and I expect it ti be answered promptly.

#153

I'm a dumbass I didn't realize this started.... will be catching up throughout the day/morning!

#154

oh never mind..

#155

You know you guys can get PM notifications through email if youbset it up that way.

#156

Elohcin wrote: ↑Mon Aug 07, 2017 8:30 am Wilgy. You voted for boomslang day 2. Does this mean you think he is civ or baddie? This is not a question about your role and I expect it ti be answered promptly.

I have no opinion on Boomslang tbh. Why I voted him is a daytime question.

#157

Now you're just being a punk.

#158

DrWilgy wrote: ↑Sun Aug 06, 2017 10:26 pm Ok, no more haikus. I can't handle it anymore. Idk how the hell Rico posts in gimmick.

Here's what's up. I'm the 3rd party tie breaker. I can win with either civs or mafia, and I'm no one's enemy.

I was waiting until I lynched a mafia to say anything as a sign of good faith towards the civs. Luckily, that happened day one.

I do need to survive for awhile in order to achieve my win condition. I won't say what that is.

As a sign of good faith towards the scum, I will not be hunting from here on out. I will vote day to day in accordance to my independent win condition.

As of right now, I have submitted a random list for who takes priority in a tie. I will not change this list until I die. Speaking of which, I can manipulate ties post mortem. If I do happen to be lynched, I will side all ties in what I think is favorable to mafia. To the opposite, if I'm nk'd I'll side all ties in what I think is favorable to civs (you see how that went with Rico).

To keep myself involved in the game somewhat. I will answer the first 2 questions presented to me from 2 separate players each day phase. I will not share my win condition regardless of question.

Shall we have some fun?

Man, you sound so much like one of those pseudo-evil negotiators from the movies.

Martini?

#159

Day 3

I wanted to get out of the city. I wanted to see the country where I grew up, but things kept pulling me back.

For example, a noted assassin was killed while trying to investigate the murder of Dr. T.J. Eckleburg. I don't know how she died. The newspapermen said it was accidental, but I know better. Someone wanted to silence her.

nijuukyugou has been killed. She was the one-shot vigilante.

It is now Day 3. You have 48 hours to lynch someone.

#160

I wish I had taken your offer for a drink Niju.

#161

Boo, sorry to see you go niju.

#162

Don't forgt to reset the poll, Epi.

#163

Who is a threat to the Nordic race?

Poll ended at Sun Aug 06, 2017 8:22 pmPlease note that if you vote, your vote will be visible.

Boomslang
3
33%

Voters: DrWilgy, TonyStarkPrime, Dom

DFaraday
0
No votes

Voters: None

Dom
0
No votes

Voters: None

DrWilgy
1
11%

Voters: Boomslang

Elohcin
0
No votes

Voters: None

Enrique
3
33%

Voters: nijuukyugou, Elohcin, DFaraday

Long Con
0
No votes

Voters: None

Made
0
No votes

Voters: None

Neverwhere
0
No votes

Voters: None

nijuukyugou
0
No votes

Voters: None

TonyStarkPrime
0
No votes

Voters: None

Tom Buchanan (The Host, the Non, the Dead)
2
22%

Voters: Epignosis, JaggedJimmyJay

Total votes: 9

#164

I friggin' knew it

Zombie martini?

#165

zombie martini!

#166

Those were pretty standard mafia kills, unfortunate that they both had roles.
I still want to lynch Boom. But I might always want to lynch Boom. Waiting on Long Con to come around. Made, do you have any thoughts?

#167

I agree with the Boom suspicion. A look at his ISO is suspicious to me. The gimmick, the Rico defense, looks bad to me.

#168

DFaraday wrote: ↑Sun Aug 06, 2017 8:16 pm
Elohcin wrote: ↑Sun Aug 06, 2017 7:14 pm I'm just afraid the no shows are civ. But then again, I have no good reason for voting any particular participating party. I'm at a loss.

Reason for why boomslang is bad? Um....he just always sounds that way to me.
I assume because he seemed to come across as defending Rico, who turned out to be bad? I don't really hold that against Boom though, since it felt a little too blatant for a teammate. I'll go ahead and vote Enrique as well, since this game really needs talkers more than not (and yes, I admit I've been part of the problem. We weren't supposed to be on our phones ).

Not many posts from DF yet. This one feels like he could be bad, and knows Boomslang is good, and is buddying a little.

#169

Dom's contributions to this game have been generally short and terse. I don't get a baddie vibe from him.

#170

rip niju.

#171

DrWilgy I believe is Indy, and helpful to the Civs. I'd like to see his rainbow list, as an order of tie-breaking priority.

#172

Elohcin, I have a good Civ vibe from at this time.

#173

Nice to have you around, LC.

I agree that boom looks bad, I do. My only concern is that blooper was killed. Would he do that? This is the only thing that has me leaning DF over boom. But, perhaps they are both bad and boom wasnt around, so DF has veen quiet and DF chose to kill bloops. It could have gone down lile that.

#174

I would be willing to vote DF over Boom.

Wilgy, I see you there.

#175

#176

Long Con wrote: ↑Tue Aug 08, 2017 9:13 am I would be willing to vote DF over Boom.

Wilgy, I see you there.

Me too. What say you, wilgy?

#177

Made wrote: ↑Thu Aug 03, 2017 12:13 pm Rico, who do you think is mafia and why is it Enrique?

Also, how are we still on page one??

This quote is probably the most relevant one of Made's. I'm trying to decide if it's a post you make to a Mafia teammate. I'm leaning to the 'no' side, but I'd like to hear other opinions.

Otherwise, his contribution is to suggest we all out ourselves. False claims can make that not work, but we don't have proof of false claims. Maybe we can keep that one in our back pocket until later?

#178

Yes...back pocket sounds good for that one. We'll have to remember it.

#179

The poll doesn't have an ending time.

#180

Also, I looked at the poll and now I can't vote in it.

#181

Long Con wrote: ↑Tue Aug 08, 2017 12:02 am I agree with the Boom suspicion. A look at his ISO is suspicious to me. The gimmick, the Rico defense, looks bad to me.

Alright, finally back at a stable computer and can respond to things. Such as Blooper's death

Vengeance shall be merciless.

The gimmick was because I love Gatsby, nothing more and nothing less; I had to drop it because I didn't have access to a copy while traveling. And it's easy to go after me for defending Rico's gimmick in hindsight, but I after I literally spent all of Night Vale defending him for a gimmick, I think he counted on me to continue that train of thought.

I'm willing to trust Wilgy after he pulled a claim similar to what I did with the Man in the Tan Jacket last time. With a mafia lynch on the first day, I'm sure he's truthful about throwing his hat in with the civs for at least the next few days.

#182

Shoot... I can't vote either after looking at the poll.

#183

Poll should be fixed.

#184

I told epi and he fixed it. My super hero!!!

#185

I still don't know when the poll ends. I feel a little better about boom after hearing from him. I'm going to go ahead and vote DF so I don't miss the vote. He is the only one I can see voting for at this time.

#186

Haha...nevermind. the time is fixed too. Still voting.

#187

lc r u bad?

#188

Me? No. Are you?

#189

Quick reads on everyone:

Boomslang - As usual, a good guy whom everyone wants dead.
DFaraday - Nothing to go off of but a drive-by on Made and an ungimmicky start-of-game post. Votes Enrique for low-posting reasons, then continues to be part of the problem after saying he'd be back yesterday. Could be bad.
Dom - Terse, healthy suspicion of multiple people. Most recently pushing LC, who hasn't gotten much flak. Probably civ.
DrWilgy - Almost certainly indy, and confidently civ aligned. Not worried about him.
Elo - Immediately goes after me based on "he just always sounds that way to me," then backs off when I actually start posting. Misses the Rico lynch, votes Enrique for low posting. Could very well be bad and pursuing easy targets.
Long Con - Likes Made's idea, doesn't like me, also doesn't like DFaraday. Seems genuinely inquisitive. Likely civ.
Made - Interacts with Rico early, goes after Enrique even earlier. Offers big claim idea, doesn't offer much after it. Dump vote on Enrique, no vote yesterday. Would like to see more; in yellow part of the rainbow.
Neverwhere - Complete no-show. At this point in the game, either bad or non-contributing civ. Nothing in her favor is not a good sign.
TSP - Dislikes Made's idea, exchanges votes with Rico first lynch, wants to lynch me because "I might always want to lynch Boom." The Rico exchange is either masterful first-day bussing or a civ clear, and I'm leaning toward the latter given Rico's genuine frustration over the lynch.

#190

Dom wrote: ↑Tue Aug 08, 2017 8:35 pmlc r u bad?

No, I'm quite Civ, old sport!

I think I'm gonna vote DFaraday now that the poll is fixed. Just gonna have a last little look around first. Won't take a sec.

#191

Yes, DF is my vote. It's now 2-2. Wilgy, what you thinkin'?

#192

Well, guess I'm voting DFaraday. Thanks Wilgy, but not putting my fate in your hands again unless absolutely necessary, lol.

#193

Who killed Myrtle Wilson?

Poll ended at Tue Aug 08, 2017 10:04 pmPlease note that if you vote, your vote will be visible.

Boomslang
2
20%

Voters: TonyStarkPrime, Dom

DFaraday
3
30%

Voters: Boomslang, Elohcin, Long Con

Dom
0
No votes

Voters: None

DrWilgy
0
No votes

Voters: None

Elohcin
0
No votes

Voters: None

Long Con
0
No votes

Voters: None

Made
0
No votes

Voters: None

Neverwhere
0
No votes

Voters: None

TonyStarkPrime
0
No votes

Voters: None

Mr. McKee (The Host, the Non, the Dead)
5
50%

Voters: sprityo, Spacedaisy, nijuukyugou, JaggedJimmyJay, Epignosis

Total votes: 10

#194

Night 3

DFaraday was Henry Gatz. He was a vanilla civilian.

It is now Night 3.

#195

Hmm... thought I had another day.

Rip in pepperoni DF.

#196

#197

Sorry DF, my read was wrong on that one.

#198

Man, civ.

Busy day ahead. Be back after it's over.

#199

Mafia, God knows what you’ve been doing, everything you’ve been doing. You may fool me, but you can’t fool God!

#200

Back. Sorry life is strange.

Rip DF

Things I caught in iso:
I fucks with the vision Wilgy. I don't, however, like the idea of potentially losing a neutral nk, so i'll make the point that should mafia think they're sufficiently town read by wilgy, they could get a nk out of him, and a tie in their favor later in the game.
Dom- help me parse your thought process? I had trouble following your Iso and want insight before I further my current train of thought.
Lastly, Neverwhere is complete no show at this point right? I'm kinda ready to lean civ on that, my thought being then that her would be teammates would pinging the crap out to keep her active.

Someone shot Mr. Gatsby- who was it?