Kylemii wrote: ↑Thu Mar 15, 2018 9:31 am
colonialbob wrote: ↑Thu Mar 15, 2018 9:30 am
Who's most likely to have killed sprit? I think that's the best way to vote this phase.
why is that the best way to vote?
Well this is assuming we can narrow that down to like 2 or 3 people, but it's the best way to vote because it gives you the best chance of catching mafia.
Based on the assumption Kites and gwil are town (which I think is a solid one):
Nut/Sig couldn't have killed sprit. Kites blocked fliers, and is immune to flier targeting, so he's locked in. (Sidenote, the discrepancy between nutella's reported night action and kites has me actually suspecting her for basically the first time all game)
Gwil doctored sprit, so the killer couldn't have been on foot or he was misdirected. Either nutella MD'd gwil, or Kenway, myself, or RDW made the kill.
Option 1: nutella MDs gwil - I don't think there's any remaining MDs in the game other than her and I, and I didn't MD last night. So either she's lying about her target (and thus presumably mafia), or she failed but didn't mention it?
Option 2: one of Kenway, me, RDW are the killer. Kenway used his power on me, so if he's town (and wasn't MD'd) neither of us could make the kill. That leaves RDW. If Kenway is mafia, he could've made the kill and lied about targeting me, meaning there could be an unknown teammate out there.
So I guess voting this way depends on your trust of Kenway and how likely you think nutella a) is mafia and b) targeted gwil.
[mention]rundontwalk[/mention] what did you do last night?