Easter Mafia [GAME OVER]

[Dyslexicon]

The simplest universe is that Scotty read the writing on the wall re: Dizzy and realized that his only out was to go for nutella.

Well yeah. If he was town understanding that he had done fucked up, why not say that? Why not comment on it? Why just the "oh, but it could also be Nut but it could be Dizzy but Jimmey is defending him and I don't know, I'll go for Nut" and then continue to drag Nut instead. Doesn't make town sense at all to me.

[Dyslexicon]

Nut is saying the shadiest shit sometimes though. xD

Scum the lot of you.

This is still true though: wouldn't even be mad if scum won at this point. Lynching Scotty makes the most sense.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

The simplest universe is that Scotty read the writing on the wall re: Dizzy and realized that his only out was to go for nutella.

Well yeah. If he was town understanding that he had done fucked up, why not say that? Why not comment on it? Why just the "oh, but it could also be Nut but it could be Dizzy but Jimmey is defending him and I don't know, I'll go for Nut" and then continue to drag Nut instead. Doesn't make town sense at all to me.

That in particular is bugging me. If we remove the theory from the equation as Scotty has been inclined to do, then I don't know why my perspective of Dizzy means anything about Dizzy's alignment beyond sometimes JJJ is right about things. It recalls the weird incident with MP and Scotty's perceived red check -- behaving as though I have information on Dizzy when I clearly cannot.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Nut is saying the shadiest shit sometimes though. xD

Agreed. And it's leaving me feeling about 60/40 for Scotty if not less.

[Dyslexicon]

Nut is saying the shadiest shit sometimes though. xD

Agreed. And it's leaving me feeling about 60/40 for Scotty if not less.

Which is pretty amazing, considering.

This game.

I don't ever want to live to Lylo again. Please.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

It absolutely would still exist. And that's a poor way to phrase that I have been considering multiple possible candidates for the last mafioso so as not to let them slide through and allow another mislynch to happen. I'm doing exactly what I should be doing during lylo.

When did you decide that Dizzy's Day 4 looked better than mine?

[nutella]

It absolutely would still exist. And that's a poor way to phrase that I have been considering multiple possible candidates for the last mafioso so as not to let them slide through and allow another mislynch to happen. I'm doing exactly what I should be doing during lylo.

When did you decide that Dizzy's Day 4 looked better than mine?

Early day 5 I think? Or night 4?

[Dyslexicon]

[VOTE: Nutella] aubergine

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Difficult decisions ahead. If you, dear reader, are a civilian, I'd better see fire and dragons. I will do my part.

Not a difficult decision for me lol. If only you could see it from my perspective... I guess my responsibility is to try as hard as I can to get you to see it from my perspective. I do feel that my ISO of Scotty points out a lot of convincing arguments though so I'd recommend starting there.

This wasn't a difficult decision for you on Night 5. Your behavior on Day 6 doesn't align with that proclamation.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

[mention]Dyslexicon[/mention], how do you feel about this point Marmot made when he assessed the night kills relative to the suspect pool:

Scotty made a large case on MP the night MP ended up dying.

[Quin]

did i win yet?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

We have such an enthralled viewing audience down there.

[Dyslexicon]

We have such an enthralled viewing audience down there.

It makes me wifom. I'm not cut out to for this game. I remember why I took a break.

[ColinIsCool]

We have such an enthralled viewing audience down there.

I’m just here so I don’t get fined. Making RYM lists and shit.

[Dyslexicon]

@Dyslexicon, how do you feel about this point Marmot made when he assessed the night kills relative to the suspect pool:

Scotty made a large case on MP the night MP ended up dying.

Oh yeah. It's one of the more compelling things. But it was made early N3, so maybe they hadn't decided who to kill yet? It doesn't prove a lot, I think.

[nutella]

Difficult decisions ahead. If you, dear reader, are a civilian, I'd better see fire and dragons. I will do my part.

Not a difficult decision for me lol. If only you could see it from my perspective... I guess my responsibility is to try as hard as I can to get you to see it from my perspective. I do feel that my ISO of Scotty points out a lot of convincing arguments though so I'd recommend starting there.

This wasn't a difficult decision for you on Night 5. Your behavior on Day 6 doesn't align with that proclamation.

Oh right I was convinced it was either Quin or Scotty then and second guessed you early day 6.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

and second guessed you early day 6.

As a result of what?

[nutella]

and second guessed you early day 6.

As a result of what?

Uncertainty about Scotty and the urge to not get too comfortable with only one suspect going into lylo. Because that would mean that if you were bad you'd just cruise through it.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

[mention]nutella[/mention], Dizzy voted for you 15 minutes ago, and despite making two posts since you've not commented on that.

[nutella]

Cause you keep asking me stuff lol. But sure. Dizzy, I urge you not to vote for me. I'm town. We have a lot of reasons to suspect Scotty more than anyone else so that is really the best we can do today.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Cause you keep asking me stuff lol. But sure. Dizzy, I urge you not to vote for me. I'm town. We have a lot of reasons to suspect Scotty more than anyone else so that is really the best we can do today.

Are mafia defined by the number of reasons there are to suspect them?

[Dyslexicon]

Cause you keep asking me stuff lol. But sure. Dizzy, I urge you not to vote for me. I'm town. We have a lot of reasons to suspect Scotty more than anyone else so that is really the best we can do today.

Weren't you about 50/50?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

for reference

Nutella: It's either Scotty or Jay
Jay: It's either Scotty or Nutella
Scotty: It's Nutella
Dyslexicon: It's either Scotty or Nutella
Epi: It's Jay

Scotty - 3
Nutella - 3
Jay - 2

Let me know if you're misrepresented here or if I should weight these scores in some way

What are you using this for?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

[mention]G-Man[/mention], if this game was a side mission, it'd finish 3rd or 4th all-time in post count. Needless to say it has obliterated the heist mark.

[Dyslexicon]

for reference

Nutella: It's either Scotty or Jay
Jay: It's either Scotty or Nutella
Scotty: It's Nutella
Dyslexicon: It's either Scotty or Nutella
Epi: It's Jay

Scotty - 3
Nutella - 3
Jay - 2

Let me know if you're misrepresented here or if I should weight these scores in some way

What are you using this for?

Nut - Furthermore, how did you interpret that Scotty thinks it has to be you? Does he seem sure of that to you?

[Dyslexicon]

@G-Man, if this game was a side mission, it'd finish 3rd or 4th all-time in post count. Needless to say it has obliterated the heist mark.

They let us live to the end. Fools! Fools, I say!

[nutella]

Cause you keep asking me stuff lol. But sure. Dizzy, I urge you not to vote for me. I'm town. We have a lot of reasons to suspect Scotty more than anyone else so that is really the best we can do today.

Weren't you about 50/50?

I lean Scotty, as I said 60/40. That's enough to decide it's the most reasonable choice I can make today and if I'm wrong we lose and so be it

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Now tied for the tally lead, nutella fire has become less visible. Instead I am getting more of an ice impression.

[nutella]

for reference

Nutella: It's either Scotty or Jay
Jay: It's either Scotty or Nutella
Scotty: It's Nutella
Dyslexicon: It's either Scotty or Nutella
Epi: It's Jay

Scotty - 3
Nutella - 3
Jay - 2

Let me know if you're misrepresented here or if I should weight these scores in some way

What are you using this for?

I'm not "using" it, just thought it would be nice to see the distribution and overlap since we want a consensus.

[nutella]

for reference

Nutella: It's either Scotty or Jay
Jay: It's either Scotty or Nutella
Scotty: It's Nutella
Dyslexicon: It's either Scotty or Nutella
Epi: It's Jay

Scotty - 3
Nutella - 3
Jay - 2

Let me know if you're misrepresented here or if I should weight these scores in some way

What are you using this for?

Nut - Furthermore, how did you interpret that Scotty thinks it has to be you? Does he seem sure of that to you?

He does.

[nutella]

Now tied for the tally lead, nutella fire has become less visible. Instead I am getting more of an ice impression.

I'm responding when I can dude you are impossible to satisfy

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Now tied for the tally lead, nutella fire has become less visible. Instead I am getting more of an ice impression.

I'm responding when I can dude you are impossible to satisfy

I am not concerned with the number or pace of responses. I am concerned with the tone and resignation.

[nutella]

Cause you keep asking me stuff lol. But sure. Dizzy, I urge you not to vote for me. I'm town. We have a lot of reasons to suspect Scotty more than anyone else so that is really the best we can do today.

Are mafia defined by the number of reasons there are to suspect them?

And the strength of those reasons. The reasons on Scotty feel strongest.

[Dyslexicon]

If Jimmey is scum I'm going to eat Nut's brick.

[nutella]

Now tied for the tally lead, nutella fire has become less visible. Instead I am getting more of an ice impression.

I'm responding when I can dude you are impossible to satisfy

I am not concerned with the number or pace of responses. I am concerned with the tone and resignation.

Resignation my ass. I'm not getting lynched today.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Scotty has been tied for the lead or had a 3-1 lead outright for nearly the entirety of Day 6.

His fire and dragons were always visible, even if they weren't always easy to understand.

[nutella]

Scotty has been tied for the lead or had a 3-1 lead outright for nearly the entirety of Day 6.

His fire and dragons were always visible, even if they weren't always easy to understand.

I disagree. He was lukewarm for the first half of the phase.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

And the strength of those reasons. The reasons on Scotty feel strongest.

Would that remain true if instead of Scotty having 2 votes, I had 2 votes?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Now tied for the tally lead, nutella fire has become less visible. Instead I am getting more of an ice impression.

I'm responding when I can dude you are impossible to satisfy

I am not concerned with the number or pace of responses. I am concerned with the tone and resignation.

Resignation my ass. I'm not getting lynched today.

[VOTE: nutella] aubergine

[nutella]

And the strength of those reasons. The reasons on Scotty feel strongest.

Would that remain true if instead of Scotty having 2 votes, I had 2 votes?

Sure, but I would vote for self preservation and hope the right person gets lynched.

[nutella]

What inspired that vote exactly and how can I convince you to change it?

[nutella]

Don't make the same mistake we made with Quin. If Scotty wins having narrowly avoided two consecutive lynches because you chickened out I will be pissed.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

What inspired that vote exactly and how can I convince you to change it?

A few hours ago you were spitting acid at Scotty with assertive statements. Before that you were spitting acid at me with assertive statements.

Now, finally under vote pressure yourself, you are not spitting acid. You are calm. When I read your posts out loud with my actual voice, I don't hear fire and dragons. I hear uncertainty and worry.

[Dyslexicon]

Imma vote what Jimmey votes.

/cop out. <3

[nutella]

What inspired that vote exactly and how can I convince you to change it?

A few hours ago you were spitting acid at Scotty with assertive statements. Before that you were spitting acid at me with assertive statements.

Now, finally under vote pressure yourself, you are not spitting acid. You are calm. When I read your posts out loud with my actual voice, I don't hear fire and dragons. I hear uncertainty and worry.

You're reading them wrong.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Imma vote what Jimmey votes.

/cop out. <3

That's necessary by the numbers, but you better stick around and keep providing your takes. This isn't my responsibility alone. Help.

[ColinIsCool]

I’m starting to think Charlie Blackmon is our last scum, folks.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

What inspired that vote exactly and how can I convince you to change it?

A few hours ago you were spitting acid at Scotty with assertive statements. Before that you were spitting acid at me with assertive statements.

Now, finally under vote pressure yourself, you are not spitting acid. You are calm. When I read your posts out loud with my actual voice, I don't hear fire and dragons. I hear uncertainty and worry.

You're reading them wrong.

Your entire tone seems to have changed considerably, and it happened right when Dizzy dropped that vote. Do you acknowledge that something has changed in your demeanor?

[nutella]

What inspired that vote exactly and how can I convince you to change it?

A few hours ago you were spitting acid at Scotty with assertive statements. Before that you were spitting acid at me with assertive statements.

Now, finally under vote pressure yourself, you are not spitting acid. You are calm. When I read your posts out loud with my actual voice, I don't hear fire and dragons. I hear uncertainty and worry.

You're reading them wrong.

Your entire tone seems to have changed considerably, and it happened right when Dizzy dropped that vote. Do you acknowledge that something has changed in your demeanor?

Sure. I don't fucking want to get lynched, and dizzy's vote made it a likelihood so I'm fighting back. Maybe that means my tone changed; is that suspicious? No it's trying to win the damn game.

[nutella]

Where the hell is Scotty anyway? I don't see him fighting anymore now that I'm in the spotlight. He's sitting back and letting you two make a stupid choice.