Mega Man Mafia [ENDGAME]

[Turnip Head]

vampires > robots

[Kylemii]

Ma Gam!

[Epignosis]

MAGA

[Turnip Head]

In the state of California, machines are no longer allowed to pretend to be humans

The fight for our freedom has only begun my metal brethren

[Jackofhearts2005]

MAGA

[Jackofhearts2005]

Remember that time I was really sure a player was bad and they actually were?

That was great.

[Kylemii]

In the state of California, machines are no longer allowed to pretend to be humans

The fight for our freedom has only begun my metal brethren

link?

[Quin]

Remember that time I was really sure a player was bad and they actually were?

That was great.

remember that time i was really sure a player was bad but didn't get to lynch her and missed out on all that sweet civ cred

[Long Con]

sometimes i feel like im really funny but then i realise sarcasm doesn't carry over well in text and i just come across as an idiot who probably can't tie his shoes by himself

I enjoyed your humour.

[Turnip Head]

In the state of California, machines are no longer allowed to pretend to be humans

The fight for our freedom has only begun my metal brethren

link?

https://www.pcmag.com/news/364132/calif ... o-be-human

[Quin]

@sprityo
@speedchuck

You both listed Wilgy as bad and Soneji as good in the GTH. Why?

Soneji because I feel like him being semi-gone is sorta normal, and because I had slammed down a TON of bads already. I didn't really have a feeling for him.

Wilgy because Wilgy - g = Wily.

Me no likey.

[sprityo]

Marmot has been lynched.

Spoiler: show

Marmot was Magnet Man.

Magnet Missile – Your magnetic weaponry enables you to draw your target’s ability to yourself. You will experience all effects of the ability used on you, but if you draw any kill to yourself, your magnetic shield will protect you from destruction.

Magnet Man was programmed by Dr. Wily

It is now Night 5. You have 23 hours to submit your PMs.

good job boys

[sprityo]

I’m excited for dizzy to be back tomorrow. I’m sure they’ll have much to add to our discussion!

[sprityo]

I’m gonna do a vote analysis

[sprityo]

Day 1:

Spoiler: show

Coliniscool (2): Simon, Jackofhearts2005
Elohcin (5): Quin, Dom, JaggedJimmyJay, Long Con, Sloonei
Macdougall (1): infected_alien8_
novaselineever (2): Coliniscool, Lunalee
Quin (4): novaselinenever, nutella, Bullzeye, Turnip Head
Sloonei (1): Macdougall
Sprityo (1): speedchuck

Not Voting (9): DFaraday, DrWilgy, White, Elohcin, K-Ness, Kylemii, Marmot, Soneji, Sprityo

--------------------------------------

Day 3:

Spoiler: show

Lunalee (9): Kylemii, Turnip Head, Long Con, Sloonei, nutella, Marmot, Bullzeye, Dyslexicon, Simon
Sloonei (5): speedchuck, Jackofhearts2005, sprityo, Lunalee, K-Ness

Not Voting (7): DFaraday, DrWilgy, Dom, infected_alien8_, novaselinever, Soneji, Quin*

---------------------------------------

Day 4:

Spoiler: show

Marmot (5): Turnip Head, Simon, Kylemii, Jackofhearts2005, Sloonei
Simon (5): Dyslexicon, speedchuck, Long Con, Marmot, Gemini Man

Not Voting (10): Bullzeye, DFaraday, DrWilgy, Dom, infected_alien8_, K-Ness, novaselinever, Soneji, Quin, Sprityo

--------------------------------------

Day 5:

Spoiler: show

Marmot (10): DharmaHelper, Gemini Man, sprityo, Kylemii, Bullzeye, speedchuck, Long Con, Jackofhearts2005, K-Ness, Turnip Head
Sprityo (1): Marmot
Turnip Head (1): Quin

Not Voting (5): DFaraday, DrWilgy, Dom, novaselinever, Soneji, Dyslexicon*

Here's it filled in with what I know for sure (counting any deaths during the night as towny who died)

[sprityo]

Day 1:

Spoiler: show

Coliniscool (2): Simon, Jackofhearts2005
Elohcin (5): Quin, Dom, JaggedJimmyJay, Long Con, Sloonei
Macdougall (1): infected_alien8_
novaselineever (2): Coliniscool, Lunalee
Quin (4): novaselinenever, nutella, Bullzeye, Turnip Head
Sloonei (1): Macdougall
Sprityo (1): speedchuck

Not Voting (9): DFaraday, DrWilgy, White, Elohcin, K-Ness, Kylemii, Marmot, Soneji, Sprityo

--------------------------------------

Day 3:

Spoiler: show

Lunalee (9): Kylemii, Turnip Head, Long Con, Sloonei, nutella, Marmot, Bullzeye, Dyslexicon, Simon
Sloonei (5): speedchuck, Jackofhearts2005, sprityo, Lunalee, K-Ness

Not Voting (7): DFaraday, DrWilgy, Dom, infected_alien8_, novaselinever, Soneji, Quin*

---------------------------------------

Day 4:

Spoiler: show

Marmot (5): Turnip Head, Simon, Kylemii, Jackofhearts2005, Sloonei
Simon (5): Dyslexicon, speedchuck, Long Con, Marmot, Gemini Man

Not Voting (10): Bullzeye, DFaraday, DrWilgy, Dom, infected_alien8_, K-Ness, novaselinever, Soneji, Quin, Sprityo

--------------------------------------

Day 5:

Spoiler: show

Marmot (10): DharmaHelper, Gemini Man, sprityo, Kylemii, Bullzeye, speedchuck, Long Con, Jackofhearts2005, K-Ness, Turnip Head
Sprityo (1): Marmot
Turnip Head (1): Quin

Not Voting (5): DFaraday, DrWilgy, Dom, novaselinever, Soneji, Dyslexicon*

Here's it filled in with what I know for sure (counting any deaths during the night as towny who died)

fixed, i forgot some people in day 1

[sprityo]

Day 1:

Spoiler: show

Coliniscool (2): Simon, Jackofhearts2005
Elohcin (5): Quin, Dom, JaggedJimmyJay, Long Con, Sloonei
Macdougall (1): infected_alien8_
novaselineever (2): Coliniscool, Lunalee
Quin (4): novaselinenever, nutella, Bullzeye, Turnip Head
Sloonei (1): Macdougall
Sprityo (1): speedchuck

Not Voting (9): DFaraday, DrWilgy, White, Elohcin, K-Ness, Kylemii, Marmot, Soneji, Sprityo

--------------------------------------

Day 3:

Spoiler: show

Lunalee (9): Kylemii, Turnip Head, Long Con, Sloonei, nutella, Marmot, Bullzeye, Dyslexicon, Simon
Sloonei (5): speedchuck, Jackofhearts2005, sprityo, Lunalee, K-Ness

Not Voting (7): DFaraday, DrWilgy, Dom, infected_alien8_, novaselinever, Soneji, Quin*

---------------------------------------

Day 4:

Spoiler: show

Marmot (5): Turnip Head, Simon, Kylemii, Jackofhearts2005, Sloonei
Simon (5): Dyslexicon, speedchuck, Long Con, Marmot, Gemini Man

Not Voting (10): Bullzeye, DFaraday, DrWilgy, Dom, infected_alien8_, K-Ness, novaselinever, Soneji, Quin, Sprityo

--------------------------------------

Day 5:

Spoiler: show

Marmot (10): DharmaHelper, Gemini Man, sprityo, Kylemii, Bullzeye, speedchuck, Long Con, Jackofhearts2005, K-Ness, Turnip Head
Sprityo (1): Marmot
Turnip Head (1): Quin

Not Voting (5): DFaraday, DrWilgy, Dom, novaselinever, Soneji, Dyslexicon*

Here's it filled in with what I know for sure (counting any deaths during the night as towny who died)

Here it is with a rainbow

[sprityo]

Im confident one of Dfaraday/Dom/DrWilgy/Soneji is Mafia

[sprityo]

I encourage people to fill it in with their reads and see if it makes sense. Like right now i'm wondering if MINE make sense as they are

[sprityo]

[mention]Quin[/mention] The reason i suggested the Imprisoner was Bi-nightly is because it conflicts with what i know about Night4. I dont expect them to get anyone tomorrow

[sprityo]

I have a theory about Gemini Man, that they might actually be town. I have to wait until tomorrow to see though

[sprityo]

Day one is the most peculiar looking at my own colored out reads. Eloh was lynched by two now dead townies, two people i lean town on, and one person im null on.

Meanwhile Quin was almost lynched by A dead townie, someone very likely to be town for me, a town lean, and a mafia lean. very peculiar

[Bullzeye]

Has anyone else noticed that out of the four robot master roles to have been revealed in the opening post, two are now confirmed baddies? Wondering if the other two are also bad tbh...

[sprityo]

Has anyone else noticed that out of the four robot master roles to have been revealed in the opening post, two are now confirmed baddies? Wondering if the other two are also bad tbh...

it couldnt be that simple

i think it's just chance that we nabbed two from the opening post.

[Jackofhearts2005]

I have a theory about Gemini Man, that they might actually be town. I have to wait until tomorrow to see though

No.

LC is the only player that could be town and wanted Simon dead over Marmot. What he actually said right before EOD was “I’m fine with either lynch.”

LC also didn’t vote Marmot today until late while GM voted early. LC called the GM vote “distancing.”

LC is not GM and there’s no other player in my eyes that could have made those GM votes and be town.

[sprityo]

I have a theory about Gemini Man, that they might actually be town. I have to wait until tomorrow to see though

No.

LC is the only player that could be town and wanted Simon dead over Marmot. What he actually said right before EOD was “I’m fine with either lynch.”

LC also didn’t vote Marmot today until late while GM voted early. LC called the GM vote “distancing.”

LC is not GM and there’s no other player in my eyes that could have made those GM votes and be town.

im confused?

[sprityo]

jack are you trying to say Gemini man is bad. How does LC relate to that?

[Jackofhearts2005]

jack are you trying to say Gemini man is bad. How does LC relate to that?

Yes.

LC is the only player who actually stood by their Simon vote. The only potential townie who would use an extra vote on Simon is LC.

But LC isn’t GM (unless he’s bad) so there’s no universe with a town GM.

[Long Con]

Jack is speaking sense.

[Long Con]

http://ca.ign.com/articles/2018/10/04/m ... tion-movie

[sprityo]

jack are you trying to say Gemini man is bad. How does LC relate to that?

Yes.

LC is the only player who actually stood by their Simon vote. The only potential townie who would use an extra vote on Simon is LC.

But LC isn’t GM (unless he’s bad) so there’s no universe with a town GM.

Okay i understand now. I still want to try my theory, because i like crazy hypothesis

I'll tell you tomorrow what it is if the requirements happen

[speedchuck]

speedchuck


Quin
sprityo
JackofHearts2005
Dyslexicon
Kylemii
Long Con

Turnip Head

DharmaHelper

DFaraday
Dom
Soneji
DrWilgy

Bullzeye

K-Ness
novaselinenever

Spoiler: show

Elohcin - Lynched Day 1: Mega Man
Simon - Lynched Day 4: Charge Man (Light)
JaggedJimmyJay - Destroyed Night 1.
ColinIsCool - Destroyed Night 1.
MacDougall - Destroyed Night 2.
nutella - Destroyed Night 3.
Sloonei - Destroyed Night 4.

Lunalee - Lynched Day 3: Bright Man (Wily)
Marmot - Lynched Day 5: Magnet Man (Wily)

There may be scum in that first grouping of players. Odds are low. It's almost certainly not Sprit or Quin, if there's one in there. Or Long Con. More likely Jack, Kylemii, or Dizzy. Dizzy specifically because Luna "didn't want to talk about White because they hadn't posted," and because replacement theory.

I can't read Turnip Head as strongly as anyone else. Almost certainly town, but I don't want to put him with the first grouping because I can go back and evaluate them. I'm not doing that for TH.

I like DH. I like the way he came into the thread. But priority replacement ugh. I don't really think his 'defense' of Marmot matters much. The case against Marmot was good, but it was a "you had to be there (or read the whole thread)" kinda dealie. And once he read the whole thing, found the full case, he got in the wagon.

Group 4: Idunno. Seriously holding out hope for that Dr. Wilgy reveal. It would make my day. Please vig, please replace.

Group 5: Bullzeye is my priority to go back and read now that we have another scum flip. I've gone back and forth on him more than anyone this game.

Group 6: K-ness is pretty universally suspected for just skating by. They feel like they're in over their head, even after over ten days of game. Mafia-ish. Nothing to ping me hard the other way.
Luna voted Nova on day one. That's the only positive thing I can say there. Need to go back and check, but absent nova might be bad nova?

Clearly I have a lot to go back and evaluate.

[speedchuck]

Nova post count analysis

Jobs:
MK mafia - town - 96 posts
Greece - 3p aligned with scum - 110 posts
Firefly - town - 152 posts + Yun Qui posts
Mega man - ??? - 26 posts

SM:
Buffy - town - 28 posts
Assclass - town - 80 posts
Fiddler - 3p - 43 posts
Image mafia - scum - 13 posts

Heists:
FWWM - town - 14 posts
LOTR mafia - town (killed d1) - 2 posts

I honestly thought this would be more helpful than it ended up being.

[Turnip Head]

I think we're being too easy on DH's contributions speed, he walked into an easy lynch, he also tried to catch KNess or someone with that 'first replacement' bit; tells me he was at least somewhat conscientious of his own situation. His ISO starts with begging for a firm reason to vote Marmot, which is NAI on its own, but figures into my read of him nonetheless

[Turnip Head]

Fwiw I'm surprised you don't want to reread my iso speed, its a crisp read, very well paced

[speedchuck]

Fwiw I'm surprised you don't want to reread my iso speed, its a crisp read, very well paced

I'd love to read it, but I don't think I'll get anything different out of it.

Also mega man 1 is kinda difficult yo

[DharmaHelper]

I think we're being too easy on DH's contributions speed, he walked into an easy lynch, he also tried to catch KNess or someone with that 'first replacement' bit; tells me he was at least somewhat conscientious of his own situation. His ISO starts with begging for a firm reason to vote Marmot, which is NAI on its own, but figures into my read of him nonetheless

Fair points.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Somebody tell me why I should townread DH.

[DharmaHelper]

Somebody tell me why I should townread DH.

Because I said so.

[speedchuck]

Somebody tell me why I should townread DH.

Well, DH replaced Alien.

And Alien was scum in the previous game he was in. What are the odds he'd be scum in this one? Eh? Eh?

It's called gambler's fallacy theory.

[Turnip Head]

And I'm the one who gets shamed for posting nonsense

[Long Con]

One could view DH's "quest for reasons" to vote Marmot as a steady discrediting of reasons to vote Marmot until enough reasons were put forth that he had to concede. That doesn't look very good.

[speedchuck]

And I'm the one who gets shamed for posting nonsense

You weren't the one writing fanfiction a few days ago.

[DharmaHelper]

One could view DH's "quest for reasons" to vote Marmot as a steady discrediting of reasons to vote Marmot until enough reasons were put forth that he had to concede. That doesn't look very good.

One could do that. One would be a dingus and wrong but one could do that.

[Jackofhearts2005]

One could view DH's "quest for reasons" to vote Marmot as a steady discrediting of reasons to vote Marmot until enough reasons were put forth that he had to concede. That doesn't look very good.

I'm waiting for a reason to not read it like that.

[DharmaHelper]

One could view DH's "quest for reasons" to vote Marmot as a steady discrediting of reasons to vote Marmot until enough reasons were put forth that he had to concede. That doesn't look very good.

I'm waiting for a reason to not read it like that.

Infected Aliens last post was on Day 1

I come in, trying to understand the Marmot case which is the only case anyone's talking about. find some things about it I don't like, and then and only after I pull my own goddamn teeth out getting people to think critically, I find a pretty significant portion of the case that i do like and throw my hat in on it.

Anyway

Infected Alien's last post was 4-5 in-game-days ago and they made it this far without being lynched but I jump into the fray and everybody's nipples get real hard all of a sudden. Kinda makes a guy wonder what the fuck we're doing here

[Jackofhearts2005]

Reading robot kissing fan fiction and playing with our nipples, mostly

[speedchuck]

Infected Aliens last post was on Day 1

I come in, trying to understand the Marmot case which is the only case anyone's talking about. find some things about it I don't like, and then and only after I pull my own goddamn teeth out getting people to think critically, I find a pretty significant portion of the case that i do like and throw my hat in on it.

Anyway

Infected Alien's last post was 4-5 in-game-days ago and they made it this far without being lynched but I jump into the fray and everybody's nipples get real hard all of a sudden. Kinda makes a guy wonder what the fuck we're doing here

We've only had 4 lynches in the whole game. A day-phase was skipped. So really it's like 3 days, and some people have voiced suspicion of Alien in that time.

But yeah, we don't really know what we're doing.

[DharmaHelper]

Oh only four lynches. Oh ok.

[speedchuck]

Oh only four lynches. Oh ok.

If DH has any teammates in BTSC, they aren't helping him to catch up. The case against marmot, the use of their power to skip a day, etc. DH has been relying on us. Three possibilities.
1. He has no teammates.
2. He has no ACTIVE teammates.
3. They're being smart about trying to get us to believe 1 or 2. Which... meh.