Hogwarts Mafia - END

[DharmaHelper]

I already shared my why's.

oh, so they are back somewhere in your iso. ok cool.

Ok I went back to the point where you brought up your Hufflepuff idea but the only person you mentioned any suspicion of in Hufflepuff is Sloonei. You were asked twice who you thought was bad and you said you'd tell us today. You've done that but I cannot find reasons. Can you point me to the post where you explained your poutanko suspicion? I just don't have time to go back even further in your ISO.

I didn't. I don't currently have a reason to suspect Poutanko, because I haven't read their posts.

ok so your suspicions are based on believing there is a scum in Hufflepuff and those are the people you have left after ruling out the others. Thats my assumption out of this anyway.

[nutella]

DH you think we started with 5:1 town:scum? But like it's not just that you're spewing out random unrelated bullshit all over the place, aren't contributing actually productive reads, and are evading direct questions and requests for poe lists. if you want town to solve the game you gotta do better.

[DharmaHelper]

DH you think we started with 5:1 town:scum? But like it's not just that you're spewing out random unrelated bullshit all over the place, aren't contributing actually productive reads, and are evading direct questions and requests for poe lists. if you want town to solve the game you gotta do better.

I dunno what you mean.

[nutella]

Picking out reasons to say "funny how x player did this thing that I already pointed out 6 times huh wild" about every single player isn't helpful, you gotta give them some weight to determine who you think is actually more or less likely scum.

[nutella]

Also give Jay a goddamn 7 name poe for the last time

[Sloonei]

DH you think we started with 5:1 town:scum? But like it's not just that you're spewing out random unrelated bullshit all over the place, aren't contributing actually productive reads, and are evading direct questions and requests for poe lists. if you want town to solve the game you gotta do better.

I dunno what you mean.

You promised updated reads the other day. Now you’ve reverted back to “hufflepuff = bad”. Ignore houses and catch bad guys.

[DharmaHelper]

Also give Jay a goddamn 7 name poe for the last time

Why do I owe Jay that?

[DharmaHelper]

DH you think we started with 5:1 town:scum? But like it's not just that you're spewing out random unrelated bullshit all over the place, aren't contributing actually productive reads, and are evading direct questions and requests for poe lists. if you want town to solve the game you gotta do better.

I dunno what you mean.

You promised updated reads the other day. Now you’ve reverted back to “hufflepuff = bad”. Ignore houses and catch bad guys.

I did other shit instead. Today I'm watching Outlaw King and maybe playing some games later.

[Jackofhearts2005]

What the hell is a Hufflepuff

[nutella]

Also give Jay a goddamn 7 name poe for the last time

Why do I owe Jay that?

You owe it to the entire town faction. Three Hufflepuffs as a poe isn't going to cut it at this stage of the game.

[Jackofhearts2005]

DH, you are ruining the spreadsheet.

[DharmaHelper]

Picking out reasons to say "funny how x player did this thing that I already pointed out 6 times huh wild" about every single player isn't helpful, you gotta give them some weight to determine who you think is actually more or less likely scum.

I dunno Nutella I think I've made some good points IDK why you think that's useless.

[DharmaHelper]

DH, you are ruining the spreadsheet.

I dunno what that means.

[Jackofhearts2005]

DH, you are ruining the spreadsheet.

I dunno what that means.

You’re never going to make it in the corporate wizarding world.

[DharmaHelper]

Also give Jay a goddamn 7 name poe for the last time

Why do I owe Jay that?

You owe it to the entire town faction. Three Hufflepuffs as a poe isn't going to cut it at this stage of the game.

I don't owe anybody anything I think.

[DharmaHelper]

7 names is a lot for POE I don't think thats how POE works.

[DharmaHelper]

ColinIsCool
Speedchuck 2.0
Sloonei
poutanko
Lunalee
MacDougall
nutella
Quin
sprityo



Here's your totally useful and completely worthwhile and not at all pointless list of names you wanted. Can we actually hunt baddies now?

[nutella]

Picking out reasons to say "funny how x player did this thing that I already pointed out 6 times huh wild" about every single player isn't helpful, you gotta give them some weight to determine who you think is actually more or less likely scum.

I dunno Nutella I think I've made some good points IDK why you think that's useless.

It's useless to repeat yourself multiple times, to call someone out for something and then give no indication that you suspect then or indicate that you think they're town, to give no relative weight to the various things you are pointing out.

[nutella]

Yeah let's please actually hunt baddies. Also that's 9.

[DharmaHelper]

Picking out reasons to say "funny how x player did this thing that I already pointed out 6 times huh wild" about every single player isn't helpful, you gotta give them some weight to determine who you think is actually more or less likely scum.

I dunno Nutella I think I've made some good points IDK why you think that's useless.

It's useless to repeat yourself multiple times, to call someone out for something and then give no indication that you suspect then or indicate that you think they're town, to give no relative weight to the various things you are pointing out.

So like a PoE list lol

[DharmaHelper]

Yeah let's please actually hunt baddies. Also that's 9.

I'm an overachiever lol got em

[nutella]

Gimme your detailed thoughts on Colin. Go

[nutella]

Picking out reasons to say "funny how x player did this thing that I already pointed out 6 times huh wild" about every single player isn't helpful, you gotta give them some weight to determine who you think is actually more or less likely scum.

I dunno Nutella I think I've made some good points IDK why you think that's useless.

It's useless to repeat yourself multiple times, to call someone out for something and then give no indication that you suspect then or indicate that you think they're town, to give no relative weight to the various things you are pointing out.

So like a PoE list lol

Sorry what? I don't follow.

[DharmaHelper]

Gimme your detailed thoughts on Colin. Go

Why tho

[nutella]

DH is like 12 pass it on


...oh wait we are all in a school for 11-17 year olds fuck

[ColinIsCool]

Gimme your detailed thoughts on Colin. Go

He does his best, and isn’t that what counts?

[juliets]

Gimme your detailed thoughts on Colin. Go

Why tho

Because discussion of candidates for scum is what helps the town find the bad guys.

[DharmaHelper]

Gimme your detailed thoughts on Colin. Go

Why tho

Because discussion of candidates for scum is what helps the town find the bad guys.

OK But why me tho and why Colin tho I very clearly stated who I suspect and why much earlier and much more often. Forcing me to make up shit just because "Honka Tonka Spreadsheet" or whatever the fuck isn't going to do anyone any favors.

[DharmaHelper]

I caught LC you guys catch the next one lol

[juliets]

Gimme your detailed thoughts on Colin. Go

Why tho

Because discussion of candidates for scum is what helps the town find the bad guys.

OK But why me tho and why Colin tho I very clearly stated who I suspect and why much earlier and much more often. Forcing me to make up shit just because "Honka Tonka Spreadsheet" or whatever the fuck isn't going to do anyone any favors.

I think nutella just took the one at the top of the list, no other reason. Start wherever you want.

[DharmaHelper]

Gimme your detailed thoughts on Colin. Go

Why tho

Because discussion of candidates for scum is what helps the town find the bad guys.

OK But why me tho and why Colin tho I very clearly stated who I suspect and why much earlier and much more often. Forcing me to make up shit just because "Honka Tonka Spreadsheet" or whatever the fuck isn't going to do anyone any favors.

I think nutella just took the one at the top of the list, no other reason. Start wherever you want.

OK. I don't want to start anywhere so I will do that.

[juliets]

Gimme your detailed thoughts on Colin. Go

Why tho

Because discussion of candidates for scum is what helps the town find the bad guys.

OK But why me tho and why Colin tho I very clearly stated who I suspect and why much earlier and much more often. Forcing me to make up shit just because "Honka Tonka Spreadsheet" or whatever the fuck isn't going to do anyone any favors.

I think nutella just took the one at the top of the list, no other reason. Start wherever you want.

OK. I don't want to start anywhere so I will do that.

You have really let Mac and Jay do a number on you.

[DharmaHelper]

Gimme your detailed thoughts on Colin. Go

Why tho

Because discussion of candidates for scum is what helps the town find the bad guys.

OK But why me tho and why Colin tho I very clearly stated who I suspect and why much earlier and much more often. Forcing me to make up shit just because "Honka Tonka Spreadsheet" or whatever the fuck isn't going to do anyone any favors.

I think nutella just took the one at the top of the list, no other reason. Start wherever you want.

OK. I don't want to start anywhere so I will do that.

You have really let Mac and Jay do a number on you.

Have I?

[nutella]

I caught LC you guys catch the next one lol

This is never the correct mindset.

[nutella]

FTR juliets is wrong I have my own reasons for asking about Colin. I'm very curious.

[DharmaHelper]

FTR juliets is wrong I have my own reasons for asking about Colin. I'm very curious.

Hello very curious I'm Negan.

[juliets]

Why tho

Because discussion of candidates for scum is what helps the town find the bad guys.

OK But why me tho and why Colin tho I very clearly stated who I suspect and why much earlier and much more often. Forcing me to make up shit just because "Honka Tonka Spreadsheet" or whatever the fuck isn't going to do anyone any favors.

I think nutella just took the one at the top of the list, no other reason. Start wherever you want.

OK. I don't want to start anywhere so I will do that.

You have really let Mac and Jay do a number on you.

Have I?

I believe so but there is no point discussing it.

linki nutella - sorry nut it just looked like you started at the beginning. Tbh I'd like to hear about Colin too.

[DharmaHelper]

Because discussion of candidates for scum is what helps the town find the bad guys.

OK But why me tho and why Colin tho I very clearly stated who I suspect and why much earlier and much more often. Forcing me to make up shit just because "Honka Tonka Spreadsheet" or whatever the fuck isn't going to do anyone any favors.

I think nutella just took the one at the top of the list, no other reason. Start wherever you want.

OK. I don't want to start anywhere so I will do that.

You have really let Mac and Jay do a number on you.

Have I?

I believe so but there is no point discussing it.

linki nutella - sorry nut it just looked like you started at the beginning. Tbh I'd like to hear about Colin too.

If there's no point in discussing it why'd you bring it up :P

If you wanna hear about Colin, talk about Colin. I'm Not Colin. I'm also not interested in making up shit to please nutella or anyone else. I'll suspect who I suspect and you guys do what you want to do.

[nutella]

I'm not asking you to make anything up. I'm asking you to summarize your thoughts on one player.

[DharmaHelper]

I'm not asking you to make anything up. I'm asking you to summarize your thoughts on one player.

I could do that later if I feel like it.

[juliets]

OK But why me tho and why Colin tho I very clearly stated who I suspect and why much earlier and much more often. Forcing me to make up shit just because "Honka Tonka Spreadsheet" or whatever the fuck isn't going to do anyone any favors.

I think nutella just took the one at the top of the list, no other reason. Start wherever you want.

OK. I don't want to start anywhere so I will do that.

You have really let Mac and Jay do a number on you.

Have I?

I believe so but there is no point discussing it.

linki nutella - sorry nut it just looked like you started at the beginning. Tbh I'd like to hear about Colin too.

If there's no point in discussing it why'd you bring it up :P

If you wanna hear about Colin, talk about Colin. I'm Not Colin. I'm also not interested in making up shit to please nutella or anyone else. I'll suspect who I suspect and you guys do what you want to do.

I brought it up because I want you to shake it off and return to your normal town game. I'm sure you'll tell me this IS your normal town game so I'll just say it for you.

[juliets]

So, I'll say regarding Colin that the reason I'm seeing him as town is because of the cop check. So if people thing poutanko is lying its of interest to me why that would be (which is how the whole DH conversation started). If there are reasons to consider Colin as scum, I'd like to discuss those too.

[juliets]

Also I think I've overdosed on speed and Quin things so I'm ready to talk about something else.

[speedchuck]

Also I think I've overdosed on speed and Quin things so I'm ready to talk about something else.

Am I not entertaining enough for you?

[Sloonei]

So, I'll say regarding Colin that the reason I'm seeing him as town is because of the cop check. So if people thing poutanko is lying its of interest to me why that would be (which is how the whole DH conversation started). If there are reasons to consider Colin as scum, I'd like to discuss those too.

My concern would be less that poutanko is lyinf, and more that their divinations were interfered with/redirected somehow.

If it were day right now I’d be voting for speedchuck again, if you want any indication of where I stand on poutanko’s claim

[Sloonei]

Also I think I've overdosed on speed and Quin things so I'm ready to talk about something else.

Sprityo and karavalenge: who are they? What do they know? Do they know things? Let’s find put.

[juliets]

Also I think I've overdosed on speed and Quin things so I'm ready to talk about something else.

Am I not entertaining enough for you?

haha you are but I can't think about that night action puzzle between you and Quin anymore today! Unless someone comes up with a brainstorm.

linki yes @Sloonei I should have put that more as a "lying or redirected" thought. Thanks for your thoughts.

Also linki ok I'll look at sprityo first since it will be pretty easy I think

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Here's your totally useful and completely worthwhile and not at all pointless list of names you wanted. Can we actually hunt baddies now?

Remember that time you did nothing all game and I had to win for you by doing things my way?

[juliets]

so the post that sticks out to me about sprityo is one that has come up before - this one:

Yeah pretty much

Ok I'm asking you all these questions because it's extremely important that you give us some thoughts of where you stand on things. Right now you are sorted into the POE mostly because you haven't participated much and we don't know where you stand on whose good or bad or any other thing going on in the thread. I know you really didn't want to play this game but now that you're here why not share some thoughts?

That’s the thing Juliets I don’t have many thoughts

Why do I need to participate when there’s perfectly capable people who can? It’s not like megaman where I needed to step up to the plate. Jay and Mac and DH are all strong enough.

If I wanted to start anywhere it would be confirming them as good or bad, but that in itself is a monumental task

Mafia are playing hard mode keeping all three alive. Is there a reason for that?

Now I have no trouble believing that a scum sprityo would lay low but as someone else brought up, would a scum sprityo say what he says here? Why participate when there are others who are doing it? And he says he doesn't need to step up to the plate. That's pretty gutsy for a scum to say, yet I still feel like his lack of participating reads bad.

@sprityo what I'm going to say to you is YES, you do need to step up to the plate and help us solve this game. Get your hands dirty - the only people who understand what's happening are the mafia so don't worry about looking foolish - just play!

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Spoiler: show

@nutella, if you take 5 or 6 of the slots below, I will take the rest. You can choose yourself or I can hand them out, whatever. Thanks again for helping.