Hogwarts Mafia - END

[Jackofhearts2005]

@nutella
Why are you voting Kara instead of Pout?

[juliets]

Wait, don't disregard. I'm wondering the same thing. I missed the logic for speed being killed by the mafia. So Jay was vigged?

It was covered in the two posts after the one I quoted.

oh, I was looking for the logic - I thought this came up earlier from someone with logic but I guess not

[juliets]

sloonei I am tempted to vote sprityo too but his total lack of anything seems almost too bold for a baddie. I mean he openly isn't trying at all. What convinced you to vote for him? Sorry if you already answered.

[nutella]

@nutella
Why are you voting Kara instead of Pout?

I'm torn between them. I guess they could both be bad but I'm less sure of pout still.

[nutella]

Colin and poutanko are our scum who's with me

If you were going to fake claim cop would you say “My teammate is town. This innocent person is scum”?

You’d mix truth with a lie. Colin really is town. Speed isn’t actually scum.

I might do this because I like to fuck with things like the rule of 3 or “he wouldn’t say this about his teammate” but I don’t think most people would do this.

Are the Pout suspicions more coming from the Colin suspicions or vice versa?

Yeah I guess.

[Lunalee]

Here is my gut-town "player salad." Based off what I've seen from these players, I'm town reading them, and wouldn't mind a lynch of anyone not on this list:
DharamaHelper
juliets
karavalenge
nutella
Quin
Sloonei
Timmer

[nutella]

Uuuuugghhhh this is hard

[Sloonei]

sloonei I am tempted to vote sprityo too but his total lack of anything seems almost too bold for a baddie. I mean he openly isn't trying at all. What convinced you to vote for him? Sorry if you already answered.

I’m simply not dissuaded by his lack of activity. I don’t suspect him purely for being inactive, but to me he seems to be wielding his inactive status as a defense mechanism, rather than trying to do anything productive with his time in the thread.

I’d offer more insight but I’m currently walking to class.

[nutella]

Here is my gut-town "player salad." Based off what I've seen from these players, I'm town reading them, and wouldn't mind a lynch of anyone not on this list:
DharamaHelper
juliets
karavalenge
nutella
Quin
Sloonei
Timmer

Why is Kara there

I somehow get quin and sloonei being on there but why kara

[Jackofhearts2005]

@nutella
Why are you voting Kara instead of Pout?

I'm torn between them. I guess they could both be bad but I'm less sure of pout still.

What's the case on Kara? I isoed you for mentions of Kara and you've got neutral statements and vague negative statements. You just kinda declare her bad and now are more sure on her than Pout.

I know why you suspect Pout. I have no idea why you suspect Kara.

[juliets]

sloonei I am tempted to vote sprityo too but his total lack of anything seems almost too bold for a baddie. I mean he openly isn't trying at all. What convinced you to vote for him? Sorry if you already answered.

I’m simply not dissuaded by his lack of activity. I don’t suspect him purely for being inactive, but to me he seems to be wielding his inactive status as a defense mechanism, rather than trying to do anything productive with his time in the thread.

I’d offer more insight but I’m currently walking to class.

ah yes that does seem like what he's doing. I didn't think about it that way. When you're not walking, driving or studying I'd love to hear the rest of your thoughts.

[nutella]

@nutella
Why are you voting Kara instead of Pout?

I'm torn between them. I guess they could both be bad but I'm less sure of pout still.

What's the case on Kara? I isoed you for mentions of Kara and you've got neutral statements and vague negative statements. You just kinda declare her bad and now are more sure on her than Pout.

I know why you suspect Pout. I have no idea why you suspect Kara.

You must have somehow missed my big long post about Kara and speed in which I argue for Kara being scum regardless of speed's alignment. The main point is what was the motivation for flooing speed, seems like scum trying to get info.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Here is my gut-town "player salad." Based off what I've seen from these players, I'm town reading them, and wouldn't mind a lynch of anyone not on this list:
DharamaHelper
juliets
karavalenge
nutella
Quin
Sloonei
Timmer

There are accusations that Timmer's not actually a vigilante. Tell me your thoughts on this and generally why Timmer is a townread.

[nutella]

Also I recommend just taking your own skim through Kara's iso, I think they look pretty generally compatible with the previously confirmed scum.

[Jackofhearts2005]

@nutella
Why are you voting Kara instead of Pout?

I'm torn between them. I guess they could both be bad but I'm less sure of pout still.

What's the case on Kara? I isoed you for mentions of Kara and you've got neutral statements and vague negative statements. You just kinda declare her bad and now are more sure on her than Pout.

I know why you suspect Pout. I have no idea why you suspect Kara.

You must have somehow missed my big long post about Kara and speed in which I argue for Kara being scum regardless of speed's alignment. The main point is what was the motivation for flooing speed, seems like scum trying to get info.

And yet Jay and Speed are dead, which implies the mafia neither killed no imperioed the vigilante. Wouldn't this imply that Kara is not scum?

[nutella]

@nutella
Why are you voting Kara instead of Pout?

I'm torn between them. I guess they could both be bad but I'm less sure of pout still.

What's the case on Kara? I isoed you for mentions of Kara and you've got neutral statements and vague negative statements. You just kinda declare her bad and now are more sure on her than Pout.

I know why you suspect Pout. I have no idea why you suspect Kara.

You must have somehow missed my big long post about Kara and speed in which I argue for Kara being scum regardless of speed's alignment. The main point is what was the motivation for flooing speed, seems like scum trying to get info.

And yet Jay and Speed are dead, which implies the mafia neither killed no imperioed the vigilante. Wouldn't this imply that Kara is not scum?

[Jackofhearts2005]

sloonei I am tempted to vote sprityo too but his total lack of anything seems almost too bold for a baddie. I mean he openly isn't trying at all. What convinced you to vote for him? Sorry if you already answered.

I’m simply not dissuaded by his lack of activity. I don’t suspect him purely for being inactive, but to me he seems to be wielding his inactive status as a defense mechanism, rather than trying to do anything productive with his time in the thread.

I’d offer more insight but I’m currently walking to class.

You're not wrong but didn't you say you have no reads because you haven't read last day phase?

[Sloonei]

Here is my gut-town "player salad." Based off what I've seen from these players, I'm town reading them, and wouldn't mind a lynch of anyone not on this list:
DharamaHelper
juliets
karavalenge
nutella
Quin
Sloonei
Timmer

There are accusations that Timmer's not actually a vigilante. Tell me your thoughts on this and generally why Timmer is a townread.

I’m still unclear on the order of events with timmer’s claim. He was both blocked and (allegedly) arresto’d by Quin night 1, then killed INH(?) Night 2, and has done no killing since then?

[nutella]

Maybe they wanted the vig to kill speed anyway. Again maybe to throw us off the trail especially if quin is innocent.

[Jackofhearts2005]

@nutella
Why are you voting Kara instead of Pout?

I'm torn between them. I guess they could both be bad but I'm less sure of pout still.

What's the case on Kara? I isoed you for mentions of Kara and you've got neutral statements and vague negative statements. You just kinda declare her bad and now are more sure on her than Pout.

I know why you suspect Pout. I have no idea why you suspect Kara.

You must have somehow missed my big long post about Kara and speed in which I argue for Kara being scum regardless of speed's alignment. The main point is what was the motivation for flooing speed, seems like scum trying to get info.

And yet Jay and Speed are dead, which implies the mafia neither killed no imperioed the vigilante. Wouldn't this imply that Kara is not scum?

The way this works is that you're supposed to admit I'm right and change your opinion or you're supposed to tell me why I'm wrong and maintain yours.

Linki: There you go.

[Sloonei]

sloonei I am tempted to vote sprityo too but his total lack of anything seems almost too bold for a baddie. I mean he openly isn't trying at all. What convinced you to vote for him? Sorry if you already answered.

I’m simply not dissuaded by his lack of activity. I don’t suspect him purely for being inactive, but to me he seems to be wielding his inactive status as a defense mechanism, rather than trying to do anything productive with his time in the thread.

I’d offer more insight but I’m currently walking to class.

You're not wrong but didn't you say you have no reads because you haven't read last day phase?

Several days ago, yeah, and I said so while actively trying to develop my own reads. I’ve seen none of that from sprit.

Also I reserve the right to be as big a hypocrite as I want to be if I have an earnest suspicion.

[Lunalee]

Here is my gut-town "player salad." Based off what I've seen from these players, I'm town reading them, and wouldn't mind a lynch of anyone not on this list:
DharamaHelper
juliets
karavalenge
nutella
Quin
Sloonei
Timmer

Why is Kara there

I somehow get quin and sloonei being on there but why kara

Kara feels genuine. He got frustrated at earlier suspicions, and wrote a long post about it that didn't seem like something a scum would write.

[Lunalee]

Here is my gut-town "player salad." Based off what I've seen from these players, I'm town reading them, and wouldn't mind a lynch of anyone not on this list:
DharamaHelper
juliets
karavalenge
nutella
Quin
Sloonei
Timmer

There are accusations that Timmer's not actually a vigilante. Tell me your thoughts on this and generally why Timmer is a townread.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but don't vigilantes usually align with town? Just the majority of scum kills early on happened during the night, which looks like the vig was on our side.

[ColinIsCool]

If timmer isn’t the vig, why wouldn’t a real vig kill him for obviously lying/taking credit?

[Lunalee]

@nutella
Why are you voting Kara instead of Pout?

I'm torn between them. I guess they could both be bad but I'm less sure of pout still.

What's the case on Kara? I isoed you for mentions of Kara and you've got neutral statements and vague negative statements. You just kinda declare her bad and now are more sure on her than Pout.

I know why you suspect Pout. I have no idea why you suspect Kara.

You must have somehow missed my big long post about Kara and speed in which I argue for Kara being scum regardless of speed's alignment. The main point is what was the motivation for flooing speed, seems like scum trying to get info.

Kara is new to the syndicate, but actually knows speed irl. Makes since to me that he would pick speed to chat with.

[nutella]

Man I can't help but imagine both speed and jay tossing around in their graves screaming at us to just lunch quin

[Lunalee]

Man I can't help but imagine both speed and jay tossing around in their graves screaming at us to just lunch quin

No thanks. I packed my lunch today.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

This game got violent fast.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Here is my gut-town "player salad." Based off what I've seen from these players, I'm town reading them, and wouldn't mind a lynch of anyone not on this list:
DharamaHelper
juliets
karavalenge
nutella
Quin
Sloonei
Timmer

There are accusations that Timmer's not actually a vigilante. Tell me your thoughts on this and generally why Timmer is a townread.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but don't vigilantes usually align with town? Just the majority of scum kills early on happened during the night, which looks like the vig was on our side.

They do. They also usually kill people and Timmer has not killed anyone or been nightkilled and there hasn't been an obviously misdirected vig kill either. It's Day 5. Timmer claimed iirc Day 2.

If timmer isn’t the vig, why wouldn’t a real vig kill him for obviously lying/taking credit?

1) Cause Timmer really is the vig.
2) Cause there's a high chance of multiple vigs and so the vig is hesitant to kill Timmer.
3) Cause there are more consensus scum out there than hunches Timmer is lying like LC and Speedzeye.

I personally can't tell you anything Timmer has done all game besides claim vig because I've just assumed Timmer is town for claiming vig. I get the feeling a lot of people have been doing the same.

[Jackofhearts2005]

It occurs to me that it would be really stupid to falseclaim vigilante on D2 in a game where you expect there to be multiple vigilantes. Like asking to get shot. He's not even doing stuff like having the scum kill suspected players and claim that he killed them.

This is more likely a player not used to games with claiming/this much madness struggling with the mechanics (ie the correct time to claim vigilante in this setup) than a goon trying to set up a reason to not be suspected.

[Jackofhearts2005]

7 player poe
Chuck
Quin
Luna
Kara
Sprityo
Colin
Pou

Spoiler: show

To be continued.

[ColinIsCool]

DharmaHelper, I know you've been persistently commenting about Owner lying/suspicions of them and Sloonei, etc. Why is your vote on Quin?

[juliets]

@nutella I can only say I see a way that Quin is not bad. I can't guarantee it. And as long as I see that chance that he's not bad (and its not something all convoluted) I won't vote him because I don't see the rest of his behavior in a bad light.

[juliets]

I'm going to go ahead and vote spirityo but @Sloonei I'd still like to hear your additional thoughts.

[DharmaHelper]

DharmaHelper, I know you've been persistently commenting about Owner lying/suspicions of them and Sloonei, etc. Why is your vote on Quin?

I dunno.

[timmer]

I’m still unclear on the order of events with timmer’s claim. He was both blocked and (allegedly) arresto’d by Quin night 1, then killed INH(?) Night 2, and has done no killing since then?

I haven't successfully killed a single person all game. INH wasn't me, there should be an even night version of me who handled that.

[timmer]

You must have somehow missed my big long post about Kara and speed in which I argue for Kara being scum regardless of speed's alignment. The main point is what was the motivation for flooing speed, seems like scum trying to get info.

I don't get this, or at least I don't get as a big enough reason to actually suspect someone.

I'm civ. I was trusting speedchuck. If I had floo powder, there is a good chance I'd have picked speed to chat with, as well.

[juliets]

I’m still unclear on the order of events with timmer’s claim. He was both blocked and (allegedly) arresto’d by Quin night 1, then killed INH(?) Night 2, and has done no killing since then?

I haven't successfully killed a single person all game. INH wasn't me, there should be an even night version of me who handled that.

So who killed Nova night 1? I guess it's not worth worrying about but I had assumed it was you all this time.

[poutanko]

Epi kill:
Juliet: Why did the maf kill Epi? That's so random.
Luna: Hey, maybe it's someone he sussed, let's take a look!

Jay kill:
Juliet & Luna: Let's talk about something else.

@juliets @Lunalee Why is this different treatment? What will be accomplished by talking about Epi kill? Why no one talk about Jay kill when:
>Jay is a big fish
>Speed watched Jay and LC visited him N1 (cop? block?)
>Jay survived until D4
>Suddenly killed N4
If talking about who's getting killed by scum could accomplish something, isn't talking about Jay kill will bear more fruit than Epi? You two talked about Epi but not about Jay. Why?

[timmer]

So who killed Nova night 1? I guess it's not worth worrying about but I had assumed it was you all this time.

JJJ said he blocked me, though, and he was civ, so I doubt he was lying. And I never targeted Nova.

[juliets]

Because I can see exactly why Jay was killed. He was supatowning. Epi was not supatowning, he was in the background though he was participating. The Jay kill was not a surprise - the Epi kill was. I never said "let's talk about something else". I think it's good to look at who Jay suspected in the last day and night, I just haven't done it yet.

[poutanko]

Because I can see exactly why Jay was killed. He was supatowning. Epi was not supatowning, he was in the background though he was participating. The Jay kill was not a surprise - the Epi kill was. I never said "let's talk about something else". I think it's good to look at who Jay suspected in the last day and night, I just haven't done it yet.

Was not a surprise, yes. But why now? Why not earlier if he's a supatown? That timing alone is weird enough and should be talked

[timmer]

Moved my vote to sloonei. The Owner suspicion has been there since day fucking 1, and Long Con SAVED Owner...

[juliets]

So who killed Nova night 1? I guess it's not worth worrying about but I had assumed it was you all this time.

JJJ said he blocked me, though, and he was civ, so I doubt he was lying. And I never targeted Nova.

oh right I forgot Jay said that. Did you target someone else? You don't have to tell me who. If you did do you have any reason why they didn't die? If you are the odd night big I imagine they are blocking you ever odd night at this point but I don't get why they would do that night 1, unless they were just lucky.

[juliets]

Because I can see exactly why Jay was killed. He was supatowning. Epi was not supatowning, he was in the background though he was participating. The Jay kill was not a surprise - the Epi kill was. I never said "let's talk about something else". I think it's good to look at who Jay suspected in the last day and night, I just haven't done it yet.

Was not a surprise, yes. But why now? Why not earlier if he's a supatown? That timing alone is weird enough and should be talked

Well my guess is the other people they killed were higher priority though I don't know why Epi beat out Jay for being killed.

Gone to eat dinner, will be back.

[Sloonei]

Moved my vote to sloonei. The Owner suspicion has been there since day fucking 1, and Long Con SAVED Owner...

Has anything happened since Day 1 that I can talk about? I’m not public enemy #1 or anything, but it’s irritating that there is a nagging suspicion about me which pre-exists my participation in the game.

[poutanko]

Didn't Timmer claim to target Bullz N1?

[timmer]

Didn't Timmer claim to target Bullz N1?

Yes, I tried to off Bullz night 1.

[timmer]

Has anything happened since Day 1 that I can talk about? I’m not public enemy #1 or anything, but it’s irritating that there is a nagging suspicion about me which pre-exists my participation in the game.

Long Con saved you in a lynch. You are one of three people from the one house where we haven't found a baddie yet. Owner's day 1 play was suspish. And you have kind of even-keeled/steady-as-she-goe'd since taking over, participating but not sticking your neck out. AndI didn't like the night action dump earlier, though that is more minor.

[poutanko]

Didn't Timmer claim to target Bullz N1?

Yes, I tried to off Bullz night 1.

@_@ so we have 2 odd night vigs or there's an SK (but write up indicated nothing). We had 2 kills N1, could it be another Hippo? But there are 3 N2 if it's Hippo.