ColinIsCool wrote: ↑Fri Nov 16, 2018 6:48 pm
If you are a town vig you should vig me tonight. This is not a trick. Don’t waste the lynch on me.
This isn't productive. Not pro town by the numbers, and stating stuff like this openly at the beginning of night just invites scum to do something screwy in their favor. Better for you to actually try to convince us of your townieness. I still think it could be Luna and I even think there's a crazy possible world in which DH pulled a Firefly Golden on all our asses (but Jesus DH I swear to fuck mountain if that's the case I'm gonna.... )
I really do not know what else I can do to convince anybody of anything and even if I did I don’t have the time. Either you believe me or you don’t and I’ve done what I can about it.
ColinIsCool wrote: ↑Fri Nov 16, 2018 8:18 pm
I really do not know what else I can do to convince anybody of anything and even if I did I don’t have the time. Either you believe me or you don’t and I’ve done what I can about it.
You still have a shot. I'm leaning toward Luna atm and we have a whole phase to discuss it.
nutella wrote: ↑Fri Nov 16, 2018 7:45 pm This isn't productive. Not pro town by the numbers, and stating stuff like this openly at the beginning of night just invites scum to do something screwy in their favor. Better for you to actually try to convince us of your townieness. I still think it could be Luna and I even think there's a crazy possible world in which DH pulled a Firefly Golden on all our asses (but Jesus DH I swear to fuck mountain if that's the case I'm gonna.... )
lol nutella, DH has no reason to switch the lynch on Jack's direction if they're team mates
oh no, I see it wasn't sprityo. RIP sprit, see you in the next game.
So I don't know who it is, right now I'm not even leaning anyone's direction. And I'm tired, it was a grueling day on the road. So maybe tomorrow I can figure something out. If it's DH or nutella...
ColinIsCool wrote: ↑Fri Nov 16, 2018 8:18 pm
I really do not know what else I can do to convince anybody of anything and even if I did I don’t have the time. Either you believe me or you don’t and I’ve done what I can about it.
You still have a shot. I'm leaning toward Luna atm and we have a whole phase to discuss it.
I didn't even join the townyo lynch today and you think I'm bad?
I feel like we have had two people claim cop wrongly. It is a very powerful ability and I’m not sure DDL would keep 2 in the set-up
Of pout and Luna, Luna has seemed very opportunistic at times. Maybe it’s just the way her hunting works but she seems to discard reasons to suspect people easily and adopt them even moreso. Like when she uses my hypothetical reason for lynching Speed as a reason to “suspect” me — it feels contrived and convenient. And that post above suggests calculation to me. Idk
juliets wrote: ↑Fri Nov 16, 2018 10:06 pm
oh no, I see it wasn't sprityo. RIP sprit, see you in the next game.
So I don't know who it is, right now I'm not even leaning anyone's direction. And I'm tired, it was a grueling day on the road. So maybe tomorrow I can figure something out. If it's DH or nutella...
Hey Juliets can you do me a huge favor
if Glorf bailed on his mafia team can you just say that. It would mean literally the whole world to me.
DharmaHelper wrote: ↑Fri Nov 16, 2018 10:52 pm
Wouldn't it be wild if I was Jacks teammate and we decided if I outted him nobody would ever lynch me so he'd stay unkillable.
nutella wrote: ↑Fri Nov 16, 2018 7:45 pm This isn't productive. Not pro town by the numbers, and stating stuff like this openly at the beginning of night just invites scum to do something screwy in their favor. Better for you to actually try to convince us of your townieness. I still think it could be Luna and I even think there's a crazy possible world in which DH pulled a Firefly Golden on all our asses (but Jesus DH I swear to fuck mountain if that's the case I'm gonna.... )
lol nutella, DH has no reason to switch the lynch on Jack's direction if they're team mates
He absolutely would. If DH is bad he's been playing the deepest wolf game ever and he just needs to keep looking town and as long as he survives he's in good shape.
ColinIsCool wrote: ↑Fri Nov 16, 2018 8:18 pm
I really do not know what else I can do to convince anybody of anything and even if I did I don’t have the time. Either you believe me or you don’t and I’ve done what I can about it.
You still have a shot. I'm leaning toward Luna atm and we have a whole phase to discuss it.
I didn't even join the townyo lynch today and you think I'm bad?
DharmaHelper wrote: ↑Fri Nov 16, 2018 10:52 pm
Wouldn't it be wild if I was Jacks teammate and we decided if I outted him nobody would ever lynch me so he'd stay unkillable.
Sure would.
Shame I'd never scumbag two teammates in one game.
DharmaHelper wrote: ↑Fri Nov 16, 2018 10:52 pm
Wouldn't it be wild if I was Jacks teammate and we decided if I outted him nobody would ever lynch me so he'd stay unkillable.
Sure would.
Shame I'd never scumbag two teammates in one game.
Seems like a good plan if you knew the horcrux would keep your team in the running as long as one person who made every effort to appear town was kept alive.
DharmaHelper wrote: ↑Fri Nov 16, 2018 10:52 pm
Wouldn't it be wild if I was Jacks teammate and we decided if I outted him nobody would ever lynch me so he'd stay unkillable.
Sure would.
Shame I'd never scumbag two teammates in one game.
Seems like a good plan if you knew the horcrux would keep your team in the running as long as one person who made every effort to appear town was kept alive.
Oh also I had sufficient enough town cred for dunking on Long Con and Luna had already cop-cleared me so its like....why go through the dumb hassle of revealing Jack and revealing the Horcrux thing when I coulda saved that shit for a rainy day, and Jack coulda been un-vig-killable on the low-low.
juliets wrote: ↑Fri Nov 16, 2018 10:06 pm
oh no, I see it wasn't sprityo. RIP sprit, see you in the next game.
So I don't know who it is, right now I'm not even leaning anyone's direction. And I'm tired, it was a grueling day on the road. So maybe tomorrow I can figure something out. If it's DH or nutella...
Hey Juliets can you do me a huge favor
if Glorf bailed on his mafia team can you just say that. It would mean literally the whole world to me.
No, Glorf did not bail on his mafia team, lol. He alignment claimed town. Sorry.
DharmaHelper wrote: ↑Fri Nov 16, 2018 10:52 pm
Wouldn't it be wild if I was Jacks teammate and we decided if I outted him nobody would ever lynch me so he'd stay unkillable.
I think night is almost over so legacy posting in case I die. I think we need to seriously consider the angle that DH may have fooled us all. I still think Luna or Colin is more likely the last scum and would go for them first, but I don't want to continue giving DH a pass. My order looks like this right now:
Luna
Colin
DH
poutanko
juliets
timmer
Mac
Yes imo mac (and thus according to him 95% timmer) is more confirmed town than juliets. But I'm pretty sure the scum is in the first three. Mayyybe poutanko but I don't really have a case for her.
Finally, barring further shenanigans, I nullified DH's vote for day 7. May have been a poor choice, but using my other ability felt too much like it could backfire on me and I wanted to do something more or less safe.
Maybe I won't die, but with the prevalence of diricawls and other such madness I'm paranoid. But I'm also kind of hoping someone vigs Luna or Colin and we get lucky. If one of them dies and flips town, definitely just go ahead and lynch the other. If it's between them... we should do more research and carefully consider everything because there are points in both of their favor and points against them both. But my main word of advice is that if we don't find scum in either of them to not let DH slide by without further scrutiny. I know it feels like we've had this game in the bag for a while but we can't get cocky or we're susceptible to... well, a long con. Keep up the good fight, town.
nutella wrote: ↑Sat Nov 17, 2018 4:00 pm
I think night is almost over so legacy posting in case I die. I think we need to seriously consider the angle that DH may have fooled us all. I still think Luna or Colin is more likely the last scum and would go for them first, but I don't want to continue giving DH a pass. My order looks like this right now:
Luna
Colin
DH
poutanko
juliets
timmer
Mac
Yes imo mac (and thus according to him 95% timmer) is more confirmed town than juliets. But I'm pretty sure the scum is in the first three. Mayyybe poutanko but I don't really have a case for her.
Finally, barring further shenanigans, I nullified DH's vote for day 7. May have been a poor choice, but using my other ability felt too much like it could backfire on me and I wanted to do something more or less safe.
Maybe I won't die, but with the prevalence of diricawls and other such madness I'm paranoid. But I'm also kind of hoping someone vigs Luna or Colin and we get lucky. If one of them dies and flips town, definitely just go ahead and lynch the other. If it's between them... we should do more research and carefully consider everything because there are points in both of their favor and points against them both. But my main word of advice is that if we don't find scum in either of them to not let DH slide by without further scrutiny. I know it feels like we've had this game in the bag for a while but we can't get cocky or we're susceptible to... well, a long con. Keep up the good fight, town.
I agree with you except I don't know how Mac got to the top of your list (and therefore timmer). Did you explain this already and I just missed it because I didn't read all of yesterday?
You should read. They vouched for each other mechanically and I think I might understand what they are hinting at. (Plus Mac was already my strongest townread so this just solidified that)
nutella wrote: ↑Sat Nov 17, 2018 4:16 pm
You should read. They vouched for each other mechanically and I think I might understand what they are hinting at. (Plus Mac was already my strongest townread so this just solidified that)
timmer decided to investigate on his own. Surely, some might say that was not a wise idea, but he was a skilled wizard. He prosmised himself he wouldn't take crazy risks, and went to it.
He patrolled the school for multiple nights, but nothing seemed to happen. The bad guys were weakened now, and would probably not do things in the open. No, they would make this a war of attrition, and try to slowly reduce the good guys' numbers, until they could win.
One night, timmer found something. After passing through the same corridor three times, a door showed up that he hadn't seen before. He stopped for a few seconds, and then it clicked. That was the legendary Room of Requirement! He had only heard of it in stories, but most students didn't know where it was actually located.
The Room of Requirement showed what the person visiting it needed at the time. timmer needed to find the New Death Eaters. Maybe the room would give him some magical tools that would lead him to them!
He opened the door. But inside, there was no one. Some shelves with books, a cauldron that seemed like it had been used recently, some scraps of food, but no magical tools. Unless... this was where they were actually hiding?
He had no time to waste. He had to report this information to someone.
But before he could leave, he saw the door knob spinning.
timmer knew he had a few seconds to leave. And he would probably not survive a duel against the New Death Eaters. But he couldn't die without leaving this information to someone.
The door opened. A flash of green light burst in front of it.
nutella wrote: ↑Sat Nov 17, 2018 4:00 pm
I think night is almost over so legacy posting in case I die. I think we need to seriously consider the angle that DH may have fooled us all. I still think Luna or Colin is more likely the last scum and would go for them first, but I don't want to continue giving DH a pass. My order looks like this right now:
Luna
Colin
DH
poutanko
juliets
timmer
Mac
Yes imo mac (and thus according to him 95% timmer) is more confirmed town than juliets. But I'm pretty sure the scum is in the first three. Mayyybe poutanko but I don't really have a case for her.
Finally, barring further shenanigans, I nullified DH's vote for day 7. May have been a poor choice, but using my other ability felt too much like it could backfire on me and I wanted to do something more or less safe.
Maybe I won't die, but with the prevalence of diricawls and other such madness I'm paranoid. But I'm also kind of hoping someone vigs Luna or Colin and we get lucky. If one of them dies and flips town, definitely just go ahead and lynch the other. If it's between them... we should do more research and carefully consider everything because there are points in both of their favor and points against them both. But my main word of advice is that if we don't find scum in either of them to not let DH slide by without further scrutiny. I know it feels like we've had this game in the bag for a while but we can't get cocky or we're susceptible to... well, a long con. Keep up the good fight, town.
Hey does anyone *actually* have proof/a good enough piece of evidence that "I blocked the guy who was trying to block the mafia" is a civ? Because if not :/
This isn't productive. Not pro town by the numbers, and stating stuff like this openly at the beginning of night just invites scum to do something screwy in their favor. Better for you to actually try to convince us of your townieness. I still think it could be Luna and I even think there's a crazy possible world in which DH pulled a Firefly Golden on all our asses (but Jesus DH I swear to fuck mountain if that's the case I'm gonna.... 
)
