Hogwarts Mafia - END

[DharmaHelper]

Cool.

Hey if you could Block Colin how come you didn't block Jack tho

Seemed too obvious and someone had already said they were doing so, but I thought it was sloonei lol

You thought it was Sloonei or you forgot it was Colin?

[nutella]

To be honest I'm not sure it occurred to me at the time, probably since it had already been discussed. I just really wanted to block kara since I felt really sure they were bad, and when I realized they weren't around I changed it to my second top suspect. In retrospect, I suck. Except that Colin probably is Jack's teammate and was a good target to block anyway. But then jack must have done the kill since three people died anyway... probably because he had Colin say he was gonna block him so he could assume nobody would actually block him holy shit that makes so much sense lol absolutely wild.

[nutella]

Cool.

Hey if you could Block Colin how come you didn't block Jack tho

Seemed too obvious and someone had already said they were doing so, but I thought it was sloonei lol

You thought it was Sloonei or you forgot it was Colin?

Both yes

[DharmaHelper]

Hey if you can block people how come last night you didn't block Jack tho.

[nutella]

Hey if you can block people how come last night you didn't block Jack tho.

Was a one-shot

[DharmaHelper]

Hmhmhmm Checks out.

[Lunalee]

[mention]DharmaHelper[/mention] [mention]nutella[/mention] So you think it's more likely Poutanko got a bunk check on Colin than it is that Mac lied about giving Timmer an elixer?

[DharmaHelper]

@DharmaHelper @nutella So you think it's more likely Poutanko got a bunk check on Colin than it is that Mac lied about giving Timmer an elixer?

[nutella]

@DharmaHelper @nutella So you think it's more likely Poutanko got a bunk check on Colin than it is that Mac lied about giving Timmer an elixer?

Yes because timmer confirmed that mac did indeed do something for him...??? Like?? How can you argue with that

[nutella]

There are so many reasons I absolutely think that's obviously more likely why is this even a question

[nutella]

- we already know cop checks are fallible in this game due to the overwhelming number of redirects/diricawls/imperios/etc
- it makes sense that scum would diricawl with town to appear town (and to deflect whatever other things hit them)
- Mac was already obvtown and Colin has a significantly strong case against him with the easily false cop check being pretty much the only caveat
- timmer vouched for mac having done something nice for him, the only way that could be wrong is if mac somehow knew that somebody gave timmer an elixir and I can't think of a way he would (except maybe imperio but why would scum imperio someone into protecting a townie lol)

[nutella]

like. mac is town. colin is probably scum. I don't understand how you can think anything else is more likely at this point.

[DharmaHelper]

Yo I should make a Red Dead Redemption Mafia lol

[nutella]

hey everyone do me a favor and vote for colin and don't make it a close lynch because I fucked up and barring shenanigans dh's vote doesn't count so help me repent by making it not matter

[nutella]

can't believe I didn't just use my other ability I'm such a fucking coward there weren't even multiple deaths last night it would've been fiiiine I'm an idiot

[nutella]

........still don't get why gryffindor won the cup again. there's gotta be nefarious fuckery going on there

[DharmaHelper]

........still don't get why gryffindor won the cup again. there's gotta be nefarious fuckery going on there

I'm not one to look a gift horse in the mouth.

[Jackofhearts2005]

like. mac is town. colin is probably scum. I don't understand how you can think anything else is more likely at this point.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Yo I should make a Red Dead Redemption Mafia lol

You are (RDRedemption1 spoilers)

Spoiler: show

an inexplicable 300 man force tasked with taking down a lone farmer in an ending people will pretend is amazing for years to come.

[sprityo]

like. mac is town. colin is probably scum. I don't understand how you can think anything else is more likely at this point.

if only you said this last day phase :dissapointed:

[juliets]

Sorry, we've been driving through the state of Alabama today to our next stop.

I have held out on Colin all this time because of pout's check and the fact that it doesn't seem reasonable that pout had two bad checks. But with nutella, Mac and DH all agreeing - and I think they are all town - I guess I have to give up clinging to that piece of information. I'll go ahead and vote there now. Did Colin say he wasn't going to be around today?

[juliets]

Also, I thought I read that [mention]poutanko[/mention] nko also didn't trust her Colin check but I notice she is not voting for him. Pout is it true that you don't trust that check?

[juliets]

Naturally, I'm here when no one else is.

[Sloonei]

spooky ghost noises

[Jackofhearts2005]

Naturally, I'm here when no one else is.

I’m here and maybe you’re wrong about everything.

[DharmaHelper]

I'm here but juliets has been saucy recently and I don't wanna make her mad at me lol

[juliets]

I'm here but juliets has been saucy recently and I don't wanna make her mad at me lol

lolol - I was just in a mood.

[poutanko]

Colin definitely looks the worst from his interaction with the confirmed scums, Jack avoiding to vote him/LC and him voting me together with Jack and didn't move it (previously he asked to keep Sloonei's wagon after your claim and when it's between Jack and me, he chose to keep his vote on me - you're guilty of this too ). But then, I green checked him. Don't think scum would Imperio'd me twice or me hitting a dodo'ed target twice in a row. If scum have a "secret" to turn me into insane cop, they wouldn't obliviate me. N2 might have another way to fool invest (if Polyjuice is in the game - it should fall under potion ability, need 1 night to make) but Colin was not that high on sus list. Higher possibility of it being correct check.

What do you think of Nutella's and Mac's night action claim on Colin?

[mention]juliets[/mention]

[poutanko]

MacD still looks Town to me if he's scum, why would he give Elixir to Timmer?

[DharmaHelper]

MacD still looks Town to me if he's scum, why would he give Elixir to Timmer?

Fat lot of good it seems to have done ol' Timmer.

[poutanko]

What fat? Some of you speak unknown version of English

[ColinIsCool]

When I flip, refocus your attention on [VOTE: LUNALEE] aubergine. She interceded on Sloonei’s behalf because he was barking up the wrong trees but could earn towncred by saving him. It’s as easy as that.

I was blocked last night.

I’m using canary cream tonight on juliets. Jack and Luna will not be able to use dark arts abilities.

See ya.

[Jackofhearts2005]

MacD still looks Town to me if he's scum, why would he give Elixir to Timmer?

Maybe he’s pulling a * sips his drink* long con.

[Jackofhearts2005]

MacD still looks Town to me if he's scum, why would he give Elixir to Timmer?

Fat lot of good it seems to have done ol' Timmer.

Maybe it was a defective batch?

[Jackofhearts2005]

When I flip, refocus your attention on [VOTE: LUNALEE] aubergine. She interceded on Sloonei’s behalf because he was barking up the wrong trees but could earn towncred by saving him. It’s as easy as that.

I was blocked last night.

I’m using canary cream tonight on juliets. Jack and Luna will not be able to use dark arts abilities.

See ya.

Not if we lynch you today.

[DharmaHelper]

When I flip, refocus your attention on [VOTE: LUNALEE] aubergine. She interceded on Sloonei’s behalf because he was barking up the wrong trees but could earn towncred by saving him. It’s as easy as that.

I was blocked last night.

I’m using canary cream tonight on juliets. Jack and Luna will not be able to use dark arts abilities.

See ya.

Not if we lynch you today.

Sad 2 say House Cup items are used up automatically. So if Colin's being truthful you are already blocked.

[Jackofhearts2005]

If Colin is scum, why does he keep trying to stop me from killing?

[Jackofhearts2005]

Checkmate, townies.

[DharmaHelper]

[MacDougall]

MacD still looks Town to me if he's scum, why would he give Elixir to Timmer?

Fat lot of good it seems to have done ol' Timmer.

I gave it to him on night 3.

[DharmaHelper]

MacD still looks Town to me if he's scum, why would he give Elixir to Timmer?

Fat lot of good it seems to have done ol' Timmer.

I gave it to him on night 3.

Erm if he drank it at all between then and now he'd not have been killed so.... I dunno if that tracks fam.

[MacDougall]

MacD still looks Town to me if he's scum, why would he give Elixir to Timmer?

Fat lot of good it seems to have done ol' Timmer.

I gave it to him on night 3.

Erm if he drank it at all between then and now he'd not have been killed so.... I dunno if that tracks fam.

Can you count?

[MacDougall]

I cannot even ... how am I currently having to explain this. Did I take over Timmer's account and clear myself?

[DharmaHelper]

MacD still looks Town to me if he's scum, why would he give Elixir to Timmer?

Fat lot of good it seems to have done ol' Timmer.

I gave it to him on night 3.

Erm if he drank it at all between then and now he'd not have been killed so.... I dunno if that tracks fam.

Can you count?

Can you my guy

[MacDougall]

MacD still looks Town to me if he's scum, why would he give Elixir to Timmer?

Fat lot of good it seems to have done ol' Timmer.

I gave it to him on night 3.

Erm if he drank it at all between then and now he'd not have been killed so.... I dunno if that tracks fam.

Can you count?

Can you my guy

He either drank it the night I gave it to him, was super killed or didn't drink it. Trying to imply I didn't is the dumbest shit I have had to contend with in my near decade of forums Mafia.

[Jackofhearts2005]

What if he accidentally spilled it?

[MacDougall]

Maybe he gave it to someone else. Fucked if I know. I literally gave the guy my elixir of life and I am being questioned. Y'all absolutely need Jesus.

[MacDougall]

Like a better argument might be that I gave it to him to town clear myself later before super killing him once I got my civ clear.

I wish I had have. That would be some sexy ruthless shit.

[DharmaHelper]

MacD still looks Town to me if he's scum, why would he give Elixir to Timmer?

Fat lot of good it seems to have done ol' Timmer.

I gave it to him on night 3.

Erm if he drank it at all between then and now he'd not have been killed so.... I dunno if that tracks fam.

Can you count?

Can you my guy

He either drank it the night I gave it to him, was super killed or didn't drink it. Trying to imply I didn't is the dumbest shit I have had to contend with in my near decade of forums Mafia.

He couldn't have drank it the night you gave it to him
He wasn't super killed (INH had the Even Night Skrewt)
Why wouldn't he drink it as soon as he could between N4 and now, being outed as a vig.

Whatever you said to him or did to him was enough to convince him you're good, which is odd to me, but it is what it is. I just don't know if I believe it was an Elixer of Life.

Either way I believe you enough not to vote for you, you keep adding info on top of it.

[nutella]

MacD still looks Town to me if he's scum, why would he give Elixir to Timmer?

Fat lot of good it seems to have done ol' Timmer.

I gave it to him on night 3.

Erm if he drank it at all between then and now he'd not have been killed so.... I dunno if that tracks fam.

Can you count?

Can you my guy

He either drank it the night I gave it to him, was super killed or didn't drink it. Trying to imply I didn't is the dumbest shit I have had to contend with in my near decade of forums Mafia.

Yeah if he drank it on night 3 which seems likely it had expired by last night. Also isn't there another possibility that he was already targeted with a kill that absorbed the protection.