Hogwarts Mafia - END

[MacDougall]

Even if Luna is town this Pout wagon is a rush lynch and Pout hasn't even been here to defend. It's pretty characteristic of a mislynch.

If we are counterwagoning it really should be Colin.

[Lunalee]

INH was the source of most of your doubt during day 2. Why did you not cop check him?

I don't remember my exact thought process. But if Epi had been scum then I would have made a good choice, because we were able to lynch INH anyways. There were too many options for cop checks, and I know you would have probably made completely different choices in my shoes.

[Lunalee]

Even if Luna is town this Pout wagon is a rush lynch and Pout hasn't even been here to defend. It's pretty characteristic of a mislynch.

If we are counterwagoning it really should be Colin.

But why is Colin scum? He looks town to me. Especially his reaction to almost getting lynched before.

[juliets]

Even if Luna is town this Pout wagon is a rush lynch and Pout hasn't even been here to defend. It's pretty characteristic of a mislynch.

If we are counterwagoning it really should be Colin.

I'm actually in agreement that it's not a good idea to Lynch someone who is not here to defend. But I don't think I want to change to Colin.

[MacDougall]

Luna you voiced no suspicion of Epi during day 2. He did however voiced suspicion of you. In fact you ignored his prods for the most part. You actually had great suspicion of INH on day 2 as well as Bullzeye. Yet you cop checked a player who suspected you rather than you suspect. A suspect that died that very night and flipped mafia btw.

To me this is the best case we have.

Then I wouldn't have accomplished much by checking him if he died before he could get lynched. Believe me, it's not easy choosing who to check each night. Everyone looked guilty to me.

I know it's not. I have a similar role. I can sympathise. But you can't have known he would die. Surely a day 2 civ Luna with a significant suspicion of INH cop checks him as opposed to a player that you had not even mentioned.

Epi suspected you. You divined him and discovered he was a threat and kill him night three. Your suspicion of INH was fabricated scum distancing right?

[MacDougall]

INH was the source of most of your doubt during day 2. Why did you not cop check him?

I don't remember my exact thought process. But if Epi had been scum then I would have made a good choice, because we were able to lynch INH anyways. There were too many options for cop checks, and I know you would have probably made completely different choices in my shoes.

I am quite sure INH was vigged actually.

[MacDougall]

Even if Luna is town this Pout wagon is a rush lynch and Pout hasn't even been here to defend. It's pretty characteristic of a mislynch.

If we are counterwagoning it really should be Colin.

But why is Colin scum? He looks town to me. Especially his reaction to almost getting lynched before.

Anyone with a pulse can look sincere when they are about to get lynched. Colin has the most well documented cases. We are off the map with this Pout stuff. At least Colin is on the map.

If we lose this game and Colin turns out to be the last Mafia I would feel very bad.

[Lunalee]

Go ahead and lynch me if you want but spend some time this phase looking at other people because when I flip town the numbers are going to be significantly less better for the civs than they were an hour ago.

like would scum Colin say this?

[juliets]

Go ahead and lynch me if you want but spend some time this phase looking at other people because when I flip town the numbers are going to be significantly less better for the civs than they were an hour ago.

like would scum Colin say this?

my experience is scum would say anything.

[MacDougall]

Of course if your argument is just "I dunno it's hard" or some such then that is your argument and I cannot argue against that.

I personally was hoping you would say that you did it because he was suspecting you but you tried to make it sound like you suspected him. The former would have been a real nice green peek of honesty because I really think that it is why you did it. That you didn't admit that means you have a guilty mind about it.

[Lunalee]

Go ahead and lynch me if you want but spend some time this phase looking at other people because when I flip town the numbers are going to be significantly less better for the civs than they were an hour ago.

like would scum Colin say this?

my experience is scum would say anything.

so you want to lynch Colin over Pout?

[MacDougall]

Go ahead and lynch me if you want but spend some time this phase looking at other people because when I flip town the numbers are going to be significantly less better for the civs than they were an hour ago.

like would scum Colin say this?

That is an excerpt from "How to Scum by Darth Sloonei". I have six copies.

[juliets]

Go ahead and lynch me if you want but spend some time this phase looking at other people because when I flip town the numbers are going to be significantly less better for the civs than they were an hour ago.

like would scum Colin say this?

my experience is scum would say anything.

so you want to lynch Colin over Pout?

Actually I'm more likely to move to you than Colin.

[ColinIsCool]

Go ahead and lynch me if you want but spend some time this phase looking at other people because when I flip town the numbers are going to be significantly less better for the civs than they were an hour ago.

like would scum Colin say this?

That is an excerpt from "How to Scum by Darth Sloonei". I have six copies.

Yup, I appreciate the cred but this is not a great argument.

[Lunalee]

Of course if your argument is just "I dunno it's hard" or some such then that is your argument and I cannot argue against that.

I personally was hoping you would say that you did it because he was suspecting you but you tried to make it sound like you suspected him. The former would have been a real nice green peek of honesty because I really think that it is why you did it. That you didn't admit that means you have a guilty mind about it.

Can i not have multiple reasons for suspecting someone? I gave you both in thread and apparently you only saw the one you wanted to see to make me out to be scum.

[Lunalee]

I really should be doing stuff other than mafia rn. But you guys are keeping this too interesting

[ColinIsCool]

From what I have read and analysed in this game holistically I would have Luna as my top choice with much doubt. Colin is still second. Everyone else is tied as tinfoil candidates for me.

Linki: The problem is if I was going to pick someone to defer my vote to you wouldn't be it. This Pout wagon only exists because you tried to save yourself. That alone makes it flawed.

I'm still trying in this game because I'm not dead yet. If I were scum I would have given up by now.

This is the fakest sounding post I have read all game. I am sorry if you are town Luna but no part of me believes this. I am not moving my vote.

[Lunalee]

Go ahead and lynch me if you want but spend some time this phase looking at other people because when I flip town the numbers are going to be significantly less better for the civs than they were an hour ago.

like would scum Colin say this?

That is an excerpt from "How to Scum by Darth Sloonei". I have six copies.

Yup, I appreciate the cred but this is not a great argument.

Okay, cool. So we should lynch you?

[juliets]

Is DH here? DH, are you still convinced it's pout?

[Dragon D. Luffy]

I really should be doing stuff other than mafia rn. But you guys are keeping this too interesting

You're welcome.

[nutella]

From what I have read and analysed in this game holistically I would have Luna as my top choice with much doubt. Colin is still second. Everyone else is tied as tinfoil candidates for me.

Linki: The problem is if I was going to pick someone to defer my vote to you wouldn't be it. This Pout wagon only exists because you tried to save yourself. That alone makes it flawed.

I'm still trying in this game because I'm not dead yet. If I were scum I would have given up by now.

This is the fakest sounding post I have read all game. I am sorry if you are town Luna but no part of me believes this. I am not moving my vote.

Gotta say this sounds pretty fake itself.

[Lunalee]

From what I have read and analysed in this game holistically I would have Luna as my top choice with much doubt. Colin is still second. Everyone else is tied as tinfoil candidates for me.

Linki: The problem is if I was going to pick someone to defer my vote to you wouldn't be it. This Pout wagon only exists because you tried to save yourself. That alone makes it flawed.

I'm still trying in this game because I'm not dead yet. If I were scum I would have given up by now.

This is the fakest sounding post I have read all game. I am sorry if you are town Luna but no part of me believes this. I am not moving my vote.

Apology accepted.

[MacDougall]

Juliets and Nutella have put themselves well out of scum range during this EOD as they are obviously trying to gamesolve even though they have no pressure.

Lunalee would be doing this either way probably.

Colin and DH are around but just letting things unfold which I don't like. Pout is not around at all.

[nutella]

DH you never answered me as to whether your vote counts

[MacDougall]

Oh now Colin appears.

[nutella]

Everyone back onto Colin yea/nay?

[MacDougall]

From what I have read and analysed in this game holistically I would have Luna as my top choice with much doubt. Colin is still second. Everyone else is tied as tinfoil candidates for me.

Linki: The problem is if I was going to pick someone to defer my vote to you wouldn't be it. This Pout wagon only exists because you tried to save yourself. That alone makes it flawed.

I'm still trying in this game because I'm not dead yet. If I were scum I would have given up by now.

This is the fakest sounding post I have read all game. I am sorry if you are town Luna but no part of me believes this. I am not moving my vote.

Gotta say this sounds pretty fake itself.

I don't agree.

[nutella]

From what I have read and analysed in this game holistically I would have Luna as my top choice with much doubt. Colin is still second. Everyone else is tied as tinfoil candidates for me.

Linki: The problem is if I was going to pick someone to defer my vote to you wouldn't be it. This Pout wagon only exists because you tried to save yourself. That alone makes it flawed.

I'm still trying in this game because I'm not dead yet. If I were scum I would have given up by now.

This is the fakest sounding post I have read all game. I am sorry if you are town Luna but no part of me believes this. I am not moving my vote.

Gotta say this sounds pretty fake itself.

I don't agree.

fair enough

[Lunalee]

Juliets and Nutella have put themselves well out of scum range during this EOD as they are obviously trying to gamesolve even though they have no pressure.

Lunalee would be doing this either way probably.

Colin and DH are around but just letting things unfold which I don't like. Pout is not around at all.

but pretty sure Pout is in a very different time zone and probably asleep

[MacDougall]

Everyone back onto Colin yea/nay?

No I like my Lunalee vote. I think it is most likely her for reasons I have progressively outlined all of day 7.

[MacDougall]

Juliets and Nutella have put themselves well out of scum range during this EOD as they are obviously trying to gamesolve even though they have no pressure.

Lunalee would be doing this either way probably.

Colin and DH are around but just letting things unfold which I don't like. Pout is not around at all.

but pretty sure Pout is in a very different time zone and probably asleep

I know. Pout has a legit excuse for not being here defending.

[Lunalee]

Everyone back onto Colin yea/nay?

No I like my Lunalee vote. I think it is most likely her for reasons I have progressively outlined all of day 7.

*sigh* okay. I tried.

[juliets]

I am moving to Luna. I just can't stick with pout since she still isn't here.

[nutella]

DH please is this a tie or no

[nutella]

nvm k

[MacDougall]

I'm going to have essentially zero time until Tuesday night or Wednesday. While I'm not here y'all best find excuses to do work and not excuses to do fuck all. Epi's recent grumbles are valid.

[VOTE: Quin] aubergine, because he said some shit I didn't like earlier. He provided a token response to Epi's dig at juliets which just looked like "this is where I am supposed to interject with this here comment" instead of "this is a problem and I want to address it".

This is the post in question:

juliets and I are not teammates.

There. Go. Find bad guys.

so you know you're on different teams

I don't know about anyone else, but I wouldn't have read anything at all into Quin saying that, and the fact that Jay did is a little weird.

You know what, I think that this is a scum slip.

Nobody liked this?

[Lunalee]

I am moving to Luna. I just can't stick with pout since she still isn't here.

But really. You guys should probably look closer at a Colin lynch tomorrow

[ColinIsCool]

I popped in because I thought the phase ended sooner. If it’s not Luna then pout I guess but the scum strategy would be confoundingly bold at that point and I’ll be getting lynched ahead of them so

[MacDougall]

Everyone back onto Colin yea/nay?

No I like my Lunalee vote. I think it is most likely her for reasons I have progressively outlined all of day 7.

*sigh* okay. I tried.

You did and either way it's admirable. You have played well no matter what.

[ColinIsCool]

I'm going to have essentially zero time until Tuesday night or Wednesday. While I'm not here y'all best find excuses to do work and not excuses to do fuck all. Epi's recent grumbles are valid.

[VOTE: Quin] aubergine, because he said some shit I didn't like earlier. He provided a token response to Epi's dig at juliets which just looked like "this is where I am supposed to interject with this here comment" instead of "this is a problem and I want to address it".

This is the post in question:

juliets and I are not teammates.

There. Go. Find bad guys.

so you know you're on different teams

I don't know about anyone else, but I wouldn't have read anything at all into Quin saying that, and the fact that Jay did is a little weird.

You know what, I think that this is a scum slip.

Nobody liked this?

I did, I just didn’t yell “LIKE!” as others might have.

[nutella]

Everyone back onto Colin yea/nay?

No I like my Lunalee vote. I think it is most likely her for reasons I have progressively outlined all of day 7.

*sigh* okay. I tried.

[VOTE: luna] aubergine


linki [mention]MacDougall[/mention] I didn't get how it was a slip. I use "wouldn't have" and similar language in that way all the time.

[Lunalee]

I'm going to have essentially zero time until Tuesday night or Wednesday. While I'm not here y'all best find excuses to do work and not excuses to do fuck all. Epi's recent grumbles are valid.

[VOTE: Quin] aubergine, because he said some shit I didn't like earlier. He provided a token response to Epi's dig at juliets which just looked like "this is where I am supposed to interject with this here comment" instead of "this is a problem and I want to address it".

This is the post in question:

juliets and I are not teammates.

There. Go. Find bad guys.

so you know you're on different teams

I don't know about anyone else, but I wouldn't have read anything at all into Quin saying that, and the fact that Jay did is a little weird.

You know what, I think that this is a scum slip.

Nobody liked this?

I didn't really understand why you thought it was a slip

[juliets]

I popped in because I thought the phase ended sooner. If it’s not Luna then pout I guess but the scum strategy would be confoundingly bold at that point and I’ll be getting lynched ahead of them so

So wait Colin are you saying you popped in because you thought EOD was over?

[Lunalee]

wow the fact that Colin got it and likes it looks bad for him

[MacDougall]

Everyone back onto Colin yea/nay?

No I like my Lunalee vote. I think it is most likely her for reasons I have progressively outlined all of day 7.

*sigh* okay. I tried.

[VOTE: luna] aubergine


linki @MacDougall I didn't get how it was a slip. I use "wouldn't have" and similar language in that way all the time.

Ok

[MacDougall]

wow the fact that Colin got it and likes it looks bad for him

Lol that's clutching.

[ColinIsCool]

I popped in because I thought the phase ended sooner. If it’s not Luna then pout I guess but the scum strategy would be confoundingly bold at that point and I’ll be getting lynched ahead of them so

So wait Colin are you saying you popped in because you thought EOD was over?

Yeah, I wanted to see if I was right about Luna.

[MacDougall]

Lunalee says she wouldn't have, rather than didn't have or do not. Wouldn't have. Strange choice of words there. I am sure that if I was making that statement I would have said:

"I don't know about anyone else, but I don't read anything at all into Quin saying that, and the fact that Jay does is a little weird."

or

"I don't know about anyone else, but I didn't read anything at all into Quin saying that, and the fact that Jay did is a little weird."

[Lunalee]

wow the fact that Colin got it and likes it looks bad for him

Lol that's clutching.

just giving any input I can before i go

[MacDougall]

FWIW DH I mostly just started attacking you because I wanted to see how people would react to it. Nutella and juliets quite rightly tinfoiled. Lunalee tried to make out like I am an insane person for entertaining it.