Mafia: A World Asunder - GAME THREAD [Day 13]

[Sloonei]

[mention]MacDougall[/mention] [mention]DharmaHelper[/mention] Wanna take a look at this post and tell me what you think of its content? Please and thanks.

[Kylemii]

i meant to come on here earlier but smash bros

Did you like my smash bros reference just now?

where

[MacDougall]

It reminds me of that time when MP and I were literally the only two people in the thread in Search for Quin and he insisted that I must be scum because I was the only person in the game actively pushing any theories. Because I was the only other person bothering to do anything at all. I got lynched because nobody else was playing.

That's essentially what Mac is suggesting right now. It's obnoxious and idiotic and if I get lynched I'm gonna be annoyed and sign up for Colin's heist.

So let's get this straight.

G-Man arbitrarily decides to case a group of people when he is one vote from being lynched.
G-Man decides that juliets is Mafia.
Captain Sloonei chooses G-Man of all people to follow the case of when he is also one vote from being lynched.
Captain Sloonei agrees with G-Man and tries to build a case on juliets.

Can they be town? Sure.

Do they look like teammates. Absolutely.

[Dana]

@Dana who are you? where are you from? who do you know, what kind of experience do you have in terms of mafia etc.

I am Dana, nice to meet you! I like cats. I'm from New York but if you mean digitally, I'm from here I guess? I've played a few games here many years ago. I know Enrique and Nutella the best out of the people here, but I wouldn't even say I know them super well in terms of their mafia game. Other names I recognize are DharmaHelper, Epignosis, insertnamehere, Juliets, LoRab, Quin, Sorsha, spirityo, and SVS. I don't have a lot of mafia experience in general, just the few games I've played here, I want to say like 3 or 4? And tons of in-person mafia but that's a different beast.

[MacDougall]

i meant to come on here earlier but smash bros

Did you like my smash bros reference just now?

where

http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 81#p501281

[Sloonei]

It reminds me of that time when MP and I were literally the only two people in the thread in Search for Quin and he insisted that I must be scum because I was the only person in the game actively pushing any theories. Because I was the only other person bothering to do anything at all. I got lynched because nobody else was playing.

That's essentially what Mac is suggesting right now. It's obnoxious and idiotic and if I get lynched I'm gonna be annoyed and sign up for Colin's heist.

So let's get this straight.

G-Man arbitrarily decides to case a group of people when he is one vote from being lynched.
G-Man decides that juliets is Mafia.
Captain Sloonei chooses G-Man of all people to follow the case of when he is also one vote from being lynched.
Captain Sloonei agrees with G-Man and tries to build a case on juliets.

Can they be town? Sure.

Do they look like teammates. Absolutely.

Sloonei has been trying to look at alternative candidates for a couple of hours.
G-man suggests a player who has floated by without any criticism all game.
Sloonei decides to check that player out. Sloonei agrees with G-man.
Macdougall eats his own poop.

[Kylemii]

[mention]Sloonei[/mention] in general do you expect a civ juliets to be more assertive?

[MacDougall]

Sloo I find it strange that you are off looking at other candidates about an hour before EOD when we have about 18 people with votes on them.

I don't feel strongly about any of these candidates, and clearly there's no consensus anywhere. What's wrong with looking at other options?

Nothing on the surface I suppose but there's just something weird about the scientific way you are going about it all. I am currently doing mental gymnastics trying to build the synapse connections to quantify your alignment to your posts.

... huh? I'm looking at specific ISOs. That's... how people usually do this sort of thing. G-Man mentioned juliets, I realized I'd not given any thought to her this game. I looked, she's got an uninspiring ISO. I voted for her. Nobody has more than 3 votes in the poll and we've got over an hour to go. I'm confused by your confusion. This would hardly even qualify as a CFD. There's plenty of time and no established frontrunners.

At the time G-Man did that you were both on 2 votes. I put it to you that G-Man are working together to prevent each other's lynch on account of being Mafia together.

My argument. None of the other viable wagons are flailing around looking to build cases on the likes of juliets and sig. Both easy targets. You guys are doing it because you feel like you have more to lose than the rest of the candidates do because you are 2 members of the same Mafia team. Boom game set. Get out of my thread.

Why not just got back to Colin or wilgy tho

Decent questions. Most logical answer is they actually have a genuine scum read on juliets more so than they do on Colin or Wilgy. Remember we have mafia who can hunt mafia in this here game and it's always safer for them to be sincere especially in the early game.

[colonialbob]

tfw you're not sure if people see your posts

[Sloonei]

... G-Man has switched his vote to me too. Cool.

[timmer]

Sloo I find it strange that you are off looking at other candidates about an hour before EOD when we have about 18 people with votes on them.

I don't feel strongly about any of these candidates, and clearly there's no consensus anywhere. What's wrong with looking at other options?

Can you quickread speedchuck?

[MacDougall]

It reminds me of that time when MP and I were literally the only two people in the thread in Search for Quin and he insisted that I must be scum because I was the only person in the game actively pushing any theories. Because I was the only other person bothering to do anything at all. I got lynched because nobody else was playing.

That's essentially what Mac is suggesting right now. It's obnoxious and idiotic and if I get lynched I'm gonna be annoyed and sign up for Colin's heist.

So let's get this straight.

G-Man arbitrarily decides to case a group of people when he is one vote from being lynched.
G-Man decides that juliets is Mafia.
Captain Sloonei chooses G-Man of all people to follow the case of when he is also one vote from being lynched.
Captain Sloonei agrees with G-Man and tries to build a case on juliets.

Can they be town? Sure.

Do they look like teammates. Absolutely.

Sloonei has been trying to look at alternative candidates for a couple of hours.
G-man suggests a player who has floated by without any criticism all game.
Sloonei decides to check that player out. Sloonei agrees with G-man.
Macdougall eats his own poop.

You know who else has floated by without any criticism all game.

Heaps of players.

You chose a suspicious player to follow the case of. That's weird enough as it is. Have you documented any thoughts on G-Man during this game so far?

[MacDougall]

... G-Man has switched his vote to me too. Cool.

[Kylemii]

@Dana who are you? where are you from? who do you know, what kind of experience do you have in terms of mafia etc.

I am Dana, nice to meet you! I like cats. I'm from New York but if you mean digitally, I'm from here I guess? I've played a few games here many years ago. I know Enrique and Nutella the best out of the people here, but I wouldn't even say I know them super well in terms of their mafia game. Other names I recognize are DharmaHelper, Epignosis, insertnamehere, Juliets, LoRab, Quin, Sorsha, spirityo, and SVS. I don't have a lot of mafia experience in general, just the few games I've played here, I want to say like 3 or 4? And tons of in-person mafia but that's a different beast.

what are your favorite cat breeds? do you have any cats of your own? this isn't for the game anymore this is just regular questions

what do you think of enrique and nutella so far?

[Sloonei]

@Sloonei in general do you expect a civ juliets to be more assertive?

I guess so. I was hoping people who've got more experience with her than me would weigh in. In a vacuum, her play so far looks extremely weak. I don't recall specifics, but I've seen juliets play plenty of strong town games in the past.

[DharmaHelper]

@MacDougall @DharmaHelper Wanna take a look at this post and tell me what you think of its content? Please and thanks.

Based on my own experience with juliets and her post/play style in this game I have her at 55% bad.

[Sloonei]

It reminds me of that time when MP and I were literally the only two people in the thread in Search for Quin and he insisted that I must be scum because I was the only person in the game actively pushing any theories. Because I was the only other person bothering to do anything at all. I got lynched because nobody else was playing.

That's essentially what Mac is suggesting right now. It's obnoxious and idiotic and if I get lynched I'm gonna be annoyed and sign up for Colin's heist.

So let's get this straight.

G-Man arbitrarily decides to case a group of people when he is one vote from being lynched.
G-Man decides that juliets is Mafia.
Captain Sloonei chooses G-Man of all people to follow the case of when he is also one vote from being lynched.
Captain Sloonei agrees with G-Man and tries to build a case on juliets.

Can they be town? Sure.

Do they look like teammates. Absolutely.

Sloonei has been trying to look at alternative candidates for a couple of hours.
G-man suggests a player who has floated by without any criticism all game.
Sloonei decides to check that player out. Sloonei agrees with G-man.
Macdougall eats his own poop.

You know who else has floated by without any criticism all game.

Heaps of players.

You chose a suspicious player to follow the case of. That's weird enough as it is. Have you documented any thoughts on G-Man during this game so far?

I ISO'd Jack five minutes earlier because you had mentioned him. Fuck this.

[Kylemii]

i meant to come on here earlier but smash bros

Did you like my smash bros reference just now?

where

http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 81#p501281

"game set"?.... is the reference?

[colonialbob]

Sloo I find it strange that you are off looking at other candidates about an hour before EOD when we have about 18 people with votes on them.

I don't feel strongly about any of these candidates, and clearly there's no consensus anywhere. What's wrong with looking at other options?

Nothing on the surface I suppose but there's just something weird about the scientific way you are going about it all. I am currently doing mental gymnastics trying to build the synapse connections to quantify your alignment to your posts.

... huh? I'm looking at specific ISOs. That's... how people usually do this sort of thing. G-Man mentioned juliets, I realized I'd not given any thought to her this game. I looked, she's got an uninspiring ISO. I voted for her. Nobody has more than 3 votes in the poll and we've got over an hour to go. I'm confused by your confusion. This would hardly even qualify as a CFD. There's plenty of time and no established frontrunners.

At the time G-Man did that you were both on 2 votes. I put it to you that G-Man are working together to prevent each other's lynch on account of being Mafia together.

My argument. None of the other viable wagons are flailing around looking to build cases on the likes of juliets and sig. Both easy targets. You guys are doing it because you feel like you have more to lose than the rest of the candidates do because you are 2 members of the same Mafia team. Boom game set. Get out of my thread.

Why not just got back to Colin or wilgy tho

Decent questions. Most logical answer is they actually have a genuine scum read on juliets more so than they do on Colin or Wilgy. Remember we have mafia who can hunt mafia in this here game and it's always safer for them to be sincere especially in the early game.

Do you think the case on juliets was better than the other two? More well constructed, I mean, not whether you believe it

[Sloonei]

@MacDougall @DharmaHelper Wanna take a look at this post and tell me what you think of its content? Please and thanks.

Based on my own experience with juliets and her post/play style in this game I have her at 55% bad.

Is that enough to vote for her?

[MacDougall]

@MacDougall @DharmaHelper Wanna take a look at this post and tell me what you think of its content? Please and thanks.

You are posting like an antagonist from Nineteen Eighty Four.

[Turnip Head]

Voting Sloonei up in here. Get around it.

Sloon is town tho

[DharmaHelper]

@MacDougall @DharmaHelper Wanna take a look at this post and tell me what you think of its content? Please and thanks.

Based on my own experience with juliets and her post/play style in this game I have her at 55% bad.

Is that enough to vote for her?

no.

[MacDougall]

i meant to come on here earlier but smash bros

Did you like my smash bros reference just now?

where

http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 81#p501281

"game set"?.... is the reference?

Yes

[MacDougall]

I don't feel strongly about any of these candidates, and clearly there's no consensus anywhere. What's wrong with looking at other options?

Nothing on the surface I suppose but there's just something weird about the scientific way you are going about it all. I am currently doing mental gymnastics trying to build the synapse connections to quantify your alignment to your posts.

... huh? I'm looking at specific ISOs. That's... how people usually do this sort of thing. G-Man mentioned juliets, I realized I'd not given any thought to her this game. I looked, she's got an uninspiring ISO. I voted for her. Nobody has more than 3 votes in the poll and we've got over an hour to go. I'm confused by your confusion. This would hardly even qualify as a CFD. There's plenty of time and no established frontrunners.

At the time G-Man did that you were both on 2 votes. I put it to you that G-Man are working together to prevent each other's lynch on account of being Mafia together.

My argument. None of the other viable wagons are flailing around looking to build cases on the likes of juliets and sig. Both easy targets. You guys are doing it because you feel like you have more to lose than the rest of the candidates do because you are 2 members of the same Mafia team. Boom game set. Get out of my thread.

Why not just got back to Colin or wilgy tho

Decent questions. Most logical answer is they actually have a genuine scum read on juliets more so than they do on Colin or Wilgy. Remember we have mafia who can hunt mafia in this here game and it's always safer for them to be sincere especially in the early game.

Do you think the case on juliets was better than the other two? More well constructed, I mean, not whether you believe it

Are there cases on the other two?

[MacDougall]

Voting Sloonei up in here. Get around it.

Sloon is town tho

Based on?

[colonialbob]

... G-Man has switched his vote to me too. Cool.

(Look at me I'm Mac)

[MacDougall]

... G-Man has switched his vote to me too. Cool.

(Look at me I'm Mac)

... are you accusing me of bussing Sloonei?

[Sloonei]

timmer asked for a quick read of speedchuck

I have company today so I won't be around much.

Is there any role playing element to this game? Can I search my location for immunity idols? :P

[VOTE: DDL] aubergine

Plops an unexplained vote on DDL. He had previously questioned DDL's methods in speculating about the role alignments, but that's it.

idk how I feel about Sloondog suspecting Luna for essentially having the same suspicion as him but with less waffling. I think a baddie would at least be cognizant of how hypocritical that looks.

Hypocrisy is a staple of thr civilian playbook

But self-aware-ness is a staple of the mafia playbook.

Indirect suggestion of suspicion against Sloonie.

Btw Voted Sloonei

On the one hand, Sloonei feels pretty scum to me. On the other hand, Mega Man Mafia. *cringe*

Waffles.

I don't understand how I can be anybody's "strongest town read."

It's okay. Scum never townread the people that suspect them.

Conclusion: Speedchuck has a crush on me. I can't do much with this. He seems to want to scum read me, but he's not actually doing it. I'd like to give him an extended opportunity to flesh that out.

[colonialbob]

Nothing on the surface I suppose but there's just something weird about the scientific way you are going about it all. I am currently doing mental gymnastics trying to build the synapse connections to quantify your alignment to your posts.

... huh? I'm looking at specific ISOs. That's... how people usually do this sort of thing. G-Man mentioned juliets, I realized I'd not given any thought to her this game. I looked, she's got an uninspiring ISO. I voted for her. Nobody has more than 3 votes in the poll and we've got over an hour to go. I'm confused by your confusion. This would hardly even qualify as a CFD. There's plenty of time and no established frontrunners.

At the time G-Man did that you were both on 2 votes. I put it to you that G-Man are working together to prevent each other's lynch on account of being Mafia together.

My argument. None of the other viable wagons are flailing around looking to build cases on the likes of juliets and sig. Both easy targets. You guys are doing it because you feel like you have more to lose than the rest of the candidates do because you are 2 members of the same Mafia team. Boom game set. Get out of my thread.

Why not just got back to Colin or wilgy tho

Decent questions. Most logical answer is they actually have a genuine scum read on juliets more so than they do on Colin or Wilgy. Remember we have mafia who can hunt mafia in this here game and it's always safer for them to be sincere especially in the early game.

Do you think the case on juliets was better than the other two? More well constructed, I mean, not whether you believe it

Are there cases on the other two?

You're...

you're fucking with me right

[Sloonei]

@MacDougall @DharmaHelper Wanna take a look at this post and tell me what you think of its content? Please and thanks.

Based on my own experience with juliets and her post/play style in this game I have her at 55% bad.

Is that enough to vote for her?

no.

Why not? Who else are you considering?

[colonialbob]

... G-Man has switched his vote to me too. Cool.

(Look at me I'm Mac)

... are you accusing me of bussing Sloonei?

No I was channeling you to accuse gman of bussing Sloonei

[MacDougall]

... huh? I'm looking at specific ISOs. That's... how people usually do this sort of thing. G-Man mentioned juliets, I realized I'd not given any thought to her this game. I looked, she's got an uninspiring ISO. I voted for her. Nobody has more than 3 votes in the poll and we've got over an hour to go. I'm confused by your confusion. This would hardly even qualify as a CFD. There's plenty of time and no established frontrunners.

At the time G-Man did that you were both on 2 votes. I put it to you that G-Man are working together to prevent each other's lynch on account of being Mafia together.

My argument. None of the other viable wagons are flailing around looking to build cases on the likes of juliets and sig. Both easy targets. You guys are doing it because you feel like you have more to lose than the rest of the candidates do because you are 2 members of the same Mafia team. Boom game set. Get out of my thread.

Why not just got back to Colin or wilgy tho

Decent questions. Most logical answer is they actually have a genuine scum read on juliets more so than they do on Colin or Wilgy. Remember we have mafia who can hunt mafia in this here game and it's always safer for them to be sincere especially in the early game.

Do you think the case on juliets was better than the other two? More well constructed, I mean, not whether you believe it

Are there cases on the other two?

You're...

you're fucking with me right

Go ahead and point at the cases.

[Sloonei]

Please don't make me default to a wilgy vote.

[Sloonei]

Remember that time we lynched a guy who posted 200 times on Day 1? lol wild, great game

[DharmaHelper]

@MacDougall @DharmaHelper Wanna take a look at this post and tell me what you think of its content? Please and thanks.

Based on my own experience with juliets and her post/play style in this game I have her at 55% bad.

Is that enough to vote for her?

no.

Why not? Who else are you considering?

I guess I could be persuaded to vote for a nonparticipant since I dunked on one in Hogwarts and that turned out OK, but I'm pretty content w/ my vote all told.

[Turnip Head]

Voting Sloonei up in here. Get around it.

Sloon is town tho

Based on?

He had finals or midterms or whatever, perfect excuse to lay low yet he has 150+ posts on Day 1, do you think he's some kind of masochistic moron?

[Long Con]

40 minutes until lynch time!

[colonialbob]

At the time G-Man did that you were both on 2 votes. I put it to you that G-Man are working together to prevent each other's lynch on account of being Mafia together.

My argument. None of the other viable wagons are flailing around looking to build cases on the likes of juliets and sig. Both easy targets. You guys are doing it because you feel like you have more to lose than the rest of the candidates do because you are 2 members of the same Mafia team. Boom game set. Get out of my thread.

Why not just got back to Colin or wilgy tho

Decent questions. Most logical answer is they actually have a genuine scum read on juliets more so than they do on Colin or Wilgy. Remember we have mafia who can hunt mafia in this here game and it's always safer for them to be sincere especially in the early game.

Do you think the case on juliets was better than the other two? More well constructed, I mean, not whether you believe it

Are there cases on the other two?

You're...

you're fucking with me right

Go ahead and point at the cases.

Oh god now I have to dig through Sloonei's iso rip me

[MacDougall]

... G-Man has switched his vote to me too. Cool.

(Look at me I'm Mac)

... are you accusing me of bussing Sloonei?

No I was channeling you to accuse gman of bussing Sloonei

Oh.

[Sloonei]

@MacDougall @DharmaHelper Wanna take a look at this post and tell me what you think of its content? Please and thanks.

Based on my own experience with juliets and her post/play style in this game I have her at 55% bad.

Is that enough to vote for her?

no.

Why not? Who else are you considering?

I guess I could be persuaded to vote for a nonparticipant since I dunked on one in Hogwarts and that turned out OK, but I'm pretty content w/ my vote all told.

Which nonparticipants intrigue you most?

[wolbre04]

Sloonei, I am not convinced that you're mafia and It looks like its you and wilgy on the chopping block for now, I'd rather see wilgy go if necessary and I can tie it up if no one else is willing to budge
Not really sure why Sloonei is suddenly gaining mafia credit but whatever

I can kinda see how the juliets deal is really problematic, I think most people dismiss her as an enemy bc shes so nice

wtf

[wolbre04]

Love spending the last 5 minutes trying to publish my post

[MacDougall]

Voting Sloonei up in here. Get around it.

Sloon is town tho

Based on?

He had finals or midterms or whatever, perfect excuse to lay low yet he has 150+ posts on Day 1, do you think he's some kind of masochistic moron?

Posting a lot as Mafia on day 1 of a huge game where there are two teams meaning that he can genuinely scum hunt doesn't make him a masochistic moron, it makes him someone trying to win the game as Mafia.

[LoRab]

crapweasel. I just got back from a wedding and thought I had another hour...only to remember that I'm a time zone back from normal. Going to skim quickly posts since last night. And hopefully read enough to figure out some semblance of something.

linkitis: You people keep posting!!!

[DharmaHelper]

TBQH Tranq seemed willfully ignorant with his poll question and then has been kinda blendy since then IDK.

[MacDougall]

wtf

Indeed

[Sloonei]

Sloonei, I am not convinced that you're mafia and It looks like its you and wilgy on the chopping block for now, I'd rather see wilgy go if necessary and I can tie it up if no one else is willing to budge
Not really sure why Sloonei is suddenly gaining mafia credit but whatever

I can kinda see how the juliets deal is really problematic, I think most people dismiss her as an enemy bc shes so nice

wtf

Epi's case against me is fake and I am nearly certain he doesn't actually want me to be lynched.
DH is voting for me because he's wrong.
Mac is voting for me because he's an idiot.
G-Man is voting for me because... I don't know. He wants to prove to Mac that he's an idiot, maybe.

[colonialbob]

I would rather vote out Colin than either wilgy or Sloonei

[wolbre04]

I just don't think the amount of posting he's done can make me believe hes mafia atm