Mafia: A World Asunder - GAME THREAD [Day 13]

[juliets]

[mention]DharmaHelper[/mention] when I re-read Luna I couldn't see what you did when you said "something's up with Luna". Did you say that because of her G-Man post? Or was it something else that you saw?

[colonialbob]

Hey, yall!! I still have an eye on Wilgy. And the Sloonei 5 is interesting. That said, we don't know who killed LA. We all seem to be assuming it was a baddie (myself included), but we don't know that.

juliets this is why I put LoRab on my list.

I find all the "maybe mafia didn't kill Nutella" unconvincing at best, and this goes a step beyond that.

I am sympathetic to LoRab here. I see that as healthy skepticism, which is a good thing.

It's also exactly what I would expect a teammate to do. Perhaps my feelings on LoRab are better framed as "teammate-compatible," I don't feel this is a valid lynch reason on its own. But I will also take jules' opinion that this is typical for her into account.

[DharmaHelper]

@DharmaHelper when I re-read Luna I couldn't see what you did when you said "something's up with Luna". Did you say that because of her G-Man post? Or was it something else that you saw?

General vibe. I'm not seeing a smoking gun yet but I'm nervous about taking her off the table completely.

[juliets]

@DharmaHelper when I re-read Luna I couldn't see what you did when you said "something's up with Luna". Did you say that because of her G-Man post? Or was it something else that you saw?

General vibe. I'm not seeing a smoking gun yet but I'm nervous about taking her off the table completely.

Ok that makes sense to me. Thanks.

[MacDougall]

Quin has seemed fairly civ to me. If I had a bullet I had to use on one of these 5 right now it would be G-Man I would shoot.

[juliets]

Hey, yall!! I still have an eye on Wilgy. And the Sloonei 5 is interesting. That said, we don't know who killed LA. We all seem to be assuming it was a baddie (myself included), but we don't know that.

juliets this is why I put LoRab on my list.

I find all the "maybe mafia didn't kill Nutella" unconvincing at best, and this goes a step beyond that.

I am sympathetic to LoRab here. I see that as healthy skepticism, which is a good thing.

It's also exactly what I would expect a teammate to do. Perhaps my feelings on LoRab are better framed as "teammate-compatible," I don't feel this is a valid lynch reason on its own. But I will also take jules' opinion that this is typical for her into account.

Someone I think who knows her game better than I do is @S~V~S but I can't get this dang mention function to work with S~V~S's name. I'd really like to know her opinion on Lorab.

[MacDougall]

SVS is Mafia.

[Sloonei]

Hey, yall!! I still have an eye on Wilgy. And the Sloonei 5 is interesting. That said, we don't know who killed LA. We all seem to be assuming it was a baddie (myself included), but we don't know that.

juliets this is why I put LoRab on my list.

I find all the "maybe mafia didn't kill Nutella" unconvincing at best, and this goes a step beyond that.

I am sympathetic to LoRab here. I see that as healthy skepticism, which is a good thing.

It's also exactly what I would expect a teammate to do. Perhaps my feelings on LoRab are better framed as "teammate-compatible," I don't feel this is a valid lynch reason on its own. But I will also take jules' opinion that this is typical for her into account.

this all seems fair

[MacDougall]

This is the civviest CBob I have ever seen

[speedchuck]

Hey, yall!! I still have an eye on Wilgy. And the Sloonei 5 is interesting. That said, we don't know who killed LA. We all seem to be assuming it was a baddie (myself included), but we don't know that.

juliets this is why I put LoRab on my list.

I find all the "maybe mafia didn't kill Nutella" unconvincing at best, and this goes a step beyond that.

I am sympathetic to LoRab here. I see that as healthy skepticism, which is a good thing.

It's also exactly what I would expect a teammate to do. Perhaps my feelings on LoRab are better framed as "teammate-compatible," I don't feel this is a valid lynch reason on its own. But I will also take jules' opinion that this is typical for her into account.

Someone I think who knows her game better than I do is @S~V~S but I can't get this dang mention function to work with S~V~S's name. I'd really like to know her opinion on Lorab.

[mention]S~V~S[/mention]

That might do it

[MacDougall]

Fuck it. My day 2 priority is saving Quin.

For Australia!

[MacDougall]

We lynching G-Man ppl. Get around it.

[DharmaHelper]

We lynching G-Man ppl. Get around it.

You gonna move off me or what fam

[DharmaHelper]

Oh nvm you did, bless.

[S~V~S]

Hey, yall!! I still have an eye on Wilgy. And the Sloonei 5 is interesting. That said, we don't know who killed LA. We all seem to be assuming it was a baddie (myself included), but we don't know that.

juliets this is why I put LoRab on my list.

I find all the "maybe mafia didn't kill Nutella" unconvincing at best, and this goes a step beyond that.

I am sympathetic to LoRab here. I see that as healthy skepticism, which is a good thing.

It's also exactly what I would expect a teammate to do. Perhaps my feelings on LoRab are better framed as "teammate-compatible," I don't feel this is a valid lynch reason on its own. But I will also take jules' opinion that this is typical for her into account.

Someone I think who knows her game better than I do is @S~V~S but I can't get this dang mention function to work with S~V~S's name. I'd really like to know her opinion on Lorab.

@S~V~S

That might do it

Haven't seen enough of her to have one. I know she has been busy irl with the Holiday, but I can reread her during the night if you like. This is a very LoRab thing to say, though. She is always looking at it from the skeptical angle.

[MacDougall]

I consider everyone voting for Quin at best a bully

[MacDougall]

SVS is suspicious

[juliets]

[mention]Dragon D. Luffy[/mention] I want to quote a part of your long post on the 5. This is from your Quin summary:

A lot of posts are good stuff. He is hunting. I don't feel him as civ that much after his ISO though. Something about him feels... thuggish I guess. He's making cases but not commiting on them, too. I don't know, Quin is always sarcastic, but when he's a civ there is this feeling of a poor kid who is desperate because people are wanting things from him and he's super lost, so he's trying his best. Here he seems a bit more arrogant, more overconfident.

I felt this was the way Quin was in Hogwarts - confident almost to arrogance. Do you feel like he was different in that game than he is here?

[juliets]

Hey, yall!! I still have an eye on Wilgy. And the Sloonei 5 is interesting. That said, we don't know who killed LA. We all seem to be assuming it was a baddie (myself included), but we don't know that.

juliets this is why I put LoRab on my list.

I find all the "maybe mafia didn't kill Nutella" unconvincing at best, and this goes a step beyond that.

I am sympathetic to LoRab here. I see that as healthy skepticism, which is a good thing.

It's also exactly what I would expect a teammate to do. Perhaps my feelings on LoRab are better framed as "teammate-compatible," I don't feel this is a valid lynch reason on its own. But I will also take jules' opinion that this is typical for her into account.

Someone I think who knows her game better than I do is @S~V~S but I can't get this dang mention function to work with S~V~S's name. I'd really like to know her opinion on Lorab.

@S~V~S

That might do it

Haven't seen enough of her to have one. I know she has been busy irl with the Holiday, but I can reread her during the night if you like. This is a very LoRab thing to say, though. She is always looking at it from the skeptical angle.

Yes, that's the way I remember it too. Thanks for your input.

[Sorsha]

Put a vote on wilgy for now. Maybe he will come out of hiding again?

[sprityo]

Im back and here to tell you more of my time visiting this old lady in the woods

[sprityo]

I asked this, Woman in the woods about "any shady, evil, scary characters" that had passed by lately.

To which she replied that she "saw sabie12 with a jagged blade with her." followed by if i "understood that innuendo" and gave me a wink.

To anyone still stumped, she has essentially told me that sabie12 is a member of the jagged blade. Who we know is one of the mafia teams

[DharmaHelper]

I asked this, Woman in the woods about "any shady, evil, scary characters" that had passed by lately.

To which she replied that she "saw sabie12 with a jagged blade with her." followed by if i "understood that innuendo" and gave me a wink.

To anyone still stumped, she has essentially told me that sabie12 is a member of the jagged blade. Who we know is one of the mafia teams

....or that she was traveling with a member of the Jagged Blade faction.

[sprityo]

Same thing ain’t it?

[Lunalee]

I asked this, Woman in the woods about "any shady, evil, scary characters" that had passed by lately.

To which she replied that she "saw sabie12 with a jagged blade with her." followed by if i "understood that innuendo" and gave me a wink.

To anyone still stumped, she has essentially told me that sabie12 is a member of the jagged blade. Who we know is one of the mafia teams

Woah, okay. Maybe we should lynch sabie today

[sprityo]

I don’t take it as literal because she followed up with saying it’s an innuendo

[DharmaHelper]

Same thing ain’t it?

No? If she's on the same square as a Jagged Blade player, then the suspect is that player and not her. If "she has a Jagged Blade with her" means she is the Jagged Blade member, then she is the suspect.

[sabie12]

Put a vote on wilgy for now. Maybe he will come out of hiding again?

Maybe but even when he did last time he was very nonchalant about everything like oh I have votes okay whatever I dont care bye. I feel like usually people who don't post much explain that they're busy or something. And typically at least attempt to defend themselves. He voted no explanation and then disappears and comes back with just wanted to tie things up and then nothing.


And spirityo that sounds like a baddie was near me not that I'm a baddie. I now see you are just misinterpreting the info given to you.

Moving my vote to wilgy.

[sprityo]

Im willing to bet my theory is correct. Trusting strange old women in the woods sounds sound to me

[sprityo]

In any case, it’s been made known what I know. So either Sabie gets lynched or the other mafia team or any of the other killing roles hunt her down

[sabie12]

Im willing to bet my theory is correct. Trusting strange old women in the woods sounds sound to me

I'm willing to bet her info was correct you are just interpreting it wrong. Thanks for sharing helped confirm my suspicions.

[sprityo]

You’re saying you suspect someone near you is mafia then?

[Lunalee]

Moving my vote to sabie, because she very obviously is bad if sprityo's information is correct. Also I don't think sprityo would lie about what he learned, because if sabie flipps town we would all know.

[sprityo]

Which I guess is implying you know who’s near you?

[DharmaHelper]

Sabie, hypothetically if you were to take Sprityo's information to mean that you are NOT bad, who would you say is

[DharmaHelper]

Nevermind Sabie I dunno if legally you can answer that

[S~V~S]

SVS is suspicious

No she is not, S~V~S is 100% town, my fren.

I am as civvie as the day is long. How about you?

Also, I am going to reread some of the posts of the 5 people, I don't like info drops any more than Tranq does, but Sloonei made cases first, so I will deal. I am not going to entertain info drops with no cases, though.

At this stage, I am null about both Quin and G Man, I reread him today and feel better about Kyle than I did, Luna as well, but not 100% there. DDL is someone I want to reread, his one post pinged me, but nothing since, really. If I had to vote this second (GTH) it would be G Man, I think. While not a truth meta guy like Glor, he does not love lying much and has not said some stuff I kind of expected him to say. But not sure yet.

[DharmaHelper]

SVS is suspicious

No she is not, S~V~S is 100% town, my fren.

I am as civvie as the day is long. How about you?

Also, I am going to reread some of the posts of the 5 people, I don't like info drops any more than Tranq does, but Sloonei made cases first, so I will deal. I am not going to entertain info drops with no cases, though.

At this stage, I am null about both Quin and G Man, I reread him today and feel better about Kyle than I did, Luna as well, but not 100% there. DDL is someone I want to reread, his one post pinged me, but nothing since, really. If I had to vote this second (GTH) it would be G Man, I think. While not a truth meta guy like Glor, he does not love lying much and has not said some stuff I kind of expected him to say. But not sure yet.

Not to brag but I've put out a buncha reads and cases without infodumping if that's your jam.

[sabie12]

Nevermind Sabie I dunno if legally you can answer that

I dont know if I legally can either but I think I've made it pretty clear indirectly.

[S~V~S]

SVS is suspicious

No she is not, S~V~S is 100% town, my fren.

I am as civvie as the day is long. How about you?

Also, I am going to reread some of the posts of the 5 people, I don't like info drops any more than Tranq does, but Sloonei made cases first, so I will deal. I am not going to entertain info drops with no cases, though.

At this stage, I am null about both Quin and G Man, I reread him today and feel better about Kyle than I did, Luna as well, but not 100% there. DDL is someone I want to reread, his one post pinged me, but nothing since, really. If I had to vote this second (GTH) it would be G Man, I think. While not a truth meta guy like Glor, he does not love lying much and has not said some stuff I kind of expected him to say. But not sure yet.

Not to brag but I've put out a buncha reads and cases without infodumping if that's your jam.

Thanks! I am a bit overwhelmed in this game, too many suspicions coming from too many directions, it is hard to remember who suspects whom, lol. I will look them up.

Thoughts on G Man? I seem to recall that you had thoughts on him.

[DharmaHelper]

SVS is suspicious

No she is not, S~V~S is 100% town, my fren.

I am as civvie as the day is long. How about you?

Also, I am going to reread some of the posts of the 5 people, I don't like info drops any more than Tranq does, but Sloonei made cases first, so I will deal. I am not going to entertain info drops with no cases, though.

At this stage, I am null about both Quin and G Man, I reread him today and feel better about Kyle than I did, Luna as well, but not 100% there. DDL is someone I want to reread, his one post pinged me, but nothing since, really. If I had to vote this second (GTH) it would be G Man, I think. While not a truth meta guy like Glor, he does not love lying much and has not said some stuff I kind of expected him to say. But not sure yet.

Not to brag but I've put out a buncha reads and cases without infodumping if that's your jam.

Thanks! I am a bit overwhelmed in this game, too many suspicions coming from too many directions, it is hard to remember who suspects whom, lol. I will look them up.

Thoughts on G Man? I seem to recall that you had thoughts on him.

Orange/Red alert on G-Man.

[speedchuck]

Quin isn't responding today and I'm going to be busy this eve.

Voting doc Wilgy

Still want Quin's reaction to recent events.

[Lunalee]

Nevermind Sabie I dunno if legally you can answer that

I dont know if I legally can either but I think I've made it pretty clear indirectly.

yeah, I don't know if I buy this. Sprityo asked if any shady characters had been by that way. The woods lady says, "yeah, I saw sabie with a jagged blade." If sabie were just standing on the square, minding her own business when an actual baddie happens by (like she claims), the wood lady would have told sprityo the other name instead of sabie's.

[LoRab]

Do we know anything about the woman in the woods? Does her information come from the hosts or from another player? Does she have good intentions or bad ones? Does she always tell the truth?

All that said, I do suspect sabie, as I said earlier. So, still tempted to vote there.

And yes, I do tend to be skeptical, lol.

And I can't really argue with suspicion based on that. But, yeah. Insert trademark LR twirl here

Heading home from work now. Will ponder on the drive. More thoughts when I get home.

[S~V~S]

Nevermind Sabie I dunno if legally you can answer that

I dont know if I legally can either but I think I've made it pretty clear indirectly.

yeah, I don't know if I buy this. Sprityo asked if any shady characters had been by that way. The woods lady says, "yeah, I saw sabie with a jagged blade." If sabie were just standing on the square, minding her own business when an actual baddie happens by (like she claims), the wood lady would have told sprityo the other name instead of sabie's.

So you fully believe Sprityos story enough to end someones game solely based on it? You know this woman is honest?

I see bloodthirsty Luna is back.

linki @ Lorab lol

[sabie12]

Nevermind Sabie I dunno if legally you can answer that

I dont know if I legally can either but I think I've made it pretty clear indirectly.

yeah, I don't know if I buy this. Sprityo asked if any shady characters had been by that way. The woods lady says, "yeah, I saw sabie with a jagged blade." If sabie were just standing on the square, minding her own business when an actual baddie happens by (like she claims), the wood lady would have told sprityo the other name instead of sabie's.

I dont think that's true. It says "with" meaning there was a person with me. If the info was given by the hosts I think it was intentionally ambiguous as to not completely give eveything away. From what I know of the hosts they're not going to make things that easy and just say this person is bad. It has a different meaning from the way he was interpreting it.

[Sloonei]

Nevermind Sabie I dunno if legally you can answer that

I dont know if I legally can either but I think I've made it pretty clear indirectly.

yeah, I don't know if I buy this. Sprityo asked if any shady characters had been by that way. The woods lady says, "yeah, I saw sabie with a jagged blade." If sabie were just standing on the square, minding her own business when an actual baddie happens by (like she claims), the wood lady would have told sprityo the other name instead of sabie's.

Unless the wood lady is not allowed to do that.

[S~V~S]

I am gonna go back to my day one vote for now and switch it to Lunalee while I read DHs cases. It could change again.

She was quick to believe an info drop that could be interpreted in more ways than one, and she isn't really considering that aspect. I had seen her as being less aggro, but maybe not.

[VOTE: Lunalee] aubergine

[juliets]

I am gonna go back to my day one vote for now and switch it to Lunalee while I read DHs cases. It could change again.

She was quick to believe an info drop that could be interpreted in more ways than one, and she isn't really considering that aspect. I had seen her as being less aggro, but maybe not.

[VOTE: Lunalee] aubergine

I'm at a loss as to why [mention]Lunalee[/mention] has jumped to a conclusion so quickly. Especially in a game like this where you really need to look carefully at info. Luna, can you explain at all why you aren't more circumspect?

[juliets]

Sorry I used that word wrong. I hope its not confusing.