Mafia: A World Asunder - GAME THREAD [Day 13]

[colonialbob]

Would appreciate thoughts on Jack's and my votes on Tranq.

My info isn’t stopped by anything I see on the front page. Not Hollowman. Not Trickster.

What about the 11 roles with *secrets* ?
What about certain squares that may mess with the info?
What about certain items that may mess with the info?

I guess we should just ignore info then, huh?

Where was this skepticism yesterday? You trusted your own info even after Wilgy flipped town.

Sounds to me like you want to discredit my info cause you don’t want me to lynch your buddies.

This stinks.

[VOTE: Tranq] aubergine

[timmer]

MP made up a scroll in Sword of Truth but that was years ago on the Piano. Someone else may have done it more recently.

OMG, the fucking parchment... legendary...

[timmer]

I've caught up to the end of the night period. I will have plenty of time tomorrow to catch up the rest.

[Lunalee]

So I didn’t read into TH being bad or really read at all, but could someone clear out the possibility for me that TH wasn’t forged into being the trickster upon death?

I never trust flavor posts out of habit (speedchuck and I probably share this) this is a role that can make anyone else they kill reveal as something else. It’s not like I can ask long con “did the trickster for real for real die?”

Linki: very well, I’ll keep that in mind sloon

The answer to your question is that it seems like it would be theoretically possible. If the trickster is bad and killed th and forged it to say th was the trickster and was bad, sure. But... why would they do that? It's interesting that you bring up such a specific question when you have barely participated.

The simplest answer is that a mafia person died. If we make that assumption, we can move forward with analyzing TH and sussing out someone to lynch today. If we get all suspicious that TH only flipped bad, and wasn't really bad, then we don't have a clear path forward for today's lynch. I'd rather assume the simplest scenario that TH was bad, and use that information to move forward.

I like how I pointed at this as Luna's civviest post and now all her recent posts are speculating about secrets and decoys.

This game is full of craziness, and I find it sort of fun to discuss what's going on.

[Lunalee]

I should probably vote at some point. I want to vote sabie, but her posts are just so calm and civ-like that I'm having doubts even though she was basically scum-firmed by sprityo.

[insertnamehere]

I think that Sabie would be a poor choice for the lynch. For multiple reasons

State these reasons.

This so-called Sprityo scumslip. I have reasons, provided by my contact, who has joined in the crowd to condemn me, to doubt that the truth is being told. Look into Sprityo's possible ulterior motives.

[LoRab]

I think that Sabie would be a poor choice for the lynch. For multiple reasons

State these reasons.

This so-called Sprityo scumslip. I have reasons, provided by my contact, who has joined in the crowd to condemn me, to doubt that the truth is being told. Look into Sprityo's possible ulterior motives.

I highly doubt Sprityo is lying about the crazy old woman and her message. The way the info was shared in multiple ways, makes me trust that it was very likely real. That said, whether what the crazy old woman said was fully or at all true or not remains to be seen. And, either way, that does not clear sprityo.

You, on the other hand, I see no reason to trust. Like, at all.

[insertnamehere]

I think that Sabie would be a poor choice for the lynch. For multiple reasons

State these reasons.

This so-called Sprityo scumslip. I have reasons, provided by my contact, who has joined in the crowd to condemn me, to doubt that the truth is being told. Look into Sprityo's possible ulterior motives.

I highly doubt Sprityo is lying about the crazy old woman and her message. The way the info was shared in multiple ways, makes me trust that it was very likely real. That said, whether what the crazy old woman said was fully or at all true or not remains to be seen. And, either way, that does not clear sprityo.

You, on the other hand, I see no reason to trust. Like, at all.

I would very highly suggest that everyone not listen to a single word that crazy old lady says if they want to, y'know, win this friggin' game.

[Epignosis]

I changed my vote to Tranq.

[Epignosis]

Magic Mirror on the wall
Who is the guiltiest one of all?

Spoiler: show

[DharmaHelper]

Tranq and the MIrror of Ebyam

[Epignosis]

Tranq and the MIrror of Ebyam

Maybe objects in the mirror are guiltier than they appear.

[MacDougall]

You people are sheep

[sabie12]

I think that Sabie would be a poor choice for the lynch. For multiple reasons

State these reasons.

This so-called Sprityo scumslip. I have reasons, provided by my contact, who has joined in the crowd to condemn me, to doubt that the truth is being told. Look into Sprityo's possible ulterior motives.

I highly doubt Sprityo is lying about the crazy old woman and her message. The way the info was shared in multiple ways, makes me trust that it was very likely real. That said, whether what the crazy old woman said was fully or at all true or not remains to be seen. And, either way, that does not clear sprityo.

You, on the other hand, I see no reason to trust. Like, at all.

I would very highly suggest that everyone not listen to a single word that crazy old lady says if they want to, y'know, win this friggin' game.

Did you also encounter this crazy lady?

ugh I'm sick guys i think a bad cold so I have gotten to that point where I'm reading the same sentence over and over and getting nowhere trying to still keep up but I need a lot of sleep so I may not be on as much

[Epignosis]

You people are sheep

Sheep with win conditions.

[insertnamehere]

I think that Sabie would be a poor choice for the lynch. For multiple reasons

State these reasons.

This so-called Sprityo scumslip. I have reasons, provided by my contact, who has joined in the crowd to condemn me, to doubt that the truth is being told. Look into Sprityo's possible ulterior motives.

I highly doubt Sprityo is lying about the crazy old woman and her message. The way the info was shared in multiple ways, makes me trust that it was very likely real. That said, whether what the crazy old woman said was fully or at all true or not remains to be seen. And, either way, that does not clear sprityo.

You, on the other hand, I see no reason to trust. Like, at all.

I would very highly suggest that everyone not listen to a single word that crazy old lady says if they want to, y'know, win this friggin' game.

Did you also encounter this crazy lady?

mayhaps.

[Kylemii]

so mac is goth now

[Kylemii]

i meant to spend today digging deep into juliets and TH's isos but woke up with a headache and ended up napping and watching cartoons all day instead. life's hard sometimes for a hard=working farmer, like myself.

[MacDougall]

I am also sick. Wtf.

[Tranq]

Would appreciate thoughts on Jack's and my votes on Tranq.

I don't like them. What's your reasoning besides DH not liking a Day 0 poll post (i mean wtf) and my Wilgy vote? If i encounter any of you on a square i'll gladly tell you where i found the Mirror of Truth. Or maybe not as i wouldn't be surprised if the Tranq voters are annoyed Wilgy teammates.

[Tranq]

I think these INH and Sabie votes are silly and too easy.

Sabie's responses to Sprityo's infodump read genuine to me (I disagree with you here LoRab). As Lunalee said she responds calm and civ-like to the Woods Witch statement and that's literally all there is against her. Seen with a Jagged Blade does not mean she is a Jagged Blade. A Woods Witch is a high fantasy trope, their statements and prophecies never literally mean what they say. INH also seems to know what's up.

Anyone have any thoughts on my SVS vote? I know it's hard to make a case against her but I feel she's doing the same as she did to me in that Survivor game on RM a while ago.
I'm changing my vote to Quin who already has 1 vote and has done nothing but post nonsense.

Tranq is a civilian. I know this with 100% certainty.

Also I'm not voting anyone who claims i'm 100% civ

[sprityo]

SATONY

LIFTOACH PANDEMONIUM

ZAZAS

Good points

i feel like i have just been cursed

[sprityo]

I think that Sabie would be a poor choice for the lynch. For multiple reasons

State these reasons.

This so-called Sprityo scumslip. I have reasons, provided by my contact, who has joined in the crowd to condemn me, to doubt that the truth is being told. Look into Sprityo's possible ulterior motives.

I highly doubt Sprityo is lying about the crazy old woman and her message. The way the info was shared in multiple ways, makes me trust that it was very likely real. That said, whether what the crazy old woman said was fully or at all true or not remains to be seen. And, either way, that does not clear sprityo.

You, on the other hand, I see no reason to trust. Like, at all.

it's actually cool, i met another lady in the woods today. a different one. she didnt have anything cool to say to me though. but she seems to know the first one.

[novaselinenever]

DDL is good. Quin is bad.

[novaselinenever]

That was easy

[VOTE: Quin ] aubergine

[sabie12]

Nova welcome to the game. Have you been hiding from us? Why do you think quin is bad?

[sabie12]

So reading through the posts some people brought up the yin yang thing. How wary should we be of them? And would it behoove us to perhaps figure out who they are if one of them could possibly be recruited by a baddie team?

Anyone have any thoughts on nova appearing all of a sudden out of nowhere day 3?

[Dragon D. Luffy]

I tagged nova in another site yesterday night. Seems like it worked.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

I have a friend who speaks to me in BTSC. They’re the ones who gave me the information I passed on earlier.

To test their trust, I passed the info to the thread

Funny how you casually forget to mention this small detail until there are 4 votes on you.

I've read better excuses for obvious baddie slips.

Don't play mafia while drunk next time, I guess.

[colonialbob]

Would appreciate thoughts on Jack's and my votes on Tranq.

I don't like them. What's your reasoning besides DH not liking a Day 0 poll post (i mean wtf) and my Wilgy vote? If i encounter any of you on a square i'll gladly tell you where i found the Mirror of Truth. Or maybe not as i wouldn't be surprised if the Tranq voters are annoyed Wilgy teammates.

Did you even read the post where I voted for you? Like, at all?

[colonialbob]

I think these INH and Sabie votes are silly and too easy.

Sabie's responses to Sprityo's infodump read genuine to me (I disagree with you here LoRab). As Lunalee said she responds calm and civ-like to the Woods Witch statement and that's literally all there is against her. Seen with a Jagged Blade does not mean she is a Jagged Blade. A Woods Witch is a high fantasy trope, their statements and prophecies never literally mean what they say. INH also seems to know what's up.

Anyone have any thoughts on my SVS vote? I know it's hard to make a case against her but I feel she's doing the same as she did to me in that Survivor game on RM a while ago.
I'm changing my vote to Quin who already has 1 vote and has done nothing but post nonsense.

Tranq is a civilian. I know this with 100% certainty.

Also I'm not voting anyone who claims i'm 100% civ

[sabie12]

Okay so theres not much discussion going on today. I'm leaning on a quin vote. He defended sig who I also think is bad. He changed his vote to wolbre in the first poll and finding out he was civ was like it would have been funny if he was bad though. He votes for epi and I really didnt see any case for that. I haven't really seen much of a case for anything from him so far he also did a lot of distancing in the beginning.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Why are we not overwhelmingly lynching the guy who calimed mafia?

[Tranq]

Why are we not overwhelmingly lynching the guy who calimed mafia?

Because he isn't mafia? I'm pretty sure i know who he is

[Tranq]

I'm changing my vote back to Jack.

[Epignosis]

I should probably vote at some point. I want to vote sabie, but her posts are just so calm and civ-like that I'm having doubts even though she was basically scum-firmed by sprityo.

I want to know why civilian posts are inherently calm in your mind. Civilians should be flipping tables and swinging whips like Jesus in the temple.

THIS IS A DEN OF THIEVES

[Epignosis]

Would appreciate thoughts on Jack's and my votes on Tranq.

I don't like them. What's your reasoning besides DH not liking a Day 0 poll post (i mean wtf) and my Wilgy vote? If i encounter any of you on a square i'll gladly tell you where i found the Mirror of Truth. Or maybe not as i wouldn't be surprised if the Tranq voters are annoyed Wilgy teammates.

And then kill them?

[Epignosis]

The cool part of this story is that I know exactly where Tranq was Day 2.

[DharmaHelper]

I haven't even read this Day phase lol oops.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Why are we not overwhelmingly lynching the guy who calimed mafia?

Because he isn't mafia? I'm pretty sure i know who he is

Did the Mirror of Vague Hinting give that to you too?

[ColinIsCool]

These are all pretty good wagons tbh

[DharmaHelper]

Eh I'll Vote Tranq

[ColinIsCool]

I see the logic in lynching INH — how can you not? — but I just don’t know if I buy that that’s what he meant, honestly. I post in the thread at least once a game drunk off my rocker as many of you know and I’ve never outted myself while doing it.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Why is it so hard for people to beieve that baddies sometimes just out themselves?

Like, LC did that in the last GoC.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Tranq is giving me "too bad to be bad" gut feelings.

[DharmaHelper]

Why is it so hard for people to beieve that baddies sometimes just out themselves?

Like, LC did that in the last GoC.

Tranq is giving me "too bad to be bad" gut feelings.

Wild that these posts were made back to back.

[Lunalee]

I should probably vote at some point. I want to vote sabie, but her posts are just so calm and civ-like that I'm having doubts even though she was basically scum-firmed by sprityo.

I want to know why civilian posts are inherently calm in your mind. Civilians should be flipping tables and swinging whips like Jesus in the temple.

THIS IS A DEN OF THIEVES

so you think sabie is bad?

[colonialbob]

Why is it so hard for people to beieve that baddies sometimes just out themselves?

Like, LC did that in the last GoC.

Tranq is giving me "too bad to be bad" gut feelings.

Wild that these posts were made back to back.

Right?

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Why is it so hard for people to beieve that baddies sometimes just out themselves?

Like, LC did that in the last GoC.

Tranq is giving me "too bad to be bad" gut feelings.

Wild that these posts were made back to back.

It's different.

One thing is INH being drunk and saying something stupid on a whim.

Another is Tranq generally having a suspicious posting style across the whole game that sounds so crazy and weird you have to wonder why would a baddie be trying to post like that.

A single bad post is an accident, 50 bad posts is a trend. Do baddies try to look insane when they are bad, or do they try to look unsuspecting?

[Dragon D. Luffy]

I don't have stats but almost every time I said someone was too bad to be bad I was right.

Except for the times where someone told me the person was too bad to be bad, and they were right.

We have this tendency of lynching weirdos in this site for being weirdos. It seldom pays off.