Vault Hunt [Game Over]

[MacDougall]

I will put info in here in 5 minutes unless I hear a good reason why I shouldn't.

Soup?

So I should be night killed and take this knowledge to the grave rather than be soup killed?

[Sloonei]

I will put info in here in 5 minutes unless I hear a good reason why I shouldn't.

Soup?

So I should be night killed and take this knowledge to the grave rather than be soup killed?

[MacDougall]

What would you do?

[Sloonei]

What would you do?

[novaselinenever]

Yo spill it out. The number of roles that could have information is low, you're a dead man walking if you're truthful.

Linki

You witch.

[MacDougall]

What would you do?

Choosing to be unhelpful at this juncture is a very bad look.

[Sloonei]

What would you do?

Choosing to be unhelpful at this juncture is a very bad look.

I don’t know what you’re going through and I’ve put minimal thought into this game or its setup. Do what you think is best. You don’t need my input.

[MacDougall]

Yo spill it out. The number of roles that could have information is low, you're a dead man walking if you're truthful.

Linki

You witch.

What's the hurry? The day is young. I don't want to do it and then have someone make a really logical argument as to why I shouldn't have.

[MacDougall]

What would you do?

Choosing to be unhelpful at this juncture is a very bad look.

I don’t know what you’re going through and I’ve put minimal thought into this game or its setup. Do what you think is best. You don’t need my input.

I asked for it though. I perceive it as a critical moment for the civilian win con and want a discussion.

[MacDougall]

[mention]Jackofhearts2005[/mention] you were lurking and said nothing. Why?

[MacDougall]

Where is the day 1 poll?

[Sloonei]

What would you do?

Choosing to be unhelpful at this juncture is a very bad look.

I don’t know what you’re going through and I’ve put minimal thought into this game or its setup. Do what you think is best. You don’t need my input.

I asked for it though. I perceive it as a critical moment for the civilian win con and want a discussion.

You have strongly indicated that you have information.
There are only a limited number of roles that could gather information.
The hags can narrow their soup pool if you tell us what you are.
We can lynch one of them if your info is legit.
Or we can trust you and lynch your suspect without having you claim. That you’re prepared to claim at all might be enough for me.

Hold off for now.

[Sloonei]

[VOTE: sabie] aubergine

[novaselinenever]

Yo spill it out. The number of roles that could have information is low, you're a dead man walking if you're truthful.

Linki

You witch.

What's the hurry? The day is young. I don't want to do it and then have someone make a really logical argument as to why I shouldn't have.

The hurry is that there's going to be a lot to discuss post revelation. With no flip and the soup kill being a thing, there is nothing stopping witches from claiming a role and a guilty check on anyone. You could be one.

The hurry is that there is no logical argument as to why you shouldn't finish what you started when you're a dead man walking. The number of roles possibly having information is very limited, so you're basically dead lol. NK or Soup kill, you're gone.

The risk of you narrowing the target of soup kills by claiming is a non-sense argument 'cause witches will figure out your role one or another, by killing you at night or trying to soup-kill you guessing one of the few roles possibly having info.

[Spacedaisy]

Question: Why would Mac suspect Sabie without giving a case?

Spacedaisy: Not worth thinking about

Interesting response.

Information you are disregarding: I’ve had Mac jerk me around before because that’s the way he plays and I don’t feel like wandering down that path. If he wants o build a case he can do it, in fact I’d love to hear it because I don’t yet have a read on Sabie, feel like she has slid under my radar. If he doesn’t then I will judge Sabie on my own, separate from his no case statement.

[novaselinenever]

What would you do?

Choosing to be unhelpful at this juncture is a very bad look.

I don’t know what you’re going through and I’ve put minimal thought into this game or its setup. Do what you think is best. You don’t need my input.

I asked for it though. I perceive it as a critical moment for the civilian win con and want a discussion.

Or we can trust you and lynch your suspect without having you claim. That you’re prepared to claim at all might be enough for me.

What's stopping a witch from fake-claiming an info? No flips, counter-claim get soup-killed.

[Sloonei]

What would you do?

Choosing to be unhelpful at this juncture is a very bad look.

I don’t know what you’re going through and I’ve put minimal thought into this game or its setup. Do what you think is best. You don’t need my input.

I asked for it though. I perceive it as a critical moment for the civilian win con and want a discussion.

Or we can trust you and lynch your suspect without having you claim. That you’re prepared to claim at all might be enough for me.

What's stopping a witch from fake-claiming an info? No flips, counter-claim get soup-killed.

Nothing.

[MacDougall]

I just had a look at the way the eod unfolded and I think the POE that infodumping here creates is too good to pass up.

Lunalee was a witch.

My case on Sabie is based on my perceiving her being compatible with Luna.

[Spacedaisy]

At a certain point in this game, anybody who holds information is going to need to assess whether it’s more valuable to share or keep it secret.

Idk what else to say on this matter.

This is basically a description of every mafia game with disco role of any type ever. Thanks for the unhelpful fluff.

I will put info in here in 5 minutes unless I hear a good reason why I shouldn't.

If you’ve already outed yourself there is no reason not to share the info.

I will put info in here in 5 minutes unless I hear a good reason why I shouldn't.

Soup?

So I should be night killed and take this knowledge to the grave rather than be soup killed?

You e already claimed, you’re probably fucked. If you hadn’t claimed they might have tried a regular kill rather than a soup kill and the angels could have protected you possibly. But they can’t protect from a soup kill, so just put your info out there since you already claimed.

[MacDougall]

Now kiss.

[Spacedaisy]

Yo spill it out. The number of roles that could have information is low, you're a dead man walking if you're truthful.

Linki

You witch.

What's the hurry? The day is young. I don't want to do it and then have someone make a really logical argument as to why I shouldn't have.

Fair enough. Don’t rush. I suppose it could make a difference if there are multiple info roles, I just assumed one in particular.

[MacDougall]

Drink the soup bitches.

[MacDougall]

Yo spill it out. The number of roles that could have information is low, you're a dead man walking if you're truthful.

Linki

You witch.

What's the hurry? The day is young. I don't want to do it and then have someone make a really logical argument as to why I shouldn't have.

Fair enough. Don’t rush. I suppose it could make a difference if there are multiple info roles, I just assumed one in particular.

Do you even linki?

[MacDougall]

Go forth and analyse the dead person's interactions for clues y'all.

[Spacedaisy]

Guys, don’t forget that NKs have the chance of being protected and Soup kills do not. That is a huge difference and should be considered

[Spacedaisy]

Yo spill it out. The number of roles that could have information is low, you're a dead man walking if you're truthful.

Linki

You witch.

What's the hurry? The day is young. I don't want to do it and then have someone make a really logical argument as to why I shouldn't have.

Fair enough. Don’t rush. I suppose it could make a difference if there are multiple info roles, I just assumed one in particular.

Do you even linki?

Doesn’t work properly on phone. Deal with it.

[Sloonei]

At a certain point in this game, anybody who holds information is going to need to assess whether it’s more valuable to share or keep it secret.

Idk what else to say on this matter.

This is basically a description of every mafia game with disco role of any type ever. Thanks for the unhelpful fluff.

You're welcome.

[MacDougall]

Ouch the burn

[Spacedaisy]

I agree with your assessment of Sabie in relation to Luna. Question, how likely do you think she was to include her teammate in her top three people she’d be interested in lynching list?

[MacDougall]

I agree with your assessment of Sabie in relation to Luna. Question, how likely do you think she was to include her teammate in her top three people she’d be interested in lynching list?

Given she had barely mentioned Jack and then didn't elaborate like at all ...

[Spacedaisy]

Sloonei could also be compatible withluna, since Muriel was absent.

[novaselinenever]

That's underwhelming.

[novaselinenever]

Sloonei could also be compatible withluna, since Muriel was absent.

Lol what?

[Spacedaisy]

That was exactly what I was talking about, Jack I mean.

[Epignosis]

Y’all gotta stop putting words in my mouth, The only thing allowed in there is food, water, and my opinions

You opened that up to too many bad jokes.

[MacDougall]

And given Jack voted for me and left his vote there all day despite literally saying he didn't suspect me

[MacDougall]

That's underwhelming.

[novaselinenever]

Sprit and Epi are front-runners for scum compatibility with a potential witch Luna.

[Spacedaisy]

Sloonei could also be compatible withluna, since Muriel was absent.

Lol what?

Mac has revealed Luna was a witch. So now we can look at who Luna is compatible with. Muriel was replaced by Sloonei because Muriel was absent. With no interaction to judge from Alina could conceivably had been teammates with Muriel/Sloonei.

Unless I’m mixed up bad missing something I thought this was straightforward. Am I confused?

[novaselinenever]

That's underwhelming.

I'll just assume we got a baddie to keep the D1 streak alive

[sprityo]

At a certain point in this game, anybody who holds information is going to need to assess whether it’s more valuable to share or keep it secret.

Idk what else to say on this matter.

Okay so basically under other circumstances, we could have one person claim, like epi who insisted he’s the pope, and will be fine cause that’s a max 2 kills if mafia get lucky.

However mafia have unlimited soup kills so basically it’s not worth it to claim unless it’s damning evidence

[Spacedaisy]

Sprit and Epi are front-runners for scum compatibility with a potential witch Luna.

Explain why you think this?

[MacDougall]

Sprityo is in my locktown list.

Epi is suspect though.

[MacDougall]

Neverwhere and nutella are also town

[sprityo]

Y’all gotta stop putting words in my mouth, The only thing allowed in there is food, water, and my opinions

You opened that up to too many bad jokes.

God please nominate it for quote of the year. I’m desperate

[Epignosis]

You e already claimed, you’re probably fucked.

I'm Mordefly, and nobody killed me.

[novaselinenever]

Sloonei could also be compatible withluna, since Muriel was absent.

Lol what?

Mac has revealed Luna was a witch. So now we can look at who Luna is compatible with. Muriel was replaced by Sloonei because Muriel was absent. With no interaction to judge from Alina could conceivably had been teammates with Muriel/Sloonei.

Unless I’m mixed up bad missing something I thought this was straightforward. Am I confused?

Of course, they "could" be compatible. That's like default compatibility.

It's similar to scum-reading someone that hasn't posted. They could be scum lol

[Sloonei]

Sloonei could also be compatible withluna, since Muriel was absent.

Fair assessment.

[novaselinenever]

Who did you check Mordefly?

[Epignosis]

Sprit and Epi are front-runners for scum compatibility with a potential witch Luna.

No we're not.