I have a theory that I’d rather not bring up here.
This is a good thing to be aware of.
Moderator: Community Team
I have a theory that I’d rather not bring up here.
Where would you rather bring it up?
Another thing I have to consider about this post specifically is that there was “no issue” with Sloonei’s ISO until nutella retorted to which Dragomir then went through his ISO and made comments on itDragomir wrote: ↑Sat May 18, 2019 3:44 amI first I thought he made valid statements, but thinking about it now, I was rather fooled by his in-depth analysis. Now reading back on it, half of what he said doesn't make any sense.Like right here, not a single clue what he was trying to say here. Looks like like a bunch of words to look more in-depth with iso.The player called Sloonei is grilling nutella a little bit. Nothing serious, but the directness of the final question in this exchange suggests attentiveness on his part. nutella gives it a casual sidestep, leaning (it would seem) more toward the "General town read", but with enough resistance in the "roll of foil" comment to avoid rolling over completely. I would file this under "downplaying pressure".
Next we go to this here. This I believe to be a super trivial reason to say that you're going after the low-hanging fruit. I mean, one would really have to stretch out your sarcasm say the bolded part. Even with that, one really can't get the line of logic there. Also, at least from what I read, you made no push or any questioning/prodding directed at Sprit, going after the low-hanging fruit doesn't really work here as a reason.sprityo drops in and drops out. I don't object to keeping tabs on him and putting pressure on him to post more. What bothers me about this is the bluntness of nutella's response. She's being purposefully oppositional toward sprit. It looks more like she's putting a tab on future suspect than she is trying to wrangle content out of a quiet player. File this under "low-hanging fruit".
Only part of his post where he actually starts making sense imo. I can get how Mata falls into a low-hanging fruit category and the MafiaMenace part. But that last sentenced, the bolded I don't understand. @Sloonei what do you mean by that? So this is basically the only part of the post that I like, and it's pretty meh.I have no direct objections to her Mac suspicion here, so I've cut it out of the post. But it exists and I don't want to seem like I'm dismissing it.
Matahari and MafiaMenace are low-hanging fruit here. Mata falls into the same category as sprit. She goes after MafiaMenace for his focus on mechanics to that point, which is something I've already commented on. These are not particularly inspired suspicions.
So yeah, I can grill him more but you get the point. And about your response, I'll get to that soonish.
My dear, I have not had a hangover in ten years.
I hadn’t got to that point yet.Luxurious wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:00 amShe already said it was self-pres bro
I would ordinarily be fine with that, but she got caught up in end of Day business, and that's different.
i’ve never had a hangover but I assume that’s because I’m much younger than you!
I’ve been eyeballing this pair since matahari defended lux and then told us she wasn’t defending lux.
What was Marahari hoping to accomplish?
Not to be nit picky but she says it in the first post you quoted In Here going “i voted cooler for self-pres”Sloonei wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:09 amI hadn’t got to that point yet.Luxurious wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:00 amShe already said it was self-pres bro
I do not know what the poll looked like so I can’t really determine what the situation was when the vote was cast. Oh well.
She’s still a suspect. Epi’s got me looking at Daisy too.
I hope a goddamned seal eats you.
I’m not sure. But the wording and sequence of it was one of the more awkward moments I’ve witnessed in a mafia game in a long time.
That’s true. But that’s part of what I was saying re: Not having time to get into the game
It was, and I think we've talked about it. I still suspect her, but I'd rather you talk about the lack of Reverse Flash and the TRENCHCOAT THAT CLOSED UPON HIS BALLS.Sloonei wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:14 amI’m not sure. But the wording and sequence of it was one of the more awkward moments I’ve witnessed in a mafia game in a long time.
My biggest issue when considering my own standpoint here is thatSloonei wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:14 amI’m not sure. But the wording and sequence of it was one of the more awkward moments I’ve witnessed in a mafia game in a long time.
I can buy the Slow Speedsters theory. But another theory I can buy is that they were (are) hesitant to use Reverse Flash because it could/would signal to everyone else that one of their members was in danger of being lynched. Obviously “in danger of being lynched” is better than “lynched”, but maybe they’re a bunch of nervous nellies who thought they could get away with it and hang onto their cool ability past Day 1.Epignosis wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:17 amIt was, and I think we've talked about it. I still suspect her, but I'd rather you talk about the lack of Reverse Flash and the TRENCHCOAT THAT CLOSED UPON HIS BALLS.Sloonei wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:14 amI’m not sure. But the wording and sequence of it was one of the more awkward moments I’ve witnessed in a mafia game in a long time.
Sometimes Mafia Make MistakesLuxurious wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:19 amMy biggest issue when considering my own standpoint here is thatSloonei wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:14 amI’m not sure. But the wording and sequence of it was one of the more awkward moments I’ve witnessed in a mafia game in a long time.
I was a main lynch target from the beginning of the day. There’s no point in even HALF defending me if she’s scum because that’s counterproductive to her ultimate goal of getting a mislynch.
There’s also not point in it if we’re both buddies, since that kinda interaction would ultimately kill her in the end should I have flipped scum.
The only other option there under the Assumption that at least one of us is scum is that she hopes her flip proves I’m scum and nets a free town lynch which doesnt work! Since again, I was a main wagon the entire day
So I’m not like, inclined to believe that she’s scum
I get that. But...that means they weren't willing to use it when Lux or Mata was ahead. What say you?Sloonei wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:23 amI can buy the Slow Speedsters theory. But another theory I can buy is that they were (are) hesitant to use Reverse Flash because it could/would signal to everyone else that one of their members was in danger of being lynched. Obviously “in danger of being lynched” is better than “lynched”, but maybe they’re a bunch of nervous nellies who thought they could get away with it and hang onto their cool ability past Day 1.Epignosis wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:17 amIt was, and I think we've talked about it. I still suspect her, but I'd rather you talk about the lack of Reverse Flash and the TRENCHCOAT THAT CLOSED UPON HIS BALLS.Sloonei wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:14 amI’m not sure. But the wording and sequence of it was one of the more awkward moments I’ve witnessed in a mafia game in a long time.
Maybe but i dont really see her as scum. I only looked at it that was at EoD because her vote on me looked opportunistic from a scum standpoint since it pushed me up to lead the lynch (and i assumed day ended at 10:00pm edt)
I'm not looking for your lynch today. In the future? Perhaps. Today, no.
Yeah but I like to believe that in an idealistic world they wouldnt make such a blatant oneSloonei wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:24 amSometimes Mafia Make MistakesLuxurious wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:19 amMy biggest issue when considering my own standpoint here is thatSloonei wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:14 amI’m not sure. But the wording and sequence of it was one of the more awkward moments I’ve witnessed in a mafia game in a long time.
I was a main lynch target from the beginning of the day. There’s no point in even HALF defending me if she’s scum because that’s counterproductive to her ultimate goal of getting a mislynch.
There’s also not point in it if we’re both buddies, since that kinda interaction would ultimately kill her in the end should I have flipped scum.
The only other option there under the Assumption that at least one of us is scum is that she hopes her flip proves I’m scum and nets a free town lynch which doesnt work! Since again, I was a main wagon the entire day
So I’m not like, inclined to believe that she’s scum
That's the difference between you and me.Luxurious wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:26 amMaybe but i dont really see her as scum. I only looked at it that was at EoD because her vote on me looked opportunistic from a scum standpoint since it pushed me up to lead the lynch (and i assumed day ended at 10:00pm edt)
Otherwise everything she was doing was too openly wolfy for a wolf to be doing
I mean this is a possible considerationEpignosis wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:28 amThat's the difference between you and me.Luxurious wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:26 amMaybe but i dont really see her as scum. I only looked at it that was at EoD because her vote on me looked opportunistic from a scum standpoint since it pushed me up to lead the lynch (and i assumed day ended at 10:00pm edt)
Otherwise everything she was doing was too openly wolfy for a wolf to be doing
It isn't too evil to be evil- it can be "I'm scared and scuffling and don't know what to do." I've seen plenty of mafia do that- even experienced mafioso.
Was cooler in any danger at that point? Not having been around, I don’t know what the poll looked like. But why would anyone bother to use up that ability on Day 1 when there is no apparent danger to their own team?Epignosis wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:25 amI get that. But...that means they weren't willing to use it when Lux or Mata was ahead. What say you?Sloonei wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:23 amI can buy the Slow Speedsters theory. But another theory I can buy is that they were (are) hesitant to use Reverse Flash because it could/would signal to everyone else that one of their members was in danger of being lynched. Obviously “in danger of being lynched” is better than “lynched”, but maybe they’re a bunch of nervous nellies who thought they could get away with it and hang onto their cool ability past Day 1.Epignosis wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:17 amIt was, and I think we've talked about it. I still suspect her, but I'd rather you talk about the lack of Reverse Flash and the TRENCHCOAT THAT CLOSED UPON HIS BALLS.Sloonei wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:14 amI’m not sure. But the wording and sequence of it was one of the more awkward moments I’ve witnessed in a mafia game in a long time.
This post is something the devil makes with grenadine and bourbon.Matahari wrote: ↑Mon May 20, 2019 8:20 pmYou aren’t as good a judge of civvieness as I hoped you’d be. I can’t accept your other comments about people you think are bad, because I know you’re wrong about me. Either way, I would not place a vote on you today. I get it and I’m sure everyone else gets it too.Sloonei wrote: ↑Mon May 20, 2019 8:12 pm Similarly, Matahari’s response where she singled out Luxurious to offer a weird pseduo-defense which she later claimed was not a defense is many shades of confusing to me. I didn’t like the read she presented, and I didn’t like that she later denounced it as a defense without really explaining what the read itself.
There are multiple kills. You are not guaranteed the use of that role outside Day 1. I would have burned it Day 1 given the chance. Reverse Flash (OH YES THEY CALL HIM THE STREAK!) could be dead by now.Sloonei wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:35 amWas cooler in any danger at that point? Not having been around, I don’t know what the poll looked like. But why would anyone bother to use up that ability on Day 1 when there is no apparent danger to their own team?Epignosis wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:25 amI get that. But...that means they weren't willing to use it when Lux or Mata was ahead. What say you?Sloonei wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:23 amI can buy the Slow Speedsters theory. But another theory I can buy is that they were (are) hesitant to use Reverse Flash because it could/would signal to everyone else that one of their members was in danger of being lynched. Obviously “in danger of being lynched” is better than “lynched”, but maybe they’re a bunch of nervous nellies who thought they could get away with it and hang onto their cool ability past Day 1.Epignosis wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:17 amIt was, and I think we've talked about it. I still suspect her, but I'd rather you talk about the lack of Reverse Flash and the TRENCHCOAT THAT CLOSED UPON HIS BALLS.
Mafia Member feels some scrutiny on them and needs to present a read. The pressure is on.Luxurious wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:33 amI mean this is a possible considerationEpignosis wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:28 amThat's the difference between you and me.Luxurious wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:26 amMaybe but i dont really see her as scum. I only looked at it that was at EoD because her vote on me looked opportunistic from a scum standpoint since it pushed me up to lead the lynch (and i assumed day ended at 10:00pm edt)
Otherwise everything she was doing was too openly wolfy for a wolf to be doing
It isn't too evil to be evil- it can be "I'm scared and scuffling and don't know what to do." I've seen plenty of mafia do that- even experienced mafioso.
But on day 1 no less....
I would assume then that someone else up for the lynch would be her teammate because it doesnt make sense to backtrack on me unless the other option was someone she really didnt want to go on
Oh yes, I almost forgot this post. I gave it a scathing “Yuck” at the time, the harshest possible review any post can get.Epignosis wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:36 amThis post is something the devil makes with grenadine and bourbon.Matahari wrote: ↑Mon May 20, 2019 8:20 pmYou aren’t as good a judge of civvieness as I hoped you’d be. I can’t accept your other comments about people you think are bad, because I know you’re wrong about me. Either way, I would not place a vote on you today. I get it and I’m sure everyone else gets it too.Sloonei wrote: ↑Mon May 20, 2019 8:12 pm Similarly, Matahari’s response where she singled out Luxurious to offer a weird pseduo-defense which she later claimed was not a defense is many shades of confusing to me. I didn’t like the read she presented, and I didn’t like that she later denounced it as a defense without really explaining what the read itself.
It discredits Sloonei without suspecting him.
It says "You're wrong about everything else because you're wrong about me" which Matahari knows can't be true (she's smart).
Toys out of the pram as they say (eh Mac?) or something else?
I agree, but not everyone thinks that way.Epignosis wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:38 amThere are multiple kills. You are not guaranteed the use of that role outside Day 1. I would have burned it Day 1 given the chance. Reverse Flash (OH YES THEY CALL HIM THE STREAK!) could be dead by now.Sloonei wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:35 amWas cooler in any danger at that point? Not having been around, I don’t know what the poll looked like. But why would anyone bother to use up that ability on Day 1 when there is no apparent danger to their own team?Epignosis wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:25 amI get that. But...that means they weren't willing to use it when Lux or Mata was ahead. What say you?Sloonei wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 2:23 amI can buy the Slow Speedsters theory. But another theory I can buy is that they were (are) hesitant to use Reverse Flash because it could/would signal to everyone else that one of their members was in danger of being lynched. Obviously “in danger of being lynched” is better than “lynched”, but maybe they’re a bunch of nervous nellies who thought they could get away with it and hang onto their cool ability past Day 1.
Just want to reiterate here and say if it was The Queen who blacked and reversed a shot - the write up would probably indicate that information with a failed kill on their would be killerUltra wrote: ↑Tue May 21, 2019 11:04 pm Interesting that nobody was killed by the league.
There are few protective roles in this game, one of which belongs to the league itself.
So we can discern they either shot Thea Queen or Deathstroke. Had they hit The Queen the shot should rebound though.
But it leads to a potentially interesting conclusion - someone who was a high priority target is actually the SK
Nutella scum, Sloonei scum, Mata scum, Luxy town. Long Con maybe scum. Wilgy scum too.