Take Me Out at the Ballgame! [DAY 3]

[Michelle]

Probably doesn't kill MP:
Epignosis
Long Con

Not sure, nor is she, but possibly cleared by a cop hunt anyway:
nutella

Not sure period:
S~V~S

Don't see why they wouldn't kill MP:
Michelle
Nanook

if I were scum I wouldn't like to kill him personally. But i would let the NK for my scumpartener because I have yet little knowledge about everyone here.
On the other hand, him as veteran player is fear killed by every single player including you. Every sane mafia kills M+7 if he rands villager.

Your analysis is so wifom-y that it gives me goosebumbs.

[Michelle]

Lemme check to see who my teamates are first.

No infos in scumchat?

[Jackofhearts2005]

RIP Elvis, my favorite ball player.

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

[Jackofhearts2005]

Boooo Designated Hitter

The designated hitter makes for a more exciting game. Removing the worst batter on a team and adding someone who only bats is a good thing.

[nutella]

Still haven't read, but I think S~V~S would kill MP.

Jackofhearts2005 is pinch-hitting for SVS.

Lolololol I'm literally unlynchable. Nice try, Epi.

[Sloonei]

RIP Elvis, my favorite ball player.

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

are you sure adrian beltre isn't your favorite?

[Jackofhearts2005]

RIP Elvis, my favorite ball player.

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

are you sure adrian beltre isn't your favorite?

I like the two of them together. Elvis has other funny stuff going on without Andrian, though.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Still haven't read, but I think S~V~S would kill MP.

Jackofhearts2005 is pinch-hitting for SVS.

Lolololol I'm literally unlynchable. Nice try, Epi.

Wassup, Nutella? Who is bad?

[Jackofhearts2005]

[VOTE: Michelle] aubergine

Lay off my scum buddy >: (

[VOTE: Epic nosebleed] aubergine

Did Epi get baited?

Masterfully. And several times since his preteen years.

Gross.

[Jackofhearts2005]

[VOTE: Michelle] aubergine

For me, she seems to be trying too hard.

this word, "seems" looks like you want to shade me but you can't because you don't have any reason to scum read me.

No not at all. That's how you seem to me. What do you think of what I said, as opposed to how I said it?

You said I try hard. You didn't speculate about my AI. I think you avoid the point here.

My impression coming into Day 1 was that S~V~S and Michelle were teammates.

So this is a neat exchange. I no longer have that impression.

I kinda don't believe this but it's not like I can actually read Epi for shit.

[Jackofhearts2005]

As of page 2, I have a townread on Nutella and would not be at all surprised if Diz (now Jay iirc) and/or Epi were scum.

That probably means that Michelle isn't scum but it's not by virtue of anything she's said.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Slight townread on Nanook. It's for a stupid reason that I'm not going to tell you but I'm gonna hold onto the read until I have reason not to.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Yeah, you can take town Nutella to the bank. You're welcome.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Some things:
I didn't read Mac's post about Epi/me, but if his point is that we didn't interact then that's a bit seeelly and random. But it's ok, cause I think Mac is town. I also think he would think of me as "different". Same goes for Nut. Nobody learns my meta rip.

Wolf Dys maybe doesn't say this about two townies. Maybe they do. Idk. Seems like you should be able to extract something from this post.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Nut, SVS, Mac and Epi are all very likely to be town imo. If I'm wrong on Michelle idfk, but I don't feel like I am.

LC's post was bad and MP hasn't posted which is also bad. So it's Michelle plus one of LC and MP. I'm good a mafia sometimes, you've seen it. And if I'm not, blame my teammate Epi.

This feels pretty town tbh. Like town Dizzy in GoC mixed it up and was confident in their reads. Feels like that.

[Jackofhearts2005]

I don't want you to take offense, but if I knew nothing about baseball, your explanation about the designated hitter would only confuse me more. American League? What is that? Are all the teams American? etc. Michelle's reaction to your explanation sounded like, "Okay, we can check off interacting with one another" to me.

This is actually a pretty fair read. It's wrong and he decides it's wrong before he even gives this but this does feel like a real thought from Epi.

Shit. I need scumreads.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Town
Jack
Nutella
Dys/Jay
.....
Nanook
Epi
.....
Michelle
LC
.....
.....
Scum




Unless both power roles are in Nutella and Jay, we can pretty well guarantee a wolf lynch today since there's very likely 2 wolves in a 4 player POE and two innocent children.

[Jackofhearts2005]

I'm at the top of page 5 and going to bed.

[Michelle]

I'm at the top of page 5 and going to bed.

For the first 4 pages your rainbow reads are too soonish expressed.
Tbh I cleared Svs for fluence of posts and thoughts but she never posted reads and jumped on me without a real reason. She invented I was hard trying and never reconsidered.
M7 said she may be stubborn. I wonder if she was genuine in her belief of me being scum.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Town
Jack
Nutella
Dys/Jay
.....
Nanook
Epi
.....
Michelle
LC
.....
.....
Scum




Unless both power roles are in Nutella and Jay, we can pretty well guarantee a wolf lynch today since there's very likely 2 wolves in a 4 player POE and two innocent children.

I've already claimed a PR, so

Move me up daddy

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Probably doesn't kill MP:
Epignosis
Long Con

Not sure, nor is she, but possibly cleared by a cop hunt anyway:
nutella

Not sure period:
S~V~S

Don't see why they wouldn't kill MP:
Michelle
Nanook

if I were scum I wouldn't like to kill him personally. But i would let the NK for my scumpartener because I have yet little knowledge about everyone here.
On the other hand, him as veteran player is fear killed by every single player including you. Every sane mafia kills M+7 if he rands villager.

Your analysis is so wifom-y that it gives me goosebumbs.

Okay you’re a prime suspect for MP murder.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

[VOTE: Michelle] aubergine

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I'm at the top of page 5 and going to bed.

For the first 4 pages your rainbow reads are too soonish expressed.
Tbh I cleared Svs for fluence of posts and thoughts but she never posted reads and jumped on me without a real reason. She invented I was hard trying and never reconsidered.
M7 said she may be stubborn. I wonder if she was genuine in her belief of me being scum.

I don’t believe your S~V~S read.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I hope our civilian power roles are paying close attention to today’s developments. If Nanook goes unchallenged then we’re going to trust his claim. Someone out there should know if he is lying. If you don’t understand the matrix, let me know. I wrote it. I want to avoid silly shenanigans.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I hope our civilian power roles are paying close attention to today’s developments. If Nanook goes unchallenged then we’re going to trust his claim. Someone out there should know if he is lying. If you don’t understand the matrix, let me know. I wrote it. I want to avoid silly shenanigans.

To be clear: if anyone out there is a doctor or a cop, Nanook is lying. Don’t hide if that’s you.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Town
Jack
Nutella
Dys/Jay
.....
Nanook
Epi
.....
Michelle
LC
.....
.....
Scum




Unless both power roles are in Nutella and Jay, we can pretty well guarantee a wolf lynch today since there's very likely 2 wolves in a 4 player POE and two innocent children.

I've already claimed a PR, so

Move me up daddy

Yeah, my stupid reason for townreading you was that I thought you were hinting a power role ("I'm not getting lynched today") but I didn't want to say that out loud and get you killed if it wasn't known. Haven't gotten to the part where you outright claimed yet.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I mean

I’m not quite as in your face about it as you but I do that when I’m VT too lol

[Jackofhearts2005]

I need to steal a page out of Dyslexicon's playbook.

Our AC is fixed.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Day was full of homechores, now I am back :-)

I have a couple of mechanics questions. I have not played very many games with a matrix like this one has, and I am not 100% on the terminology.

What is a "strongman"? And a "Role Doc", that is a role checker, right?

Ok, I see the matrix setup now. No wonder nobody reacted to my "it says two scum in the OP". =p

A role cop is someone who cop town to see what role they have, vanilla or otherwise.

A role cop is a cop who's result is tne role of the target no matter AI.

So first you vote me witout any concern about my AI and you associate me at random and now you lie about what a role cop does. You posted other cop role smh

You are bad Dizzy

Not really my favorite Michelle post.

I'm reserving a full Michelle read because I like the idea of her being a freebee read like Nutella and I think I'm up to a 4 game correctly reading her streak and even my last game I incorrectly read her I was like "I townread everyone but I guess I townread Michelle least" and she was town so that's half a correct read and I don't want to bust my streak.

But yeah, not really my favorite Michelle post.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Jack's reasons for trusting my slot are dubious.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

A role cop is a cop who's result is tne role of the target no matter AI.

So first you vote me witout any concern about my AI and you associate me at random and now you lie about what a role cop does. You posted other cop role smh

You are bad Dizzy

Credit to Jack though for bringing this post up, because now that I see it I hate it.

1) Dizzy didn't "lie" about what a role cop does. In this setup with two factions, it's exactly what Dizzy said it was.

2) Why would Dizzy even lie about that? What?

3) Why is that suspicious?

This is pure shade, and it's bad. Michelle is bad.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

if I were scum I wouldn't like to kill him personally. But i would let the NK for my scumpartener because I have yet little knowledge about everyone here.
On the other hand, him as veteran player is fear killed by every single player including you. Every sane mafia kills M+7 if he rands villager.

Your analysis is so wifom-y that it gives me goosebumbs.

Let's review this doozy.

Why not? You're one of only two people here that doesn't have a history with MP to hinder your willingness to murder him.

Okay sure.

No he isn't. MP is a respected mafia talent, but sometimes folks ignore that to make a game more fun. I refused to kill Epignosis in the GOC despite him being a threat to me. This is starting to look like justification instead of conjecture.

No I don't. There is no player in this game I am less likely to kill than MP. That's why I started this course of hunting. You turning it on me like this is a defense mechanism, not an accusation.

More justification, not conjecture.

I don't believe you. Bad kill choice.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

A role cop is a cop who's result is tne role of the target no matter AI.

So first you vote me witout any concern about my AI and you associate me at random and now you lie about what a role cop does. You posted other cop role smh

You are bad Dizzy

Credit to Jack though for bringing this post up, because now that I see it I hate it.

1) Dizzy didn't "lie" about what a role cop does. In this setup with two factions, it's exactly what Dizzy said it was.

2) Why would Dizzy even lie about that? What?

3) Why is that suspicious?

This is pure shade, and it's bad. Michelle is bad.

I screwed the quotes. The thing in a "Jack" quote here was actually a Michelle post.

[Jackofhearts2005]

[VOTE: Michelle] aubergine

For me, she seems to be trying too hard.

this word, "seems" looks like you want to shade me but you can't because you don't have any reason to scum read me.

Second, this is scum language. It's "you don't have a reason to think I'm scum" instead of "I'm town".
I also agree that Michelle vibes kawaiii in the worst way in the very start of the game.

[VOTE: Michelle] aubergine

I like this post.

Several players have expressed similar things to this MP7 post. I dig the idea but I kinda disagree.

Like I can see the potential town perspective of what Michelle's saying. Like in a world where JaggedDys and Michelle are both town, JaggedDys doesn't know Michelle is town so "You say 'seems' because I'm town" doesn't really make sense as a reason JaggedDys isn't town.

I'd have worded it like "'Seems' looks like you want to shade me but you can't come up with a concrete reason to do so."

I view the wording as NAI.

Spoiler: show

Unless I later scumread Michelle, in which case I will pretend I see this as a perspective slip because I am very smart.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Jack's reasons for trusting my slot are dubious.

Who cares? I'm obvious town and will be obvious town all game. I'm only a quarter of the way through the thread. Maybe my read will change but if it doesn't, you can be happy about it.

[Jackofhearts2005]

if I were scum I wouldn't like to kill him personally. But i would let the NK for my scumpartener because I have yet little knowledge about everyone here.
On the other hand, him as veteran player is fear killed by every single player including you. Every sane mafia kills M+7 if he rands villager.

Your analysis is so wifom-y that it gives me goosebumbs.

Let's review this doozy.

Why not? You're one of only two people here that doesn't have a history with MP to hinder your willingness to murder him.

Okay sure.

No he isn't. MP is a respected mafia talent, but sometimes folks ignore that to make a game more fun. I refused to kill Epignosis in the GOC despite him being a threat to me. This is starting to look like justification instead of conjecture.

No I don't. There is no player in this game I am less likely to kill than MP. That's why I started this course of hunting. You turning it on me like this is a defense mechanism, not an accusation.

More justification, not conjecture.

I don't believe you. Bad kill choice.

Yeah, it is basically like "I wouldn't kill MP except maybe I would."

Complaining about WIFOM while saying all that is pretty yuck.

[Jackofhearts2005]

I'm not lynching Michelle for WARM-UPS banter. That's wack.

[Long Con]

I'm not lynching Michelle for WARM-UPS banter. That's wack.

Yeah?

[Michelle]

if I were scum I wouldn't like to kill him personally. But i would let the NK for my scumpartener because I have yet little knowledge about everyone here.
On the other hand, him as veteran player is fear killed by every single player including you. Every sane mafia kills M+7 if he rands villager.

Your analysis is so wifom-y that it gives me goosebumbs.

Let's review this doozy.

Why not? You're one of only two people here that doesn't have a history with MP to hinder your willingness to murder him.

Okay sure.

No he isn't. MP is a respected mafia talent, but sometimes folks ignore that to make a game more fun. I refused to kill Epignosis in the GOC despite him being a threat to me. This is starting to look like justification instead of conjecture.

No I don't. There is no player in this game I am less likely to kill than MP. That's why I started this course of hunting. You turning it on me like this is a defense mechanism, not an accusation.

More justification, not conjecture.

I don't believe you. Bad kill choice.

I don't see why you felt the need to use the most violent colours on this post but I can tell you, if you are villager that we are back to square 1 and you after few games still are unable to understand me. Shame of you sir.
I was honest, but like usual sincerity doesn't pay off.

I don't accept your take, is fake reasoning again. You and your Poe and your exercises, you jump on me again like Dizzy did in day 1 and this is the way to loose the game for town only because you think I said what i didn't say.

I DON'T BELIEVE YOU WOULDN'T KILL M7 IF YOU WERE WOLF.

And the best reason is he was town reading you. The question is, are you wolf? Because if you are not the answer at the question is as useless as mine. I would kill him BUT I DIDN'T BECAUSE I AM VILLAGER.

[Michelle]

Probably doesn't kill MP:
Epignosis
Long Con

Not sure, nor is she, but possibly cleared by a cop hunt anyway:
nutella

Not sure period:
S~V~S

Don't see why they wouldn't kill MP:
Michelle
Nanook

if I were scum I wouldn't like to kill him personally. But i would let the NK for my scumpartener because I have yet little knowledge about everyone here.
On the other hand, him as veteran player is fear killed by every single player including you. Every sane mafia kills M+7 if he rands villager.

Your analysis is so wifom-y that it gives me goosebumbs.

Okay you’re a prime suspect for MP murder.

not guilty

[Michelle]

Day was full of homechores, now I am back :-)

I have a couple of mechanics questions. I have not played very many games with a matrix like this one has, and I am not 100% on the terminology.

What is a "strongman"? And a "Role Doc", that is a role checker, right?

Ok, I see the matrix setup now. No wonder nobody reacted to my "it says two scum in the OP". =p

A role cop is someone who cop town to see what role they have, vanilla or otherwise.

A role cop is a cop who's result is tne role of the target no matter AI.

So first you vote me witout any concern about my AI and you associate me at random and now you lie about what a role cop does. You posted other cop role smh

You are bad Dizzy

Not really my favorite Michelle post.

I'm reserving a full Michelle read because I like the idea of her being a freebee read like Nutella and I think I'm up to a 4 game correctly reading her streak and even my last game I incorrectly read her I was like "I townread everyone but I guess I townread Michelle least" and she was town so that's half a correct read and I don't want to bust my streak.

But yeah, not really my favorite Michelle post.

Well, I didn't study the matrix, because as VT i don't have any info.
What from what I said is wrong?

[Michelle]

I'm at the top of page 5 and going to bed.

For the first 4 pages your rainbow reads are too soonish expressed.
Tbh I cleared Svs for fluence of posts and thoughts but she never posted reads and jumped on me without a real reason. She invented I was hard trying and never reconsidered.
M7 said she may be stubborn. I wonder if she was genuine in her belief of me being scum.

I don’t believe your S~V~S read.

You don't believe yourself i guess.

[Michelle]

Town
Jack
Nutella
Dys/Jay
.....
Nanook
Epi
.....
Michelle
LC
.....
.....
Scum




Unless both power roles are in Nutella and Jay, we can pretty well guarantee a wolf lynch today since there's very likely 2 wolves in a 4 player POE and two innocent children.

How do you know there may be 2 PRs?

[nutella]

Yeah I'm getting unusually sketchy vibes from a lot of Michelle's posts. This far into the game and I haven't felt the screen scream "Michelle is town" at me yet -- means she's probably not.

[VOTE: michelle] aubergine

[Michelle]

Looking better at Jack's reads without scum reads it's like a scum claim

[VOTE: Jack/Svs] aubergine

[Michelle]

Yeah I'm getting unusually sketchy vibes from a lot of Michelle's posts. This far into the game and I haven't felt the screen scream "Michelle is town" at me yet -- means she's probably not.

[VOTE: michelle] aubergine

you ignored me until now. As expected.

[Michelle]

I mean, Nut, how did you know Mac is villager when everyone wanted him lynched?

Why didn't you answer at my questions?

Why you expected a wagon to be formed to vote me?

[Michelle]

Why are you underwhelming? @[mention]nutella[/mention]

[Michelle]

Hey I am money launderer now

[nutella]

Yeah I'm getting unusually sketchy vibes from a lot of Michelle's posts. This far into the game and I haven't felt the screen scream "Michelle is town" at me yet -- means she's probably not.

[VOTE: michelle] aubergine

you ignored me until now. As expected.

No? I believe I've stated a few times that you were in my poe and that you haven't caused me to townread you