Take Me Out at the Ballgame! [DAY 3]

[Long Con]

Actually... Epi and S~V~S have been really tight-lipped since the announcement. That's probably a better indicator.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME

So, whaddya think? nutella and JJJ jumped right on it. Got'em?

Kinda still think it’s you tbh

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

SVS is Jack now

[Long Con]

@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME

So, whaddya think? nutella and JJJ jumped right on it. Got'em?

Kinda still think it’s you tbh

Nope.

[Long Con]

SVS is Jack now

Shit, right, I was looking at the poll.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

First thought when you’re town and someone claims a red on you is normally that they’re mafia, yeah?

[Long Con]

First thought when you’re town and someone claims a red on you is normally that they’re mafia, yeah?

My first thought was that you were pulling a scheme to flush out the baddies. A baddie wouldn't fakeclaim like that because they'd instantly get counter-claimed.

[Long Con]

I kept my mouth shut for a while to let your plan play out.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Why do you have to be so reasonable and say things that make sense

[Long Con]

Why do you have to be so reasonable and say things that make sense

Why do YOU make a cool plan and then abandon it before reaping the rewards??

[Long Con]

Like....

Eh, I was gonna do a thing but it’s too late in day. Not used to 48 hour days.

... I was like this is good shit!

[nutella]

@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME

So, whaddya think? nutella and JJJ jumped right on it. Got'em?

Kinda still think it’s you tbh

huh

[nutella]

hmmmmmmmmmm

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Yeah alright, nutes or Epi? Kinda not feeling Epi tbh

[Long Con]

Yeah alright, nutes or Epi? Kinda not feeling Epi tbh

Yeah, but does a baddie stay tight-lipped or jump on the vote to lynch town? Either way, they're hoping that you'll pay the price for the lynch.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Epi looks markedly different this game than GOC to me, idk

On the other hand nutes being scum probably means SvS/jack is the teammate?

[Long Con]

You really don't wanna believe JJJ could be the one, huh?

[Long Con]

Or, one of the two, I mean.

[nutella]

have I been fooled? was Nanook lying all along?

I'm not good enough with this kind of setup/counterclaim stuff to understand what could be happening here. Are Nanook and LC scum together and pulling some kind of... well, long con?

Jay help me out lol

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

You really don't wanna believe JJJ could be the one, huh?

He could be with Epi, just saying that nutes most likely partner is jack based off jacks read on her

Idk I have a hard time seeing him mafia but I’m not ruling it out completely

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

What I’m doing should be fairly obvious I think?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I don't see how Nanook can be anything other than a cop if still nobody has actively protested -- unless someone is just straight up paying no attention to the matrix. If LC isn't the check that doesn't particularly surprise me given that he asked me to wait on my interactive dive. I appreciate that by the way

[nutella]

What I’m doing should be fairly obvious I think?

I'm dumb tho

[JaggedJimmyJay]

So we have like 80 minutes here. Is nutella the red? I don't have all day guys lol

[JaggedJimmyJay]

What I’m doing should be fairly obvious I think?

I'm dumb tho

Nah, it's a valid way of maximizing the utility of a 1-shot check. I've pulled similar moves in other games.

[nutella]

has [mention]Jackofhearts2005[/mention] seen all the claiming stuff? Jack we need to know if you have any counterclaims to whatever is going on here based on the matrix

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Jack's ignorance of the claim scenario in his most recent condiment festival seems problematic.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

You really don't wanna believe JJJ could be the one, huh?

I'm town dude, and if you are too then give it a rest and help me figure the game out

[Long Con]

Jack's ignorance of the claim scenario in his most recent condiment festival seems problematic.

Can you rephrase that with some more direct language?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Jack's ignorance of the claim scenario in his most recent condiment festival seems problematic.

Can you rephrase that with some more direct language?

He paid the game a visit this morning and, in catch-up mode (ketchup, condiments, goofp emoji) he commented quite a bit on Michelle -- particularly with respect to the early portion of the game. His posts came pretty soon after Nanook had just suggested you're a red peek, and he didn't really do anything with that.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Thus, if you're not red, then inaction is a bad reaction to me.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Yeah let’s go with Nutella I guess and fuck me if I’m wrong

[Long Con]

LC posted my favorite gif, he deserves my vote too
[VOTE: Long Con] aubergine

Michelle put the vote down without much ado, the "favorite gif" thing is a bit sketchy with context... she knew that the check was fake, so she felt the need to give a jokey reason to cast the vote.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I’m gonna be so annoyed at myself if my fake check was actually red and I let myself be talked out of it

[Long Con]

Thus, if you're not red, then inaction is a bad reaction to me.

Yes, I see. Jack should get in here tbh

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Yeah let’s go with Nutella I guess and fuck me if I’m wrong

If it's not a red peek, then I have little faith in a "fuck me if I'm wrong" read. Why her? If MP was killed in a cop hunt, she was his civilian peek.

[nutella]

Yeah let’s go with Nutella I guess and fuck me if I’m wrong

What? Is this based on anything?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Yeah let’s go with Nutella I guess and fuck me if I’m wrong

If it's not a red peek, then I have little faith in a "fuck me if I'm wrong" read. Why her? If MP was killed in a cop hunt, she was his civilian peek.

I mean MP was widely TR, could just be as simple as that yeah

[JaggedJimmyJay]

[VOTE: Michelle] aubergine

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I can say it’s a red check if that would make you feel better

[nutella]

I can say it’s a red check if that would make you feel better

But it's not.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I can say it’s a red check if that would make you feel better

It doesn't anymore, King Shenanigan.

Why do you feel nutella is the best option? I'm listening, but outside a literal red peek that was not the direction I was headed today.

[nutella]

If there's no peek I still feel like Michelle is our best bet.

[VOTE: michelle] aubergine

[Long Con]

[VOTE: Michelle] aubergine

Yessss... I see now. Jack and Michelle. Jack allows the lynch to go through on Long Con while pushing hard on his teammate Michelle. When LC flips green, maybe we lynch Nanook, or maybe we follow his leadership and lynch Michelle, probably sealing the towncred for Jack for the rest of the game.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I’m actually reasonably sure there’s mafia in the people that jumped on the check. Jay looks best out of those imo, Michelle will go over without me, Nutella is best TK today I think

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Like I’m not saying I TR Michelle, but I’d kill Nutella first.

[Epignosis]

What do you mean by this?

I thought he jumped too easily on Michelle after Dizzy's early prod of her, and Dizzy was reacting to his vote as if he'd been caught in a trap.

Did you really think that? I vote people out of the gate all of the time. Yet in this particular scenario, I got caught in a trap? What trap? What's Michelle's alignment? What's Dyslexicon's alignment?

Girl please.

You have yet to state what your reasons were for voting Michelle. What am I to think?

That's not true.

Shortly thereafter, S~V~S slid into Michelle, and I changed my mind.

It's all quite civilianesque and reasonable.

If your suspicion was entirely predicated on them being teammates, is there a reason you chose Michelle over SVS?

S~V~S is the one more likely to yell at me.

Spoiler: show

[VOTE: Michelle] aubergine

Again? You sure lack imagination sir.

Grats guys, you are doing again the same thing you did in the previous game with 3 villagers in a row. Be proud of it.
I get now why they gave up, you are too selfish to accept you are wrong.


Let's see my wagon:
Epi said he will give 33% in this game, he gives 5%. Ugly way of playing no matter AI.

Nanook was just sheeping one or another, i don't understand this. If he thinks his red peek solves the game he is plain wrong because mafia is a team and in this game distancing is the key. Unless everyone talks in the game. But you all are ok with players who are answering with one word at questions and admire this nonsense. If they are mafia, you have zero content to work with.

Jay is an easy poster so high activity is not AI and he's imagining tests and PoEs. Town had bad results from his contribution in the games we played together. I don't trust him no matter AI. He is a genius mafia, good for him. Idk why, but I was town reading him when he subbed in the game. Maybe because he had a nice energy. I am not sure about this. His so called test is a trap and he choose to pick up my answer to push me.
Logic, any mafia would say no. I said yes. So what? And then he has like a revelation and said I am guilty. Lame

Nutella pretends to know to read me but she can't. Or she don't want to. We talked too much already.

At least one of this 4 is wolf, imo.
But I may be wrong.
If every single one is villager, then this town have a problem and we will loose this game.

I don't want to post more, I am tired to defend myself and I am not playing for this. My vote stays on Jack, his approach was bad. His reads looked fabricated and Svs's push on me in day 1 was a tunnel a villager should not make.

I may not come back until Eod not because I give up but because this game is depressing.

Good bye.

Probably doesn't kill MP:
Epignosis
Long Con

Not sure, nor is she, but possibly cleared by a cop hunt anyway:
nutella

Not sure period:
S~V~S

Don't see why they wouldn't kill MP:
Michelle
Nanook

if I were scum I wouldn't like to kill him personally. But i would let the NK for my scumpartener because I have yet little knowledge about everyone here.
On the other hand, him as veteran player is fear killed by every single player including you. Every sane mafia kills M+7 if he rands villager.

Your analysis is so wifom-y that it gives me goosebumbs.

Michelle didn't know how to answer the question in a straightforward way and ended the post by discrediting the foundation the idea rests upon.

What? I answered straightforward in other post and I said I would kill M7 if I were mafia. And the quoted post implies I wouldn't like to do this, but I would do it if needed.
The idea itself of this test is wrong because there is never a mafia admitting this. Mafia are cowards and so this test is like 'isn't it you would never do this"? And a chorus of hypocrites "no, we?, never!" mixed of townies and mafia everyone trying to look good.
Everyone from the town who scum reads me based on this 'test' will have my special thanks endgame. Because it's a sample of wifom in it's purest form.

[Long Con]

I’m actually reasonably sure there’s mafia in the people that jumped on the check. Jay looks best out of those imo, Michelle will go over without me, Nutella is best TK today I think

Why so sure? Why does a baddie need to do anything when a town lynch is underway?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

The one thing complicating this is that I’m not sure if Epi was around to see the check and actively ignored it or if he just wasn’t on to see it

[nutella]

Like I’m not saying I TR Michelle, but I’d kill Nutella first.

Well you'd be wrong

I like LC's Michelle/Jack theory.

Or LC is just Michelle's teammate after all.