Take Me Out at the Ballgame! [DAY 3]

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I’m actually reasonably sure there’s mafia in the people that jumped on the check. Jay looks best out of those imo, Michelle will go over without me, Nutella is best TK today I think

Why so sure? Why does a baddie need to do anything when a town lynch is underway?

Not 100%, but would be surprised if at least one didn’t jump.

Otherwise the team is what, Epi and jack exactly?

[nutella]

The one thing complicating this is that I’m not sure if Epi was around to see the check and actively ignored it or if he just wasn’t on to see it

Same problem with Jack though.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I can't speak for everyone, but when I ask myself how I would handle that if I was a mafioso in this setup -- dive on the peek gung-ho without a worry isn't the answer I come up with. I'm speaking mostly about nutella here -- Michelle joined the wagon a bit later in a more awkward fashion. LC mentioned it before with that gif. Instead of "okay cool red peek *vote*", she posted a joke about a gif. That feels less natural.

[Epignosis]

The one thing complicating this is that I’m not sure if Epi was around to see the check and actively ignored it or if he just wasn’t on to see it

Which check? You made three or four of them, didn't you?

I wasn't logged in, but I followed along in sips, so I'm not behind.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

The one thing complicating this is that I’m not sure if Epi was around to see the check and actively ignored it or if he just wasn’t on to see it

Same problem with Jack though.

Jack was in thread in the meantime

[Long Con]

I’m actually reasonably sure there’s mafia in the people that jumped on the check. Jay looks best out of those imo, Michelle will go over without me, Nutella is best TK today I think

Why so sure? Why does a baddie need to do anything when a town lynch is underway?

Not 100%, but would be surprised if at least one didn’t jump.

Otherwise the team is what, Epi and jack exactly?

Yes... IF no baddie jumped on. I could see a baddie doing either though.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

The one thing complicating this is that I’m not sure if Epi was around to see the check and actively ignored it or if he just wasn’t on to see it

Which check? You made three or four of them, didn't you?

I wasn't logged in, but I followed along in sips, so I'm not behind.

Red check on long con Is what I’m referring to

[JaggedJimmyJay]

For a civilian when a red peek arrives, there is a collective sigh of relief -- not only because it's a positive development, but because it relieves them of much of the day's workload. I felt more kinship with nutella in that way than with Michelle.

[nutella]

The one thing complicating this is that I’m not sure if Epi was around to see the check and actively ignored it or if he just wasn’t on to see it

Same problem with Jack though.

Jack was in thread in the meantime

Yeah but he was responding to old stuff, and his MO is to do so without paying attention to new posts. Quite possible he didn't read it.

[Epignosis]

I figured the Day was in hand and I could fuck off and start my taxes and fill out other governmental forms.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I mean I’m pretty sure there’s one baddie on minimum if LC is town, if there isn’t then idk how to play I guess

[Long Con]

I can't speak for everyone, but when I ask myself how I would handle that if I was a mafioso in this setup -- dive on the peek gung-ho without a worry isn't the answer I come up with. I'm speaking mostly about nutella here -- Michelle joined the wagon a bit later in a more awkward fashion. LC mentioned it before with that gif. Instead of "okay cool red peek *vote*", she posted a joke about a gif. That feels less natural.

So you think nutella/Michelle are the baddies.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I could be moved on a Jack lynch I think.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

The one thing complicating this is that I’m not sure if Epi was around to see the check and actively ignored it or if he just wasn’t on to see it

Same problem with Jack though.

Jack was in thread in the meantime

Yeah but he was responding to old stuff, and his MO is to do so without paying attention to new posts. Quite possible he didn't read it.

I count that as active ignoring for this purpose, presumably a teammate would’ve let him know “hey there’s a red on LC” or some such.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I can't speak for everyone, but when I ask myself how I would handle that if I was a mafioso in this setup -- dive on the peek gung-ho without a worry isn't the answer I come up with. I'm speaking mostly about nutella here -- Michelle joined the wagon a bit later in a more awkward fashion. LC mentioned it before with that gif. Instead of "okay cool red peek *vote*", she posted a joke about a gif. That feels less natural.

So you think nutella/Michelle are the baddies.

No, I think Michelle is a good candidate to be bad. I don't feel that way about nutella. I don't really see a case on her emerging from this peek stuff.

Jack and Michelle are my top suspects at the moment. They both also fit the bill for that lame ass MP kill.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I think jack/Nutella more likely than Nutella/Michelle tbh. In part because of michelle and Nutella interactions, in part because jack is TRing nutes.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I mean I’m pretty sure there’s one baddie on minimum if LC is town, if there isn’t then idk how to play I guess

I think there's a lot to gain from your maneuver here; I just don't think "who jumped on my bullshit?" is necessarily the right question to ask.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Jack/Michelle is my best guess at present.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I need [mention]nutella[/mention] to speak for her own damned self. I've made that mistake before. If you're good, tell us who isn't.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I mean I’m pretty sure there’s one baddie on minimum if LC is town, if there isn’t then idk how to play I guess

I think there's a lot to gain from your maneuver here; I just don't think "who jumped on my bullshit?" is necessarily the right question to ask.

I’m uh

Pretty sure there is though

[nutella]

I need @nutella to speak for her own damned self. I've made that mistake before. If you're good, tell us who isn't.

Michelle and Jack seems likely to me. Or like I said before Michelle and LC though LC's response to all this looks genuinely solvey. Unless he and Nanook are pulling a huge one over on us but that's significant tinfoil.

[nutella]

..........Or Jay and Jack if we're going into foil land

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Ok, I’ve gotta take off unfortunately. I really pretty strongly think nutella is a better kill today than Michelle but do what you want I guess

Assuming LC is town I’d guess teams that make most sense are like Nutella/jack, jack/Michelle, Epi/jay, something like that.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

There seems to be consistent overlap at [VOTE: Jackofhearts2005] aubergine

[nutella]

I really want to hear [mention]Jackofhearts2005[/mention] respond to all this nonsense before we just go and lynch him but he's not online uggghhhhhhhhhhh

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Ok, I’ve gotta take off unfortunately. I really pretty strongly think nutella is a better kill today than Michelle but do what you want I guess

Assuming LC is town I’d guess teams that make most sense are like Nutella/jack, jack/Michelle, Epi/jay, something like that.

Would you lynch Jack then? We all seem to agree on that one.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

/note

everyone eager to vote Michelle
recommend Jack vote and *crickets*

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I think Nutella is strictly better tbh

[Epignosis]

One hour remaining, correct?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I’d probably do jack over Michelle tho

Idk it’s on you guys now I’ve gotta go for realsies.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I think Nutella is strictly better tbh

Is it purely the things stemming from your peek that lead you here?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

One hour remaining, correct?

yes

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I think Nutella is strictly better tbh

Is it purely the things stemming from your peek that lead you here?

Largely yes

[Long Con]

I like Jack/Michelle. [VOTE: Jack] aubergine

[Epignosis]

/note

everyone eager to vote Michelle
recommend Jack vote and *crickets*

If my initial take of Michelle and S~V~S ends up being correct I'm going to be needlessly smug for some time.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

If there's someone out there that should be countering Nanook and isn't, I'm going to be really mad.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

In a Jack/Michelle world, we'll have to contend with their argument earlier this phase. Off-hand I wouldn't call it a clear dissociation, but it's still a fight. A closer look is needed.

[nutella]

If there's someone out there that should be countering Nanook and isn't, I'm going to be really mad.

I'm hesitant to lynch Jack for this very reason. Like I said I don't think he saw all the claiming stuff and he's the last one who might have a counterclaim so I really want to be able to wait for him to show up. But if his response doesn't change much I'm happy to lynch him.

[nutella]

He has less than an hour.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Town
Jack
Nutella
Dys/Jay
.....
Nanook
Epi
.....
Michelle
LC
.....
.....
Scum




Unless both power roles are in Nutella and Jay, we can pretty well guarantee a wolf lynch today since there's very likely 2 wolves in a 4 player POE and two innocent children.

I've already claimed a PR, so

Move me up daddy

Yeah, my stupid reason for townreading you was that I thought you were hinting a power role ("I'm not getting lynched today") but I didn't want to say that out loud and get you killed if it wasn't known. Haven't gotten to the part where you outright claimed yet.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

[mention]Long Con[/mention] why did you just drop me

[nutella]

Maybe the secret to lynching Jack is just when he's not around

[Long Con]

@Long Con why did you just drop me

1. I'm the only one who's remotely interested in lynching you

2. You're wearing me down with your convincingness today

[nutella]

Ooo and also it's not his name on the poll. That's definitely a faerie loophole

[VOTE: jack] aubergine

still wish he would show up though

[Epignosis]

If there's someone out there that should be countering Nanook and isn't, I'm going to be really mad.

At the risk of incurring your wrath for my potential ignorance, if Nanook isn't the cop, wouldn't it be prudent to say whom he did check and what the result was? Or did I miss it?

[Long Con]

You really don't wanna believe JJJ could be the one, huh?

I'm town dude, and if you are too then give it a rest and help me figure the game out

This post was real.

[Long Con]

If there's someone out there that should be countering Nanook and isn't, I'm going to be really mad.

At the risk of incurring your wrath for my potential ignorance, if Nanook isn't the cop, wouldn't it be prudent to say whom he did check and what the result was? Or did I miss it?

If Nanook isn't the cop, then there's no real check to share the result of...?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

If there's someone out there that should be countering Nanook and isn't, I'm going to be really mad.

At the risk of incurring your wrath for my potential ignorance, if Nanook isn't the cop, wouldn't it be prudent to say whom he did check and what the result was? Or did I miss it?

I don't entirely follow your question. It makes sense if I convert "isn't" to "is". If so, then it would be prudent of him to say that. He claimed a Night 0 civilian check on MP and has not claimed otherwise conclusively.

If you did mean "isn't", I'd ask that you try to rephrase.

[Epignosis]

If there's someone out there that should be countering Nanook and isn't, I'm going to be really mad.

At the risk of incurring your wrath for my potential ignorance, if Nanook isn't the cop, wouldn't it be prudent to say whom he did check and what the result was? Or did I miss it?

I don't entirely follow your question. It makes sense if I convert "isn't" to "is". If so, then it would be prudent of him to say that. He claimed a Night 0 civilian check on MP and has not claimed otherwise conclusively.

If you did mean "isn't", I'd ask that you try to rephrase.

"is"

I'm sorry.

[Epignosis]

So if the civilians lose because the person he checked and got a good result on gets lynched Day 2, we can yell at him?