Assassin's Creed Mafia (OVER!)

[ts account]

Then I do not want to play this game yet...

Why not? What's to lose? It's a post with names in it.

I could be wrong.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Then I do not want to play this game yet...

Why not? What's to lose? It's a post with names in it.

I could be wrong.

Who gives a crap?

[ts account]

Who gives a crap?

...Well, I do.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Who gives a crap?

...Well, I do.

Hiding behind that cowardice only serves to make you look worse than you need to look.

My guess:

Epignosis
speedchuck
Long Con

I could be wrong. No kidding. Any guess "could be" wrong. One has to try. You're about to lose nutella and I, and I want to know where you are before I leave.

[ts account]

I am lynching epignosis. That is where I am. Tomorrow, I am leaning towards lynching speedchuck, but the strange case with Tony has made me want to re-evaluate tomorrow anyway.

[Sloonei]

Who gives a crap?

...Well, I do.

Hiding behind that cowardice only serves to make you look worse than you need to look.

My guess:

Epignosis
speedchuck
Long Con

I could be wrong. No kidding. Any guess "could be" wrong. One has to try. You're about to lose nutella and I, and I want to know where you are before I leave.

This would be my exact guess as of this moment.

[nutella]

Samesies

[JaggedJimmyJay]

When I envision the prevailing attitude of this mafia team before TH's death, I think it had to be quite positive. They were fully in tact, the civilians did not seem to be settling into a sound posture and probably expected three mafia total anyway, and with four votes they could command the final lynch to close the game.

With Turnip Head dying and two avatars descending upon the land, that comfort level had to collapse quickly. A mafia team that has held itself fully together deep into a game is well-positioned to win but also at risk of a house-of-cards effect. It's difficult to get that far without forging some connections between one another publicly -- the idea is to just win before those connections are relevant.

Turnip Head opened the door for the civilians to find connections. nutella and I represented an immediate new certainty that a huge effort would be taken on to find those connections. This had to be extremely frustrating to the mafia. It was immediately visible in Epignosis's first response to our arrival: "Hey". I frankly could have lynched him after that post. I said earlier that I felt bad to some extent, because I know the mafia team couldn't predict or readily prepare for this. But here we are and we play to win.

Epi's annoyance may well translate to his teammates, as can the visibility of the connections. Epignosis and Turnip Head fit together perfectly, and many of us saw that straightaway when the investigation got started. He saw the development and threw out a desperate role claim to try to stave off the tidal wave. Eventually he submitted that he was cooked, and then promoted a little paranoia to try to shake the confidence of the civilians -- both in my specific effort and in everyone's confidence in my effort. He of course failed to address the prowess of the civilians not named JJJ -- nutella could kick his ass without my help every time.

I say all this to assert that the present morale of the mafia team is likely dampened. For that reason, low-presence among them in this thread as we fervently work to solve the game before the avatars depart, is highly compatible with such a state of morale.

speedchuck has largely left the game behind. He only briefly returned today with an extremely opportunistic attack upon Tony for his weird role claim. speedchuck is a mafioso.

Long Con has largely left the game behind. His only significant act today was to attempt to speed Epignosis through a hammer which would have silenced nutella and I. Long Con is a mafioso.

[Sloonei]

funnygurl is the only permanent member of the roster I can fully remove from the POE. If she's bad she deserves to win.

Mikey is hanging on in the POE by a slim thread. My best efforts to paint him as bad rely on too many hypotheticals falling into place.

Tony's role claim is weird, but his insistence on it today went beyond the realm of anything I'd expect from a mafioso who doesn't need to do anything at lylo.

The best argument for Long Con is still his Day 1 vote, but that was weird in every way. Turnip Head didn't flinch at it, and with the POE where it is now, and with the roles we've seen, I do not have a hard time imagining there was a convoluted gambit in play there. Maybe Turnip Head didn't flinch because he knew what was really going on.

speedchuck has no compelling argument to be town.

[Sloonei]

Epignosis currently has three votes: Long Con, speedchuck, and ts account.

His teammates want this day to be over more than the civilians do.

[ts account]

Epignosis currently has three votes: Long Con, speedchuck, and ts account.

His teammates want this day to be over more than the civilians do.

This is probably the correct read. I cannot help but be worried about Tony but it certainly does no good worrying about it today, in my mind.

[Sloonei]

Long Con never needed to vote for himself. He'd already given leetic a town read, so he couldn't justify a vote there. But leetic pushed hard for ted to be lynched that same day, and LC never really commented on that case. It would have been a far more sensible move, regardless of his alignment, to vote alongside his prominent town read who was being lynched, rather than to plop down a self-vote to tie himself with his prominent town read. A ted vote on Day 1 would have made it a 4-4 tie between ted and leetic, rather than Long Con and leetic. That move makes no sense unless he expects to survive, and even if that is the case then he is allowing leetic to be lynched after having spent a considerable amount of time and effort producing a town read on him.

[Long Con]

Long Con has largely left the game behind. His only significant act today was to attempt to speed Epignosis through a hammer which would have silenced nutella and I. Long Con is a mafioso.

I haven't left the game behind. I'm keeping up, I'm reading and judging things. I post things when they come to mind. I know I'm not much help. Sorry.

As for the Epi hammer penultimate vote thing, I wasn't trying to stifle conversation. I wasn't thinking about that. funnygurl had claimed to counter Epi's night action claim, and Sloonei had also refuted (since recanted, I know). I wasn't sitting in a baddie chat saying "let's bulldog this lynch quick!", I was just participating. I'm glad we didn't drop the hammer back then, because a lot of stuff has come to light since.

[Long Con]

Epignosis currently has three votes: Long Con, speedchuck, and ts account.

His teammates want this day to be over more than the civilians do.

If you're afraid of a sudden hammer move, I can change the vote.

[Sloonei]

Epignosis currently has three votes: Long Con, speedchuck, and ts account.

His teammates want this day to be over more than the civilians do.

If you're afraid of a sudden hammer move, I can change the vote.

That is not what I’m saying.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Long Con has largely left the game behind. His only significant act today was to attempt to speed Epignosis through a hammer which would have silenced nutella and I. Long Con is a mafioso.

I haven't left the game behind. I'm keeping up, I'm reading and judging things. I post things when they come to mind. I know I'm not much help. Sorry.

As for the Epi hammer penultimate vote thing, I wasn't trying to stifle conversation. I wasn't thinking about that. funnygurl had claimed to counter Epi's night action claim, and Sloonei had also refuted (since recanted, I know). I wasn't sitting in a baddie chat saying "let's bulldog this lynch quick!", I was just participating. I'm glad we didn't drop the hammer back then, because a lot of stuff has come to light since.

I'm not 100% you're a mafioso, so there's plenty of room still for Long Con insights. We'll be listening. If not you though, we need to know who it is.

[Long Con]

Long Con has largely left the game behind. His only significant act today was to attempt to speed Epignosis through a hammer which would have silenced nutella and I. Long Con is a mafioso.

I haven't left the game behind. I'm keeping up, I'm reading and judging things. I post things when they come to mind. I know I'm not much help. Sorry.

As for the Epi hammer penultimate vote thing, I wasn't trying to stifle conversation. I wasn't thinking about that. funnygurl had claimed to counter Epi's night action claim, and Sloonei had also refuted (since recanted, I know). I wasn't sitting in a baddie chat saying "let's bulldog this lynch quick!", I was just participating. I'm glad we didn't drop the hammer back then, because a lot of stuff has come to light since.

I'm not 100% you're a mafioso, so there's plenty of room still for Long Con insights. We'll be listening. If not you though, we need to know who it is.

Well, if Epi is a lock, then we have a hell of a lot of time to hash it out.

[Funnygurl555]

i'm hung up on tsp/speedchuck. i think it's a w/t situation

[Funnygurl555]

i think that because idk why a maf teammate would come in and call bs on another teammates claim just to qualify that claim and dip

but based on what i was thinking earlier it already looks like speed is doing his shit alone

[Funnygurl555]

[VOTE: Long Con] aubergine

Today is super busy I'll catch up later.

But I maintain that self-votes are bad.

this is the best case of genuine distancing i have for speed and lc. this could've caught on. it really could've at the beginning of d2

[Funnygurl555]

my team of three's tsp/epi/lc

[Funnygurl555]

speed's biggest scum reads were turnip and lc, ftr.

[Sloonei]

speed's biggest scum reads were turnip and lc, ftr.

Argument against speed here is that he's the player who's paid the least attention to the game, but he could very well have been 2 for 2. Does that happen naturally?

[Funnygurl555]

speed's biggest scum reads were turnip and lc, ftr.

Argument against speed here is that he's the player who's paid the least attention to the game, but he could very well have been 2 for 2. Does that happen naturally?

rarely. hm, alright

the game would be solved if i could townread one of these three uggggghhhhhh man i don't trust tsp at all

[Long Con]

[VOTE: Long Con] aubergine

Today is super busy I'll catch up later.

But I maintain that self-votes are bad.

this is the best case of genuine distancing i have for speed and lc. this could've caught on. it really could've at the beginning of d2

I guess "genuine distancing" qualifies this in the way you intend it, but generally I see "distancing" as a term solely for use for two Mafia teammates. This is exonerating speedchuck for you?

[nutella]

[VOTE: Long Con] aubergine

Today is super busy I'll catch up later.

But I maintain that self-votes are bad.

this is the best case of genuine distancing i have for speed and lc. this could've caught on. it really could've at the beginning of d2

I guess "genuine distancing" qualifies this in the way you intend it, but generally I see "distancing" as a term solely for use for two Mafia teammates. This is exonerating speedchuck for you?

I feel like the way she meant it is reasonably clear in context and your nitpicking about the exact wording not being flawless is a bad look.

[Long Con]

[VOTE: Long Con] aubergine

Today is super busy I'll catch up later.

But I maintain that self-votes are bad.

this is the best case of genuine distancing i have for speed and lc. this could've caught on. it really could've at the beginning of d2

I guess "genuine distancing" qualifies this in the way you intend it, but generally I see "distancing" as a term solely for use for two Mafia teammates. This is exonerating speedchuck for you?

I feel like the way she meant it is reasonably clear in context and your nitpicking about the exact wording not being flawless is a bad look.

Did I get it wrong? Why is it a bad look?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Absolutely nothing speedchuck has done or said today has made me ask myself “am I wrong about speedchuck?”

[Funnygurl555]

[VOTE: Long Con] aubergine

Today is super busy I'll catch up later.

But I maintain that self-votes are bad.

this is the best case of genuine distancing i have for speed and lc. this could've caught on. it really could've at the beginning of d2

I guess "genuine distancing" qualifies this in the way you intend it, but generally I see "distancing" as a term solely for use for two Mafia teammates. This is exonerating speedchuck for you?

i couldn't find a better way to phrase it at the time so i just let it go

you're right

[TonyStarkPrime]

[VOTE: Long Con] aubergine

Today is super busy I'll catch up later.

But I maintain that self-votes are bad.

this is the best case of genuine distancing i have for speed and lc. this could've caught on. it really could've at the beginning of d2

I guess "genuine distancing" qualifies this in the way you intend it, but generally I see "distancing" as a term solely for use for two Mafia teammates. This is exonerating speedchuck for you?

i couldn't find a better way to phrase it at the time so i just let it go

you're right

this makes me feel eh.

[TonyStarkPrime]

That is, I agree with Nutella on LC's post. But FG, instead of answering the actual clarification question that LC sets up (which assumes that LC is scum?), instead agrees that the vocab was confusing.

[TonyStarkPrime]

I think we're fine to lynch Epi.

[Funnygurl555]

what is your problem with me man

[Funnygurl555]

is Desmond more likely to be town or maf rn? I know we don't know, but what do you think nutella and JJJ?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

is Desmond more likely to be town or maf rn? I know we don't know, but what do you think nutella and JJJ?

The role makes no sense to me, so I don’t think it’s wise to speculate. I don’t think Tony should use it if it’s what he says it is.

[Funnygurl555]

fair. imo if another town killing role exists it prolly... shouldn't shoot. too risky

[JaggedJimmyJay]

If we were utterly clueless in our efforts to make reads right now, I might feel differently.

Today’s lynch is affirmed. speedchuck has given no inspiration to be kept alive Day 4. If we’re given a Day 5, then the suspect list ought to be pretty small. That’s not an unreasonable position for the civilian faction.

[Funnygurl555]

oh ok nvm then

do u have any more words of wisdom jjj :O

[JaggedJimmyJay]

One thing: speedchuck has entirely ignored suspicions cast by nutella and I today. It's as though we never existed. If he suddenly shows up on Day 4 when we're not here anymore, that's something I want y'all to be mindful of. And question him about.

"I'm busy, I have a baby" is not good enough. He has been in this thread and he didn't use that time in a way that I feel is trustworthy.

[Funnygurl555]

o7

[Sloonei]

Can anyone who hasn’t shared a Team of 3 please do so? I’d like us all to be able to compare our results.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Correct me if this is wrong:

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I think the third name still needs work. Hash it out thoroughly as a team. Also be mindful that while nutella and I are gone Day 4, another civilian is also likely to be killed. The voices here will be largely squelched. Whoever is left alive, the onus is on you to do everything in your power to make the mafia regret underestimating you. If they don't kill you, it's because they think you're their ticket to victory.

Kick their ass.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I suppose we'll need to drop the hammer on this guy sooner or later. We have 2.5 hours. Don't wait for the deadline to pass; it opens the door for last-second shenanigans.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

When in doubt, just claim folks. At a certain point withholding information is pointless.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Any parting words, [mention]nutella[/mention]?

[ts account]

yes, we certainly need to hammer epignosis before deadline.

[nutella]

I have nothing to add

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Any final questions for your benevolent deities?

[mention]Sloonei[/mention]
[mention]Funnygurl555[/mention]
[mention]ts account[/mention]
[mention]TonyStarkPrime[/mention]
[mention]Long Con[/mention]
[mention]speedchuck[/mention]

[ts account]

In your opinion, what is the best way to cook an egg?