Pyre Mafia [ENDGAME]

[Carotenoid]

(Gah my question was in the spoiler sorry)

Do you feel it's closer to his D1 description of his town game?

[Sloonei]

(Gah my question was in the spoiler sorry)

Do you feel it's closer to his D1 description of his town game?

Meh, a little. But it's a short burst that didn't really accomplish much.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

who are the wolves and villas tsp

villas from the player list:
me
mac
moto(?)
LC
Moth
Carotte
Lissa
Leaning towards putting Sloonei here
And then TH too but I don't remember why
soft town on brononananaaa

wolves: presumably everyone else

Why is motobot in the good pile?
What makes you hesitant about Sloonei?

hrm

I feel worse about carote than nutella in this exchange I think

Why worse?

can we talk about the other wagons eod yesterday? like wilgy that was gonna take off before he came into the thread and started contributing his open ended, blank contributions (and now vanished again) and carot.

Hey dunya, you said DrWilgy is a low-poster but in this specific game he's just almost not here. Apparently according to nutella it's normal, what do you think about that?

oh and nanook lock town for me tbh.

Is this just like a dead confident meta read or is there something else?

we were the three musketeers; no way nanook would kill tutuu and make us the two musketeers. nanook town.
[...]

Do you think w!NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME "potato" in gamethread while veto-ing night kills?

Yes I would but there’s a much more important reason mafiaNanook doesn’t want to kill in his own triumvirate.

[tedxtr]

Think KZA’s townie

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Fine if nobody is interested in engaging with me when I’m actually here

Killing within my triumvirate as mafia hamstrings night play. Thus, myself and dunia are soft cleared.

[Sloonei]

Think KZA’s townie

Explain

[KZA]

Great my top 3 scumreads are voting for me LOL

[Carotenoid]

Spoiler: show

who are the wolves and villas tsp

villas from the player list:
me
mac
moto(?)
LC
Moth
Carotte
Lissa
Leaning towards putting Sloonei here
And then TH too but I don't remember why
soft town on brononananaaa

wolves: presumably everyone else

Why is motobot in the good pile?
What makes you hesitant about Sloonei?

hrm

I feel worse about carote than nutella in this exchange I think

Why worse?

can we talk about the other wagons eod yesterday? like wilgy that was gonna take off before he came into the thread and started contributing his open ended, blank contributions (and now vanished again) and carot.

Hey dunya, you said DrWilgy is a low-poster but in this specific game he's just almost not here. Apparently according to nutella it's normal, what do you think about that?

oh and nanook lock town for me tbh.

Is this just like a dead confident meta read or is there something else?

we were the three musketeers; no way nanook would kill tutuu and make us the two musketeers. nanook town.
[...]

Do you think w!NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME "potato" in gamethread while veto-ing night kills?

Yes I would but there’s a much more important reason mafiaNanook doesn’t want to kill in his own triumvirate.

True forgot that

[Sloonei]

Great my top 3 scumreads are voting for me LOL

Talk some more about those votes

[KZA]

Great my top 3 scumreads are voting for me LOL

Talk some more about those votes

Turnip and Jovian are scum

This is a very simple conclusion

[KZA]

MacD, TSP, Carot, Moth, Ted, Lissa town

Jovian and Turnip lock scum, Dunya good bet

Sloonei probably town unless the entire wolf team is voting for me at once

[Sloonei]

Great my top 3 scumreads are voting for me LOL

Talk some more about those votes

Turnip and Jovian are scum

This is a very simple conclusion

Okay why?

[Carotenoid]

[mention]Sloonei[/mention] tell me more about your GTH, I don't get your mindset
You did a pretty chart, some notes and things and then ended your post with: "Let's explore why Radishes, Carot, Mac, and KZA were the preferred suspects."

Then you said this

@dunya @Lissa why did you GTH KZA as scum?

[VOTE: KZA] aubergine voting with my townreads

i was just about to move my vote to [VOTE: carotenoid] aubergine

And then pretty much no more Sloonei.

[KZA]

vote Jovian

[KZA]

Great my top 3 scumreads are voting for me LOL

Talk some more about those votes

Turnip and Jovian are scum

This is a very simple conclusion

Okay why?

I guess it's not a simple conclusion until I flip town

[Carotenoid]

vote Jovian

How is they wolf?

[Turnip Head]

Fine if nobody is interested in engaging with me when I’m actually here

Killing within my triumvirate as mafia hamstrings night play. Thus, myself and dunia are soft cleared.

I'm fine with you clearing yourself or whatevs but how can you clear dunia? What if she had no choice? What if there's like 5 wolves in 5 separate triumvirates... Some wolf is gonna draw that short straw. They can't avoid NKing their own triumvirates forever

[KZA]

vote Jovian

How is they wolf?

I'm not repeating myself. It's obvious.

[KZA]

Someone in my Tri died and I haven't been notified of any debuff so idk

[tedxtr]

Meh not a fan of how KZA re-entered the thread

This was the read, Sloonei

KZA -

Kinda think the "If Radish says I'm scum, you can trust him" line rings genuine, not necessarily true, by any means. I have trouble parsing that thought as a wolf, and I think it comes a lot more from town that's putting their faith into someone in order to town read them correctly. It's not really covering any bases for you as a wolf to say that kind of stuff. Unless he thinks he can handle Radishes' suspicion on him, then I think wolf!him wouldn't have even mentioned it. Within the context of the entire post, that line looks a lot better, the whole post is exuding "I'm town, Radish can potentially attest for this as well"

Feel like if he was going to mention Radishes' read on him there, as a wolf, it would've been done differently and came off with a lot more of a "if he's wrong, he's scum" vibe, but it doesn't read like that to me.

I also liked his random one line reads (Tutuu, Jovian)

[VOTE: TonyStarkPrime] aubergine
That Nanook vote weirded me out

You don't accept his reasoning? I find Tony's overall vibe scummy to this point but I don't take issue with him prodding someone that was barely noticeable. You'll notice that Nanook showed up too, and his posts didn't exactly impress me. Since you like asking questions I'll ask you one; any thoughts on Nanook himself?

Oh and I think you asked me about Moth earlier but I got distracted; he is still town.

Really like this post. I can see gears shifting in his brain and assessing the game from a villager's PoV.

Wanna say the slot is town.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

[bronana]

Dislike kza votes

Aubergine marcher

[dunya]

wait this game is 24/24?

you gotta be kidding me.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Fine if nobody is interested in engaging with me when I’m actually here

Killing within my triumvirate as mafia hamstrings night play. Thus, myself and dunia are soft cleared.

I'm fine with you clearing yourself or whatevs but how can you clear dunia? What if she had no choice? What if there's like 5 wolves in 5 separate triumvirates... Some wolf is gonna draw that short straw. They can't avoid NKing their own triumvirates forever

Not forever, but they can avoid doing it this early! Also, like, if dunia is the most obvious wolf...that just seems unlikely to me? Maybe she has a useless role, idk, but yeah, I’m definitely fine with SOFT clearing dunia today.

[Carotenoid]

Dislike kza votes

Aubergine marcher

Why?

wait this game is 24/24?

you gotta be kidding me.

Huh no??

[Carotenoid]

Yeah

"Poll runs till Mon Jun 29, 2020 8:05 pm
Please note that if you vote, your vote will be visible."

So theres 24h+ left

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Someone in my Tri died and I haven't been notified of any debuff so idk

Epi usually doesn’t notify you of that kind of thing but check the OP for how glory works

[tedxtr]

I expected 3KP in the night, I’m disappointed

[dunya]

Fine if nobody is interested in engaging with me when I’m actually here

Killing within my triumvirate as mafia hamstrings night play. Thus, myself and dunia are soft cleared.

I'm fine with you clearing yourself or whatevs but how can you clear dunia? What if she had no choice? What if there's like 5 wolves in 5 separate triumvirates... Some wolf is gonna draw that short straw. They can't avoid NKing their own triumvirates forever

i doubt 5 wolves are in 5 different triumvirates tbh. you're playing devil's advocate. im happy to lock nanook as town, now don't get in between our team

[tedxtr]

Mechanically speaking it’s best if wolves were scattered in triumvirates

Realistically speaking half the wolves didn’t give a crap about this

[dunya]

what do you mean im the most obvious wolf [mention]NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME[/mention]

why do people think happy town dunia is scum dunia. do i have to be like serious and posting 500 posts every phase? why cant people love me for who i want to be

[tedxtr]

Dunya I have decided to read you town a few pages ago

Godspeed :cheers:

[TonyStarkPrime]

who are the wolves and villas tsp

villas from the player list:
me
mac
moto(?)
LC
Moth
Carotte
Lissa
Leaning towards putting Sloonei here
And then TH too but I don't remember why
soft town on brononananaaa

wolves: presumably everyone else

Why is motobot in the good pile?
What makes you hesitant about Sloonei?

hrm

I feel worse about carote than nutella in this exchange I think

Why worse?

can we talk about the other wagons eod yesterday? like wilgy that was gonna take off before he came into the thread and started contributing his open ended, blank contributions (and now vanished again) and carot.

Hey dunya, you said DrWilgy is a low-poster but in this specific game he's just almost not here. Apparently according to nutella it's normal, what do you think about that?

oh and nanook lock town for me tbh.

Is this just like a dead confident meta read or is there something else?

we were the three musketeers; no way nanook would kill tutuu and make us the two musketeers. nanook town.
[...]

Do you think w!NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME "potato" in gamethread while veto-ing night kills?

hesitant about sloonei because I still have lasting suspicions of nutella/sloonei w/w. Moto is town because he's in my triumvirate and mechanics dictate that he must be town.

[dunya]

Dunya I have decided to read you town a few pages ago

Godspeed :cheers:

you're my new tutuu <3

ok, i'll stop being egoistical and read things that don't mention me now.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

what do you mean im the most obvious wolf @NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME

why do people think happy town dunia is scum dunia. do i have to be like serious and posting 500 posts every phase? why cant people love me for who i want to be

Wut

No, I was trying to say that if the kill was in your triumvirate and you were a wolf it would be cause you’re the most obvious wolf or you have the least useful role. I also said it’s more likely you’re just town and I’m soft clearing you

[tedxtr]

TSP my stretched town read on you isn’t as flexible anymore

Gimme some spice

[TonyStarkPrime]

someone tell me who to vote for. I think KZA is town

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Dunya I have decided to read you town a few pages ago

Godspeed :cheers:

you're my new tutuu <3

ok, i'll stop being egoistical and read things that don't mention me now.

I won’t!

[Sloonei]

vote Jovian

How is they wolf?

I'm not repeating myself. It's obvious.

It is not obvious. Please explain.

[TonyStarkPrime]

TSP my stretched town read on you isn’t as flexible anymore

Gimme some spice

two wolves on kza.

[Sloonei]

What do people see in KZA's posts that strikes them as town?

[Sloonei]

Dislike kza votes

Aubergine marcher

what do you dislike about the votes?

[TonyStarkPrime]

Also thinking nutella/sloonei v/v

[tedxtr]

Sloonei this is where I give my god read on you, ready?

[TonyStarkPrime]

What do people see in KZA's posts that strikes them as town?

this is mildly egotistic, but KZA had a scumread on me yesterday and opened with a townread today iirc. I'm insanely easy to push and already had a middleground read on KZA. The adjustment isn't really necessary as a wolf, I think.

[tedxtr]

Sloonei town

[Sloonei]

@Sloonei tell me more about your GTH, I don't get your mindset
You did a pretty chart, some notes and things and then ended your post with: "Let's explore why Radishes, Carot, Mac, and KZA were the preferred suspects."

Then you said this

@dunya @Lissa why did you GTH KZA as scum?

[VOTE: KZA] aubergine voting with my townreads

i was just about to move my vote to [VOTE: carotenoid] aubergine

And then pretty much no more Sloonei.

There was no more sloonei after that because I had to go to work.

I asked those questions because I wanted to get some discussion going about some of the reads that came out of the GTH exercise. The exercise itself is just meant (for me, at least) to get people to start thinking and talking about news things. I didn’t have as much time to play around with the results as I would have liked.

[Sloonei]

What do people see in KZA's posts that strikes them as town?

this is mildly egotistic, but KZA had a scumread on me yesterday and opened with a townread today iirc. I'm insanely easy to push and already had a middleground read on KZA. The adjustment isn't really necessary as a wolf, I think.

Fair point

[Sloonei]

Sloonei town

[tedxtr]

That wizard emoji is such a good one

Calling dibs on it

[KZA]

I am obvious town

Sloonei's mild-at-best case on me actually garnering 4 votes is questionable asf lol