TonyStarkPrime wrote: ↑Thu Jul 02, 2020 5:28 pm
Like seriously, I came into the thread last night, saw epi and mac fighting, thought "oh great this again" and haven't bothered to catch up since.
Carotenoid wrote: ↑Thu Jul 02, 2020 5:47 pm
Alison's case on me started by her quoting my "Alison is still alien" --> saying my progression on her was weird and then putting words in my mouth.
I agree with this. Not so much the wording, but the sentiment.
To be clear, I don't think a civilian treats Carotenoid that way. I'm a civilian, and while I gave Carotenoid a little shit over the choice to protect me, I'm not making things up to take her down. Alison produced a bunch of assumptions and tried to drown Carotenoid with them. I don't see why a civilian would do that.
TonyStarkPrime wrote: ↑Thu Jul 02, 2020 5:28 pm
Like seriously, I came into the thread last night, saw epi and mac fighting, thought "oh great this again" and haven't bothered to catch up since.
TonyStarkPrime wrote: ↑Thu Jul 02, 2020 5:28 pm
Like seriously, I came into the thread last night, saw epi and mac fighting, thought "oh great this again" and haven't bothered to catch up since.
That last like fifteen minutes.
Please.
it was like two pages. I've had other stuff too.
It was like 3 posts.
well i dunno I didn't read it. How have there been 500 posts today?
TonyStarkPrime wrote: ↑Thu Jul 02, 2020 5:28 pm
Like seriously, I came into the thread last night, saw epi and mac fighting, thought "oh great this again" and haven't bothered to catch up since.
That last like fifteen minutes.
Please.
it was like two pages. I've had other stuff too.
It was like 3 posts.
well i dunno I didn't read it. How have there been 500 posts today?
protocultures wrote: ↑Thu Jul 02, 2020 5:39 pm
This is a whole different ballpark from " confirmed town"
how does anyone get confirmed town status in this setup through night actions?
like, it's literally impossible because even if one townie clears another, no one has to believe that townie.
you're setting impossibly high standards here and kinda nitpicking on choice of words. the game of mafia is intuition more than it is hard cold facts that we don't always have. probability says to T!Carot that she saved a T!Epi when on an even numbered night only one kill goes through. it's not hard or farfetched to deduce that.
this is like me coming in and willingly putting myself into that pool of suspects who saved nutella by claiming after the event that i did save nutella. i had nothing to gain from being honest about how i used my bunkershot, and everything to lose.
carot has way more paranoia and things to lose than if W!Carot had not made that play. this isn't even taking into consideration dead player analysis, her communication with soneji and rej.
carot is town. i'm sure of that.
I feel like you are hard defending partner now. This game is so confusing.
i don't mind but this both doesn't clear you and is also kinda angleshooty.
I don't believe you believe this.
I do. It is. Could I like write up a list of notes, time stamp it, screen shot it, and then share it in game two days later as such? It presents clear problems.
i don't mind but this both doesn't clear you and is also kinda angleshooty.
I don't believe you believe this.
I do. It is. Could I like write up a list of notes, time stamp it, screen shot it, and then share it in game two days later as such? It presents clear problems.
I am a veteran host on this site.
Please explain to me what the difference is between posting a picture of notes and typing them out.
i don't mind but this both doesn't clear you and is also kinda angleshooty.
I don't believe you believe this.
I do. It is. Could I like write up a list of notes, time stamp it, screen shot it, and then share it in game two days later as such? It presents clear problems.
I am a veteran host on this site.
Please explain to me what the difference is between posting a picture of notes and typing them out.
It's the time stamp thing, or sort of the admission here that "these are old" (which can't be proven but can sort of be based on the state of the notes). I've scanned in pictures of paper notes before, I don't have a problem with that.
I don't get the argument, but I feel the more we talk about it now, the more potentially game breaking it *could* be simply from people's reactions, so let's just move on please ? Leave the discussion for post game maybe?
dunya wrote: ↑Thu Jul 02, 2020 8:28 pm
I don't get the argument, but I feel the more we talk about it now, the more potentially game breaking it *could* be simply from people's reactions, so let's just move on please ? Leave the discussion for post game maybe?
If you don't get the argument, then why are you asking we stop talking about it?
TonyStarkPrime wrote: ↑Thu Jul 02, 2020 8:24 pm
Like a screen shot of notes I typed up that is dated tuesday at 1:17 or whatever would be a problem
Why would that be a problem?
It's out of game information that can't be easily faked and could be used mischievously. Has no place in the game. Here it means something rather specific, since it would allow us to say that we had a specific town mechanical grasp on the game on n3 but not reveal that information until day 5 or whatever, which is substantially easier as town if the time gap can be proven.
I don't think it's a big issue here, but I'm just pointing out that I'm not going to touch "look see I did this in the past" because I don't think that argument belongs in the game. The notes themselves are fine.
I understand the argument. Can't comment much because no idea what the rules are here.
An analogy would be posting an encrypted post which needs a password to view it in the future, except you can provide any password you want to create whatever decrypted message you want and the recipient has no idea this is possible.
It's evidence of probative value as to state of mind in the past in a way that cannot be replicated in normal forum play.
No idea what a reverse angle shoot is.
In any event, I found the note from carotenoid amusing given the build up and didn't interpret it as an attempt of advantage play.
protocultures wrote: ↑Thu Jul 02, 2020 8:42 pm
I understand the argument. Can't comment much because no idea what the rules are here.
An analogy would be posting an encrypted post which needs a password to view it in the future, except you can provide any password you want to create whatever decrypted message you want and the recipient has no idea this is possible.
It's evidence of probative value as to state of mind in the past in a way that cannot be replicated in normal forum play.
No idea what a reverse angle shoot is.
In any event, I found the note from carotenoid amusing given the build up and didn't interpret it as an attempt of advantage play.
yeah I've made it pretty clear that I don't think carotte was trying anything manipulative. I'm probably also taking this too seriously.
Alison/Dunya makes sense for game state reasons and additionally I scumread them both independently. Their interactions are questionable but I think make sense as paired.